Software
Houzz Logo Print
michael357

Training Northern Spy

17 years ago

In his book, "The Apple Grower a Guide for the Organic Grower" Michael Phillips writes, after initial limb spreading to develop crotch angles he let's, "these young branches straighten until they are almost long enough to fill their envisioned lateral space and then using long spreaders (on the order of 3 to 4 feet) or tie down strings to aggressively bring my vision of branch structure to the fore". His reason for this has to do with the tree's strong tendency to grow upright.

What I don't understand is, is he doing this on the new scaffolds in their first year of growth or is the first year or more allowed to continue upward then trained down later in a later year then the spreaders installed? The passage is on pg. 122 of the revised expanded edition.

I have one Northern Spy that was a planted whip last year and grew very nicely. It was tipped and allowed to grow several scaffolds that do want to grow upright but nothing extreme compared to my other varieties.

Comments (7)

  • 17 years ago

    I don't have the book, but what I do is let the whips grow for one year before tying them down, else they tend to snap. When bending them down into place, it sometimes helps to twist the whips slightly while bending. Good luck.

  • 17 years ago

    N spy is a nightmare of vigorous upright growth. Even if you train branches to near horizontal it it very reluctant to send out any but overly vigorous secondary wood that grows and grows.

    If you can, remove all scaffolds more than 1/3 the diamter of trunk so remaining wood is only reasonably vigorous. Then you must remove most vigorous secondary wood and let remaining wood grow. The idea is to try to produce small wood for early fruiting that isn't only at the end of long scaffolds. If you keep heading wood back, I'm afraid your tree will remain a vegetable for a long time.

    I manage a lot of these trees on rootstocks ranging from 7 to seedling. If you're lucky your tree is on 26 which would be the perfect stock for a free-standing nspy.

    After years of association with this cultivar I still struggle with over-sized scaffolds I should have cut years ago but would have left big holes in the canopy.

    I'd like to hear what others have to say about this one.

  • 17 years ago

    Harvestman: thanks for your comments. It is on M7, G11 would have been better for my local, at least I'm learning.
    By secondary wood are you refering to the branches off the scaffolds and/or non-scaffolds arising from the trunk or the vigorous vertical shoots arising from the scaffolds? Being a tip bearer, I am at more of a loss how to handle this tree having never trained one. I suspect one good way to slow it down is to get it fruiting sooner rather than later. Also, doesn't training the branches closer to 90 deg vs 45 deg tend to slow their elongation? Would an open center work better than central leader? It's not too late to make that change. I'm at a loss and would appreciate all the help I can get.

  • 17 years ago

    By secondary wood I mean wood directly attached to the scaffolds and wood off secondary wood is tertiery wood. The problem with Nspy is it doesn't gladly send out tertiery wood- no matter how you spread the branches- it just sends out very vigorous uprights off the scaffold with just a few small pieces.

    Heading back doesn't help- this is all the reason Nspy takes to long to get into bearing. If you choose the less vigorous thinner branches to be scaffolds they will have less vascular tissue sending N and water from the roots and will calm down sooner. IF THE TREE PRODUCES ANY SCAFFOLDS A THIRD OR LESS DIAMETER OF THE TRUNK AT ITS POINT OF ATTACHMENT.

    When I prune Nspy I am just trying to accumulate as much small wood as possible because this is where fruit production will start. Eventually they do settle down and a mature tree behaves almost completely differently although it will continue to produce some very vigorous wood for a long time.

    On Friday I was pruning some 10 year old Nspy on seedling rootstock spaced just 18' apart. They just started bearing last year. I wish I knew when I first pruned them what I know now about prunning very vigorous excessively close trees. The customer called the shots of rootstock and spacing.

    You can do a lot of tricks with string and tape to pull upright tertiery wood to a horizontal position by tying it to other branches. If you have the time for this you can speed up the fruiting of upright growers like Nspy.

  • 17 years ago

    One thing I should say is that I have never had the chance to micromanage the training of this cultivar. On the site I mentioned are the only Spys I have trained from year one (or 2 as they grew in nursery for year). On another site I am managing about 30 ten year old Spys on M7 for a small commercial grower who completely mismanaged their training and has them spaced far to close. After 2 years I have these trees finally beginning to produce by removing excessively large scaffolds mercilessly.

    I manage several other Nspys that are up to 150 years old on a few other sites, and with all this I don't really have a complete understanding of how best to train young trees.

    If I grew it on my property I would try a lot of summer pruning to try to turn some of the vigorous secondary upright shoots that Nspy offers into spurring wood by cutting back 2 or 3 times during summer. This might be the ticket to deinvigorating this cultivar and I hope you may try it and tell me the results.

  • 17 years ago

    Harvestman: Again, thank you very much for your insights. The scaffolds from last year (the first set) were winter tipped by the deer, didn't know the deer came into town 1 1/2 blocks, DAMN! Of those 6 scaffolds I have to choose from, 2 are about 1/8" at their bases but are only 20" off the ground, the others range from 3/16 - 1/2" with the trunk about 1". I'm going to tie scaffolds on the lower side of 60 deg. and not tip prune the scaffolds I keep; that way, there can be some comparison of the deer tip-pruned scaffolds and those left not tipped. I'll definitely go the summer pruning route.

    Have you ever tried nicking down to the cambium just above a dormant bud to force one on the trunk on a young tree. The thought crossed my mind to get some better spaced and hopefully smaller scaffolds. BTW, my 7 apples, 3 pears and 1 peach definitely look like they are micro-managed... BY A NOVICE, the vegetables and small fruits look micro-managed by a professional however.

    I'd be happy to give you updates with pictures, please remind me to give them as my memory isn't what it used to be. There was something else but I can't remember what it was, honestly.

    Michael

  • 17 years ago

    I have tried that on occasion and I'm not really sure how succesful I've been- so many trees I prune. What I often do to mistrained trees with excessively upright scaffolds that are too stiff and large to bend, is create a hinge at the base of the branch by making 4 or 5 cuts at the underside of said branch about 1/3 through, so that it can be spread to near horizontal.

    Scarring might be another trick to make Nspy fruit sooner. You use your pruning saw to cut ring just beneath the cambium layer all the way around the trunk or 2 cuts half way around close to each other if you're cautious. This is done in Spring around the time blossums would be opening if tree had any. Just cut the width of the blade. It slows carbohydrate transfer to the roots and encourages flowering instead in the same manner root pruning would.

    I wouldn't try this until trees were at least 3" diameter.