Software
Houzz Logo Print
bucky130

Need Help Autumn Ridge????

18 years ago

Ok so after buying some trees, 3 orders actually, total of about 25 tree, I read some reviews of Autumn Ridge. It is then I realize I have been ripped off. All the trees i bought were semi dwarf or dwarf. I now realize that none of the trees have a graft mark on them and some that I put in the other day still had the seed attached to the root. Some of these have been in for over a year. Is there any way to fight this and maybe get my money back? I do not want to be stuck with 25 trees that arent what they are supposed to be.

Comments (33)

  • 18 years ago

    It might work on your newest purchase. But the older ones????? Didnt you realize no grafts when you planted them a year ago. Ive never delt with Autumn Ridge but a year old might not get you anywhere.

    Best thing to do is call them. Do you have rcpts??

  • 18 years ago

    No I didnt notice. Im a rookie so I just took their word for it, im to trusting I guess. Ive found lots of bad reviews compared to just a few positive. They have a guaruntee that their plants will be what they say they are. Some of my apple trees have red leaves. Im thinking they are going to grow into crab apples. Dont know where the receipts are. Dont even think i got one with the most recent purchase.

  • 18 years ago

    That's awful about your fruit tree order! But please don't consider yourself "stuck", if you have healthy rootstock. You might consider grafting the trees yourself. Dormant apple scions are available on line late winter, and are the easiest of the fruit trees to graft with success. It's not rocket science. And then you would know what varieties you have, could come up with an orchard that was really remarkable.
    I ordered an apricot tree from Autumn Ridge, and it arrived dead. I called to complain several times, and was repeatedly told: "It's just dormant. Give it time." After six months, it was still dead. I finally gave up, resolved never to order from them again.

  • 18 years ago

    The rootstock is not a dwarfing rootstock so grafting to them may let you know what you are growing but it will not produce a dwarf or simi-dwarf tree.

    I would complain but I really don't think it will get you very far. If it were me I would start replacing them and study up.

    Heck the other day when at Home depot they were selling Ultra-Dwarf Snow Queen Nectarine trees. They said this because they had been cut down to 2ft tall. Snow Queen Nectarine trees are not a dwarf let alone an Ultra-Dwarf and I knew it. I wanted a Snow Queen Nectarine tree though and I found one with 2+ inch trunk that was well branched and I purchased it.

    Now I just have to hope they were not lying to me about it being a Snow Queen too. lol!!!

    Good luck.

  • 18 years ago

    Yeah wish I could just start over but i dont like wasting $250. I do not really have the funds right now to just replace 24 trees with ones that cost $30. I do not like getting ripped off, i was very happy with them until i realized all of this. I know they are cheaper for a reason and I just figured it was because of the size and age difference but now i come to find out they arent even selling what they say they are. I called them a little bit ago and she said she would have someone call me back, we will see.

  • 18 years ago

    bucky,

    What types of trees were they?

    Are you sure you would recognize what the graft would look like? There are various techniques of grafting that leave different types of evidence.

    There are also some varieties that are genetic dwarfs meaning the variety itself has some size control even on standard root stock.

    I know this doesn't help much now, but in the future its a good idea to order trees with specific known rootstocks. At a minimum ask what rootstock the tree will be on and don't order trees if the nursery can't or won't tell you.

    Everyone has their own definition of what "dwarf" or "semi-dwarf means". In industry, anything that grows smaller than a full sized tree is considered at least semi-dwaft. So if the standard gets 40' a tree that only grows to 30' might be considered dwarfing or "semi-dwarf".

  • 18 years ago

    The site says for dwarf "These trees usually reach 6-8 feet at maturity" and semi dwarf "All semi-dwarf fruit trees grow up to 15 to 20 feet tall." Maybe can't recognize the graft. It was obvious on some tree i got from some other places. The thing that got me to start wonder was a peach and nectarine I ordered as semi dwarf. Everything I have been reading says they would need to be attached to a root stock. Well attached to the peach tree was a nice looking peach seed and attached to the nectarine was a nectarine seed. Another peach tree had asplit trunk coming off the root system. I hope you are right, i have a lot of time and work in them. When I get home tonight what should i look for? Everything I remember seeing them when i was planting them it was smooth from the where the roots quit the whole way up, I didnt see any graft union. Most of what i have is apple, and i know that if they are grown from seed they wont be what they say they are. I dont want to waste 5 years and have them turn out to be a crab apple or some other junk. What are the different types of grafting so i can google them and compare to what i have.

  • 18 years ago

    Bucky, if there is a seed attached it is not a graft.
    To me it sounds like you have been ripped off. I hve no idea if the company is going to help you or not but my guess is not.

    If you can't afford to replace them all now just do a few here and there because if you don't have room for all of those none dwarf trees its going to be a pain in the butt trying to keep ahead of the pruning.

  • 18 years ago

    First off, I'm not trying to defend the nursery and there's a good chance you did get ripped off.

    Most common grafts are probably whip and tongue vs chip budding or T-budding for young trees.

    Apples are one of the few large growing fruit trees that have truly dwarfing rootstocks that can keep them anywhere near the 6-8 feet they're talking about.

    The peach tree, even a seedling may fit into the 15-20 foot range.

    Reputable nurseries do sometimes use peach seedlings as the rootstock for peaches or plums. It can still be grafted onto a seedling rootstock.

    In general, if you don't see any discontinuities or scars within inches of ground the next thing to look for is any evidence that bud grafting has occurred up the trunk.

    I have a plum tree from Raintree Nursery that has 3 varieties of European plum budded to a peach seedling rootstock. Its pretty clear to see where each branch was budded to the rootstock including where the potential 4th variety failed.

  • 18 years ago

    Hi murky, Of course you are right that the rootstock could be from a seedling and I had not thought of that. If there is no graft union though something smells fishy. Sometimes you have to look close to see a graft union but there should be some sign that it was done.

  • 18 years ago

    Dang, Autumn Ridge really is bad news. Garden Watchdog has them at only 21% (very very poor). ALWAYS check out nurseries at Garden Watchdog before ordering.

    And, like Murky said, "in the future ... order (fruit) trees with specific known rootstocks. At a minimum ask what rootstock the tree will be on and don't order trees if the nursery can't or won't tell you."

    Here is a link that might be useful: The scoop on 'Autumn Ridge Nursery'

  • 18 years ago

    I've got 2 apples from Autumn Ridge. They were purchased 4 years ago, as of yet, neither has bloomed (which also means no fruit). Are they what I purchased? No idea.

    I'm guessing they will eventually be fodder for grafting, which is fine with me.

    I have bought apples from more reputable nurseries in the meantime that have bloomed (some even in their first year).

    ~Chills

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks for the info guys. I just came in from checking them out. I walked around with a spray bottle and sprayed the bottoms of all the trees that came from them. It left me feeling a little bit better. There was at least a line where the color changed on most of the trees but it was a very smooth natural looking transition. Then i got to the dwarf apple. There was not much difference anywhere. 6 of them were redish the whole way down into the ground and further until i quit scrappin. Which brings me to another observation, those 6 with the redish bark all have new growth that is red. They look almost identical to a mature ornamental crab apple that I have. Are red leaves normal? None of my other apples get red leaves. Oh well back out to finishing fencing them just in case.

  • 18 years ago

    chills- i doubt your apple trees are gonna bloom if they havent bloomed within 4 years

  • 18 years ago

    If chill's apples are seedlings it could easily take them much longer than 4 years to bloom and still have blooms come eventually.

  • 18 years ago

    I purchased two apricot trees, 2 sugar maples, 3 red maples and a weeping willow. The trees came like sticks, not at the advertised 2-4 feet either maybe 1 foot, needless to say that they all died except one apricot tree, and now i am wondering if it is a apricot or what kind!! The willow tree actually grew very well and I think it survived the winter.

    My problem is now I called yesterday to the company to find out about their return policy. I first was going to just chalk it up to lesson well learned, but than I thought I would just call. I asked the lady about the poor trees I recieved last year and she assured me this year the trees are much better. Do I believe her? Has any one else ordered from there this year? I am tempted to try one more time because at least at 1/2 off I can maybe get some of my money back. I think I could get 5 trees for about $20. I cant believe I am thinking of purchasing there again after I told myself I would never do it.

  • 18 years ago

    Bucky, red leaves are not normal. I have one apple that is not a crab that produces red leaves out of 150+ varieties: Belle Fleur Rouge.

    Scott

  • 18 years ago

    Bucky:

    Your experience illustrates why I generally urge first-time fruitgrowers to start out small, say 10 trees or so, and to buy the best possible quality stock from reputable nurseries. That does not necessarily mean larger trees (my own preference is for 1-year grafted whips), but cheaper is not better in the nursery stock business. I am sure you already know this now, but it might help someone else who who wants to plant out 100 cheap trees. When you plant fewer trees initially, you have a chance to learn on them, and have a much better idea of what you want to plant for the next 10.

    The only red-leafed apple tree I have is Geneva Crab, a large crab with red-fleshed apples that is sour as hell, but has a pretty color for blending in applesauce or cider. However, in this case, I grafted it myself and knew what it was like.

    The real problem with the cheap-cheap nurseries is that they will sell you seedling stock, or trees that are completely mislabled. Mistakes do happen at all nurseries, but these outfits do it as a matter of policy. They figure results of their skulduggery will not be known for years down the road, and they will get away with it. I would rather have one very good $20 tree than 5 lousy trees for $20.

    Don Yellman, Great Falls, VA

  • 18 years ago

    "...I am tempted to try one more time because at least at 1/2 off I can maybe get some of my money back. I think I could get 5 trees for about $20. I cant believe I am thinking of purchasing there again after I told myself I would never do it."

    Troman, are you being serious? If so, I have some valuable investment property I'd like to talk to you about.

  • 18 years ago

    Find the BBB online, and file a complaint. They'll have a listing of the business and will show you complaints made and settled. After filing there, contact the company and tell them that you've done so and ask for a refund.

    dave

  • 18 years ago

    This information is too late for Bucky, but for others it might be helpful. Bucky mentions 25 trees for about $250.

    For that many trees, you can go to Adams County Nursery, a reputable operation, and get 25 trees for about the same cost.

    If you order less than 25, you'll pay $20+ / tree. But, as soon as you hit 25+ trees the cost goes way down. Three years ago when I ordered, my cost averaged about $10. It seems to be a bit higher now, but still reasonable.

    I know most people don't want 25 trees, and I didn't either. But, I contacted some friends in my area who I thought might be interested and we placed one order. We ended up with 4 of us ordering, and then dividing the trees when they arrived. It worked well.

    It took a little extra work on my part to do it that way. But, I was able to get quality trees at a reasonable price.

  • 18 years ago

    To send a complaint in to the BBB.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Better Business Bureau

  • 18 years ago

    The leaves arent red red. Kinda like a dried blood red with some green. The redish color seems to be the new growth, is that normal in any apple? It looks similar to my ornamental crab that only get really small fruit, maybe the size of a pencil eraser. I have no complaints about how the tree arrived and how they are doing, most are growing very well. I think I am going to call them again today and ask for a refund or I am going to file a complaint with the BBB. One of my purchases was with a gift card so maybe I can threaten to complaint to the BBB.

  • 18 years ago

    Troman, are you being serious? If so, I have some valuable investment property I'd like to talk to you about.

    brandon7 if your property is $20 I'll take a look.

    I have spent $20 in worse places. Worst case I throw the trees away. I live in marginal fruit country and dont want to spend a ton of money to find out that I cant grow the trees. For $20 I can try out five different varieties is worth the risk.

  • 18 years ago

    Don't forget to mention that hundreds of people on Gardenweb are following your posts closely.

  • 18 years ago

    Just got off the phone with them. I asked them about their rootstocks. She said they use M105 on dwarf and M106 on semi dwarf. Anyone know anything about them? She is doing some research and said she would call me back to discuss what we are going to do. She needed to talk to someone. I told her I would like to work out a refund and she said ok, at this point I would be happy with a partial refund and i could use the old stuff as decorative stuff and move some to my "deer" orchard. Sure wish I would of noticed Adams County discount after 25 trees before, i actaually looked at them before as they are fairly close to me.

  • 18 years ago

    Bucky:

    I think the M105 is actually an artillery piece. Never heard of it as a rootstock. M106 is ok, but will grow a fairly large tree. In that size range, I prefer the M7, which I find more fruitful and slightly smaller.

    Don Yellman, Great Falls, VA

  • 18 years ago

    I found this description online for the M106 rootstock.

    MM.106 -- A hybrid of 'Northern Spy' and M.1. Precocious, well anchored, does not produce many root suckers. Fruit matures late, and trees grow late into Fall, making them prone to winter injury. Susceptible to crown and root rot. Trees about 50% of full size.

  • 18 years ago

    There is a M105 apple rootstock. As Don's comment illustrates it's not common, and I don't think it's being commercially produced. I think it's unlikely that they are using that rootstock in production. M106 is fairly common.

  • 18 years ago

    Reread the first post, there is no M 106 rootstock, the tree that you get is seedling roostock ; "I now realize that none of the trees have a graft mark on them and some that I put in the other day still had the seed attached to the root."

    I went down into my basement, I still have the Autumn Ridge delivered dead twigs and the shipping tube. Autumn Ridge scams folks with mostly dead seed grown trees. Then they offer you more at half price. No refunds.

    The BBB Online says there were 90 complaints in 3 years. Maybe 1 in 20 finds the BBB of Middle Tennessee,Inc. on the web to complain.(I didn't know last spring when I got scammed) Do the math.

    Look at the Autumn Ridge website, click 'about us'. It shows acres of potted evergreens. But Autumn Ridge sells
    small bareroot trees!(small twigs from seed)

    Here is a link that might be useful: Daves Garden Watchdog

  • 18 years ago

    theaceofspades, I don't really want to be seen as coming to the defence of a bad apple but it is possible they sell trees locally that they don't sell online.

    I still would not buy anything from them though, even at half price. Where I live there are not many varieties will fruit and I have to know what I am getting or all money and hard work is a total waste.

  • 18 years ago

    thisisme,

    "I don't really want to be seen as coming to the defence of a bad apple but it is possible they sell trees locally that they don't sell online."

    Are you thinking that they own the acres of evergreens shown on the Autumn Ridge website 'about us' link?

    Click 'Learn More' from Autumn Ridge homepage;

    " McMinnville, TN, our home, is known as the Nursery Capital Of The World. It is the home of over 350 licensed nurseries. This means we buy directly from the grower in most all instances, thereby eliminating all middlemen and passing the savings on to you, our customer."

    Likely the photo is of a real nursery.

  • 18 years ago

    I'll second (3rd, 4th, 5th, etc) recommending Adams County Nursery. Although I only got 3 trees from them, all are doing just fine. I would have gone to them again this year, but they were out of the varieties I was looking for.

    It sounds like you are starting to get somewhere with the person on the phone... but, if not, I too would recommend the using the BBB. Early this year I had a defective product and the company wouldn't give me the time of day. It wasn't until I got the BBB involved that they actually took action.

    I wish you the best in your quest.

    -Glenn