Software
Houzz Logo Print
gonebananas_gw

Does Saran wrap make a reasonable substitute for Parafilm?

18 years ago

I'm just about to run out of Parafilm, and have more scionwood waiting for me in the fridge.

I bought another type of tape from a nursery catalog but don't like it. It needs tying and I don't know whether I can cover the buds with it. It is narrower and thicker and less stretchable.

Long ago I read that one of the kitchen film wraps (I forget which one) did not let oxygen pass through, but that may not have been correct and may not matter here.

Comments (5)

  • 18 years ago

    i'm guessing you're doing cleft or whip and tongue grafts?

    I don't know about Saran but I'll bet it would work. I've been tempted to try Glad Cling too. I know some people cut strips from polyethelene bags.

    You don't say what you are grafting, but I've had my best success on apple, pear, and plum using a rubber to bring the parts together and then wrapping with parafilm. No wax or compounds necessary. I'd do the same if replacing the parafilm with budding tape or paper tape or black plastic, but might consider a coating to help reduce drying. A friend wraps the scion with "dry" tape (orange flagging tape with no adhesive) to protect the bark, and then wraps that with black plastic tape, and then coats the whole thing with tar. Eventually it all cleans up.

    Often it's feasible to slip a plastic bag over a graft to reduce drying.

    Lots of others here with more experience- I hope you'll hear from them, too.

    Good luck,

    M

  • 18 years ago

    "I've had my best success on apple, pear, and plum using a rubber to bring the parts together and then wrapping with parafilm."

    Thanks.

    I'm budding and grafting valuable (limited scionwood) pears. Dormant buds and scions onto sprouted or sprouting rootstock. I usually do exactly as you say. I have the bands but need to keep everything moist and can't wait on a Parafilm shipment. I'm still not great on the whip-and-tongue "carpentry." I probably don't have all cambrium surfaces matched so I want to reduce water stress as much as possible for a few weeks. The buds are probably less of a problem in terms of good contact.

  • 18 years ago

    Other than being difficult to handle it should do the job. I am not sure if it will degrade eventually and would watch for that. Al

  • 18 years ago

    I love w&t if the calipers are close, otherwise am comfortable enough with plain old cleft grafts.

    I think that you've nailed the crucial issues: Dormant scions or buds to active rootstocks ensures ample juices for the scions when they take off. Matching cambia is essential, of course, and in grafting, just as in economies, liquidity is a must-have. (Little joke there, hehe.)

    It is possible to graft active tissue to active tissue, but the window is narrower, if I understand correctly. I haven't had to work that way, but posters here say it can be done, and I believe them. As always, I stand ready to be corrected.

    In short:

    Cut them clean, line them up, snug them down, keep them damp.

    "Head 'em up, move 'em out ..."

    Good luck,

    M

    ps- what are your pear choices? I have a single tree with Gold Spice, Flemish Beauty, Frost, Ure, D'Anjou, Clapps Favorite, Winter Nellis, Warden Seckel, Pezzuti's Pennsylvania Wonder, and am adding White Doyenne and Dana's Hovey.We'll see ...

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks all.

    I am in the epicenter of fireblight and summer heat (which, however, I think inhibits FB when it's over 90). I'm grafting reported FB tolerant or resistant selections from many decades back: Ayers, Carrick, Waite, Tennessee, Pototoc, and (of all things) Good Christian. We will see if they live up to their reputations. If they do I will gladly give scionwood to others in my region (or whoever is interested). I am trying quite a few others too, but I'm just getting started and they are all as yet in (or soon to be in) 10-25 gallon pots. They will go in the ground eventually. Fortunately even fairly large pear trees transplant pretty easily, even bare root.