Software
Houzz Logo Print
hem_krish

Questions on fertilizers

17 years ago

I bought three kinds of fertilizers a) Water soluble powder which contains NPK [packet does not mention proportion (:-0) but mentions that it is good for flowering plants and can be used for all plants in general] b) Liquid fertilizer containing micronutrients not containing NPK c) Water soluble foliar fertilizer containing NPK 19-19-19 which I assume is balanced.

1) Which one do I use and when? I feel I should choose one between a) and c) but can I also use b) in conjunction as it contains other nutrients?

2) I initially started planting in dirt and sand but after reading these forums, started planting in peat + perlite + vermiculite. Will the fertilizer regime be same for plants in soil and and the ones in soilless mix?

3) I am confused about foliar vs root fertilizer. Can a foliar fertilizer be diluted and used while watering the plant instead of spraying on leaves? Which method is more effective?

4) Here in India, its really hot in summer and winters are cool and pleasant. I doubt whether plants will go into dormancy here. Can I continue to use fertilizers even in winters here?

5) How do I judge the effect of a dilute fertilizer? I used a) in water, diluting it to half the recommended strength and tried it on my asparagus springeri. The next day, some of the tiny leaves turned white as if burnt to ashes. I watered the plant immediately to wash out the salts and know that I should dilute it further. However, if I dilute it to 1/4 or 1/8 how will I know that the fertilizer is doing any good?

Comments (5)

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    1) "Which one do I use and when? I feel I should choose one between a) and c) but can I also use b) in conjunction as it contains other nutrients?"

    If you NEED to supply nutrients via foliar applications for houseplants, there is either something wrong with your nutrition supplementation program or there is a culturally induced deficiency, usually caused by the soil. Foliar applications are effective at supplying nutrients when they are both scarce in the soil and the plant is growing so robustly it cannot assimilate them quickly enough to allow it to grow at its genetic potential. More on this later, but there really is no reason you cannot supply all the known essential elements in one application, with a single product.

    If you ARE using a fertilizer that supplies only a few of the minor elements, then a second application of a micro-nutrient preparation is advisable. Some lack several of the minor elements, and most soluble fertilizers lack both Ca and Mg, so these elements need to be considered, especially in aging soils.

    It's best to supply nutrients in the same ratio that plants use them, unless you are using nutrition to induce a particular growth-related result. If you take an average of the ratio of NPK that a huge % of plants use, you'll find that they use it in a ratio of approximately 10:1.5:7. (ratios are different than the %s reported, though they are related) Since fertilizer formulas report phosphorus as P2O5, not actual phosphorus (P), and potassium is reported as K2O, not actual potassium (K), to convert P2O5 to actual P supplied, multiply the P2O5 value by 0.43, and to convert K2O to actual K supplied, multiply the K2O value by 0.83.

    I said all that technical stuff so I could say that .... after the math is done, almost all plants use nutrients in something extremely close to a 3:1:2, NPK ratio, so fertilizers like 24-8-16, 12-4-8, and 9-3-6 (all three are 3:1:2 RATIOS) are excellent choices for almost all plants if your goal is normal growth.

    2) "I initially started planting in dirt and sand but after reading these forums, started planting in peat + perlite + vermiculite. Will the fertilizer regime be same for plants in soil and and the ones in soilless mix?"

    No, but it isn't necessarily a soil vs soilless issue. The mix you described is a heavy (water retentive) soil and you will not be able to water freely, which will have an effect on the the frequency with which you should fertilize and the strength. With a soil like that, you should have a strategy in place that will allow you to leach salts from the soil regularly before you plant in it, and the fertilizer (and watering) strategy will be quite different and more difficult to manage effectively than if you were growing in a lighter (not water-retentive) soil.

    3) "I am confused about foliar vs root fertilizer. Can a foliar fertilizer be diluted and used while watering the plant instead of spraying on leaves? Which method is more effective?"

    The effectiveness of foliar fertilizers varies to the extreme. First, only some plants can absorb ions (and a few small proteins of little significance) through their cuticle and allow them to enter the nutrient stream. This means that only soluble solutions or the tiny ionic fraction of organic fertilizers like fish emulsion are able to pass through the cuticle of SOME plants and make it to the nutrient stream. Fish emulsion depends on micro-organisms in the soil to break it down into elemental form so it can be absorbed. These organisms are not present in measurable populations on foliage and would lack the moisture necessary to keep them viable anyway, so foliar applications of FE and other organic amendments are not measurably effective as a foliar spray.

    To answer your question directly: Any fertilizer that supplies nutrients via foliage as the primary pathway would supply the same nutrients via normal root pathways.

    Note that many nutrients are immobile in the plant (mostly micro-nutrients and Ca), so quick fixes like adding Fe (iron) via foliar applications may green up the leaves temporarily, but do nothing to actually relieve the deficiency the entire organism is dealing with.

    4) "Here in India, its really hot in summer and winters are cool and pleasant. I doubt whether plants will go into dormancy here. Can I continue to use fertilizers even in winters here?"

    There are more than one type of dormancy, and you have to consider quiescence, a period where some plants simply take a rest. Predictive dormancy occurs when a plant enters a dormant phase before the onset of adverse conditions. For example, photoperiod (day length) and decreasing temperatures "tell" plants winter is on the way & it's time for sleep. Consequential dormancy occurs when a plant enters a dormant phase after adverse conditions have arisen - commonly drought. Other plants simply take a break when day length stimulates the chemical messengers that tell the plant to slow down.

    You should watch for these signs and react appropriately. HOW you react depends in large part on what state the plant is in, what the soil the plant is in is like, and your watering habits.

    5) "How do I judge the effect of a dilute fertilizer? I used a) in water, diluting it to half the recommended strength and tried it on my asparagus springeri. The next day, some of the tiny leaves turned white as if burnt to ashes. I watered the plant immediately to wash out the salts and know that I should dilute it further. However, if I dilute it to 1/4 or 1/8 how will I know that the fertilizer is doing any good?"

    I'm going to leave a link to a discussion about fertilizing containerized plants because I've only touched on it here. I will say though, that it's not just the strength of the soluble salts in the fertilizer solution you need to consider. ALL the soluble salts in the soil AND in the fertilizer solution COMBINE to make up the concentration of the soil solution; so even though the plant may easily tolerate a 14 strength solution when there are a low level of soluble salts in the soil, it could be the straw that broke the camel's back if the soluble salts level of the soil was high when you applied the fertilizer. Again, this issue comes full circle to the soil you're using.

    Al

    Here is a link that might be useful: More about fertilizing containerized plants

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I just need to pop in here w/ a quick note to our friend Al (as this stuff is rather more technical than I readily follow), BUT I do read it:

    Dear Al,

    3rd line up from the bottom -- shall we assume you meant to type "1/4 strength solution"? Otherwise, "14 strength solution" might be rather confusing. Just imagine the folks trying to sort that out!! ;>)

    (PG) Karen

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Al gave a general (if not in dept) rundown on feeding, however it's really hard to give specifics unless you are telling us what you plan on feeding with said fertilizers. I would suggest not to go into debt over chemicals until you KNOW what plants you want to grow. Foliar feeding is wonderful for plants like jungle cacti, aroids, ferns, and hoyas which depend on bird droppings or other things to feed them in the wild, they really do no better than a regular feeding on most other plants, and can burn them. If we knew what kinds of plants you have or are going to get, then we'd be able to help better.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I did forget the s/ash, Karen - sorry. It should, of course, have been 1/4 strength, not 14 strength; and if anyone actually GOT that far besides Karen & Mentha, I apologize to them for any confusion as well.

    Al

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thank you for the detailed response Tapla! Cant say I understood 100% of it, but at least I now know some basic principles of fertilizers which is good enough for me for now. Your thread on container fertilizing made sense to me as well. Im sure IÂll learn more with experience. Thanks again.