Software
Houzz Logo Print
ocsusan

Soils and Proportions-Need Help

19 years ago

Would someone be so kind as to describe the "function" of the various planting mediums, media? I'm most interested in 1)Potting Soil 2)Sand 3)Peat Moss 4)Perlite

5)Vermiculite. I've been reading about the mixes and proportions for different plants, but don't really know what each one's contribution is. Thanks so much for any help.

Comments (4)

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    1. Potting soil - used as a general medium for plants grown in containers. Potting soil is any mixture of ingredients suitable for plant growth. Potting soil can be homemade or store bought. Specific soils can be found for cacti/succulents, orchids, and just about anything else. There is a large range of quality as well. From the very cheap that doesn't drain well and will will your plants if not amended to high quality, sterile, organic soil.

    2. Sand - sharp sand is used as an amendment to increase drainage for plants that require good aeration, such as cacti and succulents. Is it also useful to add weight to a pot so plants do not tip or blow over. Soilless mixes are often very light.

    3. Peat Moss - makes a great base for a potting mix. It is harvested from peat bogs where microbial decomposition is very slow and the plant debris accumulate faster than they decompose. There are a couple kinds of mosses used for growing media. The most familiar is the baled peat moss you find in most lawn and garden stores. It is brown in color with medium to fine texture. It has a very high water retention capacity and has a low pH. Sphagnum moss is something different. It is a long strand moss that is not decomposed. Sphagnum moss is typically used for orchids.

    4. Perlite - is siliceous rock that has been heated to very high temperature and hence expanded. The mineral structure is similar to glass. It is white in color and very porous. Typically added to soil to increase drainage and water retention. Perlite will not alter the pH of a potting mix. It is useful for propagating cutting and starting seeds.

    5. Vermiculite - is actually a type of 2:1 clay forming from weathered micas. Because it is a 2:1 clay, it is expansive, meaning it shrinks and swells upon drying and hydration, respectively. Horticulturists use vermiculite in sandy soils for better moisture retention and clay soils to improve drainage. It can be used to root cuttings and start seeds as well. pH can range from 7 to slightly higher. It has a high cation exchange capacity (CEC) and thus helps the soil retain vital nutrients. Be sure to moisten vermiculite before pouring or using in order to keep dust to a minimum. Recent events have suggested vermiculite may contain asbestos. If you're hesitant to use it, wear a mask.

    Here is my favorite homemade potting mix recipe.

    6 gallons peat moss screened to 1/4 inch + 1/4 cup lime
    4.5 gallons vermiculite
    4.5 gallons compost screened to 1/4 inch
    1.5 cups of fertilizer below
    Mix well these ingredients
    -2 cups rock phosphate
    -2 cups green sand
    -1/2 cup bone meal
    -1/4 cup blood meal

    Here's another recipe

    Equal Parts
    - coarse vermiculite
    - screened peat moss
    - coarse sand
    - decomposed leaf mold screened to 1/4 inch
    - good garden soil screened to 1/4 inch

    You can probably guess that the second soil will be much heavier due to the garden soil and sand. If you're concerned about weed seeds, you can solarize the garden soil. Simply place it under a clear plastic sheet and let cook for a few weeks to a month. This should sterilize the soil and you'll be off to the races.

    Good luck

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    1) Potting soil can be an infinite number of combinations of both organic and inorganic ingredients, many of which you mentioned. Some commercial potting soils are reasonably good and some should never be labeled as or used as potting soil. Price is no guide.

    2) Sand, as most of you think of it, is comprised of small pieces of minerals, usually quartz or granite, that can improve drainage in soils, but in the sizes we normally think of it (and I'm including builder's sand in this category) the added drainage is usually always at the expense of the air holding ability of the soil. In other words, you might improve drainage to some degree by adding sand to some soils, but it usually always has a detrimental effect on aeration. For that reason, I suggest you leave fine sands out of container soils. Sand that is regular in size and from 1/2 BB size to BB size can often be used with good effect, though. Sand is poor at holding water or nutrients.

    3) Sphagnum peat is used to hold water and nutrients

    4) Perlite is an expanded mineral product that aids drainage and aeration to soils, but also provides some water retention in micro-pores

    5) Vermiculite is also an expanded mineral product and is used primarily for it's moisture retaining ability. While it provides some aeration initially, it quickly breaks down & loses that ability. I generally never use it in container soils, though I do use it in some coarse mixes for cacti/succulents.

    6) You left out pine bark. It is an excellent soil component, providing superior aeration and structural stability when compared to peat. I use it (or fine fir bark) as the primary ingredient in most of my container soils.

    7) Turface (or a similar product) is also a wonderful soil ingredient. I actually grow many plants in 100% Turface with excellent results. It is a baked clay granule, nearly ceramic in nature, that provides drainage and water/nutrient retention.

    If most of the folks here that grow in peat based soils would switch to a gritty mix of Turface, pine bark, coarse sand (like I mentioned above) and a little peat, most of the problems encountered that are not related to light issues (including insect infestations) would largely go away, and I can back that statement with sound reasoning, science, and practical experience.

    Al

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Please note that M Taggart and I were diligently typing our replies at the same time, so my post is not a reply to M Taggart's - just my own observations & thinking. ;o)

    Al

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I am MOST grateful. I can't believe that you took such time and effort for such detail. I am not new to house plants, but I can surely say that I have never done right by them even though lots of them lived. I decided that it was time to do the job properly when I repotted, and probably in the long run save myself a lot of time on maintaining, not to mention have much happier "kids". Thanks again.