Software
Houzz Logo Print
ebeccarayray

Mulch under soil too acidic?

17 years ago

I am a leader in creating a 1 acre community vegetable garden on my school campus. The land that we have been allotted is basically a huge mound of sterile, nutrient deficient fill dirt that has been covered in about a 4 in layer of mulch.

A few of the members in the group feel that the first step should be to remove all of the mulch (over 10 000 cubic feet of it) because it would be too acidic to simply place the fertile compost on top (this compost is slightly basic). The plan is to remove it with a bunch of volunteers, some rakes and some shovels.

I feel that removing the mulch is going to be an enormous task that is not worth the time and effort involved and will slow down the project. I also think that the decomposing wood will actually add nutrients to the dead soil beneath it.

I do not know the pH of the mulch. It is a mixture of various wood chips, but probably mostly oak.

Does anyone have any advice for me? Do you think that removing the mulch is necessary?

Comments (5)

  • 17 years ago

    I would not, because any acidity could be easily compensated by adding some ground limeston or dolomite. Bigger problem would be nitrogen starvation from the decomposition of the wood chips.topdress with chicken manure and till the whole works into the top 6-7 inches of soil would be my solution.

  • 17 years ago

    Removing the mulch would be a waste of good organic material, IMO. Ammend it with a nitrogen fertilizer to aid its decomposition and lime to neutralize the pH. That will require far less labor and give you a good start in building up some decent soil. A simple, inexpensive pH test (possibly free at your garden store) will tell you how much lime to use.

    Jim

  • 17 years ago

    Umm. Let's set the facts straight as to "nitrogen starvation from the decomposition of the wood chips"

    Doesn't happen unless the chips are mixed into the soil.

  • 17 years ago

    Some of the best posters in these forums have already given you excellent advice, let me add my 0.02.

    As they say, you have to add N and raise the pH, but by no means pull the mulch out. The wood chips have no N, but they have significant amounts of P and K, that will be helpful over the long term. They will also provide plenty of organic matter.

    Let me also add that many plants will go deeper than 4 (or 8) inches, so that the lower pH zone will not affect them. You could also instruct the gardeners to plant sensitive vegetables deeper for a couple of years. These include greens, brassica, and peas. Your site will probably not be great for the first two years for some small-rooted greens, things like lettuce and tatsoi. But the tomatoes, potatoes, cucurbitas, carrots or radicchio, will be unaffected. My guess is that the beans will be unaffected also.

    Now, how to raise pH and nitrogen on the cheap. For one acre, I think you are looking at 1-2 tons of lime or the same weight in wood ash. You might find it cheaper to simply give trash cans to people who heat with wood (I save and use all my wood ash), collect the cans in March, and spread right away. One good rain and you are good to go. Spread it everywhere as all plants will benefit. Wood ash is a significantly better fertilizer than lime.

    For the N, you are looking at either 10 tons of chicken manure or some 400 lbs of urea (I think that would be $160). Spread it only where needed. It will not be needed under the beans or carrots, for example.

    Long term wood chips make soil as good as other compost, and as neutral. Even clover will grow vigorously in it. I plant in wood chips all the time, following a succession rule (first potatoes, then squashes and cukes, then tomatoes or beans). I sprinkle urea on top. I get to compost, mulch and garden in one shot, at the expense of slightly reduced yields.

    For cabbage, chard, beets, tell your gardeners to put more lime for all and more urea for all except beets at the base of the plant.

  • 17 years ago

    Thank you all!

Sponsored
Peabody Landscape Group
Average rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars8 Reviews
Franklin County's Reliable Landscape Design & Contracting