Software
Houzz Logo Print
alpharetta_gw

Two pear trees or 3x1 pear?

18 years ago

Hello All,

I need your advice. I have kind of limited place, so I am thinking about getting 3x1 pear fruit tree from Raintree. Is it good option, or I still should go with two seperate pear trees (for cross pollintion) if I have enough space?

I am living in Atlanta Metro area, where it's hot and humid and drought. Any pear variety best suite for my area?

Thanks

Alpharetta

Comments (6)

  • 18 years ago

    Plant 3 different varieties north to south spaced as close as 7 ft apart or closer. Asian pears are the easiest tree fruit to grow and they look cool. My Shinseiki pear gets water and mulch and they ripen over 3 weeks beginning late August(zone7). They are addictive. Johnsons Nursery, Ga. has the ripening dates listed for your area. Shinseiki Hosui and Olympic are the best and ripen July August and September.

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks Theaceofspades for the advice. I do have asian pears grown in my yard. They are fantastic! My question above is for European pears:

    Combo: 3x1 Euro Pear (Orcas,Resc,Hghlnd,HDelight)OHxF97
    Standalone: Barnet Perry Pear/OHxF97, Barnett Perry Pear/Common Pear rootstock, ect

  • 18 years ago

    Alpharetta, FYI in your standalone choice you list perry pears only, which are non-eating pears designed for making fermented pear cider -- perry. I have several 3x1 trees but prefer a close planting of different varieties. You can plant 2-4 different varieties as close as 1-2' and its not much differerent than the 3-way and you also get to pick the varieties. Or space them 6' apart as Ace mentions - also a good method. Personally I have all my pears at 2-3' apart. For these close planting methods you do need to make sure to prune them so they do not crowd out each other, but the 3-way will have the same issues.

    The main reason why I prefer the multiple trees to the 3-way is if your tree gets fireblight in the roots (an all too common occurrence in Atlanta) you will lose all your pears with the 3-way but if you have 4 in one hole you are just back to three in one hole. I lost four apple trees this year due to fireblight in the roots. Speaking of fireblight, I would only plant highly resistant pears there. See below for recommended varieties.

    Scott

    Here is a link that might be useful: Georgia pears

  • 18 years ago

    Scott makes several good points.
    Fireblight resistance is a major consideration in HotLanta.
    Unless you're planning to make perry, or you like eating green, unripe persimmons, you do not want perry pears - they are, for all intents and purposes, inedible - or at least, not very tasty, often with lots of astringency.
    Magness and Warren are top-quality pears, but both are pollen-sterile, and neither are very attractive to bees, as they produce little or no nectar. Anecdotal reports - and I'm beginning to believe them - are that they are best grown as a limb grafted into other variety trees here and there, rather than as a stand-alone tree - at least you'll get some bees visiting the Magness/Warren blossoms while they're working the other variety - as a stand-alone tree, there's not much to attract a bee to visit. Some pear enthusiasts are also claiming that unless you put Warren/Magness on a dwarfing rootstock, like quince(the fireblight susceptibility there scares me mightily), you'll wait 15 years or more for them to bear - and they may never fruit heavily.
    While I like Keiffer, I know that many folks don't, but it can take FB hits, shrug 'em off and keep on growing and bearing. Douglas is reputed to be better than Keiffer, while retaining similar FB-resistance. Pineapple is another one I like, and a friend in Cookeville TN is raving about the Pineapple pear crop this year - heavenly! Dabney is supposed to be another good FB-resistant hybrid selection that I didn't see on the list Scott linked.

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks for all the useful info. I will not go with combo pear 3x1.

    Jonhson Nursery (in north GA) has Pineapple and Seckel (Sugar) pears, which look so attractive to me. I may try that one.

    Cheers
    Alpharetta

  • 16 years ago

    Scekel and pineapple would be my choice if you only have two, maybe a orient for a good cooking canning pear but they get big, but nice landscape appeal.