Software
Houzz Logo Print
axel_hb

McIntosh style apples

17 years ago

Can people post their experience with the best tasting McIntosh style apple? My McIntosh style, I mean one of the many McIntosh flavored or related apples. The flesh is usually very white, crunchy, fine rather than coarse texture, highly aromatic, with that special McIntosh flavor.

A sample list of varieties that come to mind is:

- McIntosh

- jonamac (Jonathan x McIntosh)

- Newtosh (Newtown pippin X McIntosh)

- Liberty (Macoun x Purdue 54-12)

- Macoun (McIntosh x Jersey Black )

- spartan (Yellow Newtown X McIntosh)

- empire (McIntosh x Red Delicious)

- fameuse (rumored to be one of the parents of McIntosh)

- Early McIntosh (Yellow Transparent x McIntosh)

- Barry (McIntosh x Cox's Orange Pippin)

- Sweet McIntosh (not actually a McIntosh sport)

- Sharon (McIntosh x Longfield)

- Shay (Was a mcintosh like variety from Raintree)

- Berner Rosen

- summerrd (Summerland 5-4-8(McIntosh x Golden Delicious)

- Viking (Parentage includes Jonathan, Delicious, Williams Early Red, Early McIntosh and Starr)

Out of all these, only Shay and McCoun have proven to be strongly aromatic like McIntosh for me. Even fameuse isn't very aromatic when compared to McIntosh.

I'd love to hear from you what you think is the best McIntosh style apple.

Comments (13)

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Great topic, Axel! I spend a lot of time thinking about these "schools" of apple taste, and I don't think they are very well documented anywhere.

    In the McIntosh school (soft skin, on the sour side, a particular aromatics) I would also put
    Worcester Pearmain - very similar to Mac to me but no known common ancestor
    Akane - child of Worcester Pearmain x Jonathan and a "Jonamac" type to me
    Cortland - McIntosh x Ben Davis
    Doctor Mathews - a mac-like apple with an anise twist
    Belle Fleur Rouge - a more sour version of McIntosh

    I would be hard-pressed to compare which had most of the McIntosh aromatics based on my distant memory and not having tasted any of these side-by-side. My favorites are probably Akane and Doctor Mathews.

    Scott

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Nice to see McIntosh getting some love.

    McIntosh isn't aromatic for me in my yard. It's probably because McIntosh is the bar that's been set for me.
    Cortland is very aromatic in my yard.

    In most years I tell when the Cortland is ripe by how strong the smell is near the tree.
    With McIntosh I go by how many have dropped and checking taste. If there is aroma it's not strong enough to be noticed outside.

    Regular McIntosh is my favorite all around apple. It's the only apple I really like for fresh eating.
    Not that I've tried them all but IMO the original can't be improved upon, only refined for specific purposes. The original is already the perfect all around apple.

    Empire was a big flop for my tastes. It didn't improve RD, it downgraded McIntosh.
    Some of those others sound very interesting.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks for the info, this is what I was looking for. Courtland sounds very interesting, and so does dr mathews.

    Scott, what are some of the other "schools" of apple flavor?

    For me, the McIntosh school is my top favorite type of apple, but McIntosh itself doesn't have enough flavor in my garden, I prefer all the derived apples, the aromatics is what draws me.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Out here in NY, where Macintosh was king until quite recently, I have noticed that Macs are not one apple. I think there are several strains that ripen about the same time and a few more that are early Macs. Jersey Mac is one of the earlies, but there are others.

    The quality of the apples have a wide range as does coloration. There is one weak old tree of an early strain that has exceptional apples while at another site there is an early strain where the apples are merely good, at another site, where the apples are just a bit early the quality is poor. There is no way for me to know how much the quality of the apples are being affected by strain and how much by site. There is as much variation, in my experience, with the main season strains.

    One apple I'd like to add to the list is the Spartan, which is close enough to Mac to often be sold as Macintosh but is a much better storage apple with similar aromatics. It doesn't have that distinctive crunch against soft flesh that really distinguishes Macintosh- as much as Mac's aromatics, IMO. Spartan has firmer flesh and I hear, some disease resistance. It is a Cox-Mac cross, I believe.

    I appreciate Macintosh as an exceptional apple but don't care for it much myself as far as an apple I eat a lot of. I prefer denser flesh types like Baldwin, Pink Lady, Braeburn and Goldrush. Good thing- they all store much better.

    There are no kinder trees as far as regular cropping and easy pruning than Macintosh. You can count on flowers on 2-year wood.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Axel, in the modern schools there are obviously Golden Delicious, Red Delicious, and Jonathan schools since those guys have been used so often in breeding, and I expect there will be a Honeycrisp school in 50 years. I am more interested in the older schools since the parentage is often lost. The school that I found the most striking is the yellow-flesh school; it is a seemingly random collection of old apples all of which have dense, strongly yellow-colored flesh with a similar sweet/sharp flavor having relatively few aromatics. It is a school of apple which has no modern members. Here is my take on the "dense yellow" school:

    Pomme Cloche aka Glockenapfel - I consider this the center of the school, probably because it was the first to fruit for me.
    Court Pendu Plat - a milder version
    Pomme Clochard (haven't had enough to describe differences yet)
    Sturmer Pippin - similar to Cloche, maybe a touch milder
    Orleans Reinette - identical to Cloche by memory (looks totally different however so obviously not the same apple)
    Roxbury Russet - not as hard-fleshed but flesh color and taste fit.
    Pitmaston Pineapple - Perhaps the most intense-flavored of the school, but Cloche/Orleans are close

    There is of course also the well-documented Cox school, both old and new progeny. I have noticed others but don't yet have a good enough handle on what the clustering is. One I am working on for example is there seems to be a savory school with something like Berlepsch, Pigeonnet Rouge, Rambour Franc, Reinette de Cuzy, and Black Gilliflower. There is also a modern member of this school I know I have eaten in the past but I can't remember what it is since I haven't run into one in a long time.

    And then there are the truly unique apples which are a long ways from all the rest. The biggest standout there to me is Wickson. That is one heck of an apple. Too bad it cracked last year and is being biennial this year.

    Scott

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Harvestman, Spartan is on the list I originally posted, I really enjoy this apple. When I looked it up, it's parentage is Yellow Newtown X McIntosh, same as for newtosh. The only apple I found that is a MCIntosh X Cox is an obscure apple named "Barry". I don't know anything about it. I was surprised to have a difficult time finding a McIntosh X Golden Delicious cross, most likely because of the difference in flowering time, but golden delicious blooms over a longer period of time, so it should be doable.

    Scott, here are the clusterings I am starting to see - of course, take with a grain of salt, this is hard to do.

    1) Sweet sugar apples: Golden delicious, red delicious, jonagold, vanilla pippin, dorsett golden, Hawaii, Hudson's Golden gem, crown prince rudolf, cinnamon spice (delicious, this is surely a seedling of golden delicious), honeycrisp, fuji, and a whole army of Japanese crosses.

    2) Yellow Transparent apples: that includes yellow transparent, transparent to croncels, Winter banana, and a few other obscure apples. They all have the property that the skin is transluent, and they are either flat in flavor, but good texture if picked too early, or very sweet but mealy if picked too late, and they all share the property that they have a very small window of perfection, on the order of hours with yellow transparent, and on the order of a couple of days with Winter banana.

    3) The culinary apples with cidery flavors: A synonym for this is the "gravenstein" school, cidery, good balance of acids and sugars but typically more on the acid side. To me, this includes red berlepsh, ananas reinette, orleans reinette, belle de boscoop, spigold, Anna, york, st. edmunds pippin, allington pippin, Waltana, the list goes on and on. These all have those classic, old world "cider cave" flavors, they are very "earthy" apples. I think this is the same as the Scott "Cloche" school.

    4) Harvestman's dense fleshed apples, to me, they're all one school that includes pink lady, granny smith, lady williams, braeburn, Hauer pippin, sundowner, and so on. They are all late, store incredibly well, have very well balanced sugars and acids, on the acid side when picked immature but still of very good quality, and on the sugary side when tree ripened, a.k.a. granny smith for example.

    5) The cox school, can't forget that one. That includes cox, arlet, rubinette, lamb abbey pearmain, and so on. These are typically early Fall apples that have limited storage capabilities, and have very rich flavors, if I have to think of a flavor descriptor, I come up with the word "dense", as in very concentrated. They are not "light" apples. You can't just eat one casually, they really draw your attention to what's happening in your mouth.

    6) The strawberry school, these are mostly Summer apples with a lot of strawberry overtones. Pink pearl is a classic there, if you juice it, you will get a strawberry flavored pink colored apple juice, and the strawberry flavor isn't imagined because of the pink color, it's really there. A number of English Summer apples also fall into this category, so does Summer rambo.

    There are several other schools, one is the anise flavored school from France, it's not that popular due to the fact that a good 30% of the population has an aversion to anise/licorice aromatics. Another one is the rasberry school, dominated by calville rouge d'automne, firm, red skinned, dominantly acidic but simple flavored with rasberry overtones. I know there are others, but I haven't found them yet.

    Then there is the "potato" school, or peasant school for lack of a better descriptor. Dominated by anktonova, these are apples that are rugged, starchy, coarse, I'd almost use the word "medieval", the sort of thing you'd expect to find on a rugged old wood dining table in the Russian countryside. They are mostly processing apples that are barely good enough as culinary apples. I put York in the gravenstein school, but I think it also belongs here.

    I am sure there are many more schools, but these are the ones that jump out at me.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    If anyone can mention a good replacement for MacIntosh that retains most of the intense flavor, and has a bit more scab resistance, I am all ears. MacIntosh does very well in the Puget Sound but it really gets apple Scab. The newer replacements like Spartan, seem to have problem sizing and the flavor well it is just less of it. Macoun has a closer to Mac. flavor but again the Apple Scab.
    I agree it is one of the very best flavored apples. Unfortunately it seems to bruise if you even frown at it.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I like Liberty apples. They are very Mac-like, and if you like Macs and Macouns I suspect you'll like Liberties. The tree I have, on unknown semi-dwarf rootstock, is about 15 feet in height after ten years in the ground. It's a very healthy tree (rust, blight, and scab resistant) and a vigorous grower. It's a little hard to prune- wants to do its own thing. I find it necessary to thin well over 90% of the fruit set every year, and still feel that I haven't thinned enough. The apples could be larger and could keep longer, but when they're right they're great.

    I like them for pies and I think they make a "tolerable' cider, but then, I'm easy.

    Good luck,

    M

    Here is a link that might be useful: Scab resistance in Liberty

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I have to admit, I will never be a vinophile type of malusphile. It is interesting to hear of apple descriptions that are reminiscent of wine tastings but I lack the flavor memory for these types of detailed categoriztions. If I have 4 types of really good apples to get me through winter, I'm a happy man. I can keep going back to just a few without getting bored. At least it saves me the trouble of having to keep up with so many different types in storage.

    Even without a great taste memory, I feel quite confident to say that Liberty is not a very good substitute for Mac if you are either into Mac's unique texture or its aromatics. Mac is soft and crunchy at the same time- Liberty is a harder apple with a pleasent sugar acid balance but not much aroma in my opinion.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hman, I concede your greater experience, but may I argue that here in my neck of the woods Mac and Liberty are much closer in character than you have described?

    In fact, one of my issues with Liberty is that it doesn't really hold its texture any better than Macs do, and that is to say they both go mealy too easily.

    But you're right, I think, in saying that Liberty is harder and has less aroma, sad to say.

    Either way each, when captured at the right time, is wonderful.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    My McIntosh doesn't go mealy. If anything it gets overly wet when it's beyond it's prime and making sauce inside the apple.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I believe Liberty stores better than Mac in cold storage as well as controlled cold storage. No matter what you do with Macintosh and Cortland they loose there texture quickly. Not speaking from experience here (as far as storing Liberty) so I may be wrong, but this is something that I've read.

    Liberty is a good apple and I'm sure it's a different apple in different places. I don't think it's a matter of experience though, although there's going to be some variability from season to season. As I said, my "physical" memory is not very good. But the Macintosh texture and aroma are so distinctive, even I can quickly distinguish their absence in Liberty. Liberty is crisp but not crunchy.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I ditto Liberty. Here in the Willamette Valley, my Liberties are quite similar to Macs, minus the aromatics. A good eating apple and easy growing for the home garden.

    I'm looking for a good storage apple for this area. Suggestions?