Software
Houzz Logo Print
pgmike

SNAPPER Mulcher or Hi-Vac

20 years ago

I live in South Florida and need a really reliable 21-inch self propelled mower. I've had a snapper for almost 30 years, and it is great. I'm thinking of getting a new one with a Kawasaki engine, but don't know if I'd be better with a hi-vac or a mulcher. Florida's St Augustine grows thick and wet. I always mulch so I thought the mulcher was the way to go. Then I saw the hi-vac which is supposed to create more suction making bagging easier. Does it make sense to go with the hi-vac in mulching mode since the machine should produce more suction making the grass stand up better to be mulched by the Ninja blades?? Anybody have a hi-vac that they mulch with? Which way should I go....mulcher or hi-vac?? Any general thoughts on the new snappers with the Kawasaki engine?

Comments (10)

  • 20 years ago

    I would advise you against getting a Snapper altogether. I was in a situation similar to yours....I had an old Snapper that finally quit after thirteen years and wanted to replace it with a new Snapper. Boy, was I disappointed. The customer Service was lousy, it took them eight months to register my warranty card. There is an issue with the RPMs of the engine that affects the suction quality. You had an older Snapper to compare the new one to. The new Snapper will not perform any where near as good as your old Snapper and you will be disappointed. If you want to mulch, go with the Toro SR4 or the Honda. Do not go with Snapper.

  • 20 years ago

    I bought a 2005 "mulching" Snapper and after close examination, its essentially a HiVac(deck design is the same) without the bag and a Ninja blade instead of a generic blade. Does it mulch? Well, it never bogs down in wet or heavy grass, but it does tend to kick out un-mulched clippings on the left side. Snapper gets mixed reviews here. I have never owned a Toro Super Recylcer (SR4), but I also never see complaints about their mulching ability.

  • 20 years ago

    pgmike- I bought a commercial hi-vac witha kawi engine this spring.I cut centiped mostly but have a patch of st. augustine in the corner of my yard.this mower does not bog down even when cutting two wks of growth. I chose the hy-vac because of leaves in the fall. I don't think that you will be dissapointed with either mower.This mower is well built and I don't think you'll find a better engine than the kawi fji80v.Look around and compare different mowers. Thats what I did, and I'm happy with the choice I made.

  • 20 years ago

    the ninja is the best mulching sys there is. however the ninja blade creates NO lift so the hi vac dosnt come into play. i have used snappers for many years in my lawn biz and they are not reliabel in the least. they however out preform every other mower in 2 areas-mulching(ninja)and bagging/vacuming. in order to get the most out of the ninja sys you need the most powerfull engine snapper offers. do not skimp here! get the hi vac model and convert it to ninja for summer- put a gator blade on for leaf cleanup or you can bag if you want but it isnt needed for most lawn debrie.snappers only fault is a out dated and overly complex self propel mech. it is easy and cheap to repair though.

  • 20 years ago

    LAWNMOWERDAN- I see that you run several differnt types of mowers. My old Snapper was a tank, and the drive never gave me a problem...$10 in parts in 30 years - but I don't know if they are as well made as they used to be. I want something that will last...and that doesn't need to visit the dealer. What would be your pic for residential use...and I do love the Kawasaki. If I had my choice, I'd get an aluminum deck, BBC and Kawasaki engine with a trouble free drive/tranny....but they don't see t make that for under $1000. So I headed back to the Snapper dealer...and the units look very similar to my original unit. No more aluminum...no BBC...are they as good as they used to be? If not...what would you suggest? Please help.

  • 20 years ago

    the new ones have the same drive sys as 30 rys ago. nothing has changed on it -at least on the hi vac model which is what i suggest you get for its all around versatility. i would get the top home model of even the commercial model with kawi engine 180fc model. with the comm you get metal wheels and extra handle bracing etc. it actually worth the exrta $ and may be the last mower you ever buy. just remember you need a very strong motor for the ninja sys like the kawi. i dont know what other engines they offer at this time in the comm line . at briggs wont cut it -no pun intended . theyused to sell a homeowner model with kawi and steel wheels w/ninja standard. if they still sell this -this is the one i would get. was a great deal i remember.

  • 20 years ago

    lawnmowerdan
    My 2005 Snapper has a 6.5 hp Briggs. I noticed on their site that the Kawasaki they sell for comparable models is 6.0 hp OHV. Is the Kawasaki still more powerful?

  • 20 years ago

    The Kawasaki is more powerful than a locomotive. Able to leap tall buildings in a single bound. Is it a bird, or a plane......no it SUPERLAWNMOWER ENGINE!!

    I think the bench torque tests put the Kawasaki ahead of all engines out there save the 190cc Honda OHC (both are similar in power output). HP ratings are meaningless - if you have read here for awhile you would know that.

    Is your Briggs an Intek or a flathead (Quantum)? The Intek makes good power (I have one) but the Kawa has a bit more torque. The Kawa will blow the Quantum away in terms of power to the blade.

    Jim

  • 20 years ago

    its too bad snapper dosnt offer the robin engine any more -its the most powerfull 4 cycle lawnmower engine i ever saw. havnt tried a snapper with a honda ever .

  • 16 years ago

    Lol!
    Just purchase a brand new Snapper mulcher unit last week. After the dealer was able to address a couple small items and I was able to go back over the whole mower and set it up to my liking it has preformed awesome. I cant say enough good about this mower. It out preforms both my Toro SR2 mowers and it blows away the Honda in grunt and power. All these mowers are used on a commercial level 4-5 days a week. The Toro's have hundreds and hundreds of hours on them.
    C.

Sponsored
Urban Upkeep LLC
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars6 Reviews
Columbus High Quality Painting Expert