Software
Houzz Logo Print
pnbrown

mycorrhizae in action

14 years ago

So last fall I built a solar greenhouse with very deep planting beds. These beds are made up of long-time garden soil high in OM, along with some partially decomposed seaweed, various rock powders, greensand and some other goodies. I put some mature chard plants and kale plants in one of the beds. So they have been there for about 3 months. Lately, the chard has grown and thrived more than the kale, notably more. Super dark green leaves on the chard, and a brix reading of 10 and a very hazy field in the reftractometer.

The most notable difference, however, is that the kale has a lot of aphids on the lower leaves, as is common in poorly-ventilated spaces (I was away for the last month and it didn't get opened). Yet the chard is perfect, standing even touching the kale but not an aphid. I strongly suspect this is an illustration of the power of the mycos, which are making maximum nutrients available to the chard while the kale which does not work with the mycos is not getting all that it needs from the rock powders and decomposing seaweed.

Not a scientific experiment to be sure, but pretty compelling?

Comments (15)

  • 14 years ago

    Interesting observation. Willing to pull up a couple to see the roots?

  • 14 years ago

    I have kale and chard in the hoophouse, too.

    The chard was not treated with myco (and of course the kale wasn't).

    I have aphids encrusted on the undersides of the lower leaves of the kale, particularly if the leaves touch the ground. There are no aphids whatsoever on any of the chard.

    It's been my experience that aphids strongly prefer kale over chard. I guess I can't blame them, as I strongly prefer the kale, too.

  • 14 years ago

    Well, maybe that's it, mere preference of the aphids. OTOH, we can't disallow the possibility that kale is typically under-nourished and so not able to resist aphids. I didn't add any myco culture, I just think that my soil is loaded with them.

    There is also lettuce mixed in, lettuce that is heavily shaded by kale has aphids and ones that aren't are clean.

    Bi11, I reckon I am not willing to pull any chard!

  • 14 years ago

    I'd be willing to pull up a couple of my mature chard to see the roots, but I doubt that there'll be much of anything to see. Perhaps I should treat some of them with the myco powder about a month in advance of pulling them up for comparison. Since they overwintered, they're just going to go to seed anyway, is that correct?

    The bed layout in the hoophouse is being revamped this year anyhow.

    Apparently we're not the only ones with the observation of aphids attacking kale and foregoing chard though.

    Here is a link that might be useful: aphids attack kale, leave chard alone?

  • 14 years ago

    And of course the recommended solution given in the article is the usual: declare all-out full-time war on the pests. Spend all your time picking, killing, soaping bugs but no time considering what is lacking in the soil system.

  • 14 years ago

    And of course the recommended solution given in the article is the usual: declare all-out full-time war on the pests. Spend all your time picking, killing, soaping bugs but no time considering what is lacking in the soil system.

    Though they don't talk about the soil food web, it's a bit of an exaggeration to say that this article advocates an "all-out war."

    It just says:
    --Hose down the affected plants that are hosting colonies every few days
    --This won't get rid of them all, but you want to keep some aphids around so that their natural enemies, like ladybugs, stick around.
    It only says to consider the soap to contain damage but to be mindful of ecological balance of the garden.

  • 14 years ago

    I guess I over-reacted a bit. I am very opposed to the strategy of treating symptoms rather than improving soil life.

    Here are a couple of plants in question. As you can see the kale is fairly healthy even with the aphid population. I might attribute that to the high degree of nutrition in the soil, in the past I have had aphids wipe out kale, especially in less than optimum conditions like a greenhouse that did not get watered for three weeks.

    {{gwi:135383}}

  • 14 years ago

    Do a search for 'aphids in soil'. Hopefully this will provide a bit of help re these tiny critters.

  • 14 years ago

    I have a lot of experience with aphids.

    The point of this thread is the difference between their presence on the kale and their absence on the chard, despite the very close proximity and the known fact that aphids can damage chard.

  • 14 years ago

    nice looking greens, Mr. Brown

  • 14 years ago

    Thanks, Bi11.

    I think the high brix readings are also partly due to the time of year. Slow growth over a long time around the winter solstice might reasonably be supposed to give the plant more time to interact with microbes and take up nutrients? Similarly, I have found that the perennial walking onion brixes higher in its various parts than seed-grown onions. I am inclined to attribute this to the much longer time that the plant spends developing relationships.

  • 14 years ago

    In one of eliot coleman's books he noted that aphids were damaging something in his hoop house because excess nitrogen was present due to rain not leaching it out. His solution was to water even though the crop didn't need it. It helped leach some nitrogen and aphids left.

  • 14 years ago

    Yes, I have been watering quite a bit, since dryness is generally the friend of aphids. I have not applied much in the way of N sources to this bed, the rotted seaweed would have some but one wouldn't think excessively. Of course there are microbes other than rhizobia that live freely in quite live soil that fix N and perhaps that is what Coleman is referring to which builds up without rainfall.

    Also one of the chard plants is showing some odd signs of mineral deficiency now, probably due to an excess. Young leaves curling extremely and notably yellow with dying tips. I'll have to look up the symptoms of N excess in regard to suppression of other nutrients.

  • 14 years ago

    This continues to be an interesting opportunity for observation and possible learning.

    I have a number of kale plants overwintering outdoors, as per usual, and they are the exact same gene-pool as the ones in the greenhouse, all descended from russian kale seed bought 15 years ago. I just brixed some from outside and they are a hazy 10. Very respectable. Yesterday I brixed kale from in the greenhouse, which has been growing a lot and has the aphids: a straight-line 5. Less than half the nutrition of the outdoor kale. Meanwhile the indoor chard is also a hazy 10, which is massive for chard.

    Conclusions? I think it is entirely explained by the natural habits of the species. Chard will function well in much higher day-time temps than kale. The greenhouse was closed up for february so many days must have had extremely hot air temps. Combined with chard's ability to interact easily with mycos that explains it's excellent indoor performance. The outdoor kale has suffered little damage from frosts this winter and combined with the long time period to concentrate nutrients that explains its excellent nutrient levels.

  • 14 years ago

    It is my understanding that mycorrhizae do not like excessive phosphorous.

0