Software
Houzz Logo Print
crankyoldman_gw

Fertilizer recommendations for thick roots

20 years ago

I am growing mandrakes and want to get thick roots on them. They usually bulk up okay, but I would like to try some organic fertilizers that are especially geared to making big roots. I've never grown root crops, so I don't know what to use. Usually I use liquid kelp, fish emulsion, or the omega vegetative and flowering ferts from Peaceful Valley. Any recommendations from you big root growers out there?

Comments (6)

  • 20 years ago

    In general, avoid anything with lots of Nitrogen, and prefer materials with higher Phosphorus and Potassium. The things you mention (kelp, fish, commercial ferts) could meet these criteria. Kelp/seaweed is generall used for trace minerals and K, but the fish could be high N, depending on the source and how it was processed.

    Your cultivation techniques can impact root size, too. In general, infrequent but deep watering will encourage strong root growth. As well, you'd be better off amending all the surrounding soil, don't just dump stuff around the plant. Plants sitting in what amounts to a bathtub full of gatorade will be lazy and weak. You want strong roots that will go out and get what they need from the soil, in terms of water and nutrients.

    Hope this helps.

  • 20 years ago

    I bet this would work great for my tuberous aroids, like the elephant ears, too, wouldn't it, Bev? Because on the Aroid forum, it has been suggested that we use a fertilizer high in phosphorous rather than nitrogen. What say you?

    Susan

  • 20 years ago

    I'd say they're basically correct. At the risk of over-simplifying things, Phosphorus builds healthy roots and promotes flowering. Nitrogen promotes green, leafy growth to facilitate photosynthesis, which builds plant tissue and energy stores. Potassium develops the plant's "traffic control" system, the boss engineer who tells the plant which systems to turn off and on, where to send water and other "transportables", and how to respond to stress like floods, famine and frost.

    Back to Aroids. Unlike some tuberous plants, Aroids are ornamentals, right? Grown for the parts that can be seen, not for the size or nutritional value of the tubers (think potatoes, yams...)

    In ornamentals, the main point of encouraging nice big healthy (but invisible) roots/tubers is to ensure the plant has a strong food-gathering system. This lets them reach food that is farther away, outcompete the neighbouring plants, have excess capacity to deal with marauding gangs of biological bad guys, that kind of thing. A big healthy tuber also provides the plant with a strong "anchor" to keep it upright against rain, wind, and the neighbourhood cats.

    All of this applies to plants that are being grown in real soil and real sunshine with real micro-biology happening in the soil. Pot-grown plants in sterile mediums are a different story-- one that people like to argue about. So I won't get into the fray.

    I don't know much about arums, so maybe some arum experts will jump in here and finesse my post.

    (I have to mention that the whole NPK thing not only overlooks the other 13 or so "nutrients", but it is a very rudimentary way of looking at a complex system. The chemical paradigm has been foisted on us by Big Agriculture and Big Chem. We should be encouraging balanced, healthy soil that "feeds" plants through the breakdown of organic matter and minerals, not thinking of soil as an inert substance to which the appropriate chemical "plant food" is added.)

  • 20 years ago

    As a gross generalization plants that produce a lot of protein use a lot of nitrogen (a component of proteins). An obvious example is beans. Plants that produce a lot of starch use a lot of potassium which is utilized in starch synthesis (among other things). Potatoes are an example of a starch producing plant. If you look at fertilizer recommendations for various crops you will notice the trend is for higher ratios of nitrogen for protein producing plants (unless they fix their own) and higher potassium rations for starch producing plants.

    I donÂt know what a mandrake is, but it sounds like a plant that stores starches in its roots. I would suggest then that you fertilizer with a fertilizer that has a high potassium ratio. Keep in mind that over fertilizing is not likely to result in increased growth.

  • 20 years ago

    A mandrake (Mandragora sp.) is a solanaceous perennial that flowers and fruits. I would like to get these plants to fruit, but I grew them to harvest and sell the roots. They get a root that is something like the root of ginseng--branched, somewhat brittle, almost like a white radish in its consistency. They get a long taproot also, enormously long for the height of the plant itself, almost like a string for a lot of its length. Right now they are in pots under artificial light and doing fabulously well. I'm planning on shifting them outside once it warms up in the hopes they will flower and fruit. I'll probably put them in garbage cans with the bottoms cut out, because the dirt here is rocky clay and I would never be able to dig up the roots without breaking them to pieces.

    I haven't grown any root crops outside of mandrake and radishes. Do for instance carrots tend to form a lot of thready roots before they form a main tap root? Any general advice on growing for good roots? And what are good organic sources of phosphorus?

  • 20 years ago

    Good organinc sources of phosphorus are soft rock phosphate or bone meal. Neither one has nitrogen in it.