Software
Houzz Logo Print
corin99_gw

Organic Dilemma

18 years ago

Hi...I'm in my fourth year growing vegetables organically in raised beds. I've had excellent results, but noticed a drop-off last year in productivity. After thinking about how intensively I've been growing, I suspected I needed to add some nitrogen to the soil. I did a soil test with a home kit and it indicated the same thing.

So, I started looking into high-nitrogen fertilizers and was going to get some alfalfa pellets. But then started to feel that this was "cheating" in a way. After all, I'm sure the alfalfa wasn't grown organically. So really, I would just be taking advantage of the heavy use of chemical fertilizers to grow the alfalfa in order to not have to use them in my own garden. Hmm...can someone tell me I'm wrong here or suggest an alternative?

Comments (60)

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    kimmsr - I understand that the soil test may not be accurate, but given my previous seasons results I tend to believe it. Also, I haven't been diligent about nurturing my soil in previous years, so it's not surprising.

    dchall - It's true that much of the stuff going into my compost (kitchen leftovers, etc) may have been grown with chemicals, though much isn't (leaves, grass). But this is material that would otherwise have been sent to the landfill. Actually buying a non-organically grown commercial product like alfalfa meal in order to make my own garden chemical free seems like the ultimate NIMBY-ism to me. It's as if I had my nice organic garden next to a neighbor who used chemicals to grow alfalfa and the only way I could stay organic was to use his alfalfa for fertilizer.

    Of course, people go organic for different reasons. But for me, it doesn't seem very compelling if I'm just shifting the chemical usage elsewhere.

    As for compost not being fertilizer, I'm actually a little confused on that point myself. I've read this, but I've also read that it feeds the worms and organisms that then fertilize the soil. Which, to me would mean that it is, in effect, a fertilizer. I'm in no way an expert on these things, but perhaps it depends on the definition of "fertilizer".

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    To be labeled as a fertilizer a material needs to have a certain level of readily available nutrients, soluble nutrients, that can be tested and will be readable. Compost does not have this property because the nutrients in compost are tied in, not soluble, and need the activity of the Soil Food Web to release them to the plants, so compost can only be labeled as a soil amendment, not a fertilizer. So when you add compost, and other forms of organic matter, you are feeding the soil (Soil Food Web) and they will feed you plants the nutrients the plants need when they need them in the balanced quantities the plants need.
    If your soil organic matter level is not in the 5 to 8 percent range you can see many different problems with plants, all related to nutrient deficiencies. Stunted growth, lack of vigor, poor fruit production are all signs of nutrient deficiencies but not necessarily just Nitrogen, maybe Phosphorus, Potash, Magnesium, Calcium, Zinc, Molybdenum, Iron, Sulfur, and others that need to be present in balance because an excess of one can cause a plant to have a deficiency of another.
    This is why a good, reliable soil test from a good lab (which probably will not test for N), not a home soil test kit, is an important part of an organic gardeners plan of operation.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hi there,,I haven't been on this site for years, but now I am back with questions regarding the use of manures and how safe are they really??? Of course manures are safe, Yes, but what about the feed the cows are getting, or how about the bedding that the chicken manure is mixed in with in the barn? Such as Pine shavings , or the Straw? Is the straw treated in the fields with chemicals?? and are the shavings from treated wood??? Maybe I am paranoid,,but isn't this something else that should be considered? Am I worrying too much?? Or do I have a point here??
    All of your helpful comments are much appreciated !! Thanks, Ctufts

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    ctufts, you might have come to the right site. This is the organic gardening segment of Fear Factor. :-D This FF phenomenon is almost always focused on "organic" plant and soil management because we tend to fear what we cannot fully control. The joy of conventional, synthetic culture is that we can find the right synthetic chemical or process to meet specific need with supposedly predictable results. Very assuring and, we are assured, with no significant side effects. Sound Science tells us so.

    I am being a bit cynical for so early in the morning out on this coast.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Organic becomes a lifestyle. There is no way to be 100% organic considering the pollution in our world. But the more we work towards living organic lifestyles, the more we change our worlds for the better. As a person adopts an organic mindset, study is required and change happens little by little. It doesn't have to be an all or nothing proposition, every little bit helps.

    Crop rotation is part of organic gardening. Growing the same plants in the same area year after year seriously depletes soil.

    Soil should be an ecosystem. I say should be, because it is possible for soil to be virtually dead. Good soil is a living "being", if you will. Organic gardeners build good soil over time. It is a process. If you've got good soil, you've got earthworms. Earthworms cannot live in soil which is devoid of nutrients.

    One can use seaweed or kelp from Asian grocery stores for making fertilizer teas. These are very beneficial. Soak the seaweed or kelp to rehydrate it, pour off that water as there will probably be high salt content, add fresh water and liquify the seaweed or kelp in your blender. Dilute your product in a bucket of water and water your crops with it. Probably once a month would be good.

    Mushroom compost is one of the least expensive soil amendments on the market. It doesn't add living matter to the soil, but it does provide food for microrganisms and earthworms.

    If you aren't using chemical pesticides or fertilizers, you're well on your way to being an organic gardener. For a homemade compost rich in nitrogen the mix is supposed to be one-third green material to two-thirds dry leaf material. If you throw banana peels from conventionally grown banana trees into your compost heap it isn't a big deal. Probably 80% of the produce I buy is grown organically, but I sometimes buy conventionally grown produce. All of the trimmings go into my compost bin. I am nonetheless an organic gardener.

    Lorna

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Larna said, "Crop rotation is part of organic gardening. Growing the same plants in the same area year after year seriously depletes soil. "
    Crop rotation does not need to be done in an orgnaic garden because the organic gardener continually builds up the soil so it is healthier every year and if what the gardener is doing is causing a depeletion of the soil nutrients that is not organic. A person only needs to practice crop rotation if they do not practice good soil building by adding organic matter to their soil each year and do not keep the nutrients in balance and do not have an active Soil Food Web.
    ctufts wondered about manure and rightly so. Cattle that are fed a diet high in grains tend to produce manure that has more of the bad E- Coli bacteria that cattle that are fed a grass diet. All manure has some of the something over 1,000 strains of E-Coli bacteria but we need be concerened about just a few and composting will, most often, eliminate those few that do cause problems.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    HI everyone. My concern about cow manure was not only e-coli BUT mostly the chemicals that are added to the cows feed, and growth hormone sorta stuff. My other concern is the Pine shavings that are used in the chicken coop. I have been doing a search on google for PURE PINE SHAVINGS that are kiln dried with no chemicals added. I am trying to find a good source in Maine. The shavings from the coop will of course go into the garden because it would be virtually impossible to seperate the manure from the bedding. Anyways, after reading on several sites about shavings I have learned that the standard non-organic pine shavings are LOADED with chemicals, and THAT I certainly do not want in my vegetable garden. I am also trying to find a good source for CERT. organic chicken feed, OR a recipe for making my own chicken feed. I appreciate your comments. It is nice to be back on this site, I haven't been on for so long. When I was an active member of the gardenweb several years ago, I don't think they had "organic gardening" included. They have added so much,,including "farmlife", which has alot of info on raising chickens organically as well. Thanks everyone !!!
    and BTW: Is anyone else having trouble with the site being extremely slow moving?? I have a hard time navigating around without having to wait atleast 2 minutes for some pages to load. I don't have that kind of trouble with any other site..so I am assuming it is gardenweb's site.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Crop rotations have been the basis for many traditions of farming, not specific to organic culture. As an organic farmer, I practice rigorous rotation of families of veggies for reasons more related to avoiding disease and pest buildups than to maximize available nutrients. Exhausting soil nutrients is a pretty complex issue, not just accelerated by planting the same crop. Build up of pests and diseases is a lot harder to manage. Same family of plants tend to share similar pests and diseases.

    There is a simple rule called Liebig's Law of the Minimum which states that the nutrient element in least supply will be the limiting nutrient. The limiting nutrient may be a micronutrient or a secondary one rather than the commonly tested macronutrients N,K,P or secondary ones calcium, magnesium, and sulfur. I try to alter fertilizing program to accommodate the needs of the crop in question.

    Most crops are not heavy feeders (nitrogen greedy); grains tend to be the most demanding, brassicas next, leafy greens, solanum family and root crops in about that order. Listed this way doesn't ignore that at some stage of the plant growth, adequate nitrogen is important. Garlic is not a heavy feeder except for the stage just prior to bulbing, for example.

    My basic rotation is legume-->grain-->alliums (onion/garlic family)-->greens/lettuces and to either tomato/peppers/eggplants, legumes, or cucurbits. We do fallow beds for brief periods and do incorporate cut flower crops for longer breaks in rotation of food crops.

    I don't return to the same ground as follows: 5-6 years for alliums, 4-5 years for tomato family, 3-4 years for cucurbits, brassicas 1-2 years, other root crops and other greens 1-2 years or at least separated by two other croppings.

    Hope this helps.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I think the note of the energy required to make alf alfa and the synthetic nutes used to grow it is a valid concern. It'd be interesting to figure out how much energy it uses.

    I always try to use natural sources of these things with minimal energy required. Coffee grounds, for example. Seaweed, for example. Grass clippings, etc...Buying alfalfa for me means driving 90 mins round trip plus buying a bag of the stuff plus the N-R-G required to process it and make it and grow it ahhhhhhh!!!!

    Complicated world we live in!

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Coffee: average 2000 miles shipping. Seaweed: strip-mining beaches. Grass clippings: stripping nutrients from lawns.

    There are many tradeoffs. If you grow you own nutrients and soil amendments, come talk to us some more. :)

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Yes, I am sometimes having very slow downloads on GW. I wonder if it has anything to do with how many users are on at the same time. I'm guessing it is slower when there are a lot of simultaneous users. I've taken to keeping a magazine by the computer! DSL is supposed to become available in my rural area soon.
    Lorna

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    People have been rotating some crops for years, however, if you have in your garden some perennials growing that you never move why don't you if crop rotation is so important. If perennials do not need to be rotated why do annuals? If each year you properly amend the soil your plants grow in why would you need to rotate them?
    Most everything I have seen on crop rotation says the crop this year needs to be 300 feet from where it grew last year, how many people can do that in their garden?

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Interesting question. The answer perhaps is Time and life cycles of annuals versus perennials. As a landscaper and hort. gardener, I can attest to the fact that perennials can promote specific pests and diseases that preclude replanting the same in the same area unless soils are fumigated. For phytopthera fungi, the spores can survive without a host for decades or longer.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Okay, maybe the method for growing alfalfa has changed in the last 30 years, but as I remember my dad's method, he planted, watered, and harvested. No fertilizers, no herbicides. He would grow alfalfa for about 3 years, then when it had too many weeds to sell to the dairy down the road, he would plow it under and plant corn in that field and plant alfalfa where the corn had grown. The corn certainly got fertilizer (amonia in the irrigation water) and herbicide (2-4-D, a broadleaf herbicide used on wheat and corn), but nothing for the alfalfa.

    So I would say, if you can mulch with locally grown alfalfa (not alfalfa meal or pellets), go for it.

    Catherine

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    "Coffee: average 2000 miles shipping. Seaweed: strip-mining beaches. Grass clippings: stripping nutrients from lawns.

    There are many tradeoffs. If you grow you own nutrients and soil amendments, come talk to us some more. :)"

    Coffee: A byproduct of starbucks, close to me
    Seaweed: Not a problem when they normally clean the beaches *anyways* and put it into composts for the town

    Grass clippings: Free from landscapers which would otherwise go into compost heaps.

    Also you can't put 100% of your grass back onto your lawn anyways.

    Good points you brought up though..

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    When I take used coffee grounds (UCG) from a local coffee shop two blocks away, it either goes to my garden -- or it gets picked up by garbage trucks and then trucked to landfills. Which are either in the US, or a hundred miles out of my city (not sure if Toronto has yet made the shift from dumping our garbage in Michigan to dumping it in Ontario.)

    The UCG, like yard waste bags from the street which I also compost, are hauled home by me in a backpack. Sometimes the coffeeshop owners drop the UCG off at my door, which requires them to drive their car about one short block out of their way.

    I bought one 50lb bag of alfalfa pellets last year and used most of it on my garden, some went to help out my neighbours and friends in their gardens. Also bought a small bag of dolomite limestone, and a small box of blood meal to try to drive off the squirrels -- a box which is still unopened. Will try it out later this year.

    Every year my garden produces larger plants and more harvest per plant. The plants have less pest problems and appear healthier; the produce keeps tasting better. The topsoil is visibly improving.

    Personally, I'll take the tradeoffs of the very, very, very limited amounts of purchased items which I add to the garden soil here -- some of which were most certainly produced by commercial agriculture and helped consume non-renewable resources -- in order to maintain and improve my gardens, and provide a visible alternative for my friends and my neighbours to see.

    If/when Peak Oil arrives, or other radical economic circumstances dictate I have to adjust to far more limited circumstances, I will then most certainly reduce my use of imported garden amendments. In the meantime, I'm building up a soil savings bank and I'm learning what helps to make a better garden. And the vast majority -- I would guesstimate 95-98% -- of what goes to improve my soil, is currently urban trash which would at best be hauled away by truck and composted with the use of machines.

    In short: I try to minimize the inputs and maximize the results, working within the present circumstances. Last year I grew 20 fullsize heritage variety tomatoes, with no purchased inputs except the alfalfa, and gave substantial quantities of them to at least twenty people.

    I won't be worrying about the purchase of another 50lb bag of alfalfa pellets this year any more than I'll worry over a one-time purchase of a garden fork. The latter will very likely be made in China and hauled across the ocean by ship then transported by train and truck. But that won't make me set up a backyard blacksmithing operation and forge my own garden fork. :)

    I think we all need to figure out our own ways of walking lightly on the earth. It's good to keep talking and thinking about these issues, but ultimately the decisions of what to do (and not do) are personal. For now.

    All the best,
    -Patrick

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I'd like to make a plea on behalf of all lawns. Please use a mulching mower so that the grass particles and nutrients are returned to the surface where little beasties will chow down and control thatch build-up at the same time.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Patrick,

    Where did you buy your alfalfa pellets?

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Patrick, I'm also interested in your use of alfalfa pellets. Are you talking about pellets for feeding animals? I tried to get the cottontails and jack rabbits to eat alfalfa pellets instead of my arborvitae this winter. This is the first time in five years they have attacked my trees. It has been a dry winter so I assume that cut int their food sources. The rabbits haven't touched the alfalfa pellets. I figure I can make use of the pellets in my garden. What is the best way to use them?

    My county has a few recycling programs. If people have branches, dead trees, etc. to get rid of, they can take them to a recycling area where they will be ground into mulch. People can take the mulch. The mulch hasn't been sprayed with anything.

    Lorna

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hamiltongardener, I bought the alfalfa while visiting a friend's cottage near Campbellford in eastern Ontario. Dropped into a seed & feed store which supplies the local farmers and picked up a 50lb bag, think it was just over ten dollars. Any well-stocked agricultural supply store in farming country should carry alfalfa pellets and/or meal, it's a standard animal feed.

    Lorna, when preparing garden beds in spring I hand-scatter roughly a large coffee can of alfalfa pellets over a 5' x 8' garden bed. I try to make sure there are high-carbon organic materials both below and above the alfalfa, because it is very high in nitrogen.

    I've also made alfalfa tea, with a few handfuls of pellets in a five gallon pail, stirred a couple times a day, then used as a foliar feed & soil drench. No problems noted with it, and it seemed to encourage early growth.

    The pellets I've used are for animal feed, yes. However, in addition to the nitrogen boost, alfalfa also contains a natural growth stimulant (Triacontanol) which apparently encourages other plants to grow.

    Years ago I'd heard about the growth stimulant properties and was curious. So one fall when my parents built a new garden bed at the cottage, I bought half a pound of alfalfa seed at a local health food store, and sprouted it.

    I was careful to save the sprout soaking water and pour it on the new bed. Just before winter freezeup, I ran the live sprouts thru the blender and added the mush to the soil.

    The following spring my folks planted petunias in the bed. That summer I wasn't up to the cottage, but apparently they grew so tall and wide and healthy, people stopped to photograph them and asked how they grew so big. :)

    Fall tree leaves, UCG, household scraps, and a top layer of fine wood chip mulch is becoming my standard 'Lasagna Light' spring garden surface treatment of organic materials. But next to those organic additions, alfalfa is my favourite soil improvement. In the coming year I'd like to try some form of seaweed and/or fish emulsion, curious to see what affects they would have.

    All the best,
    -Patrick

    p.s. Earthworms also love alfalfa pellets, though you have to be careful not to overdose a high-carbon bin and overheat it. Did that a while ago and killed off most of the adult population. Here's a clickable photo of the surface of the worm bathtub, taken in mid-October last year:

    {{gwi:135488}}

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thank you for the info and insights, Patrick, much appreciated. It is sixty degrees in central New Mexico today. I've got a bunch of tulips popping up, but there is no sign of crocus or hyacinth as of yet. There are other hints of spring happening around the property, such as swelling leaf buds on almonds, lilacs and poplars. Some wasps and bees are moving about. Yesterday I saw some geese flying.
    Lorna

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks Patrick.

    I've been reading a lot on here about fertilizing with alfalfa, seed meals, etc. I've always thought of compost as a fertilizer but many people are saying it's not really a fertilizer, just a source of beneficial beasties.

    So now I want to give seedmeals or alfalfa pellets a try. See what happens this year.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Think of compost as a very slow release fertilizer, not just for the nutrient elements but also for feeding carbon into the microbial ecosystem. Action of soil critters keep the soil air and water moving, soil literally "breathe."

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Compost IS a fertilizer. You'll be hard pressed to find any garden literature that doesn't define it as a fertilizer. It's also a soil conditioner.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Sorry, I use standard terminology and definitions common to the fertilizer trade. Aerobic compost contains approximately 1% nitrogen and phosphorous and I make 200-300 tons of aerobic compost a year for my small farm and orchards. After 16 years of twice-yearly composting, my veggie beds require little supplemental fertilizing. The secret is the slow release of nutrient bound up in the compost.

    My soil went from

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I wanted to follow up on ctufts' question about manure.
    I, too, worry about the pine shavings in the manure. Are they okay? or no?
    The grass in my pastures has never been sprayed, but I do worry about what might have been sprayed on hay I purchased.
    I know we can't look back several "generations" into everything we put on the garden, but should I be worrying about the pine shavings and alfalfa?

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I think you are worrying too much. But if you cannot help worrying, it would probably be best for you not to use hay or anything with pine shavings.

    If you are worried about what animals have been fed, as in non-organic food stuffs, I guess the solution would be for you to get some rabbits. You could grow your own alfalfa to feed them. Rabbit manure is very good fertilizer.

    Lorna

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    It's certainly not normal practice to spray hay with anything, at least not in my experience. Fertilizer yes, pesticides no.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    wow! this is a long thread. i appreciate all of you obviously very smart people sharing your knowledge. most of what i know has come from you or links you've shared. thank you.
    now, since i'm slow minded and always have to learn the hard way, i can tell you after 4 years of organic(hahahaha) gardening, i still feel like i'm waking up in a new world every day. i guess it would help if i didn't have hard as a rock clay + rocks for soil. but, i am learning to deal with it.
    the organic part though, doesn't seem so complicated to me. if it's not engineered, processed, coated, sprayed, or other such things, its organic. my husband raises rabbits, and he feeds them alfalfa pellets. i do not use their manure, because if you've read anything about the seed companies manipulating a seed's DNA, you'll know there isn't anything they have not monkeyed with. corn, soybeans, wheat, even grasses, have all been altered, if not for enhanced production or flavor, then how about for wheat able to withstand being sprayed with round-up and not die. even vanilla, for goodness sake, can be made in a vat without a plant at all.
    after reading the Soil Food Web article, i realized how important good food was for those bugs. no one knows exactly what happens when an altered or missing protein from the DNA is ingested. and, just because somebody grew some alfalfa, heated it up, squashed it into a pellet, the rabbit ingested it, pooped it, and now for me to mix into my soil, that it would be perfectly okay for the microbes and earthworms, keeps me up at night. everybody keeps saying in their articles that there is such a delicate balance of nutrients, water, bugs, light, etc. how could this not be important? no wonder the bees are flying off and dying.
    i'm so fortunate that i live in a semi-rural area, with about 80 farms in our county. i just recently contacted as many as i could to find out if they thought the manures from the animals they raise, was safe enough for organic gardening. their short answer was "no". between the antibiotics(which really isn't all that bad), and the herbicides, i got depressed. but, they all said they move the cows, or animals, to another field before they spray, and then give it some time before they allow the cows back into the sprayed field. and something i never thought about was the cleaner used for the pens; runs out the barn, down the hill, and into the field. one farmer told me it was okay to him because he uses herbicides that are safe for human consumption because his meat is sold to the public. so there you go, no problem. i'm going to take a nap.
    fortunately, i live on 60 acres with a ton of oak trees, hay fields and grass to mow. so, i'm fine. my heirloom tomatoes don't look all that great, but they taste good and they "can" just fine. i've also stopped regarding food from mexico as "bad". since they have resisted the seed companies sales pitch, hopefully forever, so what if i have to wash it ten times. who knows what we don't know, though.
    like a previous post talked about the fear factor, and yes, i'm guilty but, i just want to live a healthy life, doing things as right as i can, growing to an old age, without some weird disease that i could have prevented, and then have to get buried next to the bees.
    i recently talked with a friend about all this and she said, "you do all you can do, then give the rest to God and He will keep you safe". she's right.



  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Okay,,SO, if pine shavings are not good to use, (and obviously they are not, unless you buy organic shavings, if available in your area), what else can be used for bedding in the coop. I really like the idea of using chicken manure in the garden, but I dont like to use hay,,that gets pretty nasty,,and chicken manure does not mix well with it,plus it doesn't keep the odor down like pine shavings.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    What am I missing here? Why aren't pine shavings safe for chicken litter? I'm not worried for one second that my pine shavings come from treated wood. If you are worried about it, call the manufacturer. Why would anyone sell treated wood for livestock bedding?

    I use straw, pine shavings and leaves in my chicken house. I use a deep litter method which composts through the winter and keeps my chickens warm. I flip my bedding periodically to keep the odor down, but I think I'll do it less enthusiastically next year. My bedding was steaming when I flipped it in Jan. I think I cooled it off by too deep flipping.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Annpat, I am not saying pine shavings are bad for chickens. I am saying pine shavings might possibly be bad for the garden, because IN FACT, pine shavings DO have chemicals in them. That is what makes them smell so nicely. I use to add the shavings and all to the garden along with the chicken manure, as it is not possible to seperate the manure from the shavings. I have heard of organic pine shavings being available,,but have not found any in my area yet. So, I am wondering what somebody else might use for bedding that is safe for the garden as well. Something that works good in the coop as well. Maybe I am worrying too much,,BUT I have read that the pine shavings are loaded with additives.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Pine boards are treated after they are cut, dried and planed. Aren't they?

    Dawner,
    In dealing with clay, Dig a large hole, fill in the bottom with some sand and raw organic matter for drainage. cover with a bit of clay topsoil.

    From there dump in your sandy compost mixture (potting soil) and bury your Heirloom Tomato up to its neck in it. It will actually be growing in the sandy potting soil until it gets very large, then it reaches into the area of raw organic matter that is now mostly worm castings. If not, then the roots will just go around in the soil like they had before.

    3 tomatoes this way 2' apart is next year's raised bed full of the organic matter that you covered the excess clay soil with. As you march the tomatoes around the garden, you are turning the area into a huge sponge :)

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I'm interested in this. The first article I read after googling said that the supposed danger to small animals is from untreated shavings. Nothing about chemical additives yet, but I just read the one article.

    Let me know if you learn anything more, will you ctufts?

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    The chemicals that concern people, as far as I can tell so far, occur naturally in the wood. Kiln-drying reduces them.

    And I can't find any article claiming that wood is odor-enhanced. The reason your shavings smell good? Wood smells good.

    The interesting thing I've learned is that dried citrus peel does something beneficial in a chicken coop. What? You ask? I don't know---the article was over my head.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hi Annpat, I will look into it further. That would be comforting to know that any chemical in the shavings is a natural occurance. I will let you know what more I find out.
    Ctufts

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    The next time I get wood shavings---maybe today---I'm going to call the manufacturer. I can't find much about it on the web, except that the University of Maine uses horse manure/shaving bedding on their gardens and MOFGA uses manure/shavings on their organic strawberries, but neither name the source of their wood shavings.

    I'm not asking for organic wood shavings at my local Feed 'n Grain, I can tell you that, 'cause they already have great scorn for me purchasing organic feed. I also paid a fortune once, when I first started with chickens, for ground corncob bedding. The Feed 'n Grains brothers could barely hide their smirks.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    ANNPAT,
    LOL....OH,,THat is SO FUNNY !!!. I know exactly what you mean !!. I get looks,,AND I AM SURE that they talk about me when I leave. LOL. WHATEVER !!!!!!!!!!

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I don't suppose you're shopping at the Ellsworth Feed 'n Grain, ctufts? I can hear the snickering when I leave. I almost bought some DDT there recently, so they'd respect me.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    HI Annpat,,no, I use to go to a store in androscoggin county. I have been in florida for the past year and a half, and will be returning to Maine next month. I am almost afraid to go in and ask for organic shavings. They will laugh me out of the store. "here comes that nutcase again". hahahahaa.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Now wait a minute. How can you be Zone 4 in Androscoggin? I'm a Brunswick girl and I can't imagine Zone 4 anywhere near me. In fact, my yard in Brunswick (near Thomas Point Beach) is zone 6.

    Anyway, may I sit outside while you get us a couple of bales of organic shavings? You might as well get us some organic scratch while you're in there. No point in us both looking foolish. :^]

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    The first article I read after googling said that the supposed danger to small animals is from untreated shavings.

    Annpat,

    I don't know about chickens, but even untreated shavings from cedar and pine are bad for hamsters and rabbits. Cedar shavings are the worst, but pine shavings are pretty bad too. Aspen is the wood of preference for their bedding.

    I believe it has something to do with the pine and cedar emitting something noxious when mixed with the animal's urine. Since chicken have a high N waste, it would emit the same thing. Whether or not this affects chickens the same way it affects other small animals, I don't know.

    All I know is that we are only supposed to use aspen shavings with the hamster.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Untreated shavings are the problem; we're in agreement. Supposedly kiln-dried shavings are okay. For chicken bedding. I know nothing about hamsters. The kiln-drying does something to the ? (resin? I can't remember the word.)

    But I haven't read anything yet that sounds conclusive either way. I just bought shavings yesterday and I think I'll call the company. As far as I can tell, though, wood shavings sold for bedding have no additives and are organic. Safe? I don't know, but they're not treated chemically as far as I can tell.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    HI Annpat,,You are zone 6 ??? must be because you are on the coast. There are definitely places in Maine that are borderline zone 4 / zone 3. Really!!. Are you sure you are not zone 5 ??? Massachusetts is zone 5....I believe. Anyways, if I am a zone 5 I will be jumping for joy,, There are ALOT of plants I would like to grow that just won't come back every year in my zone....like Rose "New Dawn" and various types of foxglove and some types of hydrangea and clematis, etc. It's really upsetting !!!.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Most of Maine is zone 5. I didn't know that any of Maine was zone 3. I thought we were 4, 5 and 6. In Brunswick, I'm on the ocean. Near Bangor, I'm on a lake with a lake effect.
    My foxglove reseed, which might be uncommon, but I've never know a clematis anywhere in the state who can't thrive. Hydrangeas? We can only grow the pink pee gee types.

    If you're in Androsgoggin, I'd be very surprised if you weren't zone 5. I'll check myself. I'm often wrong.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I have a beautiful clematis that is about 7 years old over at the old house (that we sold) next door from where we are building. It has thrived, but there are others that I would like to have that won't do well in our zone. Also, I do have alot of hydranges that do well, and they finally came up with a blue hyrangea (endless summer) that WILL come back every year, and yes, my foxglove always reseed IF I can get them to the second year when they flower. If I start them in the greenhouse early, I can get them to bloom the 1st year. There are alot of roses too that will not survive. I need to find a nice climbing rose that does well in my zone...any ideas???

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I don't know anything about roses. I had a beautiful one that I didn't mulch last year and only a little tiny part of it survived.

    I guess I thought clematis were hardier. They're fussy. I only grow Jackmanii and the native white ones.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Dude--why don't you inoculate and plant legumes? You know, Peas and Beans? It will fix a lot of nitrogen and improve the tilth of your soil.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    corin99, Try growing some Comfrey and make a tea from it - smells good! or use some Fish emulsion for quick fix.
    Make some good low C/N compost yourself so you know what goes into it. Magic stuff.
    Peas & Beans Excellent too... Our season is approaching - cant wait to put Tomatoes in again...

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    ctufts, Massachusetts runs from a cold 5 to a 7. Remember, we span quite a distance east to west, and that means warm to cold.

    I'm probably closer to 7 than 6.5 here........