Software
Houzz Logo Print
arky2

which tomato variety do i need?

20 years ago

hello, haven't posted here just a lurker, but i need to know a good variety of tomato for central arkansas. last year i grew mexico midget and they did great, but the brandywines flopped 150 plants gave me about 3 tomatoes, the rest rotted and fell off. our farm was a used up strawberry farm several years ago. i have been working on it for three years, but it is not real good soil yet, but lots better. started with heavy clay that wouldn't even grow weeds. want to grow a medium size for market. would prefer an heirloom, but have heard hybrids are better for market growers.

Comments (11)

  • 20 years ago

    Lurking for almost 4 years? Must be some sort of record! This ain't the Tomato forum but just as well as that place goes nuts sometimes, with or without my help!

    You planted 150 Brandywine and got 3 fruit. Brandywine is the "snob" variety which just never seems to do anything for us common folk! I gave up on the whole line years ago when I'd be finally getting a chance to enjoy the first ripe fruit when snow clouds were rolling in from the NW.

    You're field planting and marketing. First mistake was in planting too many of one variety. If you're planning to sell from a farmers market or roadside stand, you want to plant a wider variety with various maturity times. Having everything come ripe at once, at the end of the season, is when many customers already have their fill or there is a glut of tomatoes.

    I've recommended some of my varieties to several CSA farms with good results. Ideally you would have a selection of cherry tomatoes, of mixed colors, for snacking and salads. Then small to medium deli slicers. After that, the big hamburger slicers. Somewhere in between would be all-purpose canners plus a paste-sauce-salsa.

    If you wanted all that in 150 plants, that would be 5 plants each of 6 different cherry tomatoes and 30 each of the other 4 types. If they were halfway decent indeterminate varieties, you'd have something that every customer would like.

    Let me know if you'd like to go that route. If so, I'll supply the seeds, you handle it from there!

    Martin

  • 20 years ago

    I really like Arkansas Traveler and Juanne Flammee both of which are heirlooms. I sell these at market and they do very well. I also highly agree with paquebot that you will want a variety of different dates of maturity and a selection of different types. There's many great seed catalogs out there - read descriptions, ask around. When I try a new tomatoe I only plant about 1/2 to 1 dozen to see how it does.

  • 20 years ago

    I've not tried these yet, but they have been recommended as good choices for heirloom market varieties.

    Druzba
    Eva Puprle Ball
    Brandywine Red - different from the one you grew
    German Head
    Box Car Willie
    Mule Team
    Sioux

    All are red execpt Eva Purple Ball and German Head which are pink.

    Early varieties :

    Matina
    Stupice
    Kimberly

  • 20 years ago

    What you need is something that will not burn up in the hot humid summer. I concur that Arkansas Traveler is a terrific choice--bred for your climate, sets fruit all summer when everything else shuts down, medium size slicer with very good flavor. A surprise hevy yielder for me is Lucky Cross, which I believe is the best tasting tomato around. You can get seed at Tomato Growers or Victory Seed. Prudens Purple had goo dyield, fine flavor, and is 10 days earlier than most beefsteaks.

  • 20 years ago

    Sun Gold is an incredible cherry, should do well in your area

  • 20 years ago

    I browsed through a book at our University's arboretum (fortunately I live close and the horticultural library is housed there) and it had suggestions of which heirloom tomatoe varieties to plant for different circumstances. The title is 100 Heirloom Tomatoes by Carolyn Male. I'm new to this Gardenweb - can we quote excerpts from books?

  • 20 years ago

    I believe as long as you put it in quotations or acknowledge the source, I believe its okay. Carolyn is a frequent poster on the growing tomatoes forum on this website.

  • 20 years ago

    afaik Dr Male has NOT grown tomatoes in the heat of NM or in the altitudes of Mt Washington Just in her own area's Colo and upper NY

    Too many times a tomato will tastes different in the soils that it is grown in...

  • 20 years ago

    Try Arkansas Traveler. Extremely productive, takes the heat and bad soil, and produces a very good pink tomato.

  • 20 years ago

    thanks for all the info. i have just been lurking on this forum. i do post occasionally on the farm life forum. didn't realize there was a forum for just tomatoes, amazing.
    martin- thanks for the offer. do you think plants that do well way up there would do well in the hot humid south?

  • 20 years ago

    Arky, when it comes to tomatoes, Arkansas is sort of lumped into the Midwest. Zones 4 through 7 are where most tomatoes excel. It's 8-10 that is a different world. Although there are some which are specific to real cold zones, many do well in the warm zones. In the case of some yellow or gold varieties, they do better in the South than the North. In fact, probably a third of my seed stock would do better in South due the longer growing season.

    Nose around that tomato forum for other ideas. Just don't let the information there overwhelm you!

    Martin