Software
Houzz Logo Print
paulns

Brix, flavour, nutrition

17 years ago

The discussion on Kimmsr's recent thread had me thinking in my non-scientific way about the question 'Is organic produce superior to conventional'. I've seen it said, even by organic growers, that organic can't be proven to be nutritionally superior.

We've been selling produce for the past few years to a few restaurants in the area, and our experience has led me to some conclusions. They're generalizations, and depend on how some of these vague terms are defined, but would any of you disagree?

A good chef is an expert on flavour.

The demand from good chefs for organic produce has increased dramatically over the past few years.

Good flavour in fruits and vegetables, in the judgement of chefs, has to do with more than just sweetness/the sweeter the better.

Brix measures specific gravity, which depends mostly, but not entirely, on sugar content.

The superior flavour of organic produce comes from sugar and mineral content both. Where else does flavour in fruits and vegetables come from?

If organic produce has, ounce for ounce, more flavour, and therefore more carbohydrate and mineral content, than conventional produce, then it must be healthier.

I like to think of the above as a syllogism. Is it faulty?

Comments (36)

  • 17 years ago

    It's faulty. I think you probably have several logic errors going on. First you assume that organic vegetables/fruits taste better and attribute it to the fact there are more sugar, mineral, and carbohydrates in 'organic' produce. Then you use that assumption to commit a 'common cause fallacy'. Just because A is associated with B (chefs tend to buy organic produce) doesn't mean automatically that one causes the other. You don't consider other common causes - like trendiness. Chefs LOVE to tout their menu as 'all organic' because it attracts the type of clientèle they prefer to cook for - a cause that trendy chefs are not at all above exploiting.

    Let's take a little look at flavor. Flavor is a by-product of the plant's metabolism. It's influenced by by physical changes during the plants growth cycle and whatever chemical constituents it contains. Let's talk about fruits or tomatoes to get a feel for what affects their flavor.

    As fruits ripen, some cells rupture and release juices into the surrounding tissues, enhancing the fruit's flavor. Sugars, acids, and astringents in the juices determine the flavor. As the fruits ripen, acidity decreases and sweetness increases (think of a green apple - how astringent it is). This is a natural process that takes place at the cellular level and again, is a by-product of normal metabolism.

    We know that our tongue only senses sweet, sour, salty, and bitter, but our nose can detect the volatile compounds that also occur as a by-product of ripening or normal metabolism. Organic acids, alcohols, esthers, carbonyl compounds, hydrocarbons, terpinoids, and probably a few others I can't think of, contribute mightily to flavor. Also, the precursors to some of these compounds (long-chain amino acids, leucine, others, as well as linoleic and linolenic acids are mixed in there somewhere with the volatile compounds.

    I don't think I need to go any further to make the point that you can't say that an increase in sugars, other or minerals in fruit is the cause of flavor, much less a superior flavor.

    From a logical perspective, the first statement needs proof, but any reasonable man would allow it for the sake of your argument. The next three statements, through the one beginning with Brix measures ..." are ok. The last two statements are logical leaps you cannot make w/o proof, lest you be challenged at every turn by the logical thinker with some degree of knowledge re plant physiology.

    Al


  • 17 years ago

    That's the sort of argument I was looking for Al, thanks, although I'm not convinced. And I'm surprised at your cynicism about chefs who want organic produce. The ones I deal with have a genuine appreciation for it and thank heavens for that, because growing it is part of my livelihood. Our customers, not just the chefs, often comment on the intensity of (good) flavour of what we grow compared to what they find in the stores. Some of the difference must come from freshness, ie our produce is picked and sold the same day. But among this group - our customers and ourselves - there's a consensus that organic growing produces superior flavour. Are we deluded?

    Let's say I wanted to increase the flavour of my produce (not just the sugar content) without increasing its nutritional value, could I do it and if so how?

  • 17 years ago

    But among this group - our customers and ourselves - there's a consensus that organic growing produces superior flavour. Are we deluded?

    You might be, but who knows?

    I recall a show on TV a few years ago. Don't recall the name of it unfortunately. What was done was folks went to a fancy restaurant where the waiter was in a tux, used fancy words, accent etc. The atmosphere was very upscale. In other words the customers were pretty much sold on how incredible the food would be before it ever arrived.

    Back in the kitchen meals were being put together from frozen TV dinners and other foods we regard as 'low end'.

    All of the customers were asked to rate the quality of the food they were served and with only one exception they all raved about it. The exception was a professional food critic.

    In other words if you expect it to be better, you might find it to be better. That's why a blind taste test would be preferable.

    Moving on... Recently over on the container gardening forum there was a debate and some folks posted links to studies showing organic crops had higher levels of vitamin C, anti oxidants and other 'good' stuff.

    In reading the studies it became clear the difference in fruits wasn't really due to a difference between organic and conventional farming, but rather the different horticultural practices used between the organic and conventional growers.

    In one case the conventional farmer used too much nitrogen resulting in a poorer quality fruit and in the other case the conventional farmer provided a 'boom or bust' cycle of nutrient delivery to the plants.

    The reason the organic grown was superior was that in the organic system nutrients were provided to plants in a more consistent, even manner.

    The lesson from that is fertility management of the crop has a direct result on how nutritious the crop will be. Whether that makes it taste better is anyone's guess and would have to be considered subjective.

  • 17 years ago

    I'm not trying to convince you. ;o) You asked us to critique the logic, so I tried to point to the arguments you'll likely encounter and where the leaps were made. If you present your case, you'll need to be able to counter. I wasn't being cynical of chefs, just using the example to illustrate that there are possible other common causes. There are others, but I didn't think past 1 at the time, because 1 is enough. What about the possibility that local organic growers have a vested interest in their ability to make the claim their produce DOES taste better, and to insure that it does, so harvest it when it is at or closer to peak maturity than conventionally (mass) produced produce? See - another argument that has validity and definitely deserves consideration. ;o) You even make a similar argument that can be used against your case in "Some of the difference must come from freshness, ie our produce is picked and sold the same day." To turn the argument in his favor, your opponent needs only to say, "See - I TOLD you it wasn't because of more sugar/minerals."

    I wouldn't say that anyone is deluded, but I'm pretty sure there is a certain amount of bias caused by adherence to a chosen ideology.

    I don't know that you can necessarily build in more flavor by how you supply nutrients; I'm a physiology guy & I'll leave that argument up to those more passionate about it than I, but you can ensure the flavor of your produce by (in part) making sure it's exactly at the stage in the growth cycle where its flavor is most appealing (some plants are best when a juvenile phase others at other phases), for many- when mildly drought stressed, others still, when they are near dead-ripe when you harvest.

    I'm not sure how nutritional value and flavor are tied together, except that carbohydrates tend to build as produce matures, which is generally resultant of or in unison with a higher sugar content. I'm not sure you can extricate one from the other.

    Take care. ;o)

    Al

  • 17 years ago

    this IS Fun. ALthough I have felt, as a foodie, that organic produce, sometimes tastes better, sometimes it most definitely does not. Buy and eat organic bananas day after day and you will discover that sometimes even a ripe organic banana has NO FLAVOR, and sometimes when they are out of organic, i must say that a conventional banana has has superior flavor.

    BUT I think a significant reason for buying and using organics, chefs and all is the GREEN MOVEMENT. We don't want to feed our customers, babies pesticide laden produce. Pesticides neutralize the equal nutrient value of conventional vs organic. That is, they decrease the health value. Also chefs and other trend followers may choose to, as a value added side effect, contribute to the healthy soil-making and conserving methods that organic growers use. Conventional farming methods have polluted our county fields and streams for years, not to mention the huge reduction in top soil and its organisms--not good for the neighbors health. Yes, it may rationally appeal to us bleeding lefties to eat at restaurants that cook with organics.

  • 17 years ago

    Not a botanist, but what about this: If your soil is made of a rainbow's range of composted matter, does it not contain more nutrients than poor, agri-biz soil? And would not the superior soil content be taken up by the tomato, therefor making a more nutritious tomato (vs an agri-biz, poor-soil-grown tomato)? Actually this is an outright question, not an argument. I see that fertilizers may contain from a to z of the mineral elements, but what about the enzymes and metabolites from fungi and bacteriae, etc.

    Grass grazed beef contains more, even some omega 3 and 6, while corn fed beef contains almost none.

    as an aside: there is another flavor beside salty, sweet, sour, bitter. I'm not sure if its named, but it is the musk-type flavor experience from tomatoes and chocolate. I'm also not sure if it has its own zone in the mouth.

  • 17 years ago

    Nylisa - I alluded to the green movement in my very first paragraph when I mentioned "trendiness", but we're not talking about pesticides, rather how plant nutrition affects taste and to a lesser degree, our own nutrition.

    The nutrients that come from a rainbow's range of composted matter are exactly the same nutrients you find in chemical fertilizers. All plant nutrients that originate in soils are salts, and all organic molecules must be broken down into elemental forms (salts) that can pass through semi-permeable cell membranes. Plants don't care where their nutrition originates - bag, bottle, organic soil amendments are all the same to them.

    Symbiotic relationships with soil biota do help plants absorb nutrients, but they're rendered less important if nutrients are already available in ionic form.

    I'm not anti-organic at all. I almost never use a fertilizer in my gardens or beds, choosing to 'feed the soil' instead. That approach has blessed me with gardens that are regularly toured by several groups each year. However, when it comes to anything in containers, I discard this approach in favor of supplying nutrients in (truly) soluble form. I can control what plants are getting and when they get it. That is impossible with an organic approach.

    About the tastes: There are at least six tastes. In addition to the classic four, there are the taste of fat, and a taste called umami. "Umami" means delicious in Japanese, and is the word for the savory taste of meat. In fact, our taste buds are designed to tell us something about the nutritional qualities of the food we eat: sweet for ripe fruits and carbohydrates, sour for unripe fruit and vitamin C, salty for salt and other minerals, bitter for (sometimes) poisonous plants, umami for protein, and fat for, well ...... fat!

    Al

  • 17 years ago

    She blinded me with science.

    Taste is an individual pleasure. If you discern that organic taste better then it is what it is.

    When I first made sauerkraut I browsed the inet to pick up some tips. Many sites advised to use organically grown cabbages because they have more water content. I will never know if that is true because I will never use anthing but organically grown cabbage.

    The organic movement is relatively new. Indepth testing will be done in the future but til then my sauerkraut taste pretty good and I am satisfied.

  • 17 years ago

    Someone on these forums recently said something like, "Science is science, and wishing real hard doesn't change it."

    Of course our perception is important in determining what tastes good to us, but it's not at all unusual for our perceptions to be skewed by mindset or ideology. It's difficult even for those with scientific minds to omit bias and prejudice from their findings, let alone the casual gardener.

    Al

  • 17 years ago

    Al, so it's fair to say that you're not sure how nutritional value and flavor are tied together? ;o)

    I stand by the integrity and talent of our chefs. They've spent a lot of time in our gardens, asking questions or just strolling and enjoying, and there's nothing trendy about their desire for organics.

    From the site linked. They make a lot of claims. Is the following not true?

    What causes light to refract as it passes through plant sap?

    1. The amount of carbohydrates in the juice.
    2. The amount of dissolved minerals in the plant sap.
    3. The amount of covalent bonding.

    Here is a link that might be useful: brix site

  • 17 years ago

    Al, so it's fair to say that you're not sure how nutritional value and flavor are tied together? ;o)

    I am not Al, but...

    What does nitrogen taste like? What does calcium taste like? What does vitamin C taste like?

    I am sure that a plant growing under ideal conditions including fertility will be healthier and thus likely more nutritious than a poorly growing plant, but how that translates into flavor I don't know.

    Flavor is subjective. What is a good tasting tomato? A very tart one or a very sweet one? If poor nutrition makes an otherwise sweet tomato taste more tart and a person prefers a tart tomato then does nutrition and flavor correlate? :)

    I think one could probably be able to make and support and argument that proper fertility leads to a more nutritious plant, but it would be impossible to argue it makes the plant taste better since flavor/taste is subjective.

  • 17 years ago

    "but it's not at all unusual for our perceptions to be skewed by mindset or ideology. It's difficult even for those with scientific minds to omit bias and prejudice from their findings, let alone the casual gardener."

    Mindset is usually a problem for me but no problem if it makes my food taste better.

  • 17 years ago

    "What causes light to refract as it passes through plant sap?" has nothing to do with
    1. The amount of carbohydrates in the juice.
    2. The amount of dissolved minerals in the plant sap.
    3. The amount of covalent bonding.
    I'm a glazing contractor, so I can tell you a little about refraction. Refraction is the bending of a wave when it passes from one transparent medium into another. It is the effect of the different speeds of wave propagation in two substances that have different densities. For example, when light passes from air (less dense) into glass (more dense) it slows down by about 1/3 and is refracted. The amount of refraction depends on the densities of the media, the angle at which the wave strikes the surface of the second medium, and the amount of bending and change of velocity corresponding to the wave's frequency.

    You may be thinking of something else, called deviation, I'm not sure. It occurs if/when the faces of the transparent material are are not parallel or they are curved, as with a prism or your "drop of sap". The light rays emerging from your sap will not be parallel to the incident light. The angle between the incident ray and the emerging ray is called the angle of deviation. In any case, this has nothing to do with the three items you mentioned, either.

    "Al, so it's fair to say that you're not sure how nutritional value and flavor are tied together?"

    Mmhmm. I said I was not sure upthread. Are you? I have some ideas, but I try to stick to things I'm certain I can back with either science, or sound reasoning and logic, and I'm not interested enough to go searching for the answer.

    You, though, have already reasoned that they are linked ("If organic produce has, ounce for ounce, more flavour, and therefore more carbohydrate and mineral content, than conventional produce, then it must be healthier."), and I haven't said they are or aren't. As far as I can see, that places the onus of the burden of proof squarely on your shoulders? ;o)

    By your statement, you have to prove not only that a higher carbohydrate and mineral count causes more (and by your other inferences - 'better') flavor, but you have also to prove that it's healthier. That is, you have to PROVE it with science, not by a link to an infomercial.

    "... and there's nothing trendy about their desire for organics."

    If you think about it, you'll see that you would have a difficult time proving this statement about almost anyone, let alone chefs, because the increased interest in organic produce is, in fact, a fairly recent (certainly within the last 20 years) 'trend'.

    "Mindset is usually a problem for me but no problem if it makes my food taste better."

    If mindset is a usually a recognized problem, and you think it makes your food taste better, shouldn't we agree that it's all in your head? Certainly there is no intent to use that as an argument?

    Al

  • 17 years ago

    Oops - I meant to say ... the onus of proof ..., not "... the onus of the burden of proof ...", which is redundant. Sorry.

    Al

  • 17 years ago

    As an organic gardener and farmer for over 40 years, and the former owner and chef of two different restaurants, I can tell you that there is a huge difference in taste between organic and nonporganic produce.

    I owned those restaurants over 24 years ago when organic produce was not easily obtainable commercially. We were forced to use non-organic.

    Since I also owned a small organic farm, I had access to organic produce, although the health department prohibited using produce that was not inspected. At one point, I did it anyway.

    I had an abundance of plum tomatoes, parsley, basil, eggplant, zucchini and lettuces. When I used the organic stuff I grew myself, I got exceptional raves from my customers, many more that I usually got, which were numerous.

    Everyone wanted to know what I did to make things taste so fresh, and the taste so crisp and yet delicate. There was a dramatic contrast between the two, and people preferred the organic overwhelmingly, even thought they didn't know they were eating organic.

    Ron
    The Garden Guy
    www.TheGardenGuy.org
    Read Articles & Garden Journal Entries!!

  • 17 years ago

    I'm not biased one way or another, but you reveal you are, Ron. I don't prefer produce grown in any particular way, but I do prefer it when it's taken at the proper time and brought quickly to the table. My container tomatoes are grown in pine bark, peat, and perlite, with no fertilizers or soil amendments other than a little dolomite and a soluble 9-3-6 formulation with all the micro-nutrients. They simply burst with flavor when I pick them on a warm sunny day and eat them like an apple - as I'm sure the organically grown maters you worked over all season do, too - as do those I grow in my gardens and feed with nothing other than compost and other OM.

    Paul asked if his initial deductive was flawed, and I pointed to the flaws in his logic, as asked. So far, we haven't seen anything other than opinion from several, coupled to attempts to bolster his arguments that didn't hold water, and that could easily (almost certainly does) stem from the strict mindset I'm not saddled with.

    If you look at my posts, they're kind of matter of fact with a fair amount of science and logic tossed into the mix, while many of the other posts are full of 'beyond compare' adjectives and superlatives. I'm: "Eh - as long as it's ripe and fresh ....., I'm happy." while you guys are: "There's nothing better than my way - period."

    I've even made an effort to provide some science that you guys might be able to use to bolster your case, or at least reach a better understanding of flavor, if you wanted to do some searching and dig a little deeper. It's probably just easier for me to point out the differences in our presentation approach and just move along, than to argue in the face of rigidity, so I'll let you guys have the last word & watch to see if it's something that actually supports your presumptions.

    Take care.

    Al

  • 17 years ago

    I had an abundance of plum tomatoes, parsley, basil, eggplant, zucchini and lettuces. When I used the organic stuff I grew myself, I got exceptional raves from my customers, many more that I usually got, which were numerous.

    Was it because it was grown organically or because you harvested when it was ready instead of early and got it onto your customer's plates without it spending time being stored and shipped?

    I grow produce in ground gardens with nothing other than compost and soybean meal and also grow produce in containers much the same way Al does, using synthetic fertilizers, no compost etc.

    I can't tell the difference between the two in terms of flavor. I can tell the difference between either and a tomato that was taken from the vine too early though.

  • 17 years ago

    No way that anybody can win the organic taste argument against the scientific priciples.

    Last season some on the container gardening thread said that they had tried growing org in containers with little success. When an org gardener claimed that they were growing beautiful veg in containers a dissenter would claim that what may be beautiful to one may not be to somebody else. The challenge was to show pictures to prove that beauty is actuall beauty so to speak.

    So I did. Tomatoes and particularly hot peppers are what I grow in containers. I enjoy the flavor and taste and on a personal basis find it superior to stuff that I previously grew in th eopen garden with miricle grow.

    Celery grows ok in containers and that's about all they did for me in the open garden in previous years. I will find out about cukes this yr.

    What grows spectacularly well in org containers are red potatoes with emphasis on spectacular.

    I did not care for the way green ice lettuce grew in containers org only because the plants did not have the same crunchy texture as they did in the garden.

  • 17 years ago

    If flavour were purely subjective there would be no cooking schools, chefs, good restaurants, professional tasters...This should go without saying. And brings me to a point that hasn't been mentioned yet, which is that some people have a more discerning and developed sense of taste than others.

    In my experience, chefs' budgets are tight and yet they're willing to pay a premium for organic produce.

    About ascribing better flavour to the fact that produce is locally grown and fresh picked: in winter, when we've run out of our own carrots, and we're in the city, we'll buy organic carrots from California, 2000+ miles away, over conventionally grown local or imported ones. The organic ones are sweeter and lack that bitter tang that comes, I've heard, from petrochemical herbicides.

    Which brings up another side of superior nutrition, a generalization but it affects what we buy - organic produce lacking negative inputs like pesticide residues.

  • 17 years ago

    Al,
    If I am biased, it's because I have seen my restaurant customers reaction to the switch from non-organic to organic. That has a way of influening you.
    Justaguy - you asked if it was because the organic was fresher . . . I don't know. I know the non-organic stuff we got from the produce company had the appearance of being fresh, and I only used what was in season. I can't say for sure that it was not part of the equasion, but I doubt it was all of it.

    Ron
    The Garden Guy
    www.TheGardenGuy.com

  • 17 years ago

    No way that anybody can win the organic taste argument against the scientific priciples.

    Sure they can...with science ;)

    Define what 'good flavor' is in a non subjective way and then show what it is about organic methods that produces that better than non organic methods.

    The OP said: The superior flavour of organic produce comes from sugar and mineral content both. Where else does flavour in fruits and vegetables come from?
    If organic produce has, ounce for ounce, more flavour, and therefore more carbohydrate and mineral content, than conventional produce, then it must be healthier.

    First, the claim is organic grown results in higher sugar and mineral content.

    Next the claim is higher sugar and mineral content = better flavor.

    My own claim, a counter claim if you will, is that providing growing conditions that result in a healthier plant will yield more nutritious produce than will produce from a less healthy plant.

    Interestingly, GreenGrass, I can support that claim using 2 studies that you posted in the container gardening forum ;)

    A claim that I do not make, as I can't support it, is that higher nutritional value in produce = better tasting.

    It might be so, it might be so for some things and not others, I really don't know.

  • 17 years ago

    Either you speed-read my first post justaguy (and Al) or I didn't express myself as well as I thought. I made statements based on my experience. The rest was conjecture, not claims - like I said, I'm not a scientist. My aim was to get a discussion going and voila.

    I don't imagine higher nutritional value necessarily equals better taste (what does vitamin A taste like?), but I can believe the opposite.

  • 17 years ago

    There are findings in writing by some very reputable people that state higher nutrition in org produce. You choose to disregard unless their report is peer reviewed and published. That's your preroggative.

    Science means absolutely nothing to me in the health area. Please read last sentence one more time.

    By your own admission, you practice organic soil priciples by incorporating compost etc. So in essance much of the produce that you eat has taken up nutritional value in the way of trace elements from your org treated soil. Hence better *taste* and better nutrition. I choose to carry the procedure one step further by making it totally org by using org fert.

  • 17 years ago

    Paulns: I've attended many Acres USA annual conferences over the years and often heard it said at them: "where there's more sugar there's more minerals." And recently: "and more polyphenols and bioflavins, only more so" has been added. Now I don't know the proof of this, presumably it comes from tissue assays. I reason that more sugar means more efficient photosynthesis and therefore more of the minerals associated with photosynthesis (those we so far know about, that is) such as magnesium, calcium, phosphorus, and boron. My bottom line is that I trust my refractometer because I believe it's telling me more about nutrition than just sugar content. And I do find that, by and large, good taste goes with high Brix. Regards, Peter.

  • 17 years ago

    There are findings in writing by some very reputable people that state higher nutrition in org produce. You choose to disregard unless their report is peer reviewed and published. That's your preroggative.

    You are kidding, right? You posted two studies on this in the container gardening forum and we discussed them. Neither study concluded anything other than moderate, consistent nutrient supply worked better than over fertilization or boom/bust cycles of fertilization.

    That I prefer peer reviewed studies is kind of like saying I prefer someone who knows what they speak of to a monkey typing words. If someone is going to go through the effort of actually setting up and conducting a study, they are going to get peer reviewed unless they avoid it. If they avoid peer review, there is a reason. Science means absolutely nothing to me in the health area. Please read last sentence one more time.

    I don't need to. You are effectively saying you prefer anecdote that agrees with your preconceived ideas to reality. Your choice, but don't hold your breath waiting for others to join you. By your own admission, you practice organic soil priciples by incorporating compost etc. So in essance much of the produce that you eat has taken up nutritional value in the way of trace elements from your org treated soil. Hence better *taste* and better nutrition. I choose to carry the procedure one step further by making it totally org by using org fert.

    When I grow plants in the earth I am organic, yes. When I grow plants in containers I am not. I can't use soil in containers due to drainage problems. When growing in the earth I choose to feed the soil and let the soil feed the plant. When I grow in containers there is no soil to feed so I choose to feed the plant.

    I can't tell the difference in produce I grow in organic raised beds or synthetically fed containers.

    If you can then follow your taste buds.

  • 17 years ago

    Gee justaguy, I don't consider professor Leifert a monkey typing words and this is what he says as a result of his 10 yr study.

    "Professor Carlo Leifert, co-ordinator of the study said: "We have shown there are more of certain less nutritionally desirable compounds and less of the baddies in organic foods, or improved amounts of the fatty acids you want and less of those you don't want"."

    Ok so you say you can't tell the diff btwn your org grown produce in the earth from your inorg stuff grown in containers. That was not my point.

    My point was that you choose to grow org in your garden. Why do you do that? Why don't you just feed the plants with the inorg fert that you use in container plants?

  • 17 years ago

    You've mentioned Acres USA before, Peter, and I finally went to their website - lots of useful information there - thanks.

    It seems reasonable to me to expect organically-grown produce to contain elements and combinations of elements that science can't (yet) test for. Similarly, how do you explain the influence of 'terroir', an old and accepted concept, on flavour, scientifically? The workings of mycorrhizae aren't yet fully understood, scientifically. Etc. That doesn't mean the explanations for these things are metaphysical.

  • 17 years ago

    Gee justaguy, I don't consider professor Leifert a monkey typing words and this is what he says as a result of his 10 yr study.

    "Professor Carlo Leifert, co-ordinator of the study said: "We have shown there are more of certain less nutritionally desirable compounds and less of the baddies in organic foods, or improved amounts of the fatty acids you want and less of those you don't want"."

    I didn't say this professor was a monkey, greengrass1. I said I preferred peer reviewed material to random whateverness on the web. The quote from the prof you posted is from a yet to be reviewed/published study. Neither you nor I know what that study will end up saying about anything, right? My point was that you choose to grow org in your garden. Why do you do that? Why don't you just feed the plants with the inorg fert that you use in container plants?

    Because in my garden I have soil. I consider using homemade compost and locally grown/purchased soybean meal to be closer to a sustainable approach than store bought fertilizers (synthetic or organic). That is the high minded reason, but a more practical reason is that 'it works' and it is easy (and cheap) and I like it. I honestly don't know how to explain why I prefer organics when I grow in the soil as I know it can be done just as well with synthetic nutrient sources. It is what it is, I guess.

    I suppose I could get similar results with a bag of ammonium sulfate instead of soybean meal, but I dunno, I simply like using the soybean meal better.

    I am not sure what this has to do with flavor or nutrition though. As I noted, I can't tell the difference in flavor between veggies I grow in the garden organically and those I grow in containers with a soilless mix and synthetic fertilizers.

    Curiously, Al (Tapla) recently sent me a link to the summary of a study that showed flavor (no idea how they defined flavor) in tomatos was best when the nitrogen used in the soil was urea (ammonium based) rather than nitrate.

    Since I generally use nitrate based sources of N in containers I found this interesting.

    How does this relate to the present discussion? Organic sources of N tend to start out as ammoniacal forms and then convert in the soil (or in the plant) to nitrates.

    This study seemed to say tomatos taste best when their N isn't given as nitrates. Who knows, maybe years of cheap beer have killed my taste buds :) LOL

  • 17 years ago

    Yes I agree organic gardening is sustainable vs chemical fert that depletes soil over the yrs.

    Getting back to cabbage and the fact that some experts recommend that org be used for making sauerkraut because of water content.

    I spent some time reading info about making sk. I read over and over again on the chat lines that people had to add water to cover the cabbage. I have made 4 batches so far using both early and late cabbage. I have never had to add water because the cabbage juice easily covers by at least a couple inches. Chemically raised cabbage does not have the water content to do that in many cases. More water content better taste.

    Nice talking with you and you can have the last word as it looks like others are no longer interested.

  • 16 years ago

    Taste is too darn subjective, a to each their own sort of preference.

    While conscious of the science I find comfort in the logic of organic. In a balanced natural environment plants grow at their intended genetic rate based on the soil qualities (suitable for the plant species) and environmental influences (sun, moisture and temperature). Under organic management there is the effort to maintain the balances, particularly of soil nutrients. It is the common sense that if all the nutrients are present and balanced, that the plant obtain all they require. Research as shown higher density and diversity of nutrients in organic. Organic offers you the natural vitamins, minerals, proteins, etc that you only find in convention packaged foods as artificial fortification/replacement.

    Conversely, under conventional practice the emphasis is placed on the NPK with little attention to other nutrients. Typical conventional agriculture is mono-cropped per field planting.

    There has been little mention if any of the influence of the species variety. Most gardeners struggle to acquire the varieties most pleasing to their senses.

    A major dilemma under organic is the exploitation by corporations for the sake of profit over proper stewardship. The many factory farms are part of the vertical ownership; supply farm inputs, production, processing and wholesaling - in several cases you also find them at the retail end. It is not surprising that they also use monetary influence in lobbying for relaxation of the standards.

    Shoppers must look beyond the certification to look at the producer. Know the source of your food. Visit the farm. Find a farm market, join a CSA or locate a community garden if you need space to produce some of your own food.

    Awareness must accompany education.

    You are what you eat so make your own choice.

  • 16 years ago

    From my limited brix experience I do know that a watermelon that has 13+ brix is likely to taste very good while one with 11 brix is likely only good. Density? More complete health? Variety? Growing conditions? All of above?

  • 16 years ago

    Hi Dan:

    "Conversely, under conventional practice the emphasis is placed on the NPK with little attention to other nutrients."

    Do you mean the other macros. and all the micros.?

    Do you think Organic growers soil test more than conventional growers, if so, on what basis do you make that statement? I have no idea the frequency commonly used by commercial organic farms but have seen some commercial areas where soil sampling is used quite commonly for the same reason you state organic methods are used, "to maintain the balances, particularly of soil nutrients".

    Totally agree about the taste thing being highly personal. The post-harvest folks we worked with were hesitant to do a lot of taste testing even under controlled conditions as they knew the results often varied wildly. You say tomato, I say tomahto and I'll get to Ireland before you.

    Very good point about variety, that throws a wrench in the taste issue.

  • 16 years ago

    This winter I am taking a brix/soil nutriment workshop.

  • 15 years ago

    I grow organically , however I have to go with talpa on this one.There could be many reasons why food tastes as it does.These reasons may have absolutely nothing to do with organic vs non organic.Especially if they are purchased rather than raised.I agree that folks can be trendy if there is something at stake.Many of the so called " organic " sections of markets have produce that I would not purchase because of its poor conditions. Probably based on prices and it not moving.
    I think I can present an example of " faulty reasoning and claims ". How many times have we heard . Eat lottsa garlic , it is good for the heart. Ok . What is the dosage and contra indications? Well italians eat lottsa garlic and they do not have heart attacks. First off , is that true? And if it is true Italians have less heart attacks there could me many reasons for this , including garlic.Some one may know the dosage but I am willing to bet that the next person to tell you to eat lottsa garlic will not be able to honestly tell you how much to consume to be effective.
    Why I choose to garden organically is because in my many years of gardening I have obseved that my Flowers , Vegetables , Fruits seem to grow better when i concentrate on soil building and not so much on plant food. I also do not care for the toxic results of some chemical sprays. Nor some " organic " sprays. This is a very interesting topic and I hope we all learn from one another. I will have to say that I have purchased a brix tester and I will be able to measure somewhat my improving cultural practices.Even at that it would not be conclusive unless I tested in an unbiased way both organic and non organic cultural practices. All i will be able to say is that I had this result and after practicing my organic culture i have this result. That will be good enough for me. But i wont be trying to sell a 50 cent tomato for a dollar fifty because it is " organic ". Happy gardening Johnny

  • 15 years ago

    I have done some reading where animals do have preferences for forage and grains grown on one part of a field rather than the other part of a field that was treated differently. Cows will bypass lush grass around dung and urine spots not because they are fussy with smewll, but because the high nitrogen grass is unbalanced...and they are far better "food scientists" than we. The same goes for pigs too.

    Some calves were eating the second coat of plaster on a wall and leaving another section alone. It was discovered that the calves were highly deficient of magnesium. Turns out that the second coat of plaster was made with dolomite lime.

    I suspect that we humans are not nearly so discernible as most animals [dogs excepted...they gobble about anything!].

    Soils poorer in fertility will grow crops higher in carbohydrates, but lower in proteins.

  • 15 years ago

    Comin in way late to this one, but had to add my two cents. I'm in the Al camp in that I use chem fert in my container plants, while I use soil building techniques in my open soil. Diverting from science, I do it because it seems to make sense, not because of any specific research or anything like that. Containerized plants have the same nutrient requirements as open ground, and they gotta get it from someplace. I find that the open ground plants generally produce more (and better) fruits and veggies, but there are way too many other factors in my unscientific approach to draw any conclusions. Also mentioned long above, drought stressed fruit is sweeter, organic or not. Don't really care if it is more nutritious, I don't like watery apples. To add an additional wrinkle, i would assume (yall know what that means) that organic farmers/gardeners would tend to grow more heirloom/op varieties, which may be superior in flavor to those hybrids generally chosen by large mono crop operations. Just a thought. Wayne, great observations about animals knowing what they need. With the exception of dogs. Mine will search the yard for every last morsel of rabbit poop, and I doubt she has any kind of physiological need to do so. She's gross and knows it!