Software
Houzz Logo Print
west9491

help with lawn, soil test adjustments

18 years ago

I am wondering what amendments i need to make to my soil for my lawn, i just applied alfalfa pellets, and i think i need to apply bone meal or something phosphorus as my P is low, as for the lime i still need to get some, i haven't been outta town to do so, but was it a mistake for me to go ahead and apply the alfalfa pellets before the lime? cuz i know soil pH has a lot to do with nutrient in take. I do know i need calcitic lime, not dolomitic, cuz i don't need to raise my Mg any higher, but i do need to catch up with my Ca. And what is CEC?? here's my results so you take gimme your take on things.

-------------------------------------------------------------

P = 9 (low)

K = 227 (medium)

pH = 4.8

buffer pH = 5.8

Ca = 1556

Mg = 252 (high)

Zn = 1.2

Calculated CEC 13

%BS 35

%K: 2

%Ca 26

%H: 65

%Mg: 7

Recommendations

---------------

N: 1 to 1.5 lbs./1000 sq. ft.

P2O5: 3 to 5 lbs./1000 sq. ft.

K2O: 1 to 2 lbs/1000 sq. ft.

Lime: 220 lbs bagged lime/ 1000 sq. ft.

Zinc: none

Mg: none

- Apply 25 lbs of 5-20-20 per 1000 sq. ft. along with 220 lbs of lime per 1000 sq. ft.

------------------------------------------------------------

(end test)

Comments (9)

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Any Idea what the humus level, amount of organic matter is in that soil? The lime, at 220 pounds per 1,000 square feet, is really important, while the phosphorus at around 5 pounds per 1,000 square feet is not that necessary. Ample levels of organic matter should take care of that.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    not sure, they didn't test that. gues i gotta do the mason jar test.
    oh yeah, and putting all that calcitic lime down at once would probably burn my existing lawn right? I've broken it down into three treatments:
    front lawn is 3,000 sq ft. so 660 lbs of lime need.
    I went out n bought 6 bags yesterday so thats 240. I'll buy another 6 later, and then 5.

    and whats some good OM to raise P??

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I not only distrust soil tests but my distrust has grown into serious resentment if not hate. Did you learn anything that your next door neighbor wouldn't have already known? In my opinion unless you have problems with your soil...problems that you know about and have tried unsuccessfully to fix, then you might need a soil test from a professional, not a university. If your grass grows and looks good, forget about P.

    You have 3,000 square feet in front. How much alfalfa did you put there? The correct answer is 30-60 pounds and not more than 90 pounds. If you use too much organic fertilizer you run the risk of the sour smell chasing you away.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Many people have an aversion to having a good, reliable soil test done but there are valid reasons for doing that,
    1) So you know the base nutrient and soil pH levels.
    2) So you do not add "stuff" to your soil that it does not need, but that you do add "stuff" to your soil that it does need.
    3) So you do not add to the pollution of your environment.
    4) So you do not spend money on "stuff" you do not need.
    5) So the yields from the garden are really optimal and the plants you grow are not bothered by insect pests that are more attracted to plants under stress or that are unhealthy because their diet is wrong.
    An organic gardener should be concerned enough about the environment they live in to not want to contribute to the pollution of out planet and having a soil test done will aid in that concern.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Why test your soil

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    i put down 50 lbs. and am following that up w/ 220 lbs of calcitic lime once a month for three months to adjust ph and Ca. and plan to throw a little store bought compost in the in the mean time. I will be applying compost tea when my compost pile is finished.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Putting nutrients of any kind into your soil in excess of what is needed can result in those nutrients flowing out of the soil and into the groundwater causing pollution of that groundwater, what you eventually drink. Unfortunately that this happens has been documented by much the same people that you distrust to do your soil test. Many people think that adding manure is fine and not a problem, but the nutrients in manure can easily pollute your water, and it has often, and while what we hear about mostly involves a CAFO the same thing can happen in the backyard if too much manure, or any other nutrient source, is applied to the soil.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Nitrogen is nitrogen is nitrogen when it comes to polluting water. NW Arkansas (where I used to live) is either #1 or #2 when it comes to poultry production. Thus, loads of chicken poop. Now, we can argue that perhaps the chicken poop isn't 100% organic as it's from chickens that aren't organic, but the overabundance of chicken poop in the area causes all sorts of problems with streams, rivers, ponds, and lakes in the area.

    As to pH, if growers have extremely acidic soil, they'll want to bring it up some to grow the most common backyard veggies, or may want to lower high pH to grow something like blueberries.

    I also agree that it's more important what the plant is actually taking up (and thus think that foliar tests provide the "best" knowledge in commercial ag situations). However, a soil test will tell you if a nutrient is present and isn't available to the plants because of something like improper pH, or just isn't there in adequate levels at all. So soil tests are useful too, and in a garden situation where many different plants are being grown, foliar tests would be too expensive.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Why don't you consult Soil Food Web, Inc? I'm pretty sure they will tell you that adding that much lime is toxic to the soil biology. Isn't what organic gardening is all about? They will recommend you try something without really screwing up soil biology. They are way ahead when it comes to soil biology knowledge compared to someone like Kimmsr.