Software
Houzz Logo Print
keepitlow

Localvore...what does it really mean for us?

16 years ago

Being a localvore is a popular trend nowadays to try and save the planet.

http://www.localvore.net/

I had a photo of a localvore vs a world (diverse) eater to show you guys - but I can't find it. The localvore is about 1 to 1- 1/2 feet shorter than the world eater. In any case, lets look at this localvore thing in detail.

We can see in this photo what being a localvore would mean to many of us.

{{gwi:136719}}

The localvore fruit salad is on the left, the 'world / diverse eater' is on the right. Although even this localvore fruit salad is only so-so local. The apple I dehydrated comes from Michigan which is 350 miles away and the raisins comes from CA which is 3000 miles away.

But lets pretend I grew them local, as they are possible to grow apples and grapes here. (Although all of my grapes failed to thrive and were pulled out...but lets pretend) And if I was a better prepper and farmer I may have some canned peaches to add to the mix. And some canned or dried cherries, except the bird always pick 100% of the cherries before they even ripen.

We can see that while being a localvore sounds good, we would have to cut way back in the diversity of what we eat. The world fruit salad comes from Italy, Honduras, California, Michigan, Costa Rica, Uruguay, Argentina, Florida and Chile. Now, I didn't go out of my way to find foreign fruits for it. This is just where all this stuff comes from between October until June.

This should underscore how dependent we are on crude oil for the world we have created. Lets say I wanted to supplement my localvore fruit salad with corn grits every day. Corn grows pretty well in the Mid Atlantic area where I live. But without crude based fertilizers made from natural gas or animal based fertilizer the corn grows undersize and sparse.

If you have every lived on a diet of corn grits, it is not that great. So, instead of corn grits, I could also make oatmeal from oats...imported from Canada.

Let me tell you about the last 2 - 50 pound sacks of organic oats I bought from Canada. The oats were filthy with dirt and dust. They had rocks in them and mouse poop. But all that could have been fixed by sifting, washing and drying the oats before I would roll them. What could not be fixed was that the oats were rancid as hell. They all had to be trashed. Well, I guess I can always bake some bread...with wheat grown 2500 miles away in Montana and a grain grinder made in Korea.

You can see once we cut crude out of the picture things change dramatically for us.

It amazes me how the old timers and especially the Injuns survived these harsh winters. And I'm only in zone 6. What about the poor guys in the lower zones? Look at what I have to do to get my fruit trees to grow. The old timers did not have welded wire fencing and rabbit guards made from plastic.

{{gwi:62258}}

Without this armor plating the deer's would rip the tree in half and the squirrels and raccoons strip any fruit that would be on the tree even if there were no deer. And as an added bonus from nature...the rabbits would girdle the tree in the winter and kill it. And the voles? Well, you research that on your own.

But to top all this off, many fruit trees are biennial's with their production...they only produce fruit every other year! I guess that is why the old timers were called 'people of next year' and the modern day people are called 'people of today.'

We should have made the Injuns our gods and worshipped them for their survival skills instead of killing them off.

Who would ever have thought finding real, honest food would be so tough nowadays. I have to drive 125 miles to buy raw milk and grass fed beef. If I don't get lost, I can make the round trip in just under 3 hours.

As far as costs?

Raw milk $9.60 a gal. Grass fed beef for stew cheapest cut $8 a pound. Tack on the $24 gas for the car.

Now, I don't eat or drink much of it cause of the cost and distance. (mostly distance issue) But our food chain keeps decomposing like hell and it is getting harder to feed oneself these days if one is looking for basic untreated natural foods.

No guys, I not a doomer. I am not a negative person. I am not against eating local. But when you look at the world we have created artificially through fossil fuels and where we are headed...it is not a pretty picture for us and especially our decedents.

http://dieoff.org/

I'll leave you with a rundown on grass fed beef for those that may not know how our beef supply has changed these last few decades.

The beef and poultry are force fed unnatural diets high on genetically modified corn. (proudly advertised as an 'all-vegetarian diet' on the packaging.) The all grain diet, coupled with growth hormones make the cattle outgrow grass fed cattle more than two to one.

The animals are packed like sushi into confined animal feeding operations and wade though oceans of their own manure. This close quarter confinement and loss of roaming ability also makes the cattle put on weight much faster than grass fed cattle.

The unnatural diet raises hell with their digestion and they have to be given loads of antibiotics to not die. Their digestive tracts culture drug resistant e.coli thanks to the antibiotics and it gets into / onto the meat when they are slaughtered.

As a bonus, a lot the good omega 3 fatty acids have been taken out of grain fed cattle's meat as well as cows milk, cheese, yogurt, butter etc, since they are not fed their natural diet of grass.

Pick up a half gal of organic milk that advertises omega 3. It most likely will be fortified with algae oil. What is left in grain fed meat is an imbalance of too much omega 6 fat that fuels our heart disease problems in the US and not enough omega 3.

The grain fed meat has to be radiated to kill the e.coli but the manure is still high in e.coli and gets into our other food products such as vegetables / spinach / almonds / apple juice etc. These have to be radiated / pasteurized / steam heated / chlorine bathed to try and kill the e.coli as well.

But the antibiotics still make their way into our diet through eating the grain fed meat, drinking the milk, eating the cheese, yogurt, butter. As well as our water supply from people taking the antibiotics as medicine and eating the tainted meat. As humans excrete waste it gets into the water and we drink or bath in it and absorb it up...what a mess!

Food related news sites:

http://www.foodandwaterwatch.org/

http://civileats.com/

http://www.fooducate.com/blog/

http://producepedia.com/

http://www.metrofarm.com/mf_Food_Chain_Radio.php.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_malthus

Comments (7)

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    For industrial ag food, transportation is only ~18% of the net caloric input. For local food driven to the farmer's market, it is often more than 18% as economies of scale are lost.

    So it is important to state why local consumption is desired.

    Is it to allow Third World countries the opportunity to break the back of the WTO-World Bank? If so, what is the help you are giving the country to empower their citizenry?

    Is it to lower your carbon footprint? Then eating local likely won't do it.

    Is it to dissociate our food chain from Big Ag? This alone won't do it as their lobbyists in DC are busy loosening organic rules to favor them and have far more money than small farmers.

    There must be clear, achievable goals that make sense toward sustainability. IMHO the typical ones given are misguided or wrong. Peak Oil will take care of Big Ag and transferring knowledge to more people will ensure resilience and that should be the reason, and locavorism only goes so far toward that end.

    Dan

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    KIL, your presentation is melodramatic, IMO. Greatly exaggerated and based on presumptions. The presumption that there is some compelling need to eat an exotic array of fresh fruits at all times, for instance. The presumption that there would be no way to handle the deer problem if local food production were undertaken seriously, for another.

    Most all regions have some kind of well-established fruiting shrub, which can be eaten fresh and put up and don't require effort to cultivate. Around here examples are autumn olive, blueberry and huckleberry, blackberry, and grapes in limited areas. Thinning of forest for fuel purposes would considerably increase those and reduce deer-cover.

    Once the problem of excess animal pests is deal with, the use of well-adapted varieties of cultivated fruits, vegetables and grains makes harvests with modest use of fertilizer and water pretty reliable. Yields vary from season to season but total failure is extremely rare. That has been my experience, at least. Still, it would be smart to keep two years capacity of staple foods and planting stock on hand.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    pn, thank you for making explicit the logical fallacy above.

    Speaking of sustainability, autumn olive is invasive and shouldn't be privileged.

    Which is a good point here wrt scrutinizing the reason for the movement. Surely when transportation is much more costly tropical and Southern Hemisphere fruits will be far less common and we will need to have more food grown in our watersheds. But giving poor or poorly-thought through reasons for localvorism doesn't help anyone. Today and in the near term it won't lower the carbon footprint. It won't help sustainability, esp if proponents privilege non-native invasives. It does provide fresh food. It does provide knowledge transfer. It does promote small family farms.

    When cheap energy is gone, far more food will be grown in our watersheds, provided there are people around with the skill to do so. We need to ensure, now, that such people are around. IMHO we won't do that by poor rhetoric on any side of the issue. The period after WWII is a blip and should not be considered the norm.

    Dan

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Dan, why is a non-native invasive necessarily not sustainable? I know that many knowledgable people are highly (perhaps voraciously) opposed to them, but I don't quite 'get' it. Is autumn olive eventually going to use up its habitat and disappear? Some presumably native shrubs and trees around here seem to compete well enough with it; AO has been in this area quite a few decades and it is present in somewhat limited habitats. In truth if the local population needed to get all of its vitamins from local fruit and etc there would not be far too much autumn olive and it would likely need encouraging rather than the opposite to ensure an abundant supply in the face of huge demand. An invasive that suddenly becomes a useful crop probably won't really be an invasive, will it? It will be getting a lot of attention and kept where it produces best and is easiest to get at.

    There are native species that colonize cleared forest faster than most if not all non-natives. Around here I don't think any shrub or tree can compete with short-leaf pine in a newly-cleared forest. Autumn olive competes for control of old fields and road-sides, both of which are convenient places for gathering berries.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Is autumn olive eventually going to use up its habitat and disappear?

    Invasives disrupt energy flows. This lowers the resilience of the ecosystems affected. Lower resilience means less ability to withstand disturbance.

    Dan

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I end up localvoring more often than not, but not a fanatic about it. But high among the reasons is quality / cost. I buy my grass-fed steer from the guy across the street. The time I pay him, get it processed and packaged, it costs me $3.00 a lb. Hamburger, steaks, what ever. This is excellent meat, some of the best I've ever had.

    I have a 20 tree orchard. Last summer was a bumper crop, and I have dozens of quarts of pureed fruit, stacks of fruit leather, dried fruit, and dozens of pints of fruit butters.

    I grow a big garden. I can several hundred quarts of tomato sauces a year, dozens of qts of pickles, sauerkraut, and we fill one chest freezer with assorted frozen vegetables. I buy about 120 lbs a year of pinto beans grown up the road, and we get venison and elk. I buy locally grown flour, there's a mill in town. The point is all this stuff is far better quality and considerably cheaper than what I can get in the store.

    But I do buy rice, and there is an embarrassing stack of empty navel orange sacks in the pantry, and I love grapefruit. I'm too lazy for hens and eggs.

    Its not really a lifestyle 'statement' as much as enjoying good food, and not paying that much to do so.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Disrupt? To break apart or rip asunder the energy flow from sun to soil? Via photosynthesis. An invasive plant lives by photosynthesis; if it flows less energy to the environment than a native plant that could occupy that spot, then I suppose that might be a reduction, not really a disruption.

    A field of grasses is, as I understand it, a poor use of land that could grow forest. It has to be constantly held to that lower energy flow by human intervention. When that intervention stops, shrubs and trees begin. Some of those colonizers will be natives, some not. That process would seem to be the opposite of disruption.