Software
Houzz Logo Print
henry_kuska

What does a herbicide do to the soil?

15 years ago

Organic farming involves a decision not to use certain herbicides (and gmo products that utilize glyphosate). This very recent research paper may be useful in understanding that there is science supporting your decision:

Title: "Effect of four herbicides on microbial population, soil organic matter and dehydrogenase activity"

I particulaly recommend looking at the graphs that compare the control (blue lines) with the herbicides.

Here is a link that might be useful: link for above

Comments (23)

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Do you have something from the U.S.A.?

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    This is a January 2011 scientific paper. When another scientific paper cites this one, it will be noted in Google Scholar as part of the information for this paper.

    For earlier papers on the same subject, the reviewers through the editor will normally insist that the important previous work be included in the Introduction or the Discussion/Conclusion section(s) of the paper.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    jolj, because the USA universities depend on conpanies such as Monsanto to provide the dollars for the research they do you will probably not find much USA research that finds problems with the products these companies manufacture. On rare occassion you may find a researcher that steps out of line and publishes critical research, but few will bite the hand that feeds them.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Where there is little immediate harmful effects, little is likely to be criticized in the USDA world. However where there are immediate detrimental effects, the farmers are likely all ears.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I've tried to find a glyphosate herbicide formulation that recommends application to soil at the frequency it seems this study used. I can't find one, can anyone help me out?

    Lloyd

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I had heard that there was government criticism that the USDA should be examining GMOs more closely. The link in the box gives a brief summary of the criticism.

    The recent scientific research article published by 2 USDA laboratories should be of interest to organic growers.

    http://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/jf904342t

    Here is a link that might be useful: Link for USDA criticism.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    If I felt as bad about the USA Government & USA Universities as some of you seem too. I would move Rome.
    I use a gas powered car & get my home power from a co-op
    So I feel can not preach to the Government about the environmental. That the way I see it.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I can't open the OP's link. Here it is again.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Academic journal

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    "I would move Rome".

    And heaven and earth, too, presumably?

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I found some research DONE IN THE USA, OMG!!! That found that Glyphos apps. tie up Mn in the soil, Most regrettably, I have no idea where the darned paper was out of or where I can find it again. Just for a little confirmation, I talked to the local grain elevator manager (they custom spray 1000s of acres/yr w/glyphos) if she had heard of the Mn tie up issue. The manager stated that she was aware of it and that they will on the customers request, add Mn to the tank of glyphos mix to account for the amount that is tied up in the soil.

    Kimm - your comment about universities is insulting and a blatant lie, I worked for one of those universities you slam with blanket statements, I have more to say but it would be extremely rude and offensive, use your imagination. Oh, and it wasn't too rare that the big, evil mega-giant corps. that provided grant research money for our research were disappointed with the results of our work, meaning it didn't support what their evil, greedy hearts were hoping for. That didn't change a damned word in any our hundred +- peer reviewed papers. Deal with it.

    Perhaps you don't know that what can happen is this, good research is published for years on end, even decades on say one topic, the research points to a pretty obvious conclusion. Then, Administrators at the top of the food chain decide, for political reasons to practically speaking, change the meaning of all those years of research. It really does happen, sickening!

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Real world April 2009 evidence of glyphosate leaving the roots and having a negative effect on the plants:
    "according to work done at Purdue University, Kansas State University and the University of Nebraska, some of the glyphosate sprayed onto the corn plants eventually is exuded from the roots and is detrimental to microbial activity."
    The same batch of seed corn is grown in 2 areas.
    The first area (which I call the control) does not have glyphosate in the soil. The corn grows relatively good.

    The second area has the corn that has been sprayed. It grows poorer. The scientists concluded that the glyphosate was given off by the roots and was detrimental to soil enzyme activity. Apparently this was of concern in 3 major agricultural areas of the U.S.

    The following is from a reviewed published 2006 scientific paper.

    "These results suggest that glyphosate residues or drift may result in severe impairments in Fe and Mn nutrition of nontarget plants, possibly due to the formation of poorly soluble glyphosate−metal complexes in plant tissues and/or rhizosphere interactions."

    http://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/jf0625196
    ---------------------------------------------------
    Title: Glyphosate inhibition of ferric reductase activity in iron deficient sunflower roots

    Authors: Levent Ozturk1, Atilla Yazici1, Selim Eker2, Ozgur Gokmen1, Volker Römheld3 and Ismail Cakmak1

    Authors affiliation: 1Faculty of Engineering and Natural Sciences, Sabanci University, TUR��"34956 Istanbul, Turkey; 2Department of Soil Science, Faculty of Agriculture,
    Cukurova University, TUR��"01330 Adana, Turkey; 3Institute of Plant Nutrition, University of Hohenheim, D��"70593 Stuttgart, Germany

    Published in: New Phytologist (2008) 177: pages 899��"906

    Abstract: "Iron (Fe) deficiency is increasingly being observed in cropping systems with frequent glyphosate applications. A likely reason for this is that glyphosate interferes with root uptake of Fe by inhibiting ferric reductase in roots required for Fe acquisition by dicot and nongrass species.

    This study investigated the role of drift rates of glyphosate (0.32, 0.95 or 1.89 mM glyphosate corresponding to 1, 3 and 6% of the recommended herbicidal dose, respectively) on ferric reductase activity of sunflower (Helianthus annuus) roots grown under Fe deficiency conditions.

    Application of 1.89 mM glyphosate resulted in almost 50% inhibition of ferric reductase within 6 h and complete inhibition 24 h after the treatment. Even at lower rates of glyphosate (e.g. 0.32 mM and 0.95 mM), ferric reductase was inhibited. Soluble sugar concentration and the NAD(P)H oxidizing capacity of apical roots were not decreased by the glyphosate applications.

    To our knowledge, this is the first study reporting the effects of glyphosate on ferric reductase activity. The nature of the inhibitory effect of glyphosate on ferric reductase could not be identified. Impaired ferric reductase could be a major reason for the increasingly observed Fe deficiency in cropping systems associated with widespread glyphosate usage."

    The link is: https://research.sabanciuniv.edu/10763/1/Glyphosate_inhibition_of_ferric_reductase.pdf ******BUT be forewarned,***** my security system indicated that it may not be a safe site.

    5 more recent scientific papers have cited this paper; they can be looked at at:

    http://scholar.google.com/scholar?cites=1636036598241325543&hl=en

    When you look at the Google Scholar hits for the 5 papers, please note that the last one by Herique et.at. also has a paper citing it.

    Here is a link that might be useful: link for first paper above

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    The manager stated that she was aware of it and that they will on the customers request, add Mn to the tank of glyphos mix to account for the amount that is tied up in the soil.

    Wow, that one might warrant some looking into. I seem to recall reading something out of Iowa State in which it was stated that including Mn (or other cations like Fe, Zn, etc.) will result in the formation complexes that the plants have a tough time absorbing. This is total shoot from the hip stuff, but it seems that you might not get as good of control, resulting in either a higher rate or frequency of glyphosate application required for control and/or decreased effectiveness of the Mn application.
    I don't remember too many details regarding rates and formulations so...take it what it's worth.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Henry: I think the work I was thinking of was the stuff out of Purdue/KSU/U of NE, darned brain, the Author out of Purdue is escaping my recall but I think he might have been the lead scientist.

    Gargwarb: good point about the tank blending of glyphos and Mn, when she told me that my ears sort of pricked up along those same lines. Maybe somebody has already looked into the issue and came up with reliable practices in Iowa already. Was I too harsh on Kimmsr ya think, I just couldn't let that go?

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I thought you said precisely what needed to be said; nothing more, nothing less.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Gargwarb:

    I found this, it may be what you had read. Very interesting reading being that our water, and thus our elevator's water is very, very hard. think I'll talk to the elevator mgr. some more at least to see what form of Mn they use. It is very common to add ammonium sulfate in tank mixes w/glyphos, "for quicker burn down" but at least one other custom outfit went to a liquid stuff that is green, don't know what it is -

    http://www.css.msu.edu/varietytrials/corn/Cropping%20Systems/mngly.pdf

    And this one, bet the weed guys at Purdue aren't too pleased with one of their own, Dr. Don Huber -

    http://www.btny.purdue.edu/weedscience/2010/GlyphosateMn.pdf

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    In a round about way...yes. It wasn't either of those but the Iowa State publication I was thinking of was mentioned in the Purdue link:

    http://www.weeds.iastate.edu/mgmt/2010/glymn.pdf

    The one from MSU is pretty interesting. They mentioned that if your water is acidified with sulfuric acid, Mn antagonism of glyphosate is greatly reduce. (But they don't say how acid) That might be a factor for your folks right there. Of course, their formulation of Mn could also make the point mute as well.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Oops, forgot about the hard water part you said. And yeah, they threw in a couple of pretty good little digs in there for the good Dr. Huber, didn't they?

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Found out today that the liquid alternative mentioned to dry amm. sulf. in tank mixes is just a liquid amm. sulf.. The elevator does little of the Mn addition and does use Mn-EDTA when mixing w/glyphos. if requested, seldom requested. There are a few bigger operations that do their own spraying that deal with Mn issues on beans and include some Mn formulation w/glyphos; whether or not they are trying to reduce the antagonism and/or increase plant Mn absorption I don't know, haven't talked to those guys directly. It appears Mn and glyphos are not applied in separate sprays but combined to make only single trips over the fields required killing 2 birds with one stone.

    Like the areas in MI mentioned in one of those links provided, we have calcareous soils here w/pHs 7.0 and above, hence the micro deficiencies.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Well, if they're doing the EDTA, it sounds like it shouldn't be too much of an issue. And I feel your and their pain regarding the calcareous soils. Manganese, in particular, is a bear.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Nothing like irrigating calcareous soil with high bicarbonate water..... uh, how come my leaves always look like that?

    The solution - acid injection into the irrigation system via a Mazzei injector so water pH = 5.5, neutralizes the bicarbonates allowing micros. to stay available and the soil structure to stay intact rather than turn to water and air impenetrable wasteland. CO2 off-gases and the H+ goes into the soil to do good things there. Pain in the butt but it's better than the alternative.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    The link below is interesting information.

    Here is a link that might be useful: A link to more about glyphosate problems

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I know a man who has been growing vegetables over 55 years & owns 800 farm & vineyard.I was visiting a few years back & commented that his sweet corn rows were clean, not a weed or tool mark in the soil.
    I ask him how did he keep the corn patch so clean.
    He said he sprayed round-up on the weeds.
    Amazed anyone would chance kill the beautiful corn stalks.
    I ask how he kelp the round -up off the corn plants.
    He said he was careful & if a drop got on a blade, he would pinch it off & drop the blade on the ground.
    He planted corn there for three year, that year he had two ears on almost every stalk & all the ears, I saw shucked were full of kernel. Some 12 inch long.
    After 3 years I do not know why the corn was so beautiful.
    But this why I doubt the links & research. I have seen things to the contrary. How can it be true in Kansas & Nebraska, but not be true in South Carolina & Georgia?

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    One possibility is different soil characteristics such as organic character, mineral concentrations, phosphorous concentration, and pH. These have all been looked at by scientists.