Software
Houzz Logo Print
pepper71

Is Asphalt organic???

15 years ago

I went to my local ORGANIC garden supply and picked up some compost for my garden. I layed it out and it had a few clumps in it so I figured no big deal. We got a heavy rain and the clumps turned out to be asphalt. Is this ok?

Comments (23)

  • 15 years ago

    No! I have not idea how asphalt could get mixed into compost, but I would take back what I could and get a refund.

  • 15 years ago

    You said a few big clumps, right? Maybe at some point it was on a crumbly asphalt surface and a piece of equipment, such as a front end loader, scraped up a bit of the parking lot when loading or turning. I'd just pink out the few pieces and not worry about it.

  • 15 years ago

    I agree with rlv4, it's not ideal but sometimes these things happen. Just pick them out and if you have the desire you can mention it to the people you bought it from.
    They should be interested enough to try and solve the issue.
    As to whether the compost is dangerous, I would say no.

    Just curious, how many and what size were they and in how much compost are we talking in volume?

  • 15 years ago

    I bought 6 50lb bags of organic compost. I just came in from getting the rocks of asphalt so I could show the folks up at the store. I went through the compost a little more and came across some parts of plastic and plastic bags and a piece of glass. Is this normal for organic?

  • 15 years ago

    It may be normal for that manufacturer. You won't be poisoned by it.

    Dan

  • 15 years ago

    Why is asphalt not organic? Just curious. The encyclopedia says it is found in natural deposits or removed from petroleum and that petroleum is from fossilized organic materials.

  • 15 years ago

    Just got back from Rons Organic. They offered me 3 bags of Brand name pure compost that sells for 3 dollars a bag. The house brand I bought , which I thought was better, was 5.50 a bag. IMO , the house brand is more expensive and has TRASH in it. I have kids and they might want to walk through the garden with no shoes and the compost had glass... The brand name is pure and cheaper. I think I am done with this place. I dont like their "standards" of organic and their prices are high. Pretty much like all "organic" shops here, seems they cater to the ignorant and charge them dearly for it.

  • 15 years ago

    Why is asphalt not organic? Just curious.

    Someone who has never seen a blacktop road resurfaced! Who knew?

    Petrochemicals.

    Dan

  • 15 years ago

    Yes asphalt is organic, it is made up of rocks,sand & petroleum(tar).
    But just because crude oil was once plants(million year ago)
    does not mean it is good for your soil.

  • 15 years ago

    The tar in asphalt is not extracted from the ground, it is the byproduct of petrochemical refinement. A man-made chemical from a refinery. I'm quite sure there'd be some teeth gnashing here if petrochemical fertilizer were found in the compost. That said, the OP won't be poisoned.

    Dan

  • 15 years ago

    I think engineers call the stuff made up of rocks,sand & petroleum(tar) "asphalt cement" and that I'm guessing that is almost certainly what the OP was asking about. Again, I think asphalt is an organic product of unknown composition that is mined or removed from petroleum. I doubt if asphalt will harm, or benefit, your soil in a million years.

  • 15 years ago

    No mastter how this asphalt got mixed into the compost it should not be there and simply picking it out and not complaining to the seller alows even more of that sloppy packaging to happen. There is no excuse for junk to be mixed in with compost, since there are screens that can keep that material out of the compost.

  • 15 years ago

    I'm quite sure there'd be some teeth gnashing here if petrochemical fertilizer were found in the compost.
    Check and mate.

  • 15 years ago

    From Wiki: In American English, asphalt (or asphalt cement) is the carefully refined residue from the distillation process of selected crude oils. (emphasis mine)

    Nothing about this definition leads one to believe the product is organic!

    As to compost containing chunks of asphalt, rocks, glass, parts of plastic bags, even pieces of metal like nails, etc. -- it happens :-) Much of it originates from yard waste recycling programs where the homeowners are not properly responsible about what they include. Better composting operations will screen the finished product to remove a lot of these items but not all are completely thorough. Removing the items yourself can be a bit of a bother but doable and in no way do they alter the intended purpose of the compost or its effectiveness.

  • 15 years ago

    Several different definitions of "organic" are being confused here.

    Organic chemicals are based on carbon. Cyanide, for instance, is an organic chemical.

    Organic matter is anything that is or was once alive. This is a different sense of organic than that used for chemicals.

    Organically grown means growing without the use of synthetic pesticides, herbicides, or fertilizers. These synthetics are generally derived from petrochemicals. Petrochemicals tend to be carcinogenic.

    Asphalt is "organic" according to the chemical definition but not according to the definition we use here. It's composed of petrochemicals and is carcinogenic. That said, I would just pick it out of the compost and not buy from that place again. I would also use that compost for non-food plants, because who knows what else was in there.

  • 15 years ago

    Thanks guys for the breakdown of the bad chemicals.

    KIMMSR "No mastter how this asphalt got mixed into the compost it should not be there and simply picking it out and not complaining to the seller alows even more of that sloppy packaging to happen. There is no excuse for junk to be mixed in with compost, since there are screens that can keep that material out of the compost."

    Thats my thinking but too bad this place sells so much to listen to me. I almost had to tell the owner too shut up. She never stopped talking long enough to hear anything. "we have been in business for 15 years", she said. She offered me 3 bags of soil therapy compost to replace the store brand that had plastic, trash bags, glass and asphalt in it. I told her I payed for 6 bags not 3. Ok, I will give you 3 bags of STC and 3 bags of some compost and acidifier. Ok, how much will the compost and acidifier change the PH, IT WILL NOT, they said. I should of just went off right there. I came to the conclusion that this "ORGANIC" shop has no clue what they sell.
    oh ya, I goggled soil therapy compost and found out its not recommended for vegetable gardens ( I clearly stated this is for a vegetable garden) as its made from sewer sludge.WTF!!!!!
    All this aggravation , time , money used up on some thing I can make for free and 100x better. I wish I could kick my self. It sucks to work on the soil for 3 years and take anothers word for their product and ruin your work with their chit.

  • 15 years ago

    It is clear that some of us need to get a life.
    I am going to bed, got a real garden & compost to work tomorrow.
    pepper71, I am sorry for the trouble you had with the garden supply. I hope your next contact with a business is a good one. I agree that you can make it better your self.
    crankyoldman, thanks for the definitions.
    I had not thought of it until now.
    Coal & crude oil comes from dead plant matter, that was once alive. That means that DIAMONDS are organic!!

  • 15 years ago

    Coal & crude oil comes from dead plant matter, that was once alive. That means that DIAMONDS are organic!!
    By some of the looser definitions, yes. Naturally formed diamonds would be organic (though not synthetic diamonds). But strictly speaking, it's an allotrope of element carbon and not considered an organic material.
    (I have a life, I just can't recall where I've left it. I think it might be in my other pants.)

  • 15 years ago

    I, personally, left my life inside the record sleeve of my Born to Run album from Jr High. Its why you see me pawing thru milk crates at flea markets on the weekend.

    Dan

  • 15 years ago

    Got me there!LOL

  • 15 years ago

    Whether or not it is organic is irrelevant. It is not an ingredient you want in your garden soil. You paid for a shoddy product. She should make it right. End of discussion.

    If you paid with your credit card and the owner hasn't fully made it right by your standards (a few free bags isn't sufficient), then you can always tell her you will refute the charge with your credit card company. Tell them that the product they sold you was defective and put it back to them to make it 100% right. At the very least it will be an incredible hassle for her to defend herself against the claim and slow down her getting payment, and she might just be willing to fully compensate you for the shoddy quality soil.

    And her defensive reaction is probably an indication that they've had this complaint before. Most compost places I've ever worked with, acknowledge that all kinds of stuff can show up in compost. Most people aren't bothered by it, but I bet if I showed them big chunks of asphalt or big shards of glass, they'd just give me new soil or a refund. I'm always picking out tiny pieces of glass or the occasional shred of plastic... not enough to take it back, but if I were you and bought such a small amount, I would.

    Good luck.
    -kmama

  • 15 years ago

    Hey there Pepper71. Thanks for responding to my thread in the soil and compost section about my similar experience with high dollar lousy organic compost. So aggravating to feel like you've been ripped off! You can always write a bad review on Google maps, that tends to reach a fair number of people. I'm a sucker for reviewing places. This day of age with the internet shady companies are finally facing their dissatisfied customers for all the world to see.

    If you ever want a good laugh look under google maps "sam's sushi nashville", I've eaten there twice with some homeless friends and experienced Sam for myself. Sorry, for getting a little off topic.

  • 15 years ago

    Road asphalt might contain polyaromatic hydrocarbons (PAH), which aren't good for you. Roads are made from a strange combo of materials nowadays, most of which you wouldn't want in a garden. Also, used road beds are often contaminated with stuff that comes out of cars - oils, gas, etc.

    I've learned more than I ever wanted to know on this subject after they chip-sealed my road late last summer. My garden (rural area) is within two feet of said road. Ooodles of chips were scraped off (accidentally) by the snow plows and dumped in my organic garden. A researcher in Mass. did a study about rehabilitating urban community gardens that had been contaminated with PAHs. Once again, compost really helps. Removing the source plus treating the area with compost (lots of it) did wonders for the PAH levels. I never cease to be amazed by compost.

    The good news for me is the heavy metals testing turned out fine. We couldn't find home-scale (non-commercial) PAH testing, and my DH researched & decided heavy metals was a decent stand in.

    Meanwhile, on the original post - I just got lovely compost that had a very, very few pieces of plastic in it. I wasn't too worried - it was 1/2 yard (A LOT more than you're talking about) and just a few pieces. Chunks of asphalt - well, loads of it wasn't enough to poison my garden, so you'll probably be fine. But I sure wouldn't buy from them again.