Software
Houzz Logo Print
thorspippi_z_9b

Raid Earth Options product line

21 years ago

I just saw an ad for a new product from Raid: Earth Options. They emphasize the fact that they're using some kind of plant to kill the bugs. And the "natural clove scent". I don't think the ad says straight out that it's "organic".

Has anyone had a chance to review the ingredients and determine whether it deserves a green-friendly review?

I'm committed to 99% organic gardening (the 1% is the tiny amount of Round-up that I'll let my DH use on the weeds in the cracks of concrete). But I'm not educated enough to be able to evaluate this new product.

Raid's Earth Options Ant & Roach product

Raid's Earth Options Flying Insect Killer

Raid's Earth Options Wasp & Hornet product

Comments (7)

  • 20 years ago

    This is what I just submitted to SC Johnson via email...

    I sprayed your "earth options" raid in my garage around my entrance to my laundry room. 2 weeks later I am ripping down the stairs, drywall, insulation, and the door frame trying to remove the horrid smell of cloves that continues to permeate my garage, laundry room, kitchen, and family room. I have already spent $150 and about 40 hours trying to fix the damage that your product has done. I am appalled that you would even sell a product like this. Worse yet, you market it as "earth friendly" so people like me who actually give a crap about the environment are more likely to buy it. My wife and children have lived upstairs for the past 2 weeks while I have had to suffer through the nauseating smells trying to get rid of them. I hope I don't have to literally knock down walls to my house to rid it of this horrible smell. And yes, I followed the directions on the can and sprayed the area until wet. At most I used 1/8 of the can. If I thought I could sue for damages I would. STOP SELLING THIS PRODUCT!!!!

    If I could have typed more I would have included the fact that for the past 2 weeks my wife and 3 girls have had to live upstairs in their bedrooms to escape the smell. I was told by the CSR when I called to wash the area with soap and water (which I did 5 or more times - still smells) and to provide ventilation which I have done with a box fan for 2 weeks - and it is in my garage which we have had to leave open for 2 weeks. Still smells.

    For those of you in need of Ant control I would recommend Terro Liquid Ant Killer. Unfortunately for me, I found out about it after I had already sprayed the RAID. The raid never even worked. The Terro worked after about a week and I never noticed any smells (although they may have just been covered by the horrid clove smell). Anyone know a good lawyer?

  • 20 years ago

    Look closely at the lable which will have listed the "active" ingrediants as well as the "inert" ingrediants. Once you have those you can look up the MSDS on the internet, but this will not tell you what, if any, synergistic action may take place with these products and that can be more dangerous than the individual components.

  • 17 years ago

    Here is what you need to look at to determine toxicity, the LD-50. The lower the number the better. In the case of Raid Earth I found two results on Google. One stated a LD-50 > 2500mg, but I believe that was for Earth Fire Ants. The other stated a LD-50 > 1600mg. But it was in a PDF and when I searched the PDF I could not find it. So unfortunately the results are not completely conclusive. It appears however that it does fall into a "Caution Label" and it has the same health rating as Enforcer Pesticide, and a higher health rating then Hot Shot Kitchen Bug Killer 2.

    Perhaps the Earth Option is the fact that they are attempting to use Clove as an insect repellent. Of course I would also be repelled by a strong clove smell.

    FYI- CY-KICK CS Aerosol , the stuff I use, has an LD-50 > 2000. And that is just because I am too lazy to mix it myself. If you mix the concentrate up yourself then the product has a lower LD-50 and is actually less toxic then table salt. If you ask me that seems like a more human friendly product then Raid Earth Options. Further, Cy-kick has a residual, meaning that it will stay active for longer period of time, whereas your Raid is only a contact kill with the residual smelly repellent.

    If you want a truly Eco Friendly Product then use EcoSmart. They are all natural and pass the EPA 25 rating.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Pest Control Products with MSDS

  • 17 years ago

    Let me say that when I lived in Sacto, the Arden-Arcade watershed (Arcade Creek) was the most impaired urban water body in the US. Why? Spraying and fertilizing. The organophosphate load was huge, as were the nitrates.

    That said, it is hard to find the consituents to this product, but I was able to find Eugenol - 0.50%; 2-phenethyl Propionate - 1.25%; and other ingredients of 98.25%. Eugenol is fine and maybe so is Propionic acid, as I suspect it breaks down chitin in certain insects (not sure here). Is it organic? I guess it depends upon your definition and how the acid is produced. But it is some sort of aerosol spray.

    Dan

  • 17 years ago

    If the substances that make up a product are, by themselves, rather innocuous then there is no requirement to test them mixed for any problems and often when two chemicals that are Generally Recognized As Safe (GRAS), by themselves, get mixed there is new, more dangerous, compound created. The directions on these state that contact with the insect is not needed, just spray around and it will kill them buggers and that is an indication of a dangerous product.
    Keep in mind that any product meant to kill something can also, in the right dose, kill you, or cause health problems.

  • 17 years ago

    I've found using WD40 on Devil's Horses, which I have deemed 'monsters', works fantastic in killing them - all sizes. I thought no insect repellent/killer worked based on friends that have sprayed the monsters with whatever they had. Including Raid.

    Of course, WD40 can kill your plants. I did an experiment to see if what I thought was true. I was correct. So I've always made sure to not spray any foliage.

    However, a friend of mine came across Raid Earth Options (with the nasty clove smell) and it...kills the lubbers without, from what I've seen, killing any foliage. So I'm thinking there is some (albeit very remote or loose) connection between the ingredients that would allow something to kill these bugs - because short of stomping them, cutting them with pruners, blasting them on the jet spray of a hose...thing, a weed eater or a lawn mower, nothing killed them. They are the worst insect pest for plants period, have no natural predators and should be eradicated from the planet.