slug questions

20 years ago

this year i'm trying for the first time not tilling in my vegetable garden. i laid compost and a thick layer of aged manure on top of the vegetable beds in the spring, and planted peas and fava beans right into it. (the manure had a lot of straw in it still, but i believe the manure itself was old, judging from its location in the pile i dug it from, and the lack of any manure odor.) now the fava bean plants have a lot of slugs, and the peas a few. i just did a search on slug control and see that mulch and compost should be kept away from the plants.

question one: how do you deal with slugs in this type of pile-the-mulch-right-on-the-beds and plant into it type of gardening? is that the problem, or might it have something to do with the manure not being completely broken down?

more questions: when and where do the slugs reproduce? do they lay eggs on leaves? do they continually reproduce, or have a brief window of opportunity during the spring? if left unchecked, do they vacation all year in the garden, overwinter, and live to lay eggs again next year? then die after laying eggs? maybe this is better asked in the insects forum... does anyone here know?

thanks,

debbie

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (5)

Heathen1
20 years ago
Mulch and compost kept away from the plants? not likely in my garden! They also like to live in dirt... here where it's dry, they'll hide in the moist watered dirt. Put out a dish of beer for them... they'll herd to that and die.
buttercupia
20 years ago
The most immediate and sure way I know of to end slug problems is to use Sluggo or some form of pelletized iron sulfate under other names which, I think is an acceptable, organic solution which is not only safe for pets an people, but puts iron into the soil. It isn't cheap,(about 6 to 8 dollars a pound but it works well and lasts quite a while. However, someone in this forum may very likely object to it for some reason I don't know,.. maybe because there is some plastic on the container it comes in..or some other reason, if we wait, we'll see.

Some success has been claimed by using broken egg shells, coffee grounds or ashes( I've tried ashes, and they don't seem to work, especially after they get wet. I think coffee grounds might have a chance to work, especially if they've not been brewed..but then that's an expensive experiment..
Related Professionals
Greenville Landscape Architects & Landscape Designers · Hilton Head Island Landscape Architects & Landscape Designers · Cedar Rapids Landscape Architects & Landscape Designers · Flint Landscape Architects & Landscape Designers · Lansing Landscape Architects & Landscape Designers · Ontario Landscape Architects & Landscape Designers · Gulfport Landscape Contractors · Amherst Landscape Contractors · Webster Landscape Contractors · Clearlake Landscape Contractors · Concord Landscape Contractors · Belleville Architects & Building Designers · Morgan City Architects & Building Designers · Fall River Architects & Building Designers · Grand Forks Architects & Building Designers
Kimmsr
20 years ago
Cold, caffienated coffee, waht is left in the pot after you drink your morning cup or so, is a good slug deterent when sprayed on the affected plants leaves. One, small, problem with organic gardening is we do provide a really good habitat for slugs to live in, however once the soil is in optimal condition slugs apparently will find sufficient food to eat in the organic matter in the soil and leave your plants alone, at least the seem to around here because all the flower beds are well mulch (most of the time when the wild turkeys allow that) with many slugs but very little damage from them to the plants.
tiffy_z5_6_can
20 years ago
I have the same problem. A friend told me yesterday to take an ice cream 2 litre container, cut the bottom out, and cover the sides with vegetable oil, then place around the plant, inserting the sides into the soil a bit for stabilization. The slugs will try to climb the sides of the containers but will slide off and never get in.

Another method I've started using this year is to get the kids to deadhead the dandelions and place the flowers in a little pile here and there in the gardens. The slugs LOVE to congregate on these, and it makes it easy for me to pick them and dispose.

Slugs disappear for the winter under the soil. There they lay eggs which will hatch in early/late spring and surface. For this reason, I'm assuming they must overwinter underground, but I'm not sure on that one.

In the hosta garden, early in the season, I will water with a solution of 9 parts water to 1 part ammonia. The ammonia is nitrogen. I may repeat this a couple more times during the season if the slug population is severe. This kills the slugs and if it reaches the eggs will destroy them too.

Picking them in the evening is the best control I've found. And early in the morning. Attract them with plucked dandelion flowers, grapefruit peels, banana peels, etc. If you have a dog and racoons hanging about, be creative...
habitat_gardener
20 years ago
I occasionally find caches of slug eggs when planting new transplants. They look like osmocote -- little round whitish spheres, maybe 20-30 to a cache. Earthworm eggs are translucent yellowish with a subtle little tail on them.