Software
Houzz Logo Print
vertigo101106

Brown shrivelled roots on Phal

19 years ago

My Phal finished blooming about 4 months ago. It is inside, doesn't get much sun, but I figured it must've been enough, because it seemed happy enough. Now the weathers getting cooler, I was contemplating watering it less. If i stick my finger in the bark, it is damp after a week (when a few months ago it wasnt). Have i overwatered it? The roots that i can see above the bark have developed into shrivelled and brown-looking. Are they dead? Should i repot (i have never done this)? Can i just use any bark pieces? Should i use antifungal or something? What should i use, can i just get it from a nursery?

The leaves still look healthy.

Thanks in advance,

Linda

Comments (28)

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Linda, are you really in NSW? Your my page details say USA. If NSW, just reduce the watering frequency as the weather cools down and place the orchid so that it gets a bit more filtered sun.
    If NSW, do not even think about repotting the plant till late spring. Don't worry about a few dead roots, though there should be some new roots grown during the recent spell of warm humid weather.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    "It is inside, doesn't get much sun, but I figured it must've been enough..." Those words or words similar to them have been at the root of more orchid deaths than all the ham fisted overenthusiastic waterers combined. It 'looks' ok, sure it does, for now. But it just spent what was supposed to be its growth season in so-so light and now it's going into semi-dormancy on an empty stomach. I'm not a betting man but the odds aren't good for this one coming out the other end of winter as good as when it went in. Not unless some attempt is made to supply some artificial light to it.

    H

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hi,
    thanks to you both!

    To arthurm: Yes I am in NSW (sydney); when I signed up it didn't give me an option out of the U.S. (?) Yes, after my readings, i thought to reduce the watering, some have said to water it less once blooming has finished, others have said to reduce watering during winter months. I was mainly concerned about the roots; not sure if it fell into the class of "root rot". So you think they are just dead? If it were root rot, would the leaves & stem/rest of the plant start to look different & unhealthy? I read somewhere that you should cut the brown shrivelled roots and repot with new bark after treating with fungicide.?....

    To Howard a: Do you think, if the Phal wasn't in ideal conditions, that it would have died after 6 months in the same spot (without moving)? There is a window about one metre away, where the sunlight comes through. Is this not enough? what kind of artificial light do you mean? UV globes? or just a florescent tube? for how long? I have been giving it 'orchid food', but some say to reduce this in the non-blooming months.

    Also, another question for you both: This is (quite humiliatingly obviously) my first Phal. I love it so dearly, it has bought me such immense joy. Anything you can suggest I take in with much appreciation! This Phal flowered between August to November (NSW Sydney 2006), I cut below the 3rd node hoping to get more flowers. I could not believe how long it flowered such beautiful flowers for! Is it true that they all have a certain 'time of year' when they flower? Or is it possible for me to have a dozen Phals, each in flower at different times of the year, such that i always have one in flower?

    Thanks so much,

    Linda

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Roots that are soft are dead. If the surface roots are dead, so are the foots lower in the pot.

    I would take the plant out of the pot and clean it completely. Take off all the loose coating from the root threads. If there are little or no firm roots, leave the threads to help hold it in the pot. You can use almost any bark except chemically treated (ground cover).

    When you water an orchid use a LOT of water. Get it really wet then don't water at all until the next time.

    You should not need an anti-fungal as a routine treatment.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Orchid's can survive for quite some time in adverse conditions. Especially if they are not that adverse. They can 'bank' the excess energy from the ideal conditions in the greenhouse where they grew up. OTOH so-so conditions do nothing to improve the situation of an orchid, there is nothing being put in the bank to pull it through a hard time. Your orchid, Linda, has been making steady withdrawals at the drive thru window and the account is just about at the minimum balance. Winter is a hard time for an orchid and in NSW you are probably in the equivalent of September. For this reason I would not advise doing an extensive repot at this time. I probably could get away with it. Not because I know more! But only because my phals are growing. Simply by virtue of living in a place with the right conditions one can have orchids growing simply by dint of good fortune on Mother Nature's part. Have you seen any new leaves grow out on your phal, Linda? How long does it take for the little nubbin leaf on top to grow out to full size? As long as an orchid is growing, it can be repotted. The reason why we are universally advised only to repot in spring and summer is because for the vast majority of us, and this includes greenhouse growers, orchids do not grow in Fall and Winter.

    Overwatering? What is that? I submit (again) that there is no such thing. This is heresy, I know. Overwatering and the need to avoid it is the cornerstone philosophy of houseplant culture. It is a holdover ideology from the last generation of plantkeepers when artificial light was nowhere near as practical as it is now. When you don't have enough light you can keep plants from rotting their roots by keeping them on the edge of dehydration. They don't rot their roots but IMO they can hardly be said to be thriving. For most houseplants, living on the edge is fine but for plants which must flower it is unacceptable. Orchids are a totally unique phenomenon in the houseplant world. Flowering houseplants disappeared from the mass market scene during the early 80's as too difficult. Orchids appeared in the 90's and were sold, not to be re-bloomed, but simply to be enjoyed for the time they were in bloom and then discarded. But growers want the challenge of re-blooming them and thanks to the Internet, a thing that did not exist in the 80's, they want to learn how.

    The 'how' of it requires light, lots of it. With enough light you can water your plants every single day. You can grow them in S/H if you choose. You can grow them submerged like water lillies. You simply cannot overwater a properly lighted orchid! Together, water and light supply 90% of an orchid's needs, fertilizer only 10%. You can grow an orchid quite well for years without any additional fertilizer. Not that you should do that, but when you know just where fert rates in the scheme of things... ....

    For a single or few orchid plants an East or West facing window with a 45W compact fluorescent bulb is near ideal. In a South facing (North facing in NSW) window in winter one might not need any supplement but during summer it will be necessary. This is counter-intuitive but it is so. In summer the sun rises too high in the sky to be of any use to a plant growing in a windowsill. Can't say much more about the minutiae of growing orchids in Australia. Arthur is our resident expert in that regard but I think my observations are near universal. If I had to move my collection down under I have a strong suspicion that with the things I've learned over the years they wouldn't get on too badly once they got over the shock of seeing their first platypus.

    H

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Ok, you love your phal and want it to thrive. Here's my attempt to help:

    As arthur points out, in Aus, you are going into winter, so it will be harder on the plant than it would in spring. Also harder for you to keep it going. But you will learn a lot either way by trying. We've all killed more than one orchid while we learned.

    Repot it, as suggested by richard. If the roots have rotted (squishy), remove them. IMO, sphagnum moss in a clay pot would be better than bark.

    Look the plant over carefully on all sides. If there are any bumps starting between the leaves, painting them with a rooting hormone will help stimulate new roots to form.

    Move it closer to that sunny window. It will recover faster in better light. A meter is too far away. Light intensity is reduced by half every 12 inches. So at 1 meter the light is 1/16 of what it is at the glass.

    Move it 6-10 inches closer, then feel the leaves during the day. If they are hot, it is too close to the window. If they are not, leave it there for a couple of days, then shunt it another 6-10 inches closer. That's the only way to find the right distance from a window.

    Phals can't take hot sun, but a sunny window isn't necessarily that level of intensity.

    About blooms year round: If you buy big phals, 12" or more leaf span, and grow them well, you can get two or more spikes out of them. This should last you at least 4 months, maybe up to 6 months. Big plants are much easier to succeed with, so buy the best you can afford.

    You can have phals in bloom nearly all year if you pick well:

    Standard phals bloom in winter-spring. Another type, with different ancestors bloom in summer. The summer bloomers usually have fewer flowers at once, but keep putting out a few flowers at a time from the same spike, often for years. These have beautiful, waxy blooms that last up to two months or more each. Texas Mist is an example of this type.

    So if you have four big plants-- two standard and two summer bloomers, you can have blooms all year.

    A suggestion for an extremely vigorous and beautiful standard phal is Baldan's Kaleidoscope.

    Some awarded plants are 4N, with twice the number of chromosomes, and exceptional vigor. These are much easier plants to grow and bloom.

    Buy your first few plants from an orchid vendor and not from a florist or grocery type vendor. Find one a good one and ask them which are ones are really vigorous and easy to bloom. A good grower will know which those are. Then start with those to increase your chances of early success.

    So, with a few of the standard phals and a couple of summer bloomers, you can have flowers all year.

    Buy big, established (yes, expensive) phals and they will bloom for longer. Also, spend some time learning to grow them well. Check out the cultural notes at Robert Bedard Orchids and at Bedford Orchids for a discussion of the importance of light for blooming.

    Good luck. I started to grow orchids because I loved the long-lasting flowers, too.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    With due respect to the above posters. Do not repot that orchid. But do heed what they have all written.
    We are talking about Sydney, Australia. Not the frozen north and not the tropics either. There is no central heating in most houses.
    So, in this house the night temps in the middle of winter will drop to 10/ 12C so if you repot it now it will not survive.That is another reason to move it closer to a window, so that some warm filtered sun will warm the plant up during the day. But on the hand, do not put the plant in one of those small closed off sunrooms where warmed up dry winter air will have an almost zero
    humidity reading.
    i have about 40 phals. They are nearly all on windowsills facing West. East would be better. They all get a few hours of screened afternoon sun. The best growing siuation is behind a matchstick blind on a window facing North but only from about now to the end of September because no sun comes in that window during summer.
    Do not know where the full shade thing comes from because a little bit of filtered sun is essential. Perhaps it is just to stop people putting their Phal outside where death is certain, be it summer or winter.
    With luck and provided there are some live roots left, you should see the start of a new bloom around about May and then count 110 days to the first flower.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hi everyone,
    Wow. Such great advice! I'm taking it ALL in, even though some of it is conflicting! This particular Phal, being my first, actually has some sentimental value to it, so I'll do everything I can to save it. So thank you all for all of your well-thought out advice! Thank god for the internet Howard!
    To further feed your minds with my problem:
    Howard: The Phal had 2 leaves when I got it, one of these died and another grew, just after the flowers fell off. About 3 weeks later (Dec last year) another 2 leaves started to grow. So there are 4 leaves altogether now. They are all close to full size i think. They are not floppy and look healthy. HOWEVER: i have only just noticed today, the stem is starting to die. It is about 30cm high, and has looked ok until now. There was only the dead bit above the node where i cut it back in Novemeber, and the rest below has been green ever since. Now at least half of the stem looks like its dying :( I think i should cut it just above the crown? or should i cut it above the 1st node?
    Ok, I have gathered that my poor Phal isn't getting enough light. I am surprised, though, that it didn't show unhealthy signs until now. It must be pretty hardy, to last 6 months in an unfavoured environment! What a good girl!! I feel terrible though. It has been near a South-facing window, which, in Aus, is the least amount of sun a window can give!!
    I am worried, however, that if I move it from where it has been for so long, to the only north facing window in my house, that it will be too much for it? I've also heard that it's no good moving an orchid... If I move it to the North window, It's in a room where I never see it :( But if thats what i have to do, so be it! Or maybe I can just move it closer to the window where it already is, as Mehitabel suggested, AND have another source of light?
    Another Question: How does a florescent light bulb help the plant? It has no UV in it, which the plants need for photosynthesis? If I leave the Phal where it is, and get a light to hang above it, for how long should I have it on a timer?
    Arthur, when you said to have the phal near a north-facing window until september, then is it ok to move it? where to then and whilst it flowers? because that is when it flowers isnt it?
    Mehitabel: Thanks so much, you seem to understand how much I want to save this one! Thanks for your advcice, i think i should get the hang of a few phals, and maybe one or two others, then my goal is definately to venture out into the world of beautiful flowers all year round. And your suggestions I have saved and will look back on. I need to prove to myself first that I am able to grow the simplest of orchids!! Lets see how the Phal goes... I'll keep you 'posted'...
    Arthur: I feel closer to home with you, as you know the weather here, and have been successful growing orchids here. Where abouts in NSW are you? It looks as though this 'sphag' stuff is the way to go: should i go and get some? or does that mean repotting which you dont recommend?
    Not sure whether to cut the stem below where it looks dead. Also not sure whether to move it!
    Thanks so much all you green-thumbs, i hope to become one of you in time!!!
    Linda

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    You are best off cutting off the flowering stem all the way down to a couple of inches. It will not rebloom.

    It is okay to move the plant gradually toward more light. It will surely die where it is.

    And yes, orchids take a long time to die. But actually that means you have lots of chances to save it.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    "How does a florescent light bulb help the plant? It has no UV in it, which the plants need for photosynthesis? If I leave the Phal where it is, and get a light to hang above it, for how long should I have it on a timer?"

    The sun is a wideband emitter of a great quantity of all kinds of light, UV and infrared included. Not every creature or plant uses all of them. Plants don't have much use for the green through yellow frequencies in sunlight as they do the red and the blue, but humans do! I don't think anything living has much use for U.V., plants included. UV is not necessary for photosynthesis. UV is an element of sunlight that all earthlife 'deals' with, but if the sun stopped emitting it altogether only dermatologists and plastic surgeons would be disappointed AFAIK. Because one can use artificial light to make just about any window hospitable or even a windowless space you can choose the best location from an environmental standpoint to house your orchid(s). If you will never see the orchid in the North window it doesn't make much sense to put it there. For a single orchid it is hard to recommend more than a 23W compact flourescent bulb. For a light that small you really have to keep it on for 16 hours each day. Yes, a timer is a near must as the light will be coming on rather early, even if you are awake at 6:00am probably you have more important things on your plate than remembering to turn on the orchid's light. 12" under the CFL light the orchid will start to pick up immediately. If you were used to watering it weekly it may surprise you by needing water more often. There is still, as Arthur said, a little bit of time during Fall when some actual growth can take place. This past winter I did nothing special about temps. Renters pretty much take what they get. I doubt day temps got much over 70F ever. My phals lost color in their root tips and definitely knew it was wintertime but because their light was good they did not stall entirely. All spent the winter growing out a leaf. They were near the radiator however and may have been responding to direct infrared radiation which did not affect the actual air temperature in the room. Even if your phal stalls entirely during winter, with good light it should hold onto some decent roots and the foliage will continue to look healthy and may even improve beyond what you thought was 'healthy'.

    H

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hi Linda, I just had a thought - how big a pot do you have it in? The plant should not be over-potted, as that will prevent it drying out as quickly as it should.
    Follow all the advice of the above posters. I wouldn't repot now, unless the mix is in really bad shape. Increase the light cut off that dying spike, and things should improve.

    Good luck,
    Jane

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hello all!
    Howard, I actually have an old light that I had for a fish tank. The bulb is 15W. I need to figure out how to set it up over the top of the orchid? You said 12 inches above it? You did say a 23W globe, but since I have now moved it right next to the window, will the two add up ok?
    I have a photo, but cannot post it. I was wondering if someone emailed me at vertigo101106@yahoo.com.au i could reply and send you a photo, it would be much easier. It is difficult to describe in words!
    Jane, in the photo you can see how big the pot is. it is smaller than the span of the largest leaves.
    If I tick my finger in the bark, the whole thing still seems damp, even though it has been a week since i have watered it, which I am instinctively reluctant to do so again until I get the right light for it?
    Is it possible to give it too much light? ie closer to the window AND Florescent globe one foot above?
    I cut the stem all the way down to about 2cm above the crown. I also pulled on a few of the roots I could see, and they fell apart with a string left in the middle, and some dust. I have no idea if there are any health ones underneath, but those I could see were dead!
    What about rooting hormone? Should I get some of this? Or am I now being abit over-the-top?
    I have increased the light, and have cut the dying spike. Shall I just sit and wait?
    Thanks again everyone,
    Linda

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    The 15W aquarium light will not do. Chances are it is incandescent and 15W of incandescent light is all but useless. Fluorescent bulbs are about (about) 4.5 times as efficient at turning electricity into visible light. Of course there is the issue of quality. Incandescent light is arguably of higher 'quality' than fluorescent but not enough so that anyone is going to go back to lighting plant gardens with incandescent. In all likelihood the 23W globe or spiral CFL will be sold as if it were a 100W incandescent. So, if you really wanted to use incandescent light over that phal, in order to give it as much light as I have recommended you would need to purchase a 100W bulb. The incandescent bulb itself will be dirt cheap but the kilowatt hours drawn from your local Power and Light utility will be that much higher.

    I always wonder about the use of prepositions like "next to" as regards windows. To me 'next to' a window means just to one side of it. In front of or 'in' the window I can clearly picture and that is of course what I recommend. 'In' the window just about touching the glass but not quite with the lamp overhead. That is far from being too much light. For the foliage to look as good as you say it does requires at least some viable roots. In any case, I don't see that it matters a whole lot. To my way of thinking whether the roots are 'fine and not in need of disturbance' or whether they are a 'rotted mess' are absolutely the same scenario. Why? Because the treatment for both is absolutely identical. Good light and temps, etc. consistent with what is known to be good Phalaenopsis care. Repotting is an involved operation requiring some amount of know how and will stress a possibly already stressed orchid beyond its ability to recover. If the plant is healthy it needs good light and warmth, etc. to stay that way and if it is ailing it needs good light and warmth, etc. to recover. So, it does no harm to assume that your orchid is somewhere in between absolute phal perfection or at deaths door. Just begin today to put in place the good culture practices that have been outlined in the thread. Good luck.

    H

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hi H,
    I've had this light suspended about a foot above the orchid today. Now I've read your response, I had a look on the bulb but all it says is 'Gro-Lux F15W' so I'm not sure what it is. It isn't very bright though, so just letting you know I'm going up to buy a florescent lamp now. I wonder, is a spiral one or a tube better? I don't actually have windowsills, so it is on top of a table pushed up against the wall, about 10cm from the glass, with the light tube (long skinny tube) suspended above it. I'll try and get a florescent to fit into the case i already have.
    Thanks again for your help, I feel like she's knocking on heaven's door. Hope I can pull her back with the right care.
    L

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Linda, this has been an interesting thread and you may wonder why you got all this conflicting advice. It all comes down to conditions. Someone growing their orchids under a bank of lights can probably repot at any time and get away with it.
    Have a look at the photo taken on this gloomy, sticky day.... it shows how the camera picks up light better than the human eye. Also how dim everything appears once you get away from the windowsill.
    Need to buy another orchid? There is a vendor thing at Castle Hill Showground this coming Friday, Saturday and Sunday. I'm not going near it because i'm trying to reduce numbers.
    There is no decent orchid forum in Australia but there are 90 orchid societies/clubs in NSW and you can always go along with your orchid to the nearest one as a visitor. But beware you could get hooked and spend the rest of your life living and breathing orchids. Website with contact details is;
    http://www.orchidsocietynsw.com.au/ListAffiliatedSocieties.htm
    In the link is a rather crummy photo of part of said kitchen windowsill. I'll leave on the OS website for a day or two, but i think it sums up what Howard says about light. though the light here in winter is rather better than that in parts of the frozen north.

    Here is a link that might be useful: rough picture

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hi Arthur,
    Thanks! That was actually going to be my next post (Where to find a healthy orchid vendor in Syd?...) so thanks for that! Although i plan on getting this one (being my first) under control. Is it possible for me to post a pic? or can i email you one? If you don't want your public info displayed, email me at vertigo101106@yahoo.com.au and then ill send you the jpeg? Your orchids look closer to the window than mine, but I can't get mine any closer. Plus it is double glazed, which I failed to mention earlier (another Phal sin on my behalf)! I went and got a florescent tube, but the biggest I could get to fit into my light fitting was a 15W one. But judging from what Howard said before, it is much better than the 15W incandescent I had. Maybe I could keep it on for longer? What would you recommend? It might be easier if you see the photo. The light is about a foot above it. This is not too close?
    btw what happened to your leaf? it looks as though someone took a bite out it! Also, if you are trying to reduce numbers, you can always offload on to me! :)
    Yes it has become somewhat of a surprised obsession with this one plant - I just must save it! I must get those beautiful blooms back, and know i worked hard for them! More rewarding than having the work done for you!
    Thanks again, hope to hear from you an email.
    Linda

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Actually, scrap that last one - thanks to your photo i figured out how to put some photos up, if you want to have a look:
    http://www.flickr.com/photos/7409907@N07/

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    It really looks like your plant is not getting enough light. I certainly appears that your light fixture is too far away from it.
    If you have a floor lamp, you could just screw in a CFL and put the plant right under it. Or a fixture with a clamp which could be attached to the window.
    Your plant looks okay, but needs more light.

    Jane

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hi,
    Sorry to bother you all again!
    The latest development: so I increased the light my Phal was receiving drastically over the last 2 days. The latest 2 pics I uploaded http://www.flickr.com/photos/7409907@N07/
    show that when i came home from work today, one of the leaves is now yellowing. They didn't seem warm to touch: so I don't know if this is due to burning or the continuing plummet towards death. Should I keep the light going or not?
    Another thing I noticed today was that the bark was absolutely saturated, but i watered it yesterday. i have never seen it so wet, even straight after watering!? I know this is going to sound stupid, but would it be water coming from inside the plant? or just water being soaked up through the pieces of bark from the bottom up, and i just haven'nt noticed this before.
    Sorry - I am a never ending source of questions!
    Not sure what my next step should be.
    L

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I agree with Jane re. the condition of the plant. Cannot help with lights at all because i've never used any. Also no idea about what the effect of double glazing will be on light transmission.
    I have a big number of orchids but light is not a problem because most except the Phals are "outside." However, the light might be a bonus on your phal in winter as it could warm the leaves up a bit during the day and make the plant happy.

    There are no orchid nurseries worth visiting in the Sydney Metropolitan area. The Nurseries at the orchid fair thing are scattered far and wide in NSW and Queensland, so it is a good chance to buy orchids direct rather than by mail order.

    The chunk out of the orchid in the crummy picture just shows what will happen to a Phal that gets cold and wet in winter. Agisted my Phal. collection last winter when i went OS. They got cold and wet, a few died, some lost leaves or parts of leaves, some have "sunburn" marks on leaves.

    That particular orchid was on a wedding table in November 2005
    Cut the spike off at the base when the flowers died.
    Bloomed again November 2006. Despite ill treatment last June.
    Cut the spike off at the base again when the flowers died.
    and hopefully will bloom again later this year.
    It has never been repotted or had a root inspection.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Your next step should be to observe. The current temperature readings are
    Temperature 25.5C
    Humidity 73%
    Horrible, and the potting mix is not about to dry out in a hurry, so you may have to postpone the next watering. There is nothing wrong with the orchid at all except that it has been underlit and perhaps underfed.
    The leaves are mortal. It is perfectly normal for the oldest one to die and be replaced replaced with a new one.
    Lets see what the under lights gurus say.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I just upgraded my 23W winter fluorescents to 45W Spring fluorescents. An instant doubling of light intensity. Do I expect any adverse reaction from the orchids? Absolutely not. Steady as she goes helm, things might just get worse before they get better. As for the wet bark it may just be your increased powers of observation. You will, especially if you want to add plants to your collection, want to upgrade that 15W flourescent fixture to a standard incandescent one so you can use the nearly unlimited range of 'Compact Fluorescent lamps' which fit mogul (incandescent) sockets. Non-standard (other than 48") fluorescent tubes cost out of proportion to their size and the really tiny odd sizes like the 15W must really hurt as well as not putting out all that much illumination. You will be much better off with a 23W - 36W fluorescent especially now when the window contribution must be diminishing.

    H

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hello all,

    Just thought I'd update the situation on my Phal.
    Thank you all for such valuable advice!

    To my surprise the large amount of light generated from the 23W spiral CFL and the 15W tube, about one foot above, was not enough to 'burn' it as i had feared (on for ~14hrs/day)- i still have much to learn! I guess time will have to tell, I am trying my hardest not to watch too closely! I hope I haven't been too late.

    I have just posted a new thread on what to start on for newbies. I took Mehitabels suggestions into account there as well, but was interested to see what other opinions are.... Please visit if you have time.

    And thanks again, not only was this thread useful and informative, it was interesting to compare different opinions also.

    Keep 'em coming I say!

    Linda :)

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hi everyone,

    I believe I am along the road to saving my precious Phal! I believe this for 2 reasons:
    1. It is still alive! as the stem started dying and i lost one of the leaves, i felt certain the plummet towards death was imminent. Since no further dying, she's hangin on.
    2. The increase in light has definately saved the day. The smaller leaf opened up and must have grown, if you look at both new and old photos at
    http://www.flickr.com/photos/7409907@N07/
    you can see it is now a fully grown leaf! So since there has been growth, not just stagnant (even in winter!). It loves the light.
    Also, I Just wanted to say thanks to all who put in the time to let me sponge from your brains. I got into contact with someone locally through an Orchid society and have also sponged lots of info from his brain. He also has the orchid bug, and was told by his wife to make room in the driveway for the car again!! So luckily for me he offloaded some orchids to me! So I now have a Cymbidium for outside, the colour will be a surprise! And an Aussie native Dendrobium that I have tied to a piece of branck and put a coathanger hook through it, and it is hanging from my baclony - looks great! And an Oncydium hybrid with tiny little pink and yellow flowers, and an Encyclia Cochleata, which I love! Its flower looks like an octopus with legs!! see above link for pics :)
    Arthur, how do you think the Oncidium and Encyclia will be ok under trees outside in Sydney? getting a little filtered sun through the tree foilage?
    And the Cymbidium, how much sun does it like? a few hours in the morning ok? Theres a spike growing and i really want to see what colour the flowers will be!!
    Oh I am so excited I have more to play with!
    Thanks again everyone, i love you all but my partner despises you for your hand in my addiction!
    Until we meet again, my fellow orchid lovers!
    Linda xo

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Linda, at the risk of upsetting your partner, here is a list of all the orchid shows to be held over the coming months. A show might be just the benching at an orchid society judged by Australian Orchid Council judges or it might be a large event with orchid displays and many orchid vendors.

    Your orchid is looking much better though i cannot say if the little growth is a root or the beginnings of a new spike.

    The Cymbidium needs all day sun through about 50% shadecloth. A compromise is morning sun and more shade in the afternoon. You need to sprinkle lots of snail pellets around the plant and watch out for sneaky green caterpillars otherwise you will end up with chewed Cymbidium flowers.

    A little filtered sun through tree foliage could be the Phal early problems revisited, at this time of year orchids need about 50% shadecloth protection.

    Your purchases should be fine, it is just a matter of finding spots in your garden where they will be happy.

    Here is a link that might be useful: List of Sydney Orchid Shows

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hi,
    my phal is growing a new leaf! YAY! My partner has been reluctant to allow the extra electricity for the lighting - but he doesn't dare interfere since he knows how much it means to me! It has taken 2 weeks for the leaf to grow from a little bud to what i definately recognise as a leaf! im so happy! normally winter growth is somewhat stagnant! i look every day for a spike!! fingers crossed! xo

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Linda, you have to be very careful as i have said before because orchids will take over your life. Actually growing orchids is not an expensive hobby when compared to some. The heater is now running down the glasshouse to lift the day temp. hmmm 1100 watts for about one hour is about 20cents and the two fans running 24/7 cost....not much and 1000 or so orchids plus all the ones that have died over the years. Just as well i have never kept records.

    Finally, there are the rewards, here is a picture of our little Redlands held last week. There are lots of lovely people to meet at an orchid show.

    PS. Do not forget to let the temp drop a little bit at night, that may help your Phal to decide to spike.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Little Redlands

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Wow! What a collection!
    You're not helping the addiction...
    :)

Sponsored