Software
Houzz Logo Print
rgillenjr

Best Seed For Transitional Region

19 years ago

Next weekend I am removing the old sod from my front yard with a sod cutter. I used Round Up on it to kill any and all weeds and grasses first which seems to work. I still have a few spots that I missed the first time, though.

I am ready to purchase the grass seed but am uncertain of which type I should go with. I live in Northern Virginia near Fairfax, Va, which is in the transition zone between zones 6b and 7a. I want to use Kentucky Blue Grass but was told by a local "grass seed" company that I should go with their Tall Fescue blend. I have had Fescues but didn't have much luck with it. I don't think the Fescue was "sod quality" seed though.

Does anyone live in the Northern Virginia area (that has more than a year experience with KBG) that has used pure KBG with a blend of cultivars? And if so, how much luck have you had? Such as diseases and insects? Has anyone switched to sod quality Fescue and had good success?

I need to purchase the seed in the next few days so any responses are greatly appreciated.

I did submit a plant sample to the local exchange here in the area but haven't received the results yet. The first sample was lost and the second sample is not back yet. I do have a soil sample back which the results can be seen below.

Thanks in advance!!!

{{gwi:115395}}

Comments (25)

  • 19 years ago

    Why are you removing sod if you're going to overseed?

    You should kill it first and then leave the dead sod there to hold the seed in place and provide some degree of cover and mulching.

    The next question would be why did your tall fescue fail? If you're in a new home development dealing with compacted clay in full sun and your top soil has long since been removed then I'm not surprised. Unfortunately neither one is going to be a long term solution. KBG is not a magic bullet. If you can't grow one, you can't grow the other.

  • 19 years ago

    You already have comments on your soil test, so I'll skip that.

    Given your location, unless you are willing and able to water an inch a week, every week, all summer, you will probably be happier with turf-type tall fescus (TTTF) than with Kentucky Bluegrass (KBG) -- but you may prefer KBG if the grass all gets lots of sun and you can water EVERY week all summer long. The inch per week means an inch in one day, not a seventh of inch every day.

    You can find a lot of relevant info by going to http://www.mdturfcouncil.org/ and pick the link for "turf education and publications" (near the bottom of the tree). Then choose "Maryland extension publications". Then scroll down to publication TT-77 under the "Turf grass species and cultivar selection" subheading. The same recommendations apply to Virginia (it's joint with Virginia even though it doesn't say so). You'll also find TT-63 to be interesting. Actually, there are several very good publications on that site.

    You can also find a lot of relevant info from the National Turf Evaluation Program (www.ntep.org), and the participating site in Maryland (College Park) is not very far north of you and is at the same altitude -- see their 2003 and 2004 NTEP data.

    Any relatively new housing development near you will be a sea of TTTF, so drive around and have a look. It's the most commonly planted grass around you.

    KBG is finer textured (thinner softer blades) and a bit darker green. Elite kinds of TTTF can be very deep lush turf. Either one will require some fertilizer and water to do really well. No phosphorus or lime for your lawn though.

    If you don't like your current grass, kill it and restart from scratch rather than overseeding.

  • 19 years ago

    Quirkyquerqus: the 5.2% organic matter in his soil test sounds like topsoil to me.

    RGillen: Unless you have some reason to think there is truly bad stuff in your existing sod, Quirkyquerqus is giving you good advice to not remove the existing sod. You could, however, spread (and rake in) a thin layer of good topsoil over the lawn (maybe a quarter inch) before you reseed.

  • 19 years ago

    You are kinda borderline on growing KBG where you are. Fescue has deeper roots and is better suited to handle hot and dry weather than KBG. KBG will tend to go dormant quickly and will require consistent watering. The bigger problem for you right now is timing. You probably can't get high quality KBG seed locally. That means you would be stuck with a mediocre KBG that is probably less drought and disease tolerant than the elite types and would be even less suited for your climate. Bestlawn has posted links to several seed outlets, so you could see if any of those can rush an order out.

    As for tttf, you should be able to find quality seed at most box stores. Two brands that usually include very highly rated grasses are Southern Gold and Rebel.

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks for the replies.

    quirkyquercus, the reason for the sod cutter is to level out my yard. It is very bumpy and has several low spots. Not something that can be fixied easily by spreading a little top soil on the old sod. I have had several different contractors digging in my yard several different times in the last few years and this has left many low and high spots. The contractors also always put down cheap contractor grass seed which left clumps of Fescue all over.

    I have a sprinkler system that I installed when we moved in 6 years ago so watering won't be a problem. From reading many posts on the subject, I have learned that "proper" watering is important. I found that I previously watered too much but cut back to watering 1 day a week to get an inch of water on the lawn.

    Just prior to the builder installing the sod 6 years ago, I spread 2" of "Compro" on the hard soil. So the current grass has the compro under it. If you are unfamiliar with Compro, it is a treated waste product from sewage treatment plants. Smelly, but supposed to be good for grass.

    I plan to spread top soil after removing the sod and before seeding.

    tagged, I will review the website you suggested. Thank you very much.

    I guess I just want to start over, and removing the sod and leveling the yard will make it look a lot better. Especially with new grass on it.

  • 19 years ago

    The ntep ratings seem to indicate that KBG does indeed grow in VA. It grows here in Georgia but I think we might be not as humid or hot in most years. Could be wrong. Anyway if I were you, I'd try to diagnose the reasons the fescue failed and fix that before you go out and spend $4 a lb or more on KBG. It's true that it doesn't like shade which is why it can be challenging in warm climates. A little shade will do it some good in the summer but coupled with warm damp nights and the need to water frequently could cause disease. The lack of local sources of seed, the pain in the butt to get it started....There is no darker green than KBG but you have to really want it.

  • 19 years ago

    Border line KBG in Northen Virginia??? You must be kidding or uninformed. I'm in zone 7b (central NC) and I have a 100% KBG lawn - no fescue. It grows well here with the proper care, it should grow even better up there with the cooler summers.

    As far as the water requirements for KBG, it's mostly overrated. The blend I have (Galaxy by Turf-Seed) has proven to be VERY drought tolerant during growing conditions. Last year in late Spring we had a severe drought and didn't water it to see what it will do, and my neighbor's Fescue lawns went semi-dormant while my blue was still green and growing - then the rains came back. During the summer months and under high heat and drought conditions like we had this year in NC, KBG needs about an inch or so of water per week to keep it from going dormant. And when it goes dormant, it turns an "off green" color, nothing like any of the warm weather grasses you see during the winter months (100% brown/bluff).

    Anyway, the choice is yours, KBG or TTTF, or maybe you want to try some perennial ryegrass?

    I have it in my backyard doing VERY well despite the hot summer we had...

  • 19 years ago

    If the concern is heat tolerance, you might consider a blend of 3 Kentucky bluegrasses combined with about 20% Texas hybrid bluegrass. The new hybrids are a cross between poa praetensis (Kentucky bluegrass) and poa aracnifera (sp?) (Texas bluegrass). The benefit of hybrid bluegrass is the ability to withstand more heat than Kentucky bluegrass.
    O.M. Scotts is selling Thermal heat tolerant blue, but only in a mix with tall fescue. Another choice is Farhenheit 90 hybrid bluegrass developed at Rutgers and marketed by Mt. View Seeds. You can find it on the web.

  • 19 years ago

    Kidding or uniformed? No. There is a raleigh test site for NTEP. Every single year, every KBG takes an absolute beating in summer. If it is not watered religiously, it goes dormant instantly. The vast majority of homeowners would be unwilling to baby KBG enough to keep it growing well in raleigh. Anyplace that routinely gets 90+ degree weather for much of summer should plant a more heat and drought tolerant grass.

  • 19 years ago

    RGillen:

    I'm only a few miles from you. While it is not considered an "elite" cultivar of KBG, I had better than expected results renovating a neglected weed field of an area last fall with Scott's Heat Tolerant Blue. Granted, it is a mix of Fescues and Bluegrass. But the renovated area did far better than my existing lawn (rye/KBG/Fescue) during the last few months, and it didn't get as much water or attention as my existing lawn. I actually killed off a small area of the existing lawn a week ago to do another test area of the Heat Tolerant.

    My yard is full sun almost sun up to sun down, and it gets baked in the summer. I water an inch (maybe slightly less) each week, minus what we get in rainfall. Hope that helps.

  • 19 years ago

    bill, you continue to refer to the NTEP ratings, which do not reflect the true performance of the KBG in Raleigh. I'm not far from NC State Univ. in fact, I'm right off of exit 287 (Harrison Ave.) and I-40 in Weston. My KBG lawn does just fine here. You are welcome to come by my house and see for yourself.

    Send me an email to auteck2000@yahoo.com and I will give you my home address.

    I do acknowledge that there is a consensus that KBG does not grow here well, and that is true for the old cultivars of 50 years ago. However, it's a totally different ball game today. The KBGs have an enormus heat and drought tolerant compare to the old cultivars, and prove to that is my lawn and many others in the Raleigh area.

    I decided to grow KBG because I saw enough evidence from local sod producers of KBG in NC, and from the Rose Agri Seed (formaly Turf-Seed) research facility located in Rolesville, NC - just a few minutes north of Raleigh where KBG grows.

    BTW, I have a 50lb bag of Midnight KBG that I'm selling by the pound for $3.00 per pound - no tax.

    You can overseed your TTTF lawn with it for a darker and more dense lawn.

  • 19 years ago

    There is a reason the ntep tests and retests grasses year after year. It makes it less likely that one good result (like your yard) or one unlucky break (a fungal outbreak) doesn't unduly tilt the average results. The ntep test Midnight in Raleigh. They do it every year. Every year, they have reported poor performance in summer compared to all but the worst fescues. If you are happy with your yard, more power to ya! That doesn't mean you can generalize your experience - especially when the overwhelming test data says that your experience is the exception, not the rule.

  • 19 years ago

    The only exceptions will be a sloped yard with hard clay soils with a southern/western exposure, and that setup will make it VERY tough to grow ANY grass - warm season included. My neighbor with the Zoysia lawn waters his yard every other day. It's green, and so are hundreds of Fescue lawns in the area that are kept watered. A few of my neighbors have already sprayed their Fescues lawns with Roundup in exchange for KBG - yes, here in Cary. My lawn was more than prove to them that the newer KBG cultivars can handle our weather.

    I don't have a problem with warm season grasses, I just simply think that they are not the best adapted to our climate. If you think Bermuda or Zoysia are better adapated than KBG, think again. KBG can stay green year round with proper irrigation, the same can not be said about Bermuda or Zoysia and no one can argue that.

  • 19 years ago

    This is how KBG looks dormant in the summer of 2006 in late August under hight heat and nor rain for almost 3 weeks:

    {{gwi:99086}}

    Cavalier Zoysia mid october 2006

    {{gwi:116829}}

  • 19 years ago

    The Raleigh site in the NTEP data is called NC1.

    billl wrote that the NTEP tests Midnight in Raleigh every year and it always takes a beating in summer, that every year they report poor performance compared to all but the worst fescues. Except for summer being the time when KBG takes a beating, I'd say that's not a fair characterization of the monthly NTEP quality ratings. First of all, up until 2006 the NC1 KBG care regimen was to mow at 1.1 to 1.5 inches tall and water only to prevent dormancy, where the tall fescue was mowed tall and watered to prevent stress (a bit more water). Second, the NTEP turf quality ratings for one type of grass (KBG) are not comparable to the numbers for another type (TTTF) of grass; the KBG ratings are all relative to the best possible KBG and the TTTF ratings are all relative to tall fescue.

    If we want to restrict attention to just NC1 (Raleigh), let's look at 2006, when their KBG was mowed at lawn height of 3.1 to 3.5 inches (a lot higher), and watered to prevent stress (I think that's a bit more water than in the preceding several years). That's the regimen you'd see from a homeowner who cares about the lawn. And let's look at three prototypical improved kinds of KBG (the namesakes of entire families of KBG cultivars). I'll also include Kenblue, a common unimproved KBG. We're talking about summer, so let's give July and August full weight and show June and September for comparisons. June is before the main heat/drought stress. September is after it, so if summer really clobbers the grass, the September quality rating will be bad.

    Here are those NC1 quality ratings:
    ___________ June ___ July ___ Aug ___ Sept.
    America ____ 6.3 ____ 4.7 ____ 6.3 ___ 6.3
    Julia _______ 6.0 ____ 4.0 ____ 6.3 ___ 6.3
    Kenblue ____ 5.0 ____ 4.0 ____ 4.3 ___ 4.0
    Midnight ____ 6.7 ____ 5.3 ____ 6.7 ___ 7.7

    One sees here that Midnight did relatively well in summer compared the other cultivars of KBG (as it characteristically does). There are various other NTEP transition-zone sites, so you may want to root around in the NTEP data if you're really interested. The summary reports include tables that group the transition-zone sites. My take on these data is that comparing 2006 to the preceding several years shows why one might want to water when needed and not mow real short.

  • 19 years ago

    I live in Falls Church. Your best bet is going to be a blend of good cultivars of TTTF, but growing KBG (if you have enough sun) or Turf Type Perennial Rye is also possible with attention to proper cultural practices, especially watering in the summer.

    I am renovating this weekend with TTPR for one more year's experiment. I did the same thing last year and I loved the way it came in and looked fantastic through mid-June. Then the heat and drought and our vacation with no watering took a heavy toll. I don't mind experimenting though.

    The short answer is that good TTTF is the best suited. Merrifield has a good selection.

  • 19 years ago

    rgillenjr,

    i too live in no va (oakton), and some of the nicest lawns i've seen in my area are kbg lawns. merrifield gardens in fact carries kbg seed, but i ordered mine from pawnee about a month ago. i mention merrifield gardens because i do not believe that they would carry kbg if it did not perform in our area. there is a gentleman at pawnee named glenn who was extremely helpful, and we decided on a blend of bedazzled, moonlight, and award (33% each).

    i seeded - using a combination of regular drop and broadcast spreaders - on sept 15th after aerating the heck out of my lawn and topdressing with compost followed by yet another round of areation.

    i do believe that one must have irrigation to maintain a decent lawn in our area, which i do have.

    i see growth already after 10 days. i do think it's a good idea not to use a sod cutter to even out the bumps in your lawn. i have my own aerator, and i find that aeration alone has evened out my lawn very nicely over the past few years.

    after reading countless threads from the experts, i say go for the kbg blend. the real benefit of kbg is that i don't have to overseed every fall since it spreads by rhizomes unlike the bunching varieties of tall fescues/p ryes. given that the premium seeds are not cheap, i find this to be an extremely huge benefit of kbg. good luck.

  • 19 years ago

    Down here in Woodbridge, I'm too cheap to put in an irrigation system, so I planted Lesco Transition (TTTF) and have very good results with sprinklers.

  • 19 years ago

    rgillenjr: Don't keep us waiting!! What did you decide to go with?

  • 19 years ago

    I got a clump of KBG that I just pulled out of a loamy flowerbed planted in full sun and it has only been rained on 3 times in the past 3 and a half months. It has remained perfect quality dark green with no stress out there all alone. I am in the Atlanta area. KBG is really not as scary to maintain as the yankees on this forum want you to think.

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks everyone for the replies. Sorry I haven't replied for so long.

    Here is what I have done so far:
    I sprayed the entire front yard with Roundup twice over a period of 2 weeks. Last Friday I rented a sod cutter and removed all the dead sod from the front. I know several here recommended that I don't do that, but I don't ever remember hearing why. Anyway, I removed the sod, then brought in 7 yards of soil and sand. Actually it was 3 1/2 yards of topsoil and 3 1/2 yards of sand and then I mixed it with a shovel. This was the hardest part of the entire process. I lightly tilled the yard just before I spread the soil and rolled it with a landscape roller so it was nice and level. That was Friday, Saturday and Sunday. This past Wednesday, my Midnight KBG arrived in the mail. I was going to rent a slit seeder to put the seed down but I was worried that the weight would totally destroy the soil. So I used a tined rake and dragged it across the soil and then used a broadcast spreader to spread the seed. Once I got the seed down, I set the irrigation system to water twice a day, once at 9:00 AM and again at 2:30 PM for about 25 minutes.

    Last night we got some heavy rain for the first time in weeks. I had nightmares of waking up and finding all the soil in the neighbors yard and running down the street but I got lucky and only a little seed washed away. I have extra so I will put some down tomorrow. I also want to put down some additional topsoil on top of the seed and then put straw on top of that.

    Hopefully in two weeks from Wednesday I will have grass starting to grow. I will post some more pictures in a few weeks.

    Thanks again to all for your advice!!!

    Here are some pictures:

    After second application of Roundup

    {{gwi:116831}}

    Cutting and removing the sod

    {{gwi:116833}}


    Most of the Sod up but no soil yet

    {{gwi:116834}}


    Soil is down and waiting for seed. Still have some work to do between the curb and sidewalk. Picture makes the yard look more rounded than it really is. I also smoothed out the foot prints.

    {{gwi:116835}}

  • 19 years ago

    "Thanks again to all for your advice!!!"

    You're welcome but as it would appear you didn't follow a word of it.

  • 19 years ago

    Why in the world would you add sand to Virginia clay? It will be hard as concrete next summer.

  • 19 years ago

    Suggest irrigating for 10 minutes four times a day (shoot for just long enough to get the top of the soil wet) for the first three weeks, then resume your current irrigation schedule.

    I think half topsoil and half sand will work OK.

    It sounds like you rolled the lawn before spreading the seed and now have the seed sitting on top of the soil. If so, you need to bury the seed about an eighth to a quarter of an inch (would have been easy to do with a slit seeder, but you can just rake lightly so that you mix the seeds into the top quarter inch of soil) and then re-roll so there is good firm contact between seeds and soil. Light sprinkle of straw is OK. Don't walk on the dirt once the seed has been down for a week, as your shoes will crush the baby seedlings. You don't need more soil.

    Adding some seed that is not all "midnight type" will make your resulting lawn more satisfactory to you. If you end up with a mix of two (preferably three) distinctly different KBG varieties, you'll have a more adaptable lawn that will not all be susceptible to the same diseases. Think about working an "america type" KBG cultivar into your mix at some future point.

  • 8 years ago

    dear all, can any one of you help me with Brown Spots? i live in near fairfax and every year i get brown spots. One year, i removed all 2" of the top soil layer, and add 3" of new top soil mixed with compost. Reseeded the whole yard. The yard was beautiful until end of June. Then i get brown spots. With Merrifield recommendation, i used INFUSE systemic fungicide everry 14 days for 2 months but i still get brown spots. it is very frustrating. can you recommend a solution? Thank you. Russell

Sponsored
Peabody Landscape Group
Average rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars8 Reviews
Franklin County's Reliable Landscape Design & Contracting