Software
Houzz Logo Print
mehitabel_gw

coconut husk chips -- any tips?

18 years ago

I'm thinking of trying out chc as a potting medium for my phals.

I've read the AnTec laboratory report on use of these, but

I'd appreciate any tips about where to get good, prewashed chips, how to prepare, and use, including how to know when it needs watering, how long it lasts etc etc.

Anything you have to offer about using it is more than I know and will be appreciated.

Comments (24)

  • 18 years ago

    You CAN'T soak and rinse, soak and rinse, soak and rinse enough before you use even the "pre-washed" coconut chips !!! Do the "soak at night, rinse next morning and refill" at LEAST 3 times before you use them. They come from an extreme salt environment and absorb salts easily. I found they last about 2 years but that depends on your individual watering habit. I would recommend no more than 2 years before repotting. When in doubt, use the chopstick method to see if the media is still damp. Thoroughly flush out your plants regularly and they'll do just fine in the coco.

    HTH, Chryss

  • 18 years ago

    Hi Mehitable!

    Don't believe they're 'prewashed' but you can get chc from any number of venders including Oakhill, Natt's, etc.

    Some folks really dislike them, others seem to like them. IME, your own personal growing conditions & water regimen can have a big effect on what mix ratio you will find satisfactory. (Which really is just about par for the course with media in general. I know several growers who swear by Pro-mix. I kill anything planted in that stuff -- just doesn't work for my conditions.) Personally I find it necessary to add a lot of hydroton, charcoal, and even perlite (just about a 1:1:1:1 mix) and I generally only water once or twice a week. Otherwise the chc mixes retain too much water for me.

  • 18 years ago

    Yes, thoroughly soaking and rinsing CHC several times before using it is important to make sure you get rid of salt residue. It's also a good idea to leach it thoroughly now and then when growing in it. Fertilizer salts can become overly concentrated in CHC, particularly at the surface where it dries faster.

    With these precautions, CHC is the most perfect medium for Phals, in my opinion. It resists decay and compaction and holds both air and water very effectively, maintaining an excellent environment for their roots. Overpotting and overwatering Phals in CHC are not such a concern as when they are in bark or Sphagnum moss.

    You can buy it in fine, medium, and coarse grades. I generally use the medium grade, but have used the fine grade for very young plants.

    Here's a very good source for CHC and many other orchid media:

    Here is a link that might be useful: repotme.com

  • 18 years ago

    One recommendation I forgot to make is to use unglazed clay pots or vented orchid pots, glazed or unglazed. If a pot can't breathe, the medium can't breathe.

  • 18 years ago

    I started using the CHC mix from Kelly's Korner on some of my phals, fine rooted catts and moisture loving dens and am quite happy with it. The CHC is small and mixed with large sponge rock and various sizes of diatomite.

    I do rinse and soak three times regardless of their claims of salt-free. I soak for 24 hours, drain, rinse and soak again. I then spread the mix out and let dry before using.

    The catts and dens are growing in very shallow planted clay pots and the "adult" phals are in air cones. I consider a phal an adult when it is time for a 4" pot. If I have moisture visible in the air cone pot, I don't water. The clay pots are judged by weight.

    I have been very happy with the root growth and figure if the visible roots in the air cones are happy and growing so are the roots in the clay. I get no algae growth in the air cones unlike my pots with sphag/tree fern mix.

    I fertilize weakly each watering even if the pot gets watered more than once a week. They get flushed whenever I don't have time to fertilize, it is not on a specific schedule. I use rainwater and MSU pure.

    When I pot a plant, I use the mix bone dry so it jiggles around the roots very easily. Sometimes I soak the pot in water until saturated or if busy, I water the pot but give it another thorough watering in a few days.

    Brooke

  • 18 years ago

    Hey, everyone! Thanks for all the good information.

    Okay, soak and rinse at least three times. Flush pots often and water thoroughly when you water. Can mix with aliflor, perlite, charcoal, diatomite, etc to get a drier mix.

    Can use slit clay or aircones, and tell by weight or dry stick method whether watering is needed.

    Check, check, check.

    The An-Tec article mentions adding Calcium Nitrate and Magnesium Sulfate to the soaking water to create a cation exchange. Can I assume that's not necessary and none of you do that? (I've no idea where to get calcium nitrate)

    I'm going to try it probably in August, so they'll be adapted to the new mix before they come in in fall. Will definitely report on how it goes.

    Thanks again, for all the replies.

  • 18 years ago

    When I read about using the CHC, a couple sites said to soak in Superthrive or KLN, which I did the first couple of times. Since then I don't soak in anything but water.

    I don't see any difference between the Superthrive soaked and the plain water soaked. Or maybe I'm not very observant :>)

    Brooke

  • 18 years ago

    I've never added anything to the soaking water.

  • 18 years ago

    I use a chc mix for orchids that want to dry between waterings. IMHO, for those of us who grow inside in winter in humidity-challenged houses, it doesn't hold enough water for phals. Unless you want to water them twice a week. Sphagnum mixed with large perlite is much better.

  • 18 years ago

    I am reverting to sphag/bark mix for Phals because of the inside winter low humidity. But I do still have a few in plain chc that are doing fine although I DO water them twice a week in the winter !

    C-

  • 18 years ago

    Mehitabel-
    sorry I have no tips, just a question--why are you considering changing your growing medium?
    Nicole

  • 18 years ago

    Hi, Nicole. If you google "coconut husk chips", you'll come across the An-Tec Laboratory report in the first few entries.

    It's a report by a couple of orchid growers on the *air retention* of different media. They report that two media-- sphag and chc chips-- have the best air retention while moist. Since it's the lack of *air* in wet media that causes root rot, that's what you want for the best roots.

    I'm using sphag in clay pots now, and I like it, growth and roots are good, but it does tend to get compacted over the course of a few months, and then re-compacts fairly soon after you re-fluff it. As it compacts, it gets harder to water it "just right"

    The compacted sphag loses its air retention capabilities, so when I read that chc chips don't compact, but keep their air retention qualities for over a year, it sounded good to me.

    The authors also reported good root growth, revival of declining plants, and less decline in plants brought indoors for the fall after summering outdoors.

    All these sounded worth a try to me.

    Hope this is what you wanted to know.

  • 18 years ago

    I use sphag mixed in with CHC in plastic pots for phals. Seems to work better than straight CHC. I've also tried sphag mixed w/the round red fired pellets (Alifor?) with good results. The pellets and CHC chunks keep the sphag from getting compacted.

    (Don't laugh but sometimes I pop a piece of CHC in my mouth after soak/rinse/repeat to see if tastes "salty"... )

  • 18 years ago

    I'm in the process of repotting some phrags and paphs that have been in the CHC mix for 1 1/2 yrs now. Sorry, my memory cell forgot to remember I use it on these two genera if they are in s/h. It isn't old age that makes me forget, I'm just very busy :>)

    I am happy to report even with phrags sitting in saucers of water, the mix has not degraded at all. I could dry it and it would look like new. Since phrags are super sensitive to excessive salts, I feel confident I have rinsed the salt out of the mix.

    Brooke

  • 18 years ago

    Hey, Rita. Tasting it works for me. :D I wouldn't have thought of it, but why not? It will help to be be reassured there's no salt left in it.

    I was wondering about mixing it with sphag, so thanks for that inf, too. I'll have to experiment around with it for a while til I've got an idea of the best way to use it. Would be nice to go back to plastic pots without rot issues.

    Brooke: That's good news about the mix holding up for a year and a half. Are you saying you use chc in an s/h setup for your phrags?

  • 18 years ago

    Hi Mehitabel,
    thanks for your answer; I was wondering where the article was, and look forward to reading it!
    It's so interesting hearing what work for different people; I keep my growing area just a few degrees colder than I should in the winter, and sphagnum in clay pots stayed too cold and wet. Bark mix is what seems to work best for me now, but you never know...
    Nicole

  • 18 years ago

    I'm no expert on salts in CHC, but i thought it wasn't just sodium chloride, but rather a variety of dissolved(?) minerals.

  • 18 years ago

    Hollyt,

    I would guess that you are correct, it is not just sodium chloride, but probably all things in sea salt.

    Mike

  • 18 years ago

    My equestris here was repotted 5/05 in chc only and, even tho earmarked for repotting, I just checked and the chc has NOT broken down yet at the bottom of the pot !! I add extra holes, especially at the bottom of plastic pots. The eq is in a 5" and has 2 extra holes at the sides of each factory rectangle one. I use an empty .38 cal case (dangerous to use one that isn't, LOL !) and get it hot with a propane torch, a gas stove burner would work. The 4.5" pot below has 8 extra, 4 at bottom and 4 about half way up. I use the midway holes for Den. pots.

    {{gwi:186806}}
    {{gwi:186808}}
    {{gwi:186810}}
    {{gwi:186812}}

    Don't have any root rot problems.

    HTH, C-

  • 18 years ago

    Hey, Chryss. You absolutely win the creativity/ingenuity badge for '08 with this one! I thought I was the master pragmatist, but you beat me with this :)

    Thanks for the information about lastingness of CHC, and especially the pictures of the holes in the pot. The extra side holes at the bottom are a great idea I hadn't thought of. The side holes further up-- good idea to get air to the center of the pot.

    Really useful. So thanks again for the information and pictures.

    BTW, I use a plain old boring 3/8" saudering iron to make the extra holes. Nothing as exotic as your set up, but it's actually fun punching holes in the plastic (if I hold my breath). I'm pretty sure if I tried it your way I would drop the red hot casing onto my poor bare feet. :)

  • 18 years ago

    Great pictures. A picture is worth thousand words. Add lava rocks at the bottom will increase venting, provide more humidity, prevent rot root, also cheap too.

  • 18 years ago

    Mehitabel, not all coconut trees grow in a "salty environment". I should know.... I live on a coconut farm : )
    Since I dont know where the CHC that you get is sourced from, maybe you should go with the advice to soak and rinse.
    I dont use CHC as a medium because I found that termites love it too and my orchids are all kept outdoors. But I do use the whole split husk at times. What I do is to leave the dried coconut husk out in a corner of my garden and let the rains do the soak and rinse for me. Later, I soak it in a fungicide to be on the safer side.
    So, if you're in for rainy weather, just put the CHC in a basket (with holes on the sides) and leave it out in the rain. Let Ma Nature do your work for you.

  • 18 years ago

    Sunita, thank you! Leaving it out in an all-day rain is a terrific tip, and one I don't think I would have thought of, but will save a lot of tiresome hosing down.

    Thanks again :)

Sponsored
Peabody Landscape Group
Average rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars8 Reviews
Columbus' Reliable Landscape Design & Contracting