Software
Houzz Logo Print
betts123_gw

Fish emulsion

20 years ago

Hi. It is near winter here in NH. I would like to improve the soil in my largest flower bed - but is now a bad time to do it? I could use dilute fish emulsion, or some organic mixture of seaweed or composted manure. What would be best to do? Thank you for your input.

Comments (6)

  • 20 years ago

    I think anytime is a good time to improve soil. I think the seaweed & compost is good; I would also add dried molasses. I would save the fish emulsion for foliar feeding once things sprout in the spring.

    Just my $.02...good luck & have fun! And I am jealous...I LOVE NH! It's so gorgeous!

  • 20 years ago

    The fish emulsion might help if you have enough organic matter in your soil for the bacteria in that stuff to work on, but if there is unsufficient levels of OM applying fidh emulsion will be a waste of time, energy, and money. But then if you did have sufficient levels of orgnaic matter in your soil you probably would not need the fish emulsion. There are no shortcuts to developing a good, healthy soil, all soils need sufficient levels of organic matter.

  • 20 years ago

    Fish emulsion isn't going to do much as a soil conditioner, it is much better used as a fertilizer. You would be better off with compost, manure or other organic matter that will get eaten by soil critter over time while providing a nice water retaining, temperature moderating mulch in the process.

    Also, consider that for organic matter to break down requires warm temps. Leave meat on the counter for a few days and it is rancid. Put it in the freezer and it keeps for months. This is due to the lower temps in the freezer.

    Outside things are the same. As winter sets in it is all about soil temperature. The colder it is, the slower the biological processes take place. If you add solid material like chopped leaves they will sit there until warmer weather and begin breaking down. If you add something like liquid fish emulsion it will likely wash away by the time warmer weather returns.

    Then again I don't know what the soil temp is in your area right now. If it is below 40F (refrigerator temps)there isn't going to be much going on in the soil until it warms up.

  • 20 years ago

    Thanks, justaguy2 - what you say makes sense. Our soil will soon be frozen. We are in zone 5. Also - the part about fish emulsion washing away makes sense too. We did chop up our fall leaves and have them in a wire compost bin. From what you said (one of you) we should let them break down and then add them in the spring? I was a little concerned about smothering some of the perennials if I added too much solid stuff now.

  • 20 years ago

    If your leaves are chopped up then you can use them as a winter mulch in perennial beds (I am in zone 5 as well). If they are whole leaves then they will form a wet mat that plants will have some difficulty pushing through (although many perennials, especially bulbs, can push through most anything).

    The only word of caution I would give you in our cold zone is that come spring any kind of mulch will keep the ground cold longer. The mulch is just an insulation layer and it keeps warm soils warm just as well as it keeps cold soils cold. Also if your springs are as wet as mine are the mulch will keep the ground from drying out and this can lead to rot for plants that prefer drier conditions.

    As long as your perennials are rated to be hardy to our zone it is less work to skip the winter mulch. If you have some borderline hardy plants for our zone then certainly mulch those, but monitor things in the spring as you may wish to rake the mulch away from those plants so the soil warms, the sogginess goes away and they can get growing as soon as weather permits.

    Having said all the above, it isn't always that critical. Most plants will do fine with mulch left all year. Just keep the above in mind if you find your plants not coming up until after other people's or if you lose more plants over the winter than you were expecting. The role mulch plays in keeping things cold and wet in the spring may be the culprit.

  • 15 years ago

    Left eveything in my garden shed over a very cold winter--things like fungicides,weed killers, fish emulsion. Will they be any good now?