Software
Houzz Logo Print
orchidnick

RO vs DI water

15 years ago

This weekend a member of my society came over and help me change the membrane and the prefilter of my RO unit. I didn't need help, he just wanted to see how the system was set up and how long it took me to make the change (15 min)as he is considering dumping his DI unit. We did the math and he was blown away, he will switch.

The membrane we changed out had lasted me 3 years. I upgraded to a 100 gpd one which cost $127 including tax and shipping. I also changed the prefilter which costs $14. I use about 40 gallons a day so am wasting (not really, I'm watering plants with the waste water) about 150 gallons per day. That's 4,500 gallons per month which in my city sets me back about $7.00

The cost of watering for 3 years comes to:

membrane -------- $127

6 prefilters ------$84 (religiously change them every 6 month)

water (7 x 36)----$252

total-------------$463 or $12.86 per month

My RO unit and the pump are 9 years old, cost for both was $300 so if you amortize that it would come to an additional $2.77 per month for a grand total of $15.63 per month.

He uses less than half the amount of water I do and pays about $80 every 6 to 8 weeks to have his unit recharged. I don't know all the details about the different ways of getting DI water but it seems to me to be substantially more expensive.

This guy is switching leaving only 2 other members who stubborn cling to their DI systems claiming it gives them better water. RO does not approach distilled water but does the minute amounts that RO lets through really make a noticeable difference?

Any fans of DI want to offer their opinion as to why it is worth the extra expense?

Nick

Comments (8)

  • 15 years ago

    Nick, I'm a fan of deionized water where it's appropirate - in the laboratory! It's a waste of money to use deionizing apparatus for use on orchids.

    --Stitz--

  • 15 years ago

    Agree. The guy with the biggest collection (5,000 plants)in our society waters everything, including 200 Cymbidiums with DI water. He is well off enough so he does not have to look at the price tag of something he wishes to buy so finances don't enter into his equation. They do for me.

    Nick

  • 15 years ago

    There is another thing worth mentioning. Some one at a species society meeting of really excellent growers revealed that he uses RO and then runs the water through a DI unit before adding the fertilizer. His DI unit is not large and it takes more than a year before it needs to be recharged. His logic is that if the DI unit uses up it's resin, even if it takes 1 1/2 years, then that's how much impurity slips through the RO unit.

    We were all astonished by this and even more so when a couple of others stated that they also do this. I have not considered it, seems truly over the top for me.

    Nick

  • 15 years ago

    It is common practice in reef aquaria culture to double team incoming mains water with both RO and DI. Definitely overkill for orchids but the question was asked: why DI at all? Well... for one thing there isn't brine reject (waste) with a DI system and for many that is huge. Not everyone has a use for the wastewater and small household systems without pressure pumps can waste 4 gallons for every gallon of pure.

    H

  • 15 years ago

    In discussing RO vs DI with some of my associates, I get occasional flack about the wasted water. Basically the green people accuse me of not being green enough. I'm a little bit of a cynic when to comes to being green. My daughter, whose last name happens to be Green and her husband recycle like crazy, every scrap of paper and bit of plastic is recycled. They make a point of noting that my RO system wastes water.

    At the same time they tool around in:

    A gas guzzling Suburban with a big V8
    A gas guzzling Jeep with an inefficient V6
    A gas guzzling motor home which gets about 6 mpg.
    A 1,600 cc Harley which has a bigger motor than my first VW which had a 1,300cc motor and got better gas mileage than that monster motorcycle.

    Every one of their kids is treated to a lavish BD party with an incredible amount of junk being distributed around, this process repeats itself almost on a weekly basis for every one of their kid's school mates and play mates.

    My take on being green is to decide on what you choose to do and then do it efficiently. If you need to get from point A to point B, you can ride a bike and be stunningly green or you can drive a car and leave a carbon footprint. That's a no-brainer, drive the car but choose an efficient one. With the RO system it's the same thing. I want clean water and, being on top of the food chain, I shall have clean water. I do use the waste water but do so probably inefficiently as some of the potted palms etc may get 70 gallons in one day unless someone moves the hose around. Oh well, at least not a total waste. The RO unit has a water saving device which costs extra, now wastes 2.3 gallons for every gallon of clean water instead of the usual 4.

    And that's as far into the green world as I'm willing to go. I'm convinced that RO water is substantially cheaper than DI as described in the initial blurb. Making the extra money to pay for the 'planet saving' DI water probably also leaves a carbon footprint. I have been unable to convince our remaining DI members and have given up.

    I remind myself of George Wallace when I say RO now, RO tomorrow and RO forever.

    Nick

  • 15 years ago

    Are you talking about DI only? I assumed you were referring to RO+DI. DI only can exhaust resin quickly, and replacing it that often is both expensive and wasteful. The alternative is to recharge your resin with an acid and a base, like muriatic acid and lye. But this is a somewhat lengthy process that most people would not want to do. I tried it myself a couple times, and decided it wasn't worth it. If you could use large DI canisters, and automate the recharging process, you might have something.

    Nick, does your water saving device consist of an extra RO membrane, or is it something else? I've been considering a modification for better efficiency.

  • 15 years ago

    It's a 'water saving valve' of sorts that comes after the membrane. It's specific for every size membrane. When I moved from a 50 gpd to 100 gpd membrane, I also had to replace it at minimal extra cost. Phone 'Back to Nature Filtration', they'll explain it better. It may only work for their application, each system is different.

    Where DI after RO is often used is in managing salt water reef tanks. There water purity is absolutely critical. Probably not needed for orchids, even for the most sensitive ones. I know a couple of people who do this but even the cloud forest plant growers up north (SF) do not feel it has a role to play.

    I just moved the waste water hose from the
    Sega palm it was watering since this morning. Must have gotten at least 70 gallons.

    Nick

  • 15 years ago

    Thanks, I'll check it out.

    I agree that DI is unnecessary. In reef tanks even trace amounts of certain substances can be toxic, but plants aren't nearly as sensitive as reef invertebrates. My RO water was 3-4ppm last time I checked, and that's fine by me.

Sponsored