Software
Houzz Logo Print
alinla

I might know the answer for CCD

19 years ago

I really dont want to post my finding on this open forum about Colony Collapse Disorder (CCD) because I am not a beekeeper (although I really want to become one), but I have a strong suspicion about a mosquito control product. I want the researchers to look into the situation and determine if my suspicion is valid. I emailed my finding to them. Unfortunately, they are overwhelmed by stacks of emails and my email is just a tiny little piece in the stacks. I heard that only 30% bees left in the states today and that really makes me very nervous. I hope people can start to think about my finding, if they believe I may be right, just temporary stop using this product until the researchers find the real cause of CCD.

My relationship with bees started three years ago when I decided to build a wild life friendly cottage garden with a natural fishless pond in it. When flowers are blooming and the pond is filled with water and plants, lots of bees and dragon flies come to visit my garden and pond. I really enjoy watching and observing them. But there is one problem comes with a pond without fish: Mosquitoes.

I donÂt put fish in my pond because they will eat dragon fly nymphs and tadpoles. How to solve the mosquito problem? ThereÂs a popular product on the market that does a wonderful job by killing the mosquito in their larva stage. It looks like a donut; you put some in pond or any water container. It floats and releases BT (Bacillus thuringiensis subspecies: a bacteria based insecticide) on water surface. When mosquito larvae come to the water surface to breathe, they take some BT and die within a few days. I was a little bit skittish to use this product at first. But they say it kills nothing but mosquito larvae. After tried it several times, it seems their claim is true. It really does a wonderful job for mosquito control. It has been getting more and more popular in the last couple of years. You can find this product in any major hardware or garden supply store nationwide. Even governments have started to use this product for mosquito control in large areas of still water.

Since last year, only few bees come to visit my garden and drink in my pond. Worker bees need to drink lots of water when working on the fields. I see them keep doing the round trip fly between collecting pollen from flowers and drinking water in my pond. They usually land on my duck weeds and drink the surface water from there. I think they must prefer to drink from the still water than running water. It is the same condition that mosquito larvae prefer. Larger still waters may have also been treated by BT in recent years for mosquito control.

According to EPA report, BT has minimal toxicity to honey bees. (It is not non-toxic.) After worker bees drink lots of this treated water, do they get enough toxins to weaken their immune system and get killed by this product or other pests or fungus? The time frame of CCD seems to match the popularity of this product. It may also explain why the queen and young bees are not infected, because they usually donÂt go to the fields and get their water supply from the source that is provided by beekeepers.

I love bees and really worry about CCD. But I am not a beekeeper yet and canÂt prove my theory. I also donÂt want to hurt a good company and a wonderful product. Please reply to this post and help us and our bees solve this mystery.

FYI: I donÂt use this product in my pond any more. I am lucky enough to have a pair of pacific tree frogs that moved into my pond and do a really good job of mosquito control. This year they gave birth to at least 50 tadpoles with still more to come. :)

AL in LA

Comment (1)