Software
Houzz Logo Print
bradarmi

Companion plants....tomatoes?

17 years ago

I knew combining marigolds, basil, chives, allium, garlic, and some other herbs can decrease nematodes in vegetable beds, aphids from roses, and deter some beatles, attracting bees, etc.I was googeling some intersting information the other night, the idea of using companion plants to ward off blackspot seemed like a good idea since my zephirine droiun had an outbreak or two. Once such site recommended planting tomatoes with roses since supposedly, tomatoes can increase rose blackspot resistance. Another website also suggested rue, petunias, and pelargoniums to get rid of insidious Japanesse beatles.

Anyone have experience growing tomatoes and roses together? It is an interesting idea, since I try to plant veggies in one area, herbs in another, but really i should plant what grows well together. Something cottage-y about mixing fruit, veggies, flowers, and herbs. I am re-thinking my whole lansdcape plan for the following spring. Instead of clematis, I might be combining a rose with a tomato, how would that look?

Comments (5)

  • 17 years ago

    Be careful with Rue, it caused me to break out with hives when I worked around it. I guess I'm sensitive to it, but better for you to test it before you plant a mess of it.
    The tomato plants?
    Kept in bounds and neat, they can add to the rose garden. Make sure you leave enough room for them to spread. The fertilizer you put on your roses plus the water, will make them grow pretty big. I use tomato cages right from the start.

  • 17 years ago

    I spray my roses so I don't plant anything edible near them. You should be fine though if you don't spray. I'd allow plenty of room as the tomatoes do get large and you don't want to try to unwind the tomatoes from your thorny roses.

  • 17 years ago

    The whole idea was to combat blakspot a little more naturally, since spraying is kind of a pain, and the summers are not condusive to spraying if you follow some of the manufacturer recommendations (cool day, no wind, some sun, no rain in the forecast, etc.) those days are hard to plan around in Chicagoland - especially in our balmy and sometimes volatile early summers. I figuered since I want to grow them - what about chemical protection within the plant kingom?

  • 17 years ago

    Those recommendations you speak of are just that, recommendations! I live in NW Indiana so my conditions are similar to yours. Early morning or late evening are good times to spray. During those times there is little air movement and spray settles where you aim it. If rain is forecast, spray long enough before it begins to allow the spray to dry on the leaves. Except for some contact sprays. it will do it's job if it's dry. Daconil will wash off in the rain so it would need to be reapplied. Many others combine with the top layer of cells in the leaves as it dries and will be effective. Some even reactivate after a rain. Generally, early mornings are cool in our area and the dew on the leaves helps spread the pesticide. After a rain is also a good time. The rain cools the air, it's usually calm after a storm, and excess water can be knocked off the bush by tapping it with the spray wand before you spray.
    Don't get me wrong, I'm all for organic no spray gardening. But, your excuses for not spraying can easily be gotten around. You'll need to plant known disease resistant roses as no companion planting will work if disease pressures are great.

  • 17 years ago

    hello bradami,
    apart discussions about efficacy of allium etc. on plant's health, it would be of worth considering that blackspot primarily occurs in warm and damp weather. it's not a letal disease for roses, and that's because i refuse spraying. all you can do is by choosing blackspot resistent specimens or by increasing the constitution of resident plants.
    garlic is said to be helpfull, therefore i put a lot of it in the rose beds. let me tell you that i didn't recognize any improvement - but i felt better... :-)
    rather the same goes for tomatoes - they are right impressive and funny among the roses!
    enjoy their aspect and fruits - they also like subtropical dampness!!

    bon appétit!
    kai-eric