Software
Houzz Logo Print
larryl_gw

Gar in pond?

19 years ago

I have a 2000 gallon pond in Oregon with eight full grown Koi, some water hyacinth, and some watercress.

What do you think about the advisability of introducing a Gar into the pond? Has anyone tried Gar?

I know that Gar are mostly southern fish, but that they are found in places far enough north to have a climate as cold as southern Oregon. I have read that they are fairly gentle fish as long as their fish companions are too large to eat.

Gar are pretty cool fish. I recently saw several in Arkansas.

Comments (20)

  • 19 years ago

    Yes Gar are predators. They seem to do OK in aquariums with other fish as long as the others aren't too aggressive, or too small. The aquarium Gar seem to develop a taste for pellet food after being in the tank for awhile.

    The Shortnose Gar and the Spotted Gar reach a little less than three feet at maturity, which isn't much different than my Koi. Some of my web information indicates they don't seem to mess with fish that are too big to eat. I was hoping someone had already tried this experiment so I wouldn't find out the hard way that the information was wrong.

  • 19 years ago

    i am from arkansas and when i fish, i hope i don't catch one. i would think it would be a bad idea. hope your koi aren't that expensive to replace.

  • 19 years ago

    I imagine they would do fine as long as your filtration is adequate. Being predators they would need a high-protein diet, and that means lots of nitrogenous waste-products. If you give them feeder goldfish or minnows they probably would leave the koi alone.

    One thing I would investigate is whether they can overwinter in a pond in your zone, or if they need to be brought inside for the winter.

  • 19 years ago

    Sethwell, I'm curious why you hope you don't catch one.

    Gemini Jim, I have plenty of filtration. Gar are found as far north as Illinois, which is a lot colder than southern Oregon. My pond usually doesn't freeze. This winter I had ice over maybe half of the pond for about a week. Most winters I get no ice at all.

    I'm not worried about nitrogen, my plants consume lots of nitrogen.

  • 19 years ago

    I think they eat goldfish??Are they the gars you buy for aquaiums?

  • 19 years ago

    Larry, where would you be able to find gar in Oregon? I used to live in Oregon and never caught any gar.

    I used to catch gar in southern New Mexico when I was a kid.

  • 19 years ago

    Finding a small gar might be a problem. Honestly, I haven't even thought about it. I'm still wondering if it would be a stupid thing to do.

    My very first pond was stocked with goldfish, a bluegill, and a very small largemouth bass. Well, it seemed like a good idea at the time. Other unsuccessful experiments have involved crayfish, catfish, and turtles. My goldfish experiment (after I got rid of the bass) wasn't very successful either. Actually it was too successful, I ended up with hundreds of goldfish.

    Koi seem to work well, they are tough, long lived, and they don't seem to reproduce in my pond. So I don't want to mess things up, but I am always looking for ways to make life a little more interesting. Those Gar were way cool.

  • 19 years ago

    Larry, have you considered getting some sturgens and putting in your pond?

    I used to catch some of them on the Columbia River. They are a neat looking fish, if sort of strange.

    I have had good luck with bullhead catfish, channel catfish, bluegills and bass in my ponds. They seem to get along well with the koi and goldfish.

    I keep bluegills in with my goldfish to eat most of the small fish. Goldfish tend to overproduce very rapidly.

    Koi have to be at least 5 years old to spawn so yours may just not be old enough.

  • 19 years ago

    Larry, where do you live in Oregon? My wife and I lived at Hermiston, Oregon for a while. I loved it there since it was close to the Columbia River and the fishing was great!

  • 19 years ago

    if you want only Gar in your pond....then put gar in your pond.

    If you want anything else....then don't...

    Unless you feed them very regularly, and something they really like.....THEY WILL EAT EVERYTHING ELSE!!!!!!

    It would be like dropping a few members of the Pike or Musky family in your pond.....they are used to reduce the numbers over polluting fish

  • 19 years ago

    First, for Catfishsam and Chris, my Koi are all pretty large (2-2.5 feet long) and the youngest of them is ten years old. The largest and fattest one probably weighs 20+ pounds. The world record for a caught Spotted Gar is 8.75 pounds.

    Chris, I'm concerned about your assertion that "THEY WILL EAT EVERYTHING ELSE!!!!!!". I'm having a little trouble imagining an eight pound Gar eating a 20 pound Koi. I certainly wouldn't expect a three or four inch fish to last long, but if you have seen Gar attack large fish I would like to hear more details. It sounds like you have had some first hand encounters with Gar and I would appreciate it if you would share some of your experiences.

    Catfish, I'm in Ashland (near Medford). I have seen some pretty large sturgeon in the Klamath river so I think I'll pass on monster fish. The one I saw might have been over six feet long.

  • 19 years ago

    A smaller species of gar would do okay but make sure of what you get. A Florida gar gets up to 7-8'. An alligator gar gets up to 13'. I'm sure that these two species probably wouldn't survive in your area. My future plans include a gar pond with Florida gar. I thought about alligator gar but I never could feed anything that big.

    Happy ponding,
    Scott

  • 19 years ago

    Well, Larry, you could try some squawfish. They get pretty big in Columbia River. You probably have them in southern Oregon too?

  • 19 years ago

    Larry, I was surprised to find out that Oregon pays $3 for every squawfish over 11 inches turned in.

    Wow, when I lived there I caught a lot of squashfish out of the Columbia River. Heck, I could have made a lot of money!

    Maybe you ought to raised squawfish in your ponds and turn then in when they are large enough? LOL

    Here is a link that might be useful: Squawfish

  • 19 years ago

    Larry,

    It's true that adult Cyprinus carpio are tough buggers with thick silver-dollar size scales. Even the largest predatory fish, eagles, and the like tend to pass them over even though they are abundant and relatively slow-moving. One reason carp are so common is that they have no real predatory pressure once they get through their first growing season.

    But a pond is an artificial environment, animals are in closer quarters, and inevitably some of their natural impulses become thwarted or redirected, especially for predators. Even if the gar just indulged in some compulsive fin-nipping it could be devastating to your prized koi. In a tropical aquarium a 1" tiger barb can wreak havoc on a school of angelfish many times its size.

    It may be better to have a dedicated gar pond, perhaps with a population of goldfish or rosey reds as forage.

    And the reason I asked about overwintering is I don't know if gar have any special requirements, like a mud bottom to burrow in. Do the IL gar live in lakes and ponds, or are they just in the Mississippi River system, in which case migration may be a factor?

  • 19 years ago

    Gar are supposedly found in southern Lake Michigan. I don't know about any special requirements, but there might be some.

    The best source for gar information I have found so far is wikipedia: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gar

    Here is part of it:
    Gar in aquaria

    Gar are popular fish for public aquaria where they are often kept alongside other large, "archaic" fish such as sturgeon and paddlefish. However, a few species, most commonly Lepisosteus oculatus, are sometimes offered to aquarists as pets. They do of course need very large tanks but in all other regards they are easy to keep. They are not much bothered by water quality or chemistry, and are tolerant of a wide range of temperatures. Gar must be allowed to breathe air, so some clearance between the surface of the water and the hood is essential.[7][8]

    Gar get on well with any other fish too big to be eaten (such as large catfish, cichlids, and centrachids). They do not like aggressive tankmates, and despite being predators are essentially peaceable, sociable fish that do well with their own kind. Sturdy aquarium plants and bogwood can also be used to create hiding places, since gars are very fond of lurking in slightly shady regions.[9]

    Feeding presents no problems. Most will take all kinds of meaty foods, including mealworms, crickets, earthworms, frozen lancefish and shrimps (defrosted), and strips of squid. Oily fish (like salmon and mackerel) as well as fish guts will quickly pollute an aquarium but are very effective at tempting newly introduced specimens to eat. Once settled in many specimens will also eat floating pellets as well. There is no nutritional reason to feed gar live fish, and cheap goldfish or guppies ("feeder fish") in particular tend to introduce parasites into an aquarium.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Gar according to Wikipedia

  • 19 years ago

    Well it sounds worth a try. Getting a small school (at least 3), all of the same species, and providing hiding places, should minimize any neurotic behaviors.

    I imagine it could be a bit like introducing cats into a house with 8 friendly but boisterous labrador retrievers! Hiding places will be important!

  • 19 years ago

    Just in case anyone reads this string in the future, gar are illegal to possess or release in Oregon. If you have any questions about what fish species are legal in Oregon or what permits are required, please contact your local ODFW office. Thanks!

  • 19 years ago

    I live in Nebraska and spend a bit of time on the Platte river and have had alligator gar in many of the ponds I have had.

    My experiences have been good with them but when the water gets warm they love to jump out. They always preferred a shallow part of the pond and never bothered any big fish. I do believe they can be trained to topfeed but I mostly just let them eat all the baby fish and big insects that dropped into the water.