Software
Houzz Logo Print
kaysbelle_gw

Question for Horton

18 years ago

I have a 750 gallon pond. The water was crystal clear all last year and this year until we got 5" of rain and it has been dark, not green, ever since - three weeks ago. I used a net to "drag" the bottom but very little is there. I have an "adams" filter for my pump/fountain and the pump has a nylon filter and I put quilt batting around the filter. I clean it regularly since it does trap quite a bit of floating material. I also have a "skippy filter" that empties into my waterfall. I have some fish, which act normal, water hyacinths, water lettuce, hornwort and it gets about 4-5 hours of sun.

Now the question - your "collander filter", you use the scrubbies. How does that work. My adams filter has quilt batting in it and traps quite a bit since it is fairly dense. How to the scrubbies trap anything. Is your collander stuffed tight? And how do you clean it without taking it apart, or do you?

I'm trying to decide if I want to change to your type of filter hoping to clear up my pond. Sorry for all the questions, but "grasping at straws. Any suggestions?

Comments (3)

  • 18 years ago

    I am maybe over my head here because I just started reading about this topic today :-).

    The Horton filter is a pre-filter that goes at the intake of the line. In Horton's pictures he has a small pump inside of the colanders (the whole in the colander is for the exit line). One could also potentially stick it at the end of their intake hose if they had a bigger pump.

    I think you need to cut most of the wire ties to clean it.

  • 18 years ago

    Kaysbelle, Milwaukeeboy is quite correct the colander/basket cage is a prefilter, to stop any pea gravel or hard object from being sucked into the pumps impeller and doing damage.
    The scrubbies are used to trap the soft particulates that are drawn in by the pump.
    If left alone the bacteria will colonies on the surface of the scrubbies.
    But, here's the short fall. If the basket and scrubbies are the only means of filtration for the pond, it will have to be cleaned at times, depending on how much gunk it has to filter. Consequently, each time it is cleaned you will wash out the good bacteria that is starting to build up.

    The idea behind this prefilter [ it is now being used by various pond pump manufactures] is to protect the pump more than anything else.

    It is easier to clean than the "Adam's type" filter, which, because of the type of filter material used in it, in my opinion, tends to plug up to quickly and requires to be taken apart and cleaned regularly.
    If it is not cleaned regularly then there is a danger of the pump overheating and possibly burning out.

    The basket cage type can be opened up, if necessary, by untwisting a couple of twist ties, or cutting off the ty-rap, if that is what is used to keep the two halves of the filter together.

    Normally the cleaning the basket type cage, can be done with a blast from the garden hose once a day.
    How much or often, you need to clean out a filter is in relation to the condition of the water, size of pond and how much accumulated gunk there is to filter out.

    There is no SMALL, in pond, prefilter, homemade or professionally manufactured, I have ever come across, that does not require cleaning every so often.

    An out of pond filter will do a much better job of filtering than a small in pond filter. That to me, is by far, the best method to use.

    I know there are folks who have five gallon pails [or other types of containers] filled with, a variety of filtering materials, in their ponds.
    And though this type of filter, may do a wonderful job of keeping the pond water clear, it is not something I personally, want to look at in my pond.

    Each to their own, one mans meat etc, etc.
    "Horton"

  • 10 years ago

    Where can I see a pic of this prefilter? :-)

Sponsored
Peabody Landscape Group
Average rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars8 Reviews
Franklin County's Reliable Landscape Design & Contracting