Software
Houzz Logo Print
kawaiineko_gardener

which vegetables are best started from seed

I know as a general rule of thumb, some veggies are easy to grow from seed, and it's recommended that some are just started from plants.

Just a note regarding this post. Yes I'm going to provide a very long list of veggies. No I have no intention of planting every single one of these simultaneously; that would be pure insanity and would result in the epitome of chaos.

Below is a list of veggies that eventually I would like to grow:

*Broccoli

*sugar snap peas

*Lettuce

*Cabbage

*Bush green beans

*Sweet bell peppers

*Tomatoes

*Eggplant

*Squash (yellow/summer, zucchini, acorn, butternut, pumpkin)

*Radishes

*Beets

*Okra

*Spinach

*Turnips

*Cucumbers

*Onions

*Corn

*Carrots

*melons (watermelon, cantaloupe)

Basically there is only one question I have. Using the list above, which are best grown from seed and which are best started using plants?

I know that vegetables that are recommended that you start

from plants, the reasons for it is that they take forever to germinate.

I would still like to grow the ones from seed that are recommended you grow from plants anyway. It's just a preference. For veggies that are recommended that you start them from plants, how far in advance would you have to start them indoors? By this I mean, how far in advance would you have to start them from seed in little peat pots or cells, then transplant them, harden them off, etc. (please specify this information in weeks or months)

Comments (4)

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    What do you mean, "from seed" versus "from plants"? Almost all plants come from seeds. You mean going to a nursery to pick up plants others have already grown from seed? That's a pretty expensive way to garden, IMHO; I usually only go to a nursery for whatever plants I didn't have enough of after starting from seed.

    Now, if you're asking which ones to start outside versus indoor...

    BTW -- your "pure insanity" is, for the most part, my typical yearly garden. ;)

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    What I mean when I say some veggies are easily grown from seed and some should be planted using plants due to their long germination time is just that.

    I never implied in any shape or form that the plants you
    get at garden centers or nurseries that are vegetables are full grown plants. I also never implied that I want to buy a bunch of vegetable plants and just grow them that way; in fact I said quite clearly that even veggies that have a long germination time I would prefer to grow starting from seed.

    When I refer to vegetable plants that are best started out as plants rather than doing so from seed due to their long germination time, I mean that they have already been started from seed and are essentially baby vegetable plants.
    You use these baby plants to transplant them either to your garden or to containers and just let them grow into vegetables from there. That is what I meant.

    Now that this has been clarified, can I please receive an answer to my original question, which is this; which vegetables are best grown from seed, and which should be started using baby vegetable plants? With the ones that
    are baby vegetable plants how far ahead of time do you have to plant these indoors (please specify this in weeks or months). By starting the ones that take longer to germinate indoors I mean this; you plant them under grow lights, and wait for them to germinate. When they're big enough to be transplanted you transplant them to a bigger container. When the seedlings are big enough you gradually harden them off, and then you finally transplant them to the container you intend to grow them in, or directly into the ground that is your gardening plot.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    kawaiineko: I have to admit, your original post confused me as well. I suggest you start answering your question by doing some searching on this forum or the Vegetable forum.

    Prof

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I never implied in any shape or form that the plants you
    get at garden centers or nurseries that are vegetables are full grown plants.

    Nor did I. I just commented that it seems weird to me to plan from the outset to grow your garden from store plants; I never claimed full grown. Please don't take everything so personally.

    Now that this has been clarified, can I please receive an answer to my original question, which is this; which vegetables are best grown from seed, and which should be started using baby vegetable plants?

    This is based on a faulty premise, though -- that there are some sort of common garden plants that are unreasonably hard to grow from seed, that an expert's help is needed. Nothing that you listed is at all hard to grow from seed or has long germination times. Long germination times are things like coffee, some flowers, a number of trees, etc. Mostly exotic things. What you listed are classic garden plants, and the traditional way to grow a garden is from seed. If your garden is any sort of reasonable size, buying large numbers of nursery plants every year will cost you a pretty penny indeed.

    You should be happy with this news! You wanted to grow things from seed, and lucky for you, that's very easy for common garden plants like you listed above. Now, if you ever want to grow sequoias, or kauri, or something of that nature...

    By starting the ones that take longer to germinate indoors I mean this; you plant them under grow lights, and wait for them to germinate. When they're big enough to be transplanted you transplant them to a bigger container. When the seedlings are big enough you gradually harden them off, and then you finally transplant them to the container you intend to grow them in, or directly into the ground that is your gardening plot.

    You're making this needlessly complicated. In general, for plants started indoors, you just plant your seeds in little planter pots, cover them up with a little soil, keep them watered (preferably from the bottom) and in a place where they can get enough light so they won't get leggy, and in general just let them do their thing. You don't typically keep re-transplanting them unless you started way too early for some reason; they'll go straight from your planter pots to where you want them to grow for good (after hardening, of course).

    There are lots of variants on this, of course -- peat pots, peat pellets, germinating in plastic bags, and so on down the line, but it all works out to basically the same thing. Starting from seed isn't nearly as hard as you're making it out to be. The only real challenge, in general, is making sure they get enough light. And all seedlings need this, not just a select few (although some are more likely to die with insufficient light than others -- lettuce, brassicas, etc).

    The only transplanting I generally do apart from putting them straight into the ground is if I need to thin out some seeds; the ones that get removed get put into pots of their own. Transplanting shocks plants, slowing down their growth. Also, you want your plants to have a nice rootball that roughly fills the pot by the time they get put in the ground. If the plant is in too big of a pot, it'll lose all of the dirt, its roots will hang free, and there'll be more transplant shock.

    Not all plants need to be started indoors. In fact, some are best started outdoors because they're more sensitive to being transplanted (melons and squash are the classic examples of this). In general, almost anything *can* be started outdoors, but you'll generally get a later start on the season when you do. And if some plants are marginal where you are (for example, eggplant is for us), if you don't start indoors, it may not make it to harvest before it gets cold again.