Software
Houzz Logo Print
shadey_gw

comapact burning bush -- invasive?

17 years ago

My understanding is that Burning Bush is invasive.

A lady at a local nursery told me that the 'compact' version that they sell is *not* invasive.

This has been recommended because I have a tough, dry, deep shade spot (salty too) and I desperately need something tough and bushy for screening. It seems like the compact burning bush will fit the bill -- nothing seems to grow back there. But I don't want to plant an invasive.

And while we're on the topic, what about Silver Lace Vine? I like them, mine has not spread, but is it considered invasive?

Thanks,

Shadey

Comments (16)

  • 17 years ago

    I'm not aware of any sterile cultivars of Euonymus alatus. I'd confront the lady and ask her to show you proof that the cultivar is sterile. If there is a sterile cultivar, the information will be readily available when you google the cultivar name. If she couldn't produce results, I'd ask for the nursery's owner and inform him or her of what a disservice they are doing by selling invasive plants and lying about it. Then I'd spread the word to other local gardeners to watch out for that nursery.

  • 17 years ago

    A lady at a local nursery told me that the 'compact' version that they sell is *not* invasive.

    This is BS. AFAIK the farthest we are getting is pot trials with these cultivars and they haven't been released to the trade yet. Not that I am Mr Connected To Everybody, but it's likely we'd have heard of it if the cultivar was released.

    wrt the Polygonum, you'll want to check your state's invasive list and maybe give the Extension Office a call/e-m. Even if not invasive, you'll be spending time removing runners-sprouts from your garden. I planted one in a landscape and won't do it again (in CA).

    Dan

  • 17 years ago

    I have heard that they are non-invasive too, so the idea is out there. I also know that they are NOT sterile and likely invasive, but I would consider the response you received to be a case of misinformation on their part rather than one of deception.

  • 17 years ago

    E.a. 'Rudy Haag' is supposed to be "nearly" seedless, but that's not quite the same as being sterile. If you've run out of options and are looking for a Euonymus that stays small (smaller than 'Compactus') and produces little if any seed, this would be the one to try.

    Bob

  • 17 years ago

    I have heard that they are non-invasive too, so the idea is out there.

    I have heard the idea out there that pigs can fly too. That, however, doesn't make the idea of airborne porcine propulsion any more credible.

    There are exactly zero sterile cultivars in nurseries at this time. There are pot trials going on, but they are not complete. What brandon says is good advice and the nursery owner should know what their employees are telling customers.

    Dan

  • 17 years ago

    I had 4 burning bushes; never known them to be invasive. I removed them because they grew too big for the area. They were not turn red in fall unless they're in full sun. Never seen one grown in shade.

  • 17 years ago

    No, what Brandon is saying is a trite overreaction. There is a general belief among the public and in many gardening groups about the existence of sterile cultivars. Misinformation is NOT a crime nor is it good to go to misinformed people and accuse them of lying, then go about telling people not to buy from a location because of a well-intentioned but misinformed employee. Employees are expected to be knowledgeable, but cannot be expected to be knowledgeable on all aspects of every plant and this cultivar is PROMOTED as seedless. We know seedless does not = sterile, but it does equal that many people. Pigs can fly, but flying off the handle on the subject will just make it so what you are saying is not heard at all.

  • 17 years ago

    "Pigs can fly" - I made a mistake on that. I meant to say they cannot, even when acting as a projectile.

  • 17 years ago

    "No, what Brandon is saying is a trite overreaction."

    Care to explain?

    "Misinformation is NOT a crime."

    I never said it was, but since you mention it, in an ethical sense, I think it very well could be in some situations. When a professional that should be aware of what they are talking about provides information that results in damage to the environment, that's wrong!

    "...nor is it good to go to misinformed people and accuse them of lying"

    You misread me there. I didn't advise telling the lady she was lying. I advised asking her for proof of her statement and then bringing the issue to the nursery's management or ownership if the worker was misinformed. This could and should, of course, be done in a tactful way.

    "Employees are expected to be knowledgeable, but cannot be expected to be knowledgeable on all aspects of every plant..."

    Not being familiar with every aspect of a plant is VERY different than promising a plant to be non-invasive when you are specifically asked about that characteristic. If she didn't know, she could have just said so or tried to look up the information. Let's say I planted a zone 10 tree in a clients yard here in zone 6. Then when it didn't make it through the winter, could I get by with saying that I shouldn't be expected to be knowledgeable on all aspects of every plant? Of course not.

    "...flying off the handle on the subject will just make it so what you are saying is not heard at all."

    True, but neither will just ignoring the situation and hoping that the next customer knows to check their plant selection out on Gardenweb before buying it. And, of course, no one here was advising anyone to "fly off the handle" in the first place.

  • 17 years ago

    I had 4 burning bushes; never known them to be invasive.

    Just want to point out that you don't have to personally observe a plant being invasive for it to be so. Plants can physically invasive - that is, spreading by runners or suckers, or plants can be invasive through seeds which can be carried off by birds or windblown. Burning bush is invasive by seed via bird distribution.

  • 17 years ago

    . No professional is always aware of what they are talking about because no one individual can claim to know everything! If a professional came up to me and told me that they knew everything about their particular subject, I would laugh. To be a professional means that they possess vastly greater knowledge and understanding on the topic, not that they are some sort of superman that knows everything.

    I am with you in regards to how serious of an issue invasives is as well as how vital it is to be properly informed, and you must know as well as I do that some are misinformed or completely indifferent to the issue. Indifference is maddening, but some people just don't care. What is right and wrong is subjective as always. Flat-out advising the OP to tell others to avoid the nursery when all it may be guilty of is a misinformed or indifferent employee is an overreaction!

    This cultivar has been said to be seedless. I have been told that by several people when I pointed out that it , infact, not actually sterile. They were well-meaning people repeating the 'knowledge' they learned about this plant. It is not completely unreasonable for an employee to assume that it is sterile in that light. Incorrect, but not unreasonable or wrong. Misinformation is to be corrected, and not by confronting and challenging the employee and spreading negative word of mouth about the company on the basis of this, which is EXACTLY what you suggested in your first post on this topic. It is best to correct them and inform them not by challenging or 'asking for proof', something that tends to make people defensive, but by simply correcting and explaining the problem to the employee in question. Going to management is the equivalent of taking out the big guns.

  • 17 years ago

    Fledgeling, I'm sorry that your assumptions are making you mistake my response. You are viewing the situation from an extreme point of view which doesn't reflect my intention.

    Without "ask(ing) her to show you proof that the cultivar is sterile", there is no way to be positive that she's not correct! There may be something out there that neither you nor I know about. That doesn't mean that you have to get nose to nose with the lady!!! When you ask for proof, you could say something like, "I wasn't aware that sterile cultivars were available. Can you show me where this variety is reported to be sterile to ease my mind?" I think that most any adult would be able to come up with these words, or a similar response on their own, but here, I've spelled it out for you.

    "Spreading negative word of mouth about the company" is a final step, and is OBVIOUSLY not something that would need to be done if the company is willing to take reasonable care once a problem is spotted. Surely you don't think it would be reasonable to just start bad-mouthing someone that was trying to do their best and was willing to examine possible problems! As in my initial post (in the very last sentence) this would be a final step if all else fails.

    Don't always assume the worse. Adults should be able to diplomatically deal with situations like this! My advise is in regards to the botanical/horticultural/environmental/etc side of this situation. If you want someone to give you the correct words in the right order and with the best tone, talk to one of those advise column people in the newspaper. I don't have time!

  • 17 years ago

    The funny thing about the internet is that it does not carry inflections or tone so that they do not always read as you intended when you wrote it. I assume you have been on the internet enough to know that, atleast. But in case you have not, here it is for your benefit.

    On the internet, people can't know exactly what tone you are trying to convey, they can only attempt interpret it through your text. And unless "adults" are somehow psychic, there is no way for them to know exactly what you mean unless you actually SAY so, because tone does not carry here.

    " If she couldn't produce results, I'd ask for the nursery's owner and inform him or her of what a disservice they are doing by selling invasive plants and lying about it. Then I'd spread the word to other local gardeners to watch out for that nursery."

    There are enough people out there where that, in verbatim, is exactly what they would suggest, and I have met enough of them to not assume anything. Articulate exactly what you mean because on the internet it is necessary because we do not have the benefit of knowing what you really would say, we only have what you type. And I don't have the time to go around divining who really meant what they said and who is going to backtrack and say that they really did not mean it as they typed it, because an any body would obviously assume that what they REALLY meant was to _______.
    The words "Lying" "confront" "challenge" set an overtly negative tone in your post, and that it was precived that way should not come as a shock to you.

  • 17 years ago

    Oh, yes, I just spent the first section of my post arguing that tone does not carry and then at the end I indicated otherwise. I am quite bad at this. I think we're done here...

  • 17 years ago

    I sure hope so. I think it would be best if we stuck to the subject and worried less about how people say what they say. Catching mistakes can be educational and helpful, but lecturing someone on internet etiquette or arguing about what they meant when they said something can be less so! There may be situations where a word about how something comes across can be useful, but that should always be done sparingly, carefully, and without assumptions.

  • 17 years ago

    If I'm reading this link correctly, sterile Burning Bushes are at least in the lab. Wonder how long it will take Walmart to start carrying them. (-:

    Here is a link that might be useful: Sterile Transgenic Euonymus alatus Produced

Sponsored
Industry Leading General Contractors in Franklin County, Ohio