Software
Houzz Logo Print
woody64_gw

wildflower?

17 years ago

found this growing and was wondering is it a wildflower/

Image link:

Comments (13)

  • 17 years ago

    Linaria vulgaris, BUTTER-AND-EGGS. Nice weed.

    Joe

  • 17 years ago

    I prefer calling it a "wildflower" over "weed".

    I haven't seen or heard of butter-and-eggs before, but it's nice looking and something I would want to put in a garden (so why call it a weed?)...I've got a nice Swamp Milkweed that I brought out of the riverbed into my garden last year, and it's just starting to flower again right now. I wouldn't call that a weed either, despite its common name.

  • 17 years ago

    They actually sell swamp milkweed in garden centers. Never seen Butter and Eggs for sale, though. What it really is is a little snapdragon, if you look closely at the flowers. In fact, I saw some growing in Alaska when I was there that looked like garden snapdragons - amazing what 20 hours of sunlight will do. I don't think they're the kind of aggressive thug that you usually think of when people say 'weed'; but they like to grow in vacant lots and road edges and other 'weedy' places.

    WW

  • 17 years ago

    Linaria vulgaris, an exotic plant from Europe, is on the "Noxious Weed" list of many states in the U.S. It's on Alaska's "Invasive" list.

    It was a bothersome weed on my property in Northern Wisconsin.

    Joe

  • 17 years ago

    I see it now and again on our property, but it is usually only a solitary plant and quite uncommon. I love it.

  • 17 years ago

    how do you get seeds from it?(iam green ok,lol)

  • 17 years ago

    Toadflax is another name for butter-and-eggs. I personally like the name butter-and-eggs better. It is one of those "colorful" names for plants like john-go-to-bed-by-noon (applied to various salsify species).

    Butter-and-eggs makes seed capsules late summer - early fall. It is easy to collect the papery seed from that. Check google for germination requirements.

    As far as weed? To me a "weed" is either a plant out of place or a plant for which you have no use. And finding a plant pretty is a perfectly respectable use!

    FataMorgana

  • 17 years ago

    "a plant out of place" is a nice definition for a weed. In fact, I use it myself in my classes.

    And "a plant for which you have no use". I especially like "A plant for which a use has yet to be discovered".

    But those are all philosophical definitions.

    There are commercial, legal and technical definitions of "weed". And various states make those definitions. "Noxious" means something, especially to farmers and orchardists who have to deal with weeds in sometimes expensive ways.

    At the risk of sounding like a stick-in-the-mud, whether or not you find a plant "pretty" doesn't make it responsible to advocate planting it to others.

    One of the reasons why Linaria vulgaris is a weed in so many places is because someone found it pretty.

    I, personally, LOVE a field of dandelions (from a distance) in a lawn when they're in bloom.

    Joe

  • 17 years ago

    At the risk of sounding like a stick-in-the-mud, whether or not you find a plant "pretty" doesn't make it responsible to advocate planting it to others.

    Ah, true enough. But butter-and-eggs is not black swallow-wort, garlic mustard or Japanese knotweed. It is harmless enough and tends to prefer harsh lean, dry places that many other plants eschew like road edges, old barnyards, etc.

    And dandelion? I too love to see its cheery yellow face in early spring. Besides that, I wildcraft for a naturopath and it is the herb I collect the most of every year and so it is a useful medicine plant to me. A "weed" is truly all a point of view. :)

    FataMorgana

  • 17 years ago

    A "weed" is truly all a point of view

    Yeah I agree. Get them out of my garden, but I love stuff like dandelions growing out in a field or anywhere wild.

  • 17 years ago

    "It is harmless enough..."

    Actually, no. Maybe on your property or nearby but the reason it IS on the "Noxious Weeds" list of many states is BECAUSE it is NOT "harmless enough".

    Weeds being a "point of view" is wonderfully romantic but your neighbors don't think so.

    Collect all you want but you should not suggest to newbie gardeners to grow such, especially if you don't know where they live or what conditions they have.

    Joe

  • 17 years ago

    thanks everyone!!

  • 17 years ago

    Weeds being a "point of view" is wonderfully romantic but your neighbors don't think so.

    Then I would say the neighbors would have a different point of view - they don't want the plant because it gets in the way, while you want it because it makes a nice addition to your own garden.

    I would say a weed is a plant that is widely considered to be unwanted in any garden and usually invasive and/or persistant. Then there are those like me who admire some of them and know they have their place somewhere (unless an exotic invasive species of course).

    I even find Kudzu very fascinating with is amazing growing abilities. Of course, it can be a huge problem but that doesn't keep me away from it. Also it's a possibly good source for compost or animal forage...but then of course it's also extremely invasive in the Southeast US (where I happen to live).

    But back on the topic of my swamp milkweed, I gotta say I love that plant. The blooms smell very good (and I usually don't care for flower smells). I can see why it's sold at some nurseries. But I prefer my wild variety, knowing that it came from its natural habitat at the river rather than a greenhouse.

Sponsored
Peabody Landscape Group
Average rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars8 Reviews
Franklin County's Reliable Landscape Design & Contracting