Software
Houzz Logo Print
wren_garden

OT Join the HGTV protest Campaign

17 years ago

Are you angry, sad and disappointed about the vanishing of real garden programs on TV. Want to lend your support to the fight to turn this around. Read On

This is taken from a post on the Winter Sowing forum. I know it is long but I would guess important to most of us. There is a lot of info for action, addresses, names, sites etc. In fact Nancy Drew in the 29th post on this thread lists all the addresses and Sewobsessed (founder of the protest) has THE email address for the campaign.

OT: HGTV Protest Campaign


Posted by sewobsessed 5a Upstate Cntrl NY (My Page) on

Fri, Mar 27, 09 at 17:12

Many, many of us are fed up with the lack of real gardening programs on HGTV (what 'G'?). The more I think about all those wonderful shows that are gone/cancelled, the more I fume.

Now, they've even cancelled Gardening By The Yard with Paul James (he was too old!?). What are they thinking?

According to a producer, gardening doesn't sell, but 'landscaping' does. Hmmm, gardeners' don't count to them, only landscape/design/real estate/30-minute-makeover shows do.

Obviously, emails to HGTV don't get anyone anywhere, as you could see by doing a search on GW itself or google. You get a lousy form letter in response.

BUT,

I happen to have an email addy for a higher-up at Scripps Networks (parent of HGTV) and a list (granted, pretty short so far) of companies that are advertising through them on HGTV and their contact links.

So, if we all hit them where it hurts the most - their advertisers - and email them stating that we've noticed them advertising on HGTV and in protest of the channel cancelling real gardening programs from their lineup, we, as well as our family and friends, will not be purchasing their products or patronizing their stores, do you think we could finally make some sort of impact?

We'd all have to do it as a group on a certain day though, or it wouldn't work (maybe a couple weeks from now?). I thought of just doing it myself, but, well . . . what good is one person going to do?

Do you think something like that would finally, finally get their attention? How many of you would really be willing to do something like this?

Slam Scripps and the advertisers all in one day, they'll get that we're serious?

Anyone know a good way to get the word spread?

How about April 13 for a date? Hit them from all sides all on the same day. Enough time? Someone got a better date?

(Below is the addy for Sewobsesseds blog with more information)

http://happyhobbyhabit.blogspot.com/2009/03/hgtv-protest-campaign-april-13-2009.html

The point of the whole thing is that all those channels DIY/HGTV/FLN/Food Network/GAC are all

owned by Scripps Networks.

The individual channel programming people are the ones that really don't care what we want to watch. Emailing each channel individually results in a form letter reply. But, they have bosses (Scripps Networks). The only people who are going to listen to a complaint of any kind are the head honchos at the parent network and their advertisers. That's who we need to target and I'm trying!

Wren Garden

How could we get word to the First Lady? We could Email every Nursery we use, on or off line, to join us on the 13th. What about every and any vendor that advertises in garden magazines, most list a www.com to contact them. Any college or high school that has a horticulture program. Directors of food banks. Garden clubs and Societies. Oprah! Sewobsessed, help. email me. I am Elizabeth

Go to the Winter Sowing forum here on GW and lend your support and keep up with the developments. Add your ideas and action. Elizabeth

Comments (28)

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I hardly ever watch HGTV because unless I'm in the real estate market there's little on that channel I care to watch. There's only so much interior redecorating I'm willing to do.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    If you go to the HGTV forums, there is a lot of complaining about how the channel has turned into the "real estate" channel. They have added the new "Rate my Space" show and it has changed the nature of the "Rate my Space" website to be a bunch of people trying to get picked to be on the show instead of people showcasing their decorating efforts. People are MAD about it too!

    I don't think there were ever too many gardening shows there to begin with but it looks like they all are gone.

    I loved the gardening show from several years ago - I think it came on PBS? - with the goofy guy (with glasses?)....sure wish I could remember the name of it. He did his show from somewhere in the NE and covered all topics, including composting and stuff like that. My husband and I used to watch it every weekend morning and get motivated to get out in the yard!

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Texaslynn--

    I think the goofy guy from New England on PBS was the former host of The Victory Garden--now they have some Australian dude that I'm not too fond of. I guess they needed more handsome exotic "star power" and got rid of the likeable knowledgable nerd. I still enjoy P Allen Smith, though. And both shows are better than anything on HGTV, which I gave up on years ago, except for catching Candace Olsen every once in a while. It really HAS become the real-estate channel, and I couldn't take one more cute young twentysomething "professional" re-do a room with nothing but plywood, fabric and a hot glue gun, or landscape with random plants that they probably don't know the names of, shoved into hastily dug holes. Ok, rant over.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I gave up on HGTV. But my local PBS station is great! They've got three channels now, and one of them is the Wisconsin channel and another is the Creative channel. Both show gardening shows. I've seen P. Allen Smith's show, Garden Paths, Wisconsin Gardener, Great Lakes Gardening, and the Victory Garden. There might be another one too. Anyway, it's enough that I don't miss HGTV at all and I think my decision to cancel cable was a good one.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I live close enough to Knoxville to hear some HgTV related stories.
    Remember back when the shift happened to a lot more cooking shows there? The person behind that shift had been the HgTV person who was in charge of finding and placing their food shows- she got promoted to top hound at the station and brought her knowledge of chefs with her and to this day she's so proud of bringing Rachel Ray onto TV screens everywhere.
    I would guess that the channel has done another change of mgmt and that the new guy or gal is the one who brought along "flip this hovel" and some of their other programing.
    If they can find advertisers (and I doubt that they are looking for gardening advertisers), then HTV is only a click away.

    Surprisingly, our Local PBS has added the CreateTV option and it is now what HgTV was...with good cooking shows (Jacques Pepin among others) some gardening, some painting, some this that and t'other, but at least they are not just painting pictures of trees, but are planting a few.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    It is sad but the fact is, if the advertisers are not there to pay for the air time, the shows don't get made and don't get aired. I've seen better gardening material on YouTube lately (Paul Z. from Ashdown).

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hoovb said what I was going to say.
    What gardening there is seems to be in a situation that is not interesting to me. Five minutes of gardening and 20 minutes of cooking and showing off a kitchen, etc.

    I haven't gotten over their dropping the Disneyworld show many years ago. That was gardening at its best. How I wish they would put it back on.

    Sammy

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I doubt that anything will make a dent in the little twenty-something minds at H(G? what G?)TV. They like programs that fit their little startup lives. Not, of course that there's anything wrong with that, except it's on the air 24/7.
    I've been leery of Youtube, but if there is more gardening there like Paul's programs, then that's where I'm going. Nice that you don't have to meet a timeframe to watch...can anyone recommend any more gardening links?
    My favorite comment: "flip this hovel". cackle, snicker.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I canceled my cable and went back to my antenna. I loved watching all the gardening shows. When they all were being canceled I really saw no point in having cable.I had my mother record them for me weekly But that was in the late 90's. There were even gardening shows on regular canadian tv. Thats all changed and a new generation is here and tv will reflect there interests. Even the victory garden with the new Ausie guy on pbs here, are all repeats of older shows.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    little twenty-something minds at H(G? what G?)TV.

    It's demographics pure and simple. It is how the TV business works. Advertisers want people in the 18-34 and 34-49 age groups. They pay the most for ads for those demographics. So HGTV must offer shows that will attract that age group so the advertisers will buy time. If tweens were fascinated by gardening instead of the Jonas Brothers and were buying gardening related products, there would be a huge number of tween gardening shows.

    People over 40 who are the most avid gardeners buy less high-margin stuff. High-margin stuff is what get advertised. Therefore advertisers are not interested in them. Hence, no decent garden shows...

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hoov, you are so right. And I keep waiting for the advertisers to notice that us boring persons over 40 (way over, in my case)are the only ones left with any cash!!

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I love gardening by the yard! I record it often. I have been disappointed in the disappearing gardening shows. Gardening by the yard was the first show I had ever seen on HGTV and from there I went to watching the others. If they take Paul James off...I won't watch HGTV at all.

    Tammy

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    HGTV has been in the dumps for years. they are really out of touch since the economy took a dump - different things are important to people now. There is a huge increase in home growing and orchards because of increased produce prices... you think they would capitalize on it.

    I am with the above poster. I DVR paul james show and that is the only thing I watch. I also dvr victory garden on our pbs channels which is on sporadically (hardly ever) I don't know anyone who watches hgtv anymore really.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Re prairielaura's comment: And I keep waiting for the advertisers to notice that us boring persons over 40 (way over, in my case)are the only ones left with any cash!!

    Heh, heh - really? You have cash left over after this season's rose buying? I think I stopped going to the grocery store so much so I could have a bit more money for another plant or two! The family was always complaining that there was never any good junk in the house anymore!

    Gardening by the Yard was the show that my husband and I always watched butit's been a very long time since we've seen it. Loved Paul James!

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I recall watching quality gardening programs on it a number of years back with my Mother.Not just the usual quality fare,but specials like BBC's "Quest for the Rose."

    For me,these days HGTV isn't even worth the time it takes to look up and see how many programs that used to air on it which don't anymore.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Update, Sewobsessed has made it SO Easy to participate for the April 13th blast to HGTV with a blog just for the campaign. See you there on the 13th. Thanks, spread the word.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Some of the reall good shows were:

    Rebeccas Garden
    Gardener's Journal
    Gardener's Diary
    Gardening by the Yard, etc.

    My favorite was Victory Garden and has anyone seen
    martha Stewart rose garden? It is gorgeous!. Her gardening
    specials used to be my "can't miss" shows because, even if
    you don't like her she had a lot of info. Right now ON Demand has several little MS shorts but they are not but about 3-5 min long. I would LOVE to see an hour long special in her rose garden.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Here in Ontario there were some grand gardening programmes and one was a call-in with Ken Beatie that ran in the winter time. All gone or sad re-runs years out of date. Our CBC radio one, has a call in show Mondays at 1:00 pm with a master gardener. It is very good. The young fellow from England that does "the urban gardener" and re-newing urban gardens in the United States is very good. I especially dislike 'gardening shows', that are making the outside look like your living room. SHHHSh, my living room doesn't cost that much! Susz

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Here is a link to about 150 short videos made by KLRU for their program called "Central Texas Gardening". (Don't worry, they aren't about cactus and cowboys.) On the contrary, they are good garden tours and discussions of landscaping decisions. Since a lot of the people are not native Texans, there aren't too many of them who talk like I do, which is to say hick-sounding. Take a look.
    Laura

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I wonder how long all H(G)TV's "flip this house" and "trading (trashing) spaces" shows will survive during this recession ... wouldn't this be just the perfect time to air a new series on saving money through home veggie gardening? Where's Eliot Coleman when you need him? Or, I'd even take Roger Swain, although Eliot's much easier on the eyes!

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I watch HGTV. I liked the gardening shows, but after a while they didn't teach me anything I didn't already know.

    I like watching house hunters. The show where someone is looking for a house and they look at 3 houses and then the dramatic ending where they pick the one they want. Or at least that's what usually happens. I've seen episodes where the house hunters decided to keep renting.

    Most of the shows were obviously filmed while house prices were at or near their peak and financing was easy. I mean they have receptionists looking at $250k houses. They typically show the homeowners a few months after purchase to check up on them. They're always thrilled with their house. I'll bet many of them have now been foreclosed on. I saw one episode where the buyer was getting a more affordable option arm mortgage. The ones where you don't even have to pay the interest each month if you choose not to (Everyone pays the minimum amount each month). The unpaid interest gets added to the principal.

    I love the comments by newlyweds looking for their first home (and the look on the face of the agents). 'I don't like the kitchen knobs'. The agent informs them that for maybe $100 at home depot you can buy a new set of knobs. They look at the agent like she's nuts. How can she expect them to go to home depot?

    The buyers also look at a kitchen that doesn't have a $25k remodel job with new cherry cabinets, granite counter tops and SS appliances and say 'We would definitely have to redo the entire kitchen' even thought the kitchen is fine and could easily last another 15 years.

    This show is a documentary showing how we got into the financial mess we're in.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Calling all Gardeners and Paul James 'The Gardener Guy' FANS. Let your voice be heard.
    I work with Paul James and we love the grass roots movement. However let me clear the air on some facts. GBTY has not been cancelled, however we are not filming any new shows at this time. We finished 26 new shows that should be running now and we are being told that GBTY should keep running for the next couple years. HOWEVER with that said, HGTV has left the G out and that is wrong. ON APRIL 13TH LET YOUR VOICE BE HEARD!!!!! LET HGTV KNOW YOU AS A VIEWER WANT MORE PAUL JAMES and MORE GBTY AT A GOOOOOOOD TIME SLOT.

    Here is GOOD NEWS***** Paul James 'The Gardener Guy' has a new web site set to launch MAY 1st. Go to www.gardenerguy.com and see the count down to MAY 1st.

    LET YOUR VOICE BE HEARD APRIL 13TH

    BRAIN
    www.gardenerguy.com

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I quit watching a long time ago when it went to the beefcake/babe reality TV with a home and garden twist. "Flip this house" made me realize a big housing bubble was coming at last- a bunch of idiots were making 80 grand per house flip ("why is there a big gap between the granite countertop and the wall??" the prospective buyer asks at the open house...) As said above, they are playing to the marketing & advertising which is how they make their $$. Its just the way it works.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    T.V. has gotten to be such a bunch of mindless garbage that my husband and I looked at each other one evening and asked "Why are we paying x dollars a month for this"?! We cancelled the satellite the next day. What's really scary is if this is what the majority of American people think is great, we are most certainly in trouble.

    We haven't missed it at all, and enjoy the quality time reading and doing other things together. We even sleep better now. Any news we want we can get off the internet. And it's so nice not to be listening to a Viagra ad every other minute.

    Sandy

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I'm ready. I composed my letter and it is saved in word. Just a little copy and paste and away I go. Going to get up tomorrow, make a pot of tea, sit down at the "puter" in my PJs and lock and load. I wish us all the best in our honest efforts.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Lock and Load -- Grinnnnn! (bump)

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Consider it done..
    The following is my little note* to the 23 year old head honcho's at HGTV:

    WE, the over 40's, who have the greatest spending power, are Mad as Hell, and we are'nt going to take it any Longer!! WE WANT GARDENING PROGRAMS ON HGTV ! WE have no interest what so ever in 'Flip this Sty', 'Rate the Space I don't Own', etc!! WE, are starting a major boycott of ALL sponsers!

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Ooooo, good one Iris, Maybe I have been a little to polite so far. Maybe I could crank it up. Thanks for the inspiration.