Software
Houzz Logo Print
moongardengirl

For my first time ordering roses, please help?

16 years ago

I have a three year old medium size perennial garden of mostly white, blue/purple, and pink. I planned for some shrubs and climbing roses and this is the year!

Goal List:

Will survive Zone 3-4 windy

I would like to order all from one place

Pink and White (Not 80's Prom Dress Pink)

Of course resistance to disease is a must

I like lots of petals, like 40+

I would like big climbing or bushy plant to get the most bang for my buck

I like tightly coiled centers

Repeat bloom is good

Fragrance is nice but as you can see, last on my list

I found a place called Chamblee Rose Nursery with:

Hawkeye Belle

New Dawn

Iobelle

Belinda's Dream

Glamis Castle (Auslevel)

In order of the ones I like the best to least.

So, here is my question:

Do these roses sound like good choice for someone new to roses but not new to gardening and do you think they line up with my goals? Other recommendations that would be better suited to my goals? Feed back of any kind and especially pictures of these or other recommendations growing in Zone 3-4 Western ND would be greatly appreciated.

Thank you so much for your time, Amy

Comments (13)

  • 16 years ago

    I would say "no" to Belinda's Dream. It is only marginally hardy here in near-coastal NJ.

  • 16 years ago

    I just ordered a couple of New Dawn roses. Everyone I asked said it's a nice rose and hardy, but the thorns are wicked! I changed my mind about putting them on an arbor and decided to plant them behind some other plants, along a fence instead (where no one would be grabbed by them).

    Since we can have very cold winters some years, I decided to only get own root roses. I've ordered two Therese Bugnet rugosas, since they look very pretty (almost like a damask), smell good, are a nice shade of pink and hardy to zone 2.

    I don't know how hardy Glamis Castle is, but last year's David Austin catalog lists english roses as hardy to zone 4 as including the following: A Shropshire Lad, Abraham Darby, Charlotte, Cottage Rose, Crocus Rose, Crown Princess Margareta, Gertrude Jekyll, LD Braithwaite, Mary Rose, Redoute, Scepter'd Isle, Sharif Asma, The Dark Lady, The Mayflower and Winchester Cathedral. Hope this gives you some good ideas :)

  • 16 years ago

    Belinda's Dream is a warm weather rose. It would be highly unlikely to survive your zone. I lost a couple of mine here in Florida this winter. It was a cold, cold winter. We went down to 13 degrees one night.

    Rugosas sound like a good choice. Chamblees is a good nursery, and I am sure if you speak to the owner, he will steer you in the right direction.

    The Antique Rose Emporium, Roses Unlimited, and Vintage gardens are also great places to order roses, and will put you in touch with someone that can help you make choices. I've had great conversations with the owners of all of these nurseries, including Chamblees.

    Once you get really hooked on roses, you'll most likely be ordering something from all of them. Although they all carry many of the same roses, they also carry roses not available anywhere else but with them. Vintage in particular, has some very rare roses, but they are band size and have to be potted up several months before they can go in the ground.

    Sandy

  • 16 years ago

    The last time I saw a Chamblees catalog, they carried about three roses that I consider growable here. The Fairy, Earth Song, and a third I don't remember. Spring Valley in Wisconsin would be a much better place to start.

  • 16 years ago

    I ordered a few roses from Heirloom Roses last year. The bands were own root, small, but I put them right in the ground and they've done very well...two Fantin Latours and a miniature rose.

    This year, I'm ordering a lot of gallicas, hybrid musks and some rugosas, so I ordered my roses from Rogue Valley Roses and Northland Rosarium. I won't get them until May and June (my choice) because I need time to get my beds prepared. Gallicas are very cold hardy and after talking to a lot of people on both this forum and antique rose forum, I've decided old garden roses are a better fit for my area--with rugosas, some hybrid musks in one area that is pretty protected and warmer against the house, and a few hardy climbers.

    When I started coming to the rose forums, I thought I wanted all the roses to bloom all summer. I still have a few that repeat bloom, but many will not. Some roses may not bloom all summer, but most of my favorite flowers do not, like lilacs, peonies, daffodils, hyacinths, coneflowers, butterfly bushes, etc. I don't have a long summer, so four to six weeks is a long time for roses :)

  • 16 years ago

    I have had mixed results with roses in zone 5a. Many do not survive the winter. Here are some ideas.

    1) Easy Elegance Roses. Check the website for local nurseries.
    http://www.easyelegancerose.com/

    2) Buck Roses. Some are hardier than others. I am not sure Iobelle is hardy. Try Country Dancer, Prairie Harvest and Carefree Beauty.

    3) Old Garden Roses. Recommended: Rose de Rescht. Portlands, Hybrid Perpetuals and Bourbons are the only repeating ones. Stanwell Perpetual is also known for hardiness. Most Bourbons (except Louise Odier) are not hardy. Reine des Violettes and Compte de Chambord are usually available at Home Depot (see grafted rose note below).

    4) Austins. Many own root Austins have died in my garden but some have survived.

    5) Rugosas are nonstandard roses and are susceptible to cane borers. Don't count on them.

    6) If you buy grafted roses, bury the bud union at least 3 inches or it will get zapped during the winter. If rabbits are a problem, make hardware cloth cylinders to protect the roses.

  • 16 years ago

    Although Chamblee is my favorite nursery for own root plants, I would recommend you to get grafted plants from Pickering so you get more growth in your probably short growing season. If you plant the grafts (bud unions very deep and protect the crown in the first winter you will get a nice show by the second year.
    I think in your zone it is not too late to plant bare root plants, maybe even too early. I checked Pickering's website. They have an entire page dedicated to winter hardy roses. A lot is sold out but they still have more then enough left to start a garden. You can cross-reference some with the very disease resistant rose page and you already have a very nice list. They have New Dawn, Parade, Illusion (climbers), Crocus rose (Austin) that is supposedly a very great rose, I do want to get that next year while I got rid of Gamis Castle (but your climate is dry, so GC probably won't have constant blackspot there).

    I agree with all those above who said that Belinda's dream is a warm climate rose and won't survive in your climate though I am surprised that it didn't survive this winter in Florida. Both came through without here in coastal NC and we also had a very long cold winter. Probably some Buck roses would do OK in your zone, Pickering also has some.

  • 16 years ago

    New Dawn would very much be marginal as well. I have had trouble with its hardiness in zone 5b. Some winters it really takes a hit.

  • 16 years ago

    A good substitute for New Dawn in a very cold climate is John Davis - a lovely double pink Explorer rose that can be trained as a climber. Not as tall but a prolific bloomer is Prairie Joy - a very double pink out of the Morden series. The one-blooming Austin climber Constance Spry is also very cane hardy. Here's a picture of John Davis in my garden.

    {{gwi:239877}}

  • 16 years ago

    I just placed my order from Chamblee's. Their prices are the best of all the nurseries I checked.

  • 16 years ago

    The Austins do very well for me. Some of my best are Eglantyne, James Galway, and Sharifa Asma.

    James Galway is my tallest Austin, it reaches almost 6 feet tall.

    Glamis Castle has a unique fragrance that is not to everyone's taste.

  • 16 years ago

    Have you had a look at High Country Roses? They are located in Utah and specialize in own-root, hardy roses. I have ordered from them several times and have always been pleased. Their roses are not the largest, but have always been extremely healthy and quick-growing for me. They should be able to help you with hardiness questions.

    Good Luck
    Maureen

    Here is a link that might be useful: High Country Roses

  • 16 years ago

    I've ordered from several different places, and have so far liked them all, including Chamblees. On the one occasion when there was a severe damage problem caused en route, Chamblees replaced the rose. You do need to report the damage immediately, though, if it's so extensive that the rose might not recover.

    I've decided to stick with the easily-planted ownroot roses from wherever I end up buying any particular rose. And with the possibility of severe winter dieback, the ownroots also have an advantage over the grafted in that whatever grows back is necessarily going to be the same variety you ordered. Someone who has grown both kinds for sale, Paul Zimmerman, says that the ownroots are only smaller than grafted plants during the first three or so years because when you get them they're younger plants than the grafted roses... but that they'll soon catch up.

    One of my ownroots from Chamblees last year, Cinco De Mayo, started out as the tiniest rose I've ever seen, but had grown to about 4' wide, 4' tall, and very bushy by the fall.

    One of the best places for a newcomer to learn about growing roses is Paul Zimmerman's website with his videos covering many aspects of growing roses. (Link enclosed)

    Best wishes,
    Mary

    Here is a link that might be useful: Paul Zimmerman's rose growing videos on You Tube