Software
Houzz Logo Print
farm_boy

heat sink not working

14 years ago

I have 5 55-gallon barrels of water in my 8 x 12 greenhouse, and this morning it's 18 degrees F in there. One barrel has started to freeze. It's about 10 degrees outside.

One major problem with setting up my experiment is that no two thermometers give the same temperature. I now have bought 4 different thermometers, and some differ by as much as 8 degrees, so I just take the average.

The barrels are plastic. Should I buy metal barrels and repeat the experiment to see if I get better results?

My goal is to keep it above 32 degrees when it's 15 outside. I'm in the Ozarks, so very few nights get below 15.

Comments (6)

  • 14 years ago

    My experience tells me you need a heater.

  • 14 years ago

    I think that metal barrels painted black would work better than plastic, but the most useful thing you can do is to reduce your heat loss. There's a very helpful older book that discusses passive solar greenhouse performance in depth, it's called: The Solar Greenhouse Book by James C. McCullagh. See if your library has it or if they can get it through inter-library loan. They explain in detail and with real world cases how it is possible to keep a greenhouse well above freezing even in zone 5 or 6. The key concepts were thus:

    1. Heavily insulate the north wall/roof and also the east and west walls.
    2. Use double glazing on the south wall/roof.
    3. Add 500 to 1000 gallons of water for thermal mass. They actually recommend using lots of small containers rather than large barrels.

    The greenhouses shown in this book are mainly home scale around 200-300 square feet.

  • 14 years ago

    Thanks for the replies.

    I have a small electric space heater on stand-by. Of course, I want to use it only as a last resort.

    Today I found some more little cracks to caulk. I've used up 5 tubes of caulking so far.

    Thanks for the book title. I'll look for it. Right now, when it gets below 25 degrees F outside it freezes inside the greenhouse. That's not good enough. I'd like to get to the point where inside it stays above 32 degrees when the outside temp gets down to 20. For those rare evenings when it gets lower than 20, I'll plug in the space heater.

  • 14 years ago

    farm boy:

    You can't do this without a heater or serious insulation that you apply at night. My 1700 sqft greenhouse has double inflated poly. By 9pm the temperature inside is nearly the same as outside.

    My home is a moderately insulated manufactured home. It actually has insulation floor, ceiling, and all walls. By morning without heat it is only about 20F warmer than outside. This is after heating it to 80F by day using a sunroom. If it drops below freezing that night it will be 48-50F inside by morning.

    You're wanting to hold 12F warmer inside and my home only holds 20F warmer. Serious insulation and/or heat.

  • 14 years ago

    The experiment continues. I just replaced all the plastic barrels with metal ones. The plastic barrels helped keep the inside temperature about 8 degrees above the outside temperature at night. Now I'll see how the metal barrels do.

    One unexpected "problem" recently, though, is that it's unseasonably warm, and there are no freezing temperatures in the 10-day forecast.

  • 14 years ago

    I think that you have just found out the real world.
    a Heat sink is not that much good. If you measure the water temperature at it warmest and then at its coldest..the temperature drop times the quantity of water will give you the total BTU that it provides, (Any simple physics book.)You will find the the BTUs are very small compared to even a small electric heater.
    Yes, metal is better that plastic. Yes small containers are better cause they can transfer the heat faster. Yes, heat sinks work but not very much.