Software
Houzz Logo Print
nastarana

rootstalks, how are they selected?

14 years ago

Please help me sort out rootstalks.

Dr Huey is used in USA because it roots easily? Any other reason it is better than other choices?

R. multiflora is used for some parts of the USA, mainly, I gather northern and eastern states? Would that be because it can tolerate acidity better than Dr. Huey?

R. laxa, with the gargantuan yellow taproot, is used in Europe. Why was R. cannina passed over in favor of laxa?

Fortuniana is used for Florida because it is not susceptible to menatode damage? Do I have that right?

Varieties used in the past included a R. odorata, now found wild in CA. I suppose it is not very hardy. Also Gloire des Rosomanes was once used?

Maybe developing regional roses, as some have mentioned, might include regionally appropriate rootstalks.

If you could banish Dr. Huey forever from the American rose industry, what rootstalk, if any, would you put in its place? I would think a species, grown from seed to avoid RMV transmission, would be best. Is R. laxa the best choice? What about R. cannina? Has R. arvensis ever been so used? I think it is hardy and tends to be draught resistant.

Comments (17)

  • 14 years ago

    The other reason Dr Huey and R Multiflora are used in northern states and Canada is because they're very winter hardy. They are strong growers and produce good sized grafted plants in shorter time so that they have a better chance of wintering over well.

    Fortuniana is winter tender and will die in zones lower than about 7. Although recently I've heard that if you can get it through it's first winter it will do OK after that but it's still chancy. Fort. is also used all over the south, CA and any warm climate because it grows whopping big roses and I wish it would winter here!

    I'm not familiar with R Laxa at all so I don't know why they prefer it in Europe.

    As for why the others were dropped, maybe some of our rose history buffs will know.

  • 14 years ago

    I bought a book from an estate sale that was published by the Dutch plant industry, the one that produces tens of thousands of rootstocks.

    They had the pH preferred by Dr. Huey, but other things they considered were the length of time that the very small plant would take a bud successfully. Thorns - not a good thing for budders. Winter hardiness gets listed, and so does the (at least according to them) better color developed on one type of canina versus other caninas.

    Oh, yes, Dr. Huey is a cultivar, so seedling Dr. Huey doesn't happen. There have been major efforts to grow Dr. Huey free of the assorted rose mosaic viruses that it picked up over the years. That is as opposed to seedling multiflora which is (duh) grown from seeds. And a seed is less likely to have a complex of viruses coming in with it.

    Labor costs and a lack of experienced budders is changing a lot of this.

  • 14 years ago

    Where EYE live, I'd prefer Fortuniana and/or Ragged Robin if I needed budded. But no one in the business asked me.

    :-)

    Oh, and it's rootSTOCK.

    Jeri

  • 14 years ago

    For commercial, large-scale production in the climate where it's been done for many decades, Huey was the best choice because of the adaptability to the most different types of soil; its sufficient hardiness for a great portion (not all, but MOST) of the country; its ease of rooting; extreme vigor and durability; it provides the longest period for budding of any other stock tried, the longest "window" of being ready to accept buds and it is the least likely to abort the bud due to water stress. Our rose industry had to generate a compromise product which would be successful over the largest portion of the country on the most durable, easiest to work stock. Huey fit the bill for many, many millions of plants for many decades. No, not perfect no even suitable for everywhere, but perfectly suited to the vast majority of what the market used to be. Kim

  • 14 years ago

    Below is a link to a Dr. Buck article published in the early 1950's about root stocks that you might find interesting...

    Here is a link that might be useful: Dr Buck article

  • 14 years ago

    I always wondered why such old roses were used as root stocks. They spend years developing roses for special colors, fragrance, cold hardiness, disease resistance etc... but for some reason they don't spend any time trying to create the ultimate root stock.

    I hate Dr. Huey with a passion. Only because when I see those pretty magenta roses in the spring my heart drops. Especially when I shovel prune a rose and a year later Dr. Huey is growing strong. Those roots are so hard to kill.

  • 14 years ago

    Mostly, Laxa has been used because canina has a low germination rate and terrible suckering. Even so, there is a definate difference between roses budded on Laxa and those on Canina. Bierkreek still use canina because they are adamant that the colours are brighter and they work well in an organic setting. It is a bit of a shock though, seeing these tiny little things after years of buying huge bareroots on Laxa. In truth, any vigorous rose will do as a rootstock - I used New Dawn for my grafting practice at college (so easy to root, I had loads of them around) and many of them are still going strong.

  • 14 years ago

    Canina is still the preferred rootstock in Scandinavia because it is considered hardier. But many people import roses themselves and get roses budded on Laxa and find that it's hardiness is about equal.

    BTW, it's Laxa with a capital as Campanula writes, or in full, R. corymbifera 'Laxa' not R. laxa which is another species.

  • 14 years ago

    no, they do, Decobug but these stocks are generally only seen in the 'trade'. Many growers will have their own particular strain of rootstock - I know for sure that Harkness developed one because that is one of the only strains available to the general public (and then only from particular nurseries unless you order stock material. Fruit stocks are even more fascinating - I remember a trip to East Malling where they had an amazing underground room with glass walls for viewing the many rootstocks they trialled. Amazing stuff. I am a terrible meddler with things like this - I love grafting and inosculation (a sort of approach grafting), love training and pruning....am quite certain that, given the space and time, I would be trying terrible interspecies frankenstein stuff - NOT to be trusted!

  • 14 years ago

    New Dawn would be as hated as Huey if it had been selected for that use, and for the same reasons. Many OGRs have been tried, but a large problem with many of them is they shut down, stop flowing sap earlier than what's been selected. Many are quite difficult to root, which is why they've been passed along as suckers instead of rooted pieces. Rugosas were used for some time for standards, with the results that many gardens were invaded with Rugosa suckers which required a lot of effort to eradicate.

    It boils down to what performs the way it's desired to for the producing source and the majority of their market. Palatine and Pickering produce on multiflora, which makes them unsuitable for much of the desert south west. Wasco uses predominantly Huey, which makes them unsuitable for much of the colder areas where multiflora is better suited. Campanula shared why Laxa and Canina are often used there. Odorata was used extensively here early on and it's found everywhere in milder climates where it's outlived the scions. The same goes for Ragged Robin (Gloire des Rosomanes), but at least, it's worth growing for itself where repeat is desired.

    You also have genetic incompatabilities between stocks and scions. Huey accepts many more different types and classes of scions than many others. A local nurseryman of years past tried Cl Cecile Brunner, which rooted and grew spectacularly, but rejected many scions he tried on it. Old ARS annuals have many reports of why some stocks were used for Pernetianas while others were used for Teas, HTs, etc., because it was felt colors were better on one than another; or some types grew better than on others, and much of that is rather logical. Pernetianas have strong Foetida influence and would perform best on stocks which begin pushing earlier than others because Foetida begins pushing earlier than many Teas and Chinas. Some types require more sap to be pushed than others, so a stock which is known for pushing a strong flow of sap would be more appropriate, producing better perfomance.

    Mostly, though, it depends upon what stock produces the greatest quantity of highest quality of sellable units for the individual producer and that is mostly climate related. Kim
    Kim

  • 14 years ago

    Thank you to everyone for the information (and spelling corrections!).

    Maybe we should switch to New Dawn in the USA, in preference to the good Dr.

    What, if any, effects do the varying rootstocks have on growth of the plant (is scion the correct word for the plant grafted onto the rootstock?) I have had some tell me that there is no effect at all, but that can't be true. Puny growing varieties, like Crimson Glory, which allegedly stay around 1' tall on their own roots, do grow much larger when grafted onto a vigorous rootstock.

  • 14 years ago

    OK, not that knowledgeable about rose root stock but as far as fruit goes, the rootstock is of crucial importance in deciding ultimate size and also the precocity (how quickly the seedling fruit trees bear fruit) Whilst the size of the overall tree is dependant on the stock, the actual size of the fruit produced will always be the same depending on the scion used - that is, a tiny little rootstock such as M27 will still produce full size apples. I would have to say that the rose rootstock also has a determining effect on the overall size and vigour of the plant but is possibly not as deterministic as it is for fruit trees.

  • 14 years ago

    How do you know what rootstock your rose is on. There is no ID. Do you just know what the supplier uses? I'd like to try some on Fortunia. Where can I get that?? (roses budded onto F.)

  • 14 years ago

    You know pretty much by where the rose came from. Where did you get yours? If they were produced in Wasco, CA, (Week's, Star, J&P) 99% probability they're on Huey. Texas could be either Huey or multiflora; Palatine and Pickering are multiflora. Did I hit your source yet? Kim

  • 14 years ago

    Pickering uses multiflora except for when they use Laxa, on some OGRs, as Trospero has informed us on another thread.

  • 14 years ago

    I grow my own rootstock so I can t-bud many hard to get roses.

    Here in Denmark - I planted the seeds from Multiflora hips kept in ziplock bags in the fridge in February in trays and the germination rate is higher than Rosa Canina. Come May - I plant the small Multiflora seedlings in rows in my former vegetable garden and thin out the best plants to about 8 inches apart - After one year they are ready to be used as root stocks for grafting in late july/august - and topgrowth are cut about the roses showing growth of the bud-union next year in early April.

    For many years Rosa Canina was the preferred rootstock here in Scandinavia - like Marianne wrote - supposed to be hardier ...but the biggest commercial rosegrowers here use Multiflora now- while others still use Rosa Canina.

    Plants grafted on Rosa Canina are in my experience smaller than those grafted on multiflora and takes a few more seasons to become become established/shoot enough basals to form a nice rosebush.

    Most of the roses I have gotten from different other nurseries in Europe use R.Laxa - and for me they have turned out to perfom really bad - per tradition we plant roses in October/November when the roses go dormant and harvested from the rosefields - 8 out of 10 roses I have planted using R. Laxa as rootstock die - those that does show a little growth the first season - have almost all gone own-root -since I plant the bud-union about 3 inches below soil level - when dug up 1- years later since I give up on them - the rootstock is dead -but the spindly canes surviving have all gone own root and after a few years - begins to form a small roseplant that might even bloom :-) - so needless to say I do not buy roses on R.Laxa rootstock anymore - even though they are sold in warmer climate areas of Europe.

    I strongly encourage you to try to bud your own roses on the rootstock that do best in your area of the world - it is easier than trying to root cuttings ...if you do not own a greenhouse. Do remember only to propagate rose cultivars - that are not under patent/licensed/still require royalties to the hybrizer/company.

  • 14 years ago

    Cool Roses and K & M Roses both use fortuniana root stock.

0