Software
Houzz Logo Print
kathile

Strange--no aphids this year!?!

18 years ago

Every year that I have grown roses, I have had lots of aphids in the spring. It had gotten to the point that I almost rejoiced to see them, like any other sign of spring.

This year I have not seen any! Perhaps I should be grateful! (I WISH the same thing would happen with the Japanese beetles!) But it makes me worried that I've upset the ecology in the yard or something. What will the ladybugs and birds eat?

Anyone else not have aphids (who usually has them?)

Comments (15)

  • 18 years ago

    you must have sent them all over here to party...tons of them here. They may be on the way though because they have only been here 2-3 weeks. Enjoy it while it lasts.

    Sunni

  • 18 years ago

    The @#$%*& things are all in California!

    But the Bush Tits, Lady Bugs, and hummingbirds are eating 'em as fast as they can. The lizards look pretty smug, too.

    Jeri

  • 18 years ago

    No insect pest and you worry that you've upset the ecology in your garden? We've traveled a long road since man first turned the earth to make his living. (I'm trying to be funny, I guess, but I'm not trying to ridicule your concern, it has been a very long road).

  • 18 years ago

    Yep, they're all over my roses here in central Oklahoma. Ugg! Aphids and HUGE grasshoppers. . .

    Since you guys are on aphids - what can I use on my roses to get rid of those darned things? I usually just spray them with water - but worry about causing black-spot. . . Seven dust has worked in the past, but isn't there anything organic out there?

  • 18 years ago

    In CA, aphids disappear as soon as the birds arrive to eat them, and the weather warms up.
    Bushtits have been clearing away our aphids for the past couple of days.

    Jeri

  • 18 years ago

    In zone 6b it just isn't warm enough yet... give them time... they are coming :)

  • 18 years ago

    The reason they are not in Western KY is because they are all here in the southwest. I have a ton of them. I go out and spray them off then within a day or two they are right back. I have seen quite a few ladybugs but, not as many as I would like to see.
    Carrie

  • 18 years ago

    They're here in Southwest Washington as well. Big fat green ones clinging to the tender baby leaves. I hosed them off this morning, but i'm sure there will be more ... :)

  • 18 years ago

    Don't use sevin for aphids. That's like using a nuclear bomb for a bank robber.

    As long as you spray the water on the rose during the day and it has time to dry, it will not cause black spot. You can also make up a spray bottle of dishwashing liquid and water and spray that on them. Or just wipe them off with your fingers. It's gross but effective.

  • 18 years ago

    I was wondering the same thing, then one morning there were birds everywhere in my roses. The next day there were also ladybugs. I've done a little spraying with water and treating with dish soap. Usually the large populations of aphids are pretty short-lived and I don't remember seeing any damage but every spring when I see them all over certain roses.. EEEEK! The birds haven't found the tent caterpillars on the black cherry tree yet either, so I'm busy with the hose.

  • 18 years ago

    I would gladly send you some of mine! They're coming out like crazy now. One good thing.... I did see a couple of ladybugs too. And soon the soldier beetles will be out in the evenings to chow on them.

  • 18 years ago

    I just read recently that if you underplant your roses with Nasturtiums they repel aphids.

  • 18 years ago

    If you really want them, you can have mine. They are feasting big time, little soft bodied suckers!

    Carla

  • 18 years ago

    My home office looks out over a huge Scentimental and it's wonderful to sit there and watch the sparrow blooms the sprout up on it. That particular bed has a few clumps of society garlic so the aphid population isn't as great as in some of the other beds anyway. I've got a hummingbird patrol going on in another bed and the green lacewings and some predator wasps have moved in now, too. Wish they'd go to the south side of the house and take care of the climbers. Those bushes are inundated with aphids and are a pain to drag a hose over to but looks like that's my job tomorrow morning.

    The thrips have moved in full force and are chewing on the reds this year. Now that just angers me to no end since I planted several Cachet for them to chew on so they'd leave my reds and yellows alone.

  • 18 years ago

    I have thousands of rose buds and millions of aphids on my roses too. I counted 3 ladybugs when I was washing them off yesterday. Mine won't go away for about another month when the little baby toads appear. Birds don't come eat them because I've got too many cats hanging in the yard. I alternate between the insecticidal soap and then in an hour or so washing it off and other days simply washing off all the bushes. The roses are getting too wet though, but the aphids are so thick on all the buds and leaves and even the canes. I got some bananas today to put out the peels from. After they dry up you bury them for compost.

    I caught my neighbor using Sevin on here couple of roses, Iceberg in particular is covered with them. Apparently she came over and looked in my beds and since they weren't overly aphid infested she thought I must have used that. I told her I had been out earlier in the day and washed them off. I showed her an organic insecticidal soap to use and offered her my hose on that side of the house which will reach here roses. I told her she was killing all the good bugs with what she was using. She had mixed it up and poured it over the roses and the leaves. I did ask her if it worked at all, she professed not, said it smothered both. I noticed yesterday that she washed her roses off.

    I had thrips really bad last year but not aphids, so I'm hoping, but not really believing, I'll have the reverse this year from this start.