Software
Houzz Logo Print
szut

Selecting/Planning new greenhouse

12 years ago

Hello -
I'm planning a new twinwall polycarbonate greenhouse after gardening for a few seasons under a plastic film covered hoop house. I'm looking for advice on the greenhouse recommended (I'm leaning toward the Riga IV), the type of foundation (eg: metal plate, a 2ft cement wall, or a 4-5ft deep foundation), advice on growing in the ground (vs in pots) and preparing the soil, etc. Any and all advice is greatly appreciated!!!

I'm looking to garden in this structure primarily for 3 seasons - spring, fall and winter. I do not think I'll use it in the summer since I don't want to fight the heat.

Last winter I followed Eliot Coleman's advice from the Winter Harvest Handbook and with limited heat (xmas lights and a small heater if the temps went below 25) but some thermal mass (~1,000gals) and one wall insulated with foam board, I grew all of our greens in our hoophouse with floating row covers. I'm now hooked on a winter garden. I'm expecting my greenhouse to work for growing in the winter and hence some of my "requirements" are based on this.

Some questions:
(1) What greenhouse do you recommend and why? The ones I frequently hear of recommended are the Rigas, The cross country and the Juliana. Are there others that are good? Why did you pick one of these and how is it holding up? I'm looking for low maintenance and sturdy. I never want to chase after blown away panels and don't want to be replacing parts too frequently. What would you consider next time if you had to purchase a greenhouse again?

(2) What foundation do you use? Most greenhouse kits offer a metal foundation base that theoretically you can sit on the ground. I don't love this since it seems hard to insulate the ground from the earth inside the greenhouse. One contractor nearby mentioned doing a 2ft cement "honch" foundation - I could then insulate the outside and fill the inside with whatever I want... Or the kits say to go below the frost line (at least 4 ft here) and do a true foundation. The cost differences are significant between these three... Any advice?

(3) I believe to grow optimally in the winter I need to grow in-ground. Am I correct? How would you recommend setting up the "soil" and separate paths? What would you use for soil and how deep? Or do you think having soil is just going to cause problems down the road?

(4) Most greenhouses that I'm looking at come ~ 9ft wide. I'm thinking of 3ft beds on each side of a 3ft path. Does that sound/feel right? Or any additional advice?

(5) Did you install a knee wall? If so why and how is it working for you? If not why and would you go back and do one? I'm concerned with winter gardening that the knee wall will add "significant" shade... But then the snow will as well! :-)

Thanks in advance!!!

Comments (11)

  • 12 years ago

    I forgot to add that I almost exclusively grow vegetables and do not plan to grow heat-needing vegetables in the winter. The spring would be to jump-start my plants, the fall would be to extend my harvest. The winter would be for cold-tolerant greens. I start my own trays of tomatoes, peppers, etc. I also have earthboxes that I can move in/out for growing certain plants (for season extension).

  • 12 years ago

    I wish someone had answered this, I have very similar questions. Keep us updated on what you decide!

  • 12 years ago

    I think raised beds that sit on the ground would work. In the winter, you can set a frost blanket on them overnight, and also build low tunnel hoop covers for added freeze protection.

  • 12 years ago

    I have a Riga and love it so much.
    In an old thread I shared details of our setup, which answers a lot of your questions.

    Here is a link that might be useful: My Riga

  • 12 years ago

    I never like putting a metal foundation base directly on the ground due to concerns about corrosion and wanting my greenhouse to be totally level, and also so I wouldn't have to worry about "liftoff" in strong windstorms.

    When I put in my last greenhouse, I dug out a perimeter, poured a simple, rectangular footing, and laid cinder blocks to about 8 inches higher then ground level. Then I capped it with pavers and bolted my metal frame to that. Everything is dead flat and plumb, and I gained a little height.

    It looks like you are in a colder Zone than mine, so I don't know how deep you need to go to get below the frost line, but it would be a benefit to excavate the whole footprint of the greenhouse (perimeter plus floor area), and put in a foundation wall all around up to ground level or a few inches higher, and thus have a floor that was a couple of feet lower than the surrounding ground level; if you also insulated the outside of the foundation walls with foamboard, you would gain a thermal advantage. You would also have the advantage of a taller working space inside since the base of the greenhouse would rest atop the perimeter foundation and the floor would be lower.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Frost line map

  • 12 years ago

    I can't comment on the various kits, as I have always built my GHs from custom designs.

    But, in terms of the knee wall, a few considerations: Knee walls are great if you are putting in raised beds around the perimeter and will be using the knee wall as the outside support for those beds. If so, you'll need to insulate the outside of the knee wall otherwise it will loose a bunch of heat in the cold seasons.

    If you don't plan raised beds, the knee wall will shade the outside of your ground level planting area, reducing the growable space inside. Generally something to avoid in GHs.

    I have a GH both with and without a knee wall perimeter. Each works well, but I do have a raised bed up against the knee wall.

    For cold climates, the knee wall is generally an expensive form of construction, with no solar gain, that requires insulation. Quite a bit more costly per sq ft than most GH glazing/framing systems. It can be useful if you on sloping ground or for some other design needs. But in general, I don't know that I would use it unless I had to...

  • 11 years ago

    karin_MT - I have to admit that your post on the Riga has made me lean very heavily in that direction! Your post is very detailed - thanks! I do have a question - is your insulation adjacent to the base or only under it? If adjacent is the insulation on the inside or outside? Does RIGA recommend to dig in the base or is it meant to be on top of the ground? Any issues with corrosion?

    steve333 - how do you build your greenhouses? Are they wood frames? I'd love to build/design my own but I don't want the maintenance of wood and potentially not the maintenance of steel. And I don't know enough about building a greenhouse with aluminum. We are very handy (have built sheds, roofed, etc). Any advice?

    Cole_Robbie - do you think a raised bed is better than an in-grown bed? What would you use for soil?

    kudzu9 - I wish I didn't have to go deep for a foundation to miss the frost line! Sigh. We are ~ 4ft and one quote for a foundation for a 10x14 greenhouse was nearly $10k! Vs a honch of This winter I determined the final spot for the greenhouse since we had 2-3 in mind. Yay! Now for the rest of the planning! Thank you for the help!

  • 11 years ago

    szut, I have built both a wood framed and steel framed GH. First was the wood one. It has survived well but is in need of a repaint and recaulk which was part of the reason I went with steel for the second GH. The other reason was strength. Wood 2x framing is fine for smaller structures. But if you are trying to span longer widths, the size of the wood becomes prohibitive. Especially if you have high snow or wind loads to contend with (I have both).

    I think you will find Al for structural members is not doable for other than rather small sizes (hobby GHs, etc). Perhaps if you use built up Al girders, but that would be very pricey.

    Most commercial GHs use steel structures. I ended up going with steel tube arches from a commercial GH, which I made into a lean-to GH on the side of a barn. Given the structural loads it had to meet (50# snow and 135mph wind) it was relatively cheap (no doubt would have been cheaper in less extreme environments).

    IMO if you can build with wood 2x material, making the transition to steel tubing should not be that hard. You'll need a few new tools (metal saw and drill), but in many ways it was just like working on a big erector set.

    As a cost saving, you could look into buying a used commercial GH, or at least the frame. That could give you the structural material at a very inexpensive cost. Something that is harder to do with wood 2x material.

    My steel GH is too new for me to say how it will fair on the maintenance side. But I expect it to handle the moisture better than wood, although it will need some touch up painting no doubt in time.

  • 11 years ago

    Steve333 - thanks! What do you use for glazing on your steel greenhouse? Do you have automatic ventilation?

  • 11 years ago

    I used twin walled Polycarbonate GH sheets for glazing (with purlins and spacers).

    I do have a ventilation fan, which gets run almost daily in the summer. I also have a SHCS type of underground heat storage which provides some additional cooling (but not enough on hot sunny days).

  • 11 years ago

    Hi Szut,

    I'm happy to help! It's always nice to be a satisfied customer and share good experiences.

    The insulation is just inside the base frame. So, the outer edge of the stryofoam is up against the inside edge of the foundation frame.

    The frame is intended to be dug into the ground. Although I have seen one case where someone built a poured concrete knee wall, and then put the foundation frame on top of that. But that's not how it is designed (even though I'm sure it would work anyway).

    No issues with corrosion. This thing is bomber!

    Hope that helps - good luck researching and deciding!

    Karin