Software
Houzz Logo Print
scottfsmith

My oddball greenhouse

21 years ago

I have a complete oddball of a greenhouse that was built as part of my house. It has a lean-to roof of 45 degrees coming off the house and going all the way to the ground almost. Now here is the strange part: the room itself comes off the basement! So the height of the ceiling in the room is from 8' to about 20' tall. During the winter no light shines on the floor of the greenhouse, so I have to put everything at least 3' off the floor and even higher like 5' for seedlings if they are to get sun.

I don't think the architect looked into greenhouse design too much, it has no air shutter intake and only a wimpy 100 or thereabouts CFM fan in it. I was generally only using the house in early spring for seedlings, but I recently decided to put some year-round plants in it and discovered the hard way that it is waaay too hot: it was 106F this week when it was in the 70's outside. I have ordered an Aluminet screen and a 1500CFM fan and shutter to hopefully solve that problem.

One other oddball thing I don't understand is the walls of the basement inside the greenhouse are insulated over the cinder block. Why do you want to insulate the basement walls?? The temp of the ground there is going to be 55F-ish and so will warm things in the winter and cool things in the summer. I had earlier thought the guy knew what he was doing but my revised opinion is he didn't, and this foam insulation on the basement walls is just stupid. Right? Another thing he did wrong was on the roof sides, which are normal walls and not glass, he put the standard roll fiberglass between the 2x4's, but didn't cover it from the inside. Thus there is no air barrier and so you are going to lose most of the good of the insulation. Right?

Hey here is a picture which may help illustrate what I have:

{{gwi:306204}}

The wall on the right is the cinder block house basement wall, and the three walls of the greenhouse are also cinder block walls.

One last question: the greenhouse faces south, but do you think I should put some glass on the ends to let in more sun, or since it gets the midday sun is that enough? The roof is rotting so I am going to have to redo it one of these days anyway.

Scott

Comments (4)

  • 21 years ago

    That is a little odd. Here are some thoughts:

    1) The insulation on the side walls will work OK, but the problem will be moisture. Anticipating higher humidity in the GH area, you need a better moisture barrier. That insulation in the photo looks like roll fiberglass insulation with a vapor barrier (the silver colored backing) already attached. As I recall, the backing is generally made wide enough to staple it to the studs on either side, thus creating a moisture barrier without having to add a sheet of poly over it. You might do that.

    2) I don't know about the rigid styrofoam over the cinder blocks. I don't know how significant the summer cooling effect would be, and I wonder just how well the cinder blocks can act as a heat reservior when the sun never hits them. Again, I'd be worried about moisture, in this case moisture and mold behind the styrofoam and rotting the wood spacers between the sytrofoam pieces.

    3) I would switch out the side walls for glass because it looks to me as if you can use the added light.

    4) Ventilation could be a little tricky. Presumably the fan and shutters will move outside air across the GH, but this means you will only be exchanging the air in the top half. HAF fans will help exchange air top to bottom.

    5) What about elevating the floor? Frame up a platform with steps up from the basement, maybe 3 feet high? Storage underneath? Just a thought.

    It would be really interesting to see the temp differential at different times between the upper areas and the lower areas of the space.

  • 21 years ago

    Thanks, stressbaby. I realized I made a minor mistake above, I don't really need a year-round greenhouse since I want to move things outside in the summer. All I need is an October through March greenhouse so I can grow some tropical plants. I had thought I wouldn't need to worry about the greenhouse getting too hot in October, but then came the 106F. So, I don't need the greatest cooling system in the world or maybe even the greatest sun exposure (?), just enough to keep the plants reasonably happy until the next summer.

    Keeping it above freezing on those 0F days is critial, and I don't have a heater in it now. The basement walls will give off heat from the soil, not heat stored up from the sun that day. 55F is downright toasty compared to 0F so I thought it would make a difference even if the sun is not striking them. But maybe not enough.

    I did think a bit about elevating the floor. One nice thing about having the floor low is there is no need to kneel down since the plants are all on tables. But for the seedlings it is a bit of a pain to work with them when they are 5' high. Maybe just a 2' raised floor would be worth it - that would put the seedlings at a very handy 3' off the floor if I put a table on the riser. One other aspect of this low floor is I can only use the right half of the greenhouse. The left part is all in the shade. The floor would have to come up a whole lot to make the left part usable: 5' or more.

    The temperature differential is huge, it felt cool by the floor when it was 106F halfway up in the shade. It was probably 115F at the top at that point.

    Scott

  • 21 years ago

    From looking at the pictures it seems to me that maybe this was not built to be a greenhouse. It may have been an attempt at solar heating for the house. I see there is a window coming out of the basement. Is there also a window up on the 1st/2nd floor? If that is the case maybe to utilize the solar heat the windows were opened to acheive a passive airflow...(cool air from basement enters greenhouse space is heated and then flows up and through the upstairs window heating the house.

    Anyway...

    What you could do is raise the floor and create a thermal store in the space below the floor. You will need to fill the space with a thermal mass (drums of water, stone, etc.) and insulate the space. With a few sensors, vents, fans you could take hot air from the top of the space and move it into the below floor storage. Then when the space cools down you could utilize the "stored" heat.

    Do a few internet searches on solar thermal storage and you should be able to find some ideas...

    Good luck and have fun!!

  • 21 years ago

    Ponder, there is no upstairs window and the wall with the house is insulated so the greenhouse is "outside" as far as the house is concerned. So its just a greenhouse. The architect is from India and I think he missed all the heat and sun of India and so he added this room. He told me he would sit and work in it.

    The thermal storage idea sounds interesting, and since I have "free" space there it may not require a whole lot of work. Having a fan pumping air down would independently improve the problem with the temperature differential.

    I am going to see how well the greenhouse does in the next six months and then decide what to do with it.

    Scott