Software
Houzz Logo Print
vuwugarden

Grass killer in rose beds

16 years ago

I was reading a past post on another forum, and they mentioned that RoundUp can cause damage to nearby rose bushes, companion plants, etc.

I thought it was safer to go another route by selecting a grass killer specific agent instead of an all-in-one killer.

Does anyone have experience with Spectracide Weed and Grass Killer?

Or do you recommend an alternative solution other than hand pulling. Ive tried hand pulling in the beds, and the Bermuda grass keeps on coming back.

IÂve tried the lasagna method and that doesnÂt work with Bermuda either.

RoundUp has worked really well in areas where IÂm starting a brand new bed, but this question is in regards to existing beds with invasion of the Bermuda grass also known as the weed from H@#%.

Thanks for any help you can provide.

Audrey

Comments (21)

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Audry -- Grass-Be-Gone does not seem to impact roses et al.

    DO NOT spray Roundup ANYWHERE near plants you care about. Even a little spray drift will do grave harm. I hate the stuff.

    I know about Bermuda Grass tho. I maintain that, after a nuclear holocaust, the remaining Earthly life will be cockroaches and Bermuda Grass. :-(
    Grass-Be-Gone can kill Bermuda, but you have to spray, then pull the "dead" stuff. Then spray again. Then pull again . . . and our Bermuda Grass is probably going to outlast us.

    Jeri

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Excuse me, but what is the LASAGNA method?

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I still use my trusty pieces of roofing shingle.... when I have a weed I just shove the shingle over onto it and in a week or two the weed is baked to death.. suffocated ! gone ! works good on grass also.... sally

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I consider weeding a meditation and an opportunity to expand one's fantasy life. I discovered this when I was a kid and weeding was a punishment. It is also an opportunity to observe not only your roses but bugs, birds, and the sounds of the neighborhood. It also allows you to avoid mopping the floor.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks for the prompt replies!

    catsrose, you are funny. I try to find any excuse to not mop the kitchen too!

    I don't mind weeding, and do weed other weeds that enter the beds without issues, but these darn Bermuda are aggressive. I can pull a root and then have it break on me at 14 inches or so plus.

    It's hard to weedeat around the bushes now, and I also worry that the Bermuda are robbing the roses of the nutrients, etc. Rose fertilizers are expensive so I don't want the menace grass to rob the roses of their food. Bermuda can stay in the lawn, but it has to vacate the beds

    Rosymom, lasagna bed gardening methods are for the lazy gardener, like me. Its a great way to build raised beds without double digging into the ground. I have heavy, impacted clay soil so I do not have the strength or the time to properly amend my soil. I may not be doing the lasagna method correctly, but this is what I do.

    I outline the area of grass where the intended bed will be located, either with gardener upside-down paint, water hose, strings on stakes, whatever you have on stock. I will go through several weeks of consistent killing of the vegetation in the area with RoundUp. I use RU because its the only effective method of eradicating Bermuda in my area.

    After the vegetation is dead make sure its dead, if not youll be in the same position as Im in, asking the above question lay card boards or several layers of newspaper over the dead vegetation. Stock pile more organic materials on the card boards like mulch, leaves, compost, etc. I suggest building a high pile as during decomposition, the pile will "shrink." Then my last material is topsoil.

    You continue piling more materials on the pile as time goes by, even more newspapers, as the worms will be eating these materials and making garden rich loamy soil. I would say give it a season to two seasons, more if you are patient, not me hence the problem Im in.

    Sorry for the long outline. I currently have several lasagna beds "cooking" in my work-in-progress garden. Its so much easier! The tiller that I purchased when I first started gardening is stored away in the garage, hasnt been touched in years.

    Hope this helps you, rosymom.

    Take care,

    Audrey

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Audrey's correct.
    Weeding, per se, will NEVER rid you of Bermuda Grass.

    As I understand it, the roots go down as much as 6 ft., so it continually regenerates from the remaining deep roots.
    As Dr. Manners says -- "Floozy-flop" WILL get it, but it is a long, slow process.
    And, btw, solarization doesn't kill the #$%$#@! stuff, really.
    It may die back from that area, but it can, and WILL return.

    I curse whoever planted it here.

    Jeri

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I have Bermuda grass too. I've found that you can get rid of it; that is, the roots may be deep in the ground, but not much comes up and it isn't a major problem. Heavy mulch is what you need, plus weeding. After a couple of years of mulching and weeding, most of the Bermuda grass is gone.
    I agree about the satisfactions of weeding.
    Melissa

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I guess our Bermuda grass is couch - a horrid running ryegrass with vicious white rhizomes. A variety of defensive methods (trenching, timber edging, raised beds, flamethrower) sort of work, for a bit at least but.... There is considerable satisfaction in weeding it out though. A little voice in my head, every weed murder, whispers 'one less, one less'. Bindweed, everpresent is swinish but worse, i think, are the deep-rooted ones that get overlooked for just a few weeks - dock, mallow. I have landed on my backside too many times trying to yank a monster taproot. Weeding is, an elemental battle between the forces of good and evil and we, the hardy perennials, must think only of the greater good of our flowers and bravely, with our loins girded with trowels, stride out to meet the enemy and then smite them...a lot.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I know how to get rid of bermuda grass. Try to grow it in my back yard in certain spots and it will die, guaranteed! But it loves rosebuds. I just consider pulling it out all the time as therapy. I haven't tried Grass be Gone yet... I may try that.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Please be aware that because of its mode of action against grasses flauzifop-p-butyl also acts as a insecticide.

    "Tu et al. (2001) report that fluazifop-p-butyl takes 24 weeks to completely metabolize within a plant and residues of the metabolized form, fluazifop acid, can remain in the plant up to 45 days after treatment.
    Larvae ingesting enzyme inhibitors may also experience adverse effects. The mode of action in both sethoxydim and fluazifop-p-butyl is the inhibition of acetyl CoA carboxylase, a necessary enzyme required for cell membrane formation and plant growth (Walker et al. 1988; Luo et al.
    2001). This same enzyme is essential for lipid and protein synthesis in insects (Goldring and Read 1993). Acetyl CoA carboxylase enzymes trigger juvenile hormone production in insects which play a vital role in the growth, development, and reproduction (Goldring and Read 1993; Eliyahu et al. 2003; Noriega et al. 2006). In feeding experiments, Popham and Chippendale (1996) observe that the inhibition of acetyl CoA in the southern corn borer (Diatraea grandiosella, Lepidoptera:Pyralidae) is deleterious to newly hatched larvae and impacts size and development of later instar larvae."

    The above quote is taken from:

    http://www.springerlink.com/content/15g04772w14584x3/fulltext.pdf

    -----------------------------

    Another example:

    http://www.freepatentsonline.com/EP1585392.html

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    A key paper concerning transfer of Round-Up from leaves to roots, into the soil, and then being picked up by the roots of another plant is the following published in 2006:

    http://www.jpdp-online.com/Artikel.dll/02-Roemheld_MTAyNzEw.PDF

    That paper was cited by 20 more recent scientific papers which include a 2007 one:

    http://www.springerlink.com/content/q0941n83w14wq825/

    This is part of the conclusion section of the 2007 paper:

    "Second, due to translocation glyphosate can end up
    to deeper layers or root zone quite rapidly compared
    to leaching. The environmental impact of translocation
    depends on the depth of the root zone that is
    determined by the dominant weed species and the
    hydraulic conditions of the field site. Rapid release
    via roots into the rhizosphere or root channels may
    result in fairly high concentrations of glyphosate. This
    can cause various negative effects in non-glyphosate
    resistant plants through root uptake (Rodrigues et al.
    1982; Guldner et al. 2005; Neumann et al. 2006)."

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    The issue of mulch retaining the glyphosate is new to me, Malcolm - and yet another reason to steer clear of it!

    Henry's info about the insecticidal nature of fluazifop is cautionary, too. I've had rather good luck with products containing it, such as Grass-B-Gon. You need to apply it exactly as directed, including reapplying at the correct interval (I think it's two weeks). One application barely knocks it back; two are good; a third does the trick. One application fairly well kills St. Augustine grass. I had some damage on heirloom dianthus from the spray.

    There's a grass killer that only targets warm-season grasses, such as St. Augustine and Bermuda, and doesn't do much damage to cool-season turf such as bluegrass and fescue. It's Ornamec. I've never tried it.

    Melissa, I'm impressed that mulch and a couple of years of pulling it have done the trick. No such luck here. We've mulched and pulled, tried newspaper (totally ineffective) and cardboard topped with mulch (slightly effective if the layers are overlapped enough), solarized (slightly effective), black plastic topped with mulch (quite effective but I hate the idea of using impervious materials), and weed barrier cloth (slightly effective but it's almost impossible to pull the grass without tearing the cloth up). I feel that I'm a veteran of the Bermuda grass wars, and that I've got enough battle scars to whip out the herbicide and use it when the grass is growing through the roses. I definitely see no ill effect from fluazifop on the roses.

    We had a paid "gardener" plant Bermuda grass intentionally in the cemetery many years ago, and we have areas with a terrible problem. I think we'd attack him with our weeding tools if he ever showed his face in front of the rose garden volunteers. It would not be pretty.
    Anita

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Anita, Ornamec is simply the commercial form of Grass-B-Gone, with the same active ingredient (fluazifop-p-butyl).

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I've wondered about Bermuda grass elimination tricks. I'm certainly not more muscular or more determined that others gardeners who have it. Bermuda grass seems, quite reasonably, to be a lot more stubborn in areas with deep, rich soil--one reason to be glad mine is heavy and rather poor. Also I don't water in the summer, which is Bermuda grass's growing period. Could it be these two factors plus the mulch that make it possible to (largely) eliminate it in the beds? I don't mean it's entirely gone, but it ceases to be a big problem.
    Melissa

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Literature examples of how complex fluazifop-p-butyl "science" actually is:

    The following quote is from the link below it:

    "While the findings support independent research, they contradict the purported herbicide characteristics by commercial sources grass selective, post-emergent, non-residual, rapid breakdown and active through foliar application only."

    http://www.sciencedirect.com/science?_ob=ArticleURL&_udi=B6V5X-4VC743F-6&_user=10&_coverDate=04%2F30%2F2009&_rdoc=1&_fmt=high&_orig=search&_sort=d&_docanchor=&view=c&_searchStrId=1343979062&_rerunOrigin=scholar.google&_acct=C000050221&_version=1&_urlVersion=0&_userid=10&md5=04ca0a1795ac86555e182dcddd52018a
    ------------------------------------------------
    Second example:

    Title: Mitotic changes in root meristems of Lens culinaris treated with fusilade (fluazifop-p-butyl).

    Authors: Aksoy, Ozlem; Ekici, Nuran; Dane, Feruzan.

    Authors affiliation: Department of Biology, Faculty of Science and Arts, Kocaeli University, Kocaeli, Turk.

    Published in: Asian Journal of Cell Biology, volume 3, pages 34-40, (2008).

    Abstract: "In this study the genotoxic effects of Fusilade (Fluozifop-p-butyl), a selective herbicide were investigated in the mitotic cell division in lentil (Lens culinaris Medik.) root tip cells. For this aim, different doses (0.25, 5, 1 and 1.5%) of Fusilade solns. were used. Root tips after having grown to a certain length were stained according to aceto orcein squash procedure and the no. of abnormal cells was counted in each phase of mitosis. The obtained results indicate that Fusilade had the ability to cause prodn. of a large no. of mitotic abnormalities. These abnormalities appeared in varying degrees depending on the dose. The types of abnormalities produced were laggards of the chromosomes, bridges, c-metaphase, stickiness, chromatin granulation and nucleus deformation. According to our findings we can say that Fusilade can produce neg. effects on mitotic divisions in lentil root tip cells."
    ----------------------------------------------
    Third example:
    "The phytotoxicities of nine pesticides (paraquat, Xuazifop-p-butyl, haloxyfop, Xusilazole, cuproxat, cyazofamid, imidacloprid, chlorpyrifos, and abamectin) at practical dosages on photosynthesis were investigated in cucumber (Cucumis sativus L. cv. Jinyan No. 4) by gas exchange and chlorophyll Xuorescent measurements.".

    The conclusion section starts with: "As shown by declines in Pn after treatment (Table 2), all pesticides used in this experiment inhibited photosynthesis except for Xusiazole."

    The conclusion section ends with: "In conclusion, the data from this study demonstrated that pesticide application impairs the photosynthesis of cucumber seedlings. ........."

    http://www.sciencedirect.com/science?_ob=ArticleURL&_udi=B6WP8-4JDMTPV-5&_user=10&_coverDate=09%2F30%2F2006&_rdoc=1&_fmt=high&_orig=search&_sort=d&_docanchor=&view=c&_searchStrId=1344055715&_rerunOrigin=scholar.google&_acct=C000050221&_version=1&_urlVersion=0&_userid=10&md5=9dad48a835781e02ab465b9579f8d331
    --------------------------------------------
    AND "microbial activity of a soil":

    http://www3.interscience.wiley.com/journal/118602142/abstract

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Apparently fluazifop-p-butyl is also active against (at least some) plant viruses.

    --------------------------------------
    Title: The effect of some herbicides on host-virus relations.

    Authors: Kazinczi, Gabriella; Onofri, Andrea; Horvath, Jozsef; Torma, Maria.

    Authors affiliation: Plant Protection Institute, Georgikon Faculty of University of Pannonia, Keszthely, Hung.

    Published in: Cereal Research Communications (2008), 36(Suppl.), pages 1155-1158.

    Abstract: "Two years pot expts. under glasshouse conditions were conducted to study the virus inhibitory side-effect of some herbicides (napropamide, pendimethalin, and fluazifop-P-butyl) on pepper-Obuda pepper virus (ObPV) and Solarium nigrum-ObPV host-virus relations. Three types of the herbicide effects were obsd.: (1) herbicide treatments prevented virus infection of susceptible host plants; (2) plants were infected by ObPV, but the virus concn. in them was significantly lower as compared to the pos. control; and (3) herbicide treatments did not influence significantly virus concn. It has been concluded that the effect of herbicides on host-virus relations greatly depends on hosts (species, varieties), type of herbicides, mode and dosage of application, and year. The results draw attention to the fact, that certain herbicides may play an important role not only in weed control but they also have inhibitory effect on economically important plant viruses, occurring in horticultural and agricultural ecosystems. Fluazifop-P-Bu gave the best results, regarding the protective effect from viral infection, therefore it could be worth to examine the effect of other fatty acid synthesis inhibitors on host-virus relations."
    --------------------------------------

    "Application of the herbicide Fusilade S (active ingredient: fluazifop-P-butyl) at 4-6 leaf stage as a post-emergence treatment practically prevented systemic virus infection and the virus-induced changes of photosynthesis are probably due to inhibiting the virus infection/replication process."

    See:

    http://www.biomedsearch.com/nih/Herbicide-affected-plant-metabolism-reduces/17139793.html

    AND:

    http://www.znaturforsch.com/ac/v61c/61c0692.pdf

    ----------------------------------------

    It appears that it may be worth trying to purify virused roses by growth from tissue culture that contained some fluazifop-p-butyl.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Melissa, I've found that the bermuda will invade mulched beds. I goes underground and then will pop up inches or feet away. We fight this by edging deeply and cleaning out and runners that make the leap. But it's constant maintenance. The main problem I have with it is in my main rose bed. have a lawn of it and a bed separated by a 2 foot wide sidewalk. The bermuda has invaded the rose bed. At first I thought it was there by seed, and one winter I thought I had eradicated all of the bermuda. But it's back. I think it is going under the side walk and popping up on the other side. SIGH, I just can't win!!!!!

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I'm confused. I mentioned Weed-Be-Gone on a different post and got jumped on by several posters who felt it was very environmentally unsound (thought I don't remember the exact reasons now).

    Or am I confusing Weed-Be-Gone with a different product?

    I've never used it myself. I got out my shovel and re-dug my main bed section by section, carefully pulling out the bermuda grass and making sure I got all the roots--which meant digging down 3 ft in a couple spots. By the way, that project took a couple years, but I've had no significant bermuda grass problem in that bed since and that was maybe 5 years ago.

    Kate

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    dublinbay, this was probably the post:

    http://forums2.gardenweb.com/forums/load/roses/msg0413300832458.html

    "Weed-b-gone????? Are you referring to the formulation with 2,4-D?"

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Active Ingredients
    Dublinbay -- Weed Be Gone is an Ortho product. Its active ingredients are:

    .10% Quinclorac, .22% MCPP-p, .12% 2,4-D, .05% Dicamba

    See Safety Sheets At:
    Quinclorac
    http://www.quali-pro.com/pdf/Quinclorac_75DF_MSDS.pdf
    MCPP-p
    http://www.cdms.net/LDat/mp1L1003.pdf

    I do not believe I would put any of these into my environment.

    Jeri