Software
Houzz Logo Print
andreark

Can you prune to different height?

13 years ago

When I planted my first small (6) rose garden last year, I wasn't aware that the bushes grew to different heights. I now have in the same small bed Pristine (wants to be 6 ft tall), Oregold (3 ft tall), Gemini (5 ft tall) First Prize (3 ft tall).
Brandy (4 ft tall) and Olympiad 4-5 ft tall). And NOT arranged in according to height.

In my new garden next month,(7) I will have a better idea of their heights and know how to arrange them.

My question is about the first bunch...Can I prune them next spring to alter their heights somewhat or will they be as they want to be?

ak

Comments (13)

  • 13 years ago

    To a certain extent, yes. For the yearly pruning, you can shorten the taller ones and leave the shortest ones alone; when deadheading, you can take a lot of stem off of the tall ones and just snap the flower off at the abscission layer on the short ones.

    Keep in mind the phrase "to an certain extent", however. Most all plants yearn to be their DNA-determined height, and so they are going to try to grow to that height, no matter what.

    Also for the first few years do not overdo it on the pruning. Young roses need time to settle in and pruning too hard can extend the time they need to get established.

  • 13 years ago

    Thank you hoovb.

    I will do that next spring.

    By the way, I asked about standards, I have decided (with input from this forum) not to do trees. Bushes it will be.

    ak

  • 13 years ago

    I forgot to mention that about a month ago I pruned Olympiad. Not just to shorten it but to cut back all of the spindly canes.

    The plant has many new shoots on it and a number of them are from lower on the plant. I hope these lower canes will be more substantial and able to hold up a rose.

    Thanks again,

    ak

  • 13 years ago

    AK, I think every rose grower has probably experienced this at one time or another. Even with diligent research into the growth habits of my roses they still surprised me. Some that were supposed to be tall and lanky never grew beyond 3 ft. high. Others that were supposed to be short and bushy ended up 6 ft tall! Some springs I end up having a Chinese fire drill and moving them all around to get the short ones out front and the tall ones in the back like I want them. Of course that's not to say that they then don't just turn right around again, lol! They grow how THEY want to grow. You can prune a little here and there but mostly they do what they want.

  • 13 years ago

    Just -- Whatever you do -- don't prune Brandy very hard.

    It does NOT like that!

    Jeri

  • 13 years ago

    Jerijen,

    I already did just that (accidently) to Brandy. There are now many, many new growths on my favorite baby. I am so confused.... Is there a possibility that ALL these HTs grow in different ways for different gardens (and People).

    ak

  • 13 years ago

    You may find that you won't get blooms unless you let a rose get to the height it wants. It needs a certain number of leaves on a cane to produce blooms.

  • 13 years ago

    Andrea -- Sure. A rose will commonly perform differently, under different conditions. That's why advice or recommendations are most useful, when they are most-local.

    I can give my neighbor VERY accurate recommendations.
    Someone in Louisiana, or in New England, might find my advice worse than useless.

    But to get back to 'Brandy.'

    'Brandy' was one of the first HT's we planted, back in 1988. I loved it. It did well the first year, but the following January, we pruned it just as we had been taught by eminent rosarians.

    It "sulked."

    New growth was slow to push up. No new basal canes emerged. We consulted with our eminent rosarians, and were told that a harder pruning would force it to push up new growth.

    We pruned it as directed. It died.

    A couple of years down the road, we met Tom Carruth (late of Weeks Roses). Tom mentioned the beauty of 'Brandy,' and I said: "I had 'Brandy,' but it died."

    Tom replied: "You didn't prune it hard, did you? 'Brandy HATES hard pruning."

    I was so d*mned embarrassed, I hastened to say that, no, OF COURSE I had not done that (tho of course, I HAD). Tom went on to explain that 'Brandy' was one of many modern roses whose genetic background made them intolerant of that sort of treatment.

    That's how I began to learn that you don't treat roses as a CLASS, so much as seeing what a given rose needs in your conditions.

    Jeri

  • 13 years ago

    Jeri,

    That was a great and informative post. Although, as you might know, I am on a learner's permit!

    Can you tell me how hard is hard?

    Thanks,

    andrea

  • 13 years ago

    And that is a great question.
    Sadly, the answer is going to vary wildly from one environment to another.

    In many parts of the country, pruning follows a cold winter, and a lot of it consists of cutting off the dead stuff.

    In Southern California, there's not enough cold to kill canes, so you're starting out with a year of growth, most of it healthy growth. Most conventional rosarians here would say to take perhaps a third of the growth off the top, to start. Then, go into the plant, removing all growth smaller in diameter than an average pencil. Remove entirely any dead canes. Remove ageing, less-productive canes. Strip away old foliage, and you're done.

    That's not a "hard" pruning. It's pruning for garden display.

    And it sounds fine, only -- HERE -- these roses may well be in full bloom when you "must" prune them. We found that, in our conditions, MANY roses responded poorly to that treatment. And canes that were shortened -- began to die back. So, we changed our strategy. We don't shorten canes. We let them do what they want to do, and when they no longer produce, we remove that whole cane.

    "Exhibition" pruning, more of a "hard" pruning, would take off the top half of the plant. There's not a rose in my garden that really responded well to that.

    And of course, nowadays, we are down to one modern HT, so we really prune very little, and then mostly to curtail something that's grown out to where I need to walk.

    Jeri

  • 13 years ago

    Jeri,

    Thanks again. I live in the SFO Delta area. (used to live in Chicago) so we don't really have winter. MAYBE the temp gets down to low 30s in Jan or Feb. So I will assume pruning the top 1/3 will be fine. And the rest of
    what you said about 'tiny' canes and stripping foliage
    would be fine for Brandy? I would have a coronary if
    I destroyed that rose.....She is my favorite!

    Hugs for your help,

    ak (mushy person)

  • 13 years ago

    Follow Jeri's advice. She knows what she's talking about. But I'd just like to chime in on your question about every rose growing different in different peoples gardens. The answer is yes! You can't go by class alone. You have to watch and see how each of your roses grows in your yard because it will be different than it is in Jeri's yard or my yard. They all have their own personalities and it takes some time of just observing them and how they respond to what ever you do to learn what each one's likes and dislikes are. I've discovered with more experience that a lot of my roses don't particularly like being pruned all that much. So I've started letting them just grow how they want and I'm getting healthier roses that bloom more often for me.

  • 13 years ago

    Now, Seil said two things there that were massively important.

    One is that your roses will grow differently in your garden than they will in my garden, or anyone else's garden (except, maybe, your next-door neighbor).

    The other thing she said was:
    " I've discovered with more experience that a lot of my roses don't particularly like being pruned all that much. So I've started letting them just grow how they want and I'm getting healthier roses that bloom more often for me."

    There is, really, no law in the cosmos that says roses MUST be pruned. Toss that idea out, and give them a chance to show you what they want to be. They will! Just cut off dead stuff.

    And since you live in the Delta area, I would very much like you to take a day-trip to the Sacramento City Cemetery's Historic Rose Garden (1000 Broadway, Sacramento). The day we walked into that rose garden -- in mid-November! -- changed our life. Go there, and spend a day at least, and see what roses are like when they're allowed to show what they want to be.

    Jeri