Software
Houzz Logo Print
thepollywogpond

English Ivy question

15 years ago

Looking for tips on how to approach this situation.

There's a beautiful 100+ yrs old oak in my neighbor's yard that branches out over about 6 properties. I've been watching english ivy climb up further and further each year. I don't talk to this neighbor much, only to ask him if there were any particular trees he wouldn't want me planting near the fence separating our properties. Didn't strike me as a big tree guy and I'm pretty sure he doesn't appreciate what he has in his yard all that much.

I want to get that ivy off his tree somehow. Any tips on how to approach him? I don't have any credentials aside from completing a Tree Tenders course last month, but I would certainly offer to do the removal work. Looking for suggestions...

Comments (18)

  • 15 years ago

    why is it bothering you????

    maybe he needs a meadow??? ... lol

    ken

  • 15 years ago

    It should bother you. English ivy starts off innocuously enough, but when it gets mature, it starts becoming a berry producer and it shall inoculate the area with volunteer ivy plants. It also competes with the tree for nutrients, shades it enough to impact photosynthesis and becomes tremendously heavy.

    Many people don't know this, and some who do argue it. I have an ancient pine with the same problem and this is the year to at least sever the ivy leaders going up the tree and keep it contained to a ground-dwelling vine.

  • 15 years ago

    Act competent, bring him a beer, tell him why, offer to do the work, and hold him harmless. If he says no, walk away and be done with it.

    Dan

  • 15 years ago

    next time you see him, strike up a conversation with him about the tree. Just ask him how old it is ect. then tell him about the damage that english ivy can cause to a tree. Then offer to remove it.

  • 15 years ago

    I'd like to have a handout ready as well. The best I can find is:

    http://www.nps.gov/plants/alien/fact/hehe1.htm

  • 15 years ago

    Be SURE to let him know right away that you're not asking to be paid for the removal...that you just love the tree.

    Just out of curiosity, how do you plan on removing the ivy? If he doesn't know much about trees, let's hope that you don't give him ideas about how to go about this on his own...with a sprayer full of herbicide.

  • 15 years ago

    In addition to the significant harm ivy can do to the tree, you might also want to point out that in urban settings (and more and more in suburban settings) English ivy provides habitat for rodents.......specifically rats. The mention of rats on one's property is a huge motivator for making change :-) Removing ivy is almost always a good thing, regardless of where one is located.

    I like Dan's idea - approach the guy in a friendly, non-threatening manner, explain your concerns, offer to do all the work and the clean up and I'll bet he'll jump on it!

    If the ivy is currently being used as a groundcover and has just gotten carried away with itself (as it does - and rapidly so), make suggestions for suitable replacement plants.

  • 15 years ago

    One of the things I learned in Seattle is that the Scourge to Cascadia AKA English ivy increases urban runoff due to the leaves' waxy cuticle (and complete coverage of the ground).

    IME the handout will only work if it supplements your elevator speech (no more than that, don't drone on endlessly) explaining the evils of the plant. It is not as convincing as an earnest neighbor with a beer in hand.

    Dan

  • 15 years ago

    "Yep".

    Here is a link that might be useful: Earnest Neighbor with Beer in Hand

  • 15 years ago

    If he takes me up on it, I figure I'll go with the snip at the bottom, snip a few feet up the tree method. I have a bunch of mulch from the stumps I ground up last year, so I was going to propose making a mulch ring instead of treating the ground cut with roundup. I'll give it a try tomorrow.

  • 15 years ago

    I doubt you'll be able to kill the ivy with mulch before you kill the tree with mulch. Even if you put down newspaper under the mulch, the ivy would most likely still escape back up into the tree.

    If you don't want to use herbicide (which would seem to be the easiest and most effective solution), you will probably have to come back multiple times and remove new growth. Eventually either you are the ivy will give up.

  • 15 years ago

    I am with Brandon7. Inspect and snip every couple of weeks.

  • 15 years ago

    One of the biggest problems with ivy or any vine climbing a tree is it blocks site of the tree's structure. If there is a split in the tree you are WAY WAY more likely not to notice it if some darned vine is covering it up. Then :poof: you are visiting the All State mayhem man.

    With the grape vine I mentioned in a previous thread I just cut and spray with a little round up. Really I have never killed it but now it is only in my neighbor's yards invading mine so with permission I take little field trips over the line and kill it perhaps once in the spring about now, once in the fall.

  • 15 years ago

    I would recommend taking the Ivy off the tree. If he waits to long, the Ivy will crawl further up the tree. What happens is the Ivy blocks the tree's ability to absorb photosynthesis through its leaves. A tree's leaf absorbs the necessary photosynthesis to convert it into energy for its own survival. Try to take as much Ivy off the tree as you can and cut the vine about 6 feet around the base. Let your neighbor that Ivy has the potential to kill a tree but it takes quite a while to do this. If you need any other questions, give drop me an email. DriskillLandscapeSolutions@gmail.com

    Here is a link that might be useful: GardenWeb

  • 15 years ago

    I would tell him the next time you see him that it will harm the tree. I had to do that to a neighbor who had a dog on a chain that wore a groove into a tree that I planted when the parcel was our land. He did nothing for months but eventually moved the dog. The groove may not heal, I hope it does.If you cut at ground level it should sever the food supply I would imagine and roundup that baby.

  • 15 years ago

    RoundUp and other herbicides have very little effect on English ivy. That waxy leaf cuticle Dan mentioned also makes penetration of a topical herbicide nearly impossible. And even painting full strength RU on the cut stems is not very effective - it takes multiple applications and new shoots will emerge almost immediately from the roots before the chemical has time to do any damage. The only sure way to remove ivy is to grub it out by the roots, manually.

    Most folks in the PNW are masters at removing ivy :-) We've been at it for a very long time.

  • 15 years ago

    Most folks in the PNW are masters at removing ivy :-) We've been at it for a very long time.

    Many of the kids there have a rite of passage in the summer, where they spend a miserable week or two ripping out ivy from some poor creek drainage. Surely they will tell their grandchildren...

    Dan

  • 15 years ago

    "RoundUp and other herbicides have very little effect on English ivy...even painting full strength RU on the cut stems is not very effective..."

    That's not my experience. The concentrate applied to the freshly cut stumps kills it every time for me. Trying to kill it with herbicide in winter or spring may be more challenging though.