Software
Houzz Logo Print
onthebrinck

How to encourage self-seeding Echinacea?

15 years ago

I've put in about 30 echinacea in beds around the property with the expectation that they'll self-seed and eventually fill the bed and compete with other perennials (liatris, achillea). Is there a way to assure this will happen --- should I avoid deadheading the plants, should I NOT apply Preen to the beds, should I dry the seed pods myself? Any other advice would be welcome.

Comments (9)

  • 15 years ago

    Just let the seed heads mature on the plants. You'll have all the seedlings you want. It's precisely why I dead head.

  • 15 years ago

    So, once the seed heads start to dry on the plants (which is about now), is that the end of tilling around the plants and no more Preen, right?

  • 15 years ago

    Preen prevents seed germination--not just weed seeds, all seeds from what I've read on this forum. I don't use it but other folks do and the question has been asked before whether it prevents just weed seeds from germinating. The Echinacea (and any other) seeds have to fall on untreated soil in order to germinate. Another option is to harvest the seeds, winter sow them and plant the seedlings in your flowerbed. You can expect a higher percentage of the seeds will germinate with winter sowing and the plants will be much stronger & healthier.

  • 15 years ago

    Echinacea is a rampant reseeder in my garden. So much so, that I have gotten much more ruthless about weeding out the seedlings. This didn't happen right away, but after a couple years the Echinacea plants seemed to mature and start seeding all over the place. I always never deadhead the Echinacea, because the Goldfinches love to eat the seed. In the fall, I sometimes collect dried seedheads, store them in garage, and tape them up to the bird feeder pole, and the Goldfinches will eat them over the winter. Even so, plenty of seed manages to drop to the ground and sprout.

    If you want to encourage seedlings, then don't deadhead, don't use Preen, and don't mulch heavily. It is also easy to collect the seed and start your own plants.

  • 15 years ago

    I planted three echinacea in a field about 10 years ago. Every year, in autumn, I go down to the field with a paper bag, gloves and a pair of scissors. I cut the seed heads into the paper bag, remove the seed, and then strew the seeds on undisturbed soil within an ever-increasing distance from the original planting.
    Three plants have turned into several hundred and now cover a large area. It is glorious in summer.
    The plants have never been watered, fertilized, and exist in a waste area, amid twitch grass and other obnoxious weeds.

  • 6 years ago

    Does Preen really help to prevent the real weeds?

  • 6 years ago

    for me Echinacea is not too keen on competition, if crowded too much by taller neighbours it tends to fail, gets eaten by slugs more.


    the Achillea could be too much for the Echinacea.

    seedlings in my garden do best where they have some space, and definetely need disturbed soil, like worked with a hoe or where some plant was shovel pruned, they never reseed for me in/near resilient clumps of Helianthus or daylilly

  • 6 years ago

    Even in my far north location, I often have many 'Prairie Splendor' seedling self sow and have a nice bit of variation among the blooms. Seeds heads are allowed to ripen and drop their seeds at will.