Software
Houzz Logo Print
matersingarden

Preen in veggie garden...

17 years ago

I would like to know if Preen in the Veggie garden would be ok. We have a huge veggie garden and we are short on time this year. We need a better idea to keep the weeds down.

Any thoughts??????????

Comments (20)

  • 17 years ago

    I wouldn't do it. I'm concerned for the safety of my family.

    Dan

  • 17 years ago

    What does the label say?

    If it doesn't say anything about veggies, call the manufacturer's toll free number that's on the package.

  • 17 years ago

    Needless to say there are many other options for controlling weeds in the garden - any one of the many types of mulch is only one of them - but if you want to use weed killer then as Jean said, read the label.

    If the label says it is safe to use around food crops (and if you believe what the label says) then Preen away. I wouldn't.

    {{gwi:8327}}

    Dave

  • 17 years ago

    Better than using something like this to suppress "weeds" would be mulching the soil to keep "weeds" under control. A layer of newspaper covered with a good mulch will not only help suppress "weed" growth but will also aid in soil moisture retention, keeping the soil cooler, and will add needed organic matter to the soil.

  • 17 years ago

    The original question reminds me of a very useful phrase:
    "There's never enough time and money to do it right the first time, but there's always enough time and money to do it right the second time."

    Dan

  • 17 years ago

    The label says its for veggies...

    The concern for using straw would be blowing away. Its in the country and windy there. It is a very big garden. Using newspaper would be too difficult. I would feel like the newspaper would blow away easy too.

    *****How thick would the mulch have to be with and with out newspaper??????

  • 17 years ago

    The label says its for veggies...

    The label doesn't say trifluralin - a POP - is a suspected endocrine disruptor and possible carcinogen, however.

    Come now.

    Do you have a family that will be eating out of this garden?

    Dan

  • 17 years ago

    a better idea mulch mulch and more mulch = no weeds and more nutrients in the garden if you use hay type mulches as well as less need for watering too easy hey?

    len

    Here is a link that might be useful: lens garden page

  • 17 years ago

    Nice catch, Dan.

  • 17 years ago

    matersingarden - the photo above is way out in the boonies in the country and just about as windy as it is possible to be.

    Straw and hay don't blow away once they are spread in layers and then wetted down and they go down fast over all our gardens both small and large. My plants and cages blow over in our winds off the lake but the mulch only fluffs itself a bit. ;)

    Neither do newspapers as they too are layered down in multiple wet layers - 4-8 wet sheets at a time, overlapped. Topped with 4-6" of mulch.

    Wet cardboard is another GREAT option and much easier to work with than newspaper. 1 layer of wet cardboard topped with 3" of straw or hay and viola' - no weeds.

    Clearly it is your choice which way to go in your garden, but I think I'm safe in saying that unless there is a manufacturer's rep lurking about, no one here would choose Preen over mulch. Just waayyy too many benefits to the mulch - no matter which kind you use. ;)

    Dave

  • 17 years ago

    I recently did a search on Preen, tho I was considering using it on ornamental beds, not veggie beds. I found that there's now a Preen product that claims to be organic, corn gluten based.

    I have tried paper topped with straw, then soaked, and it was blown away within days. I had to re-do it all and weigh it down with bricks.

    In 26 years I have had more roof repais here due to wind damage than I can count. Last September's storm took the lions share of my roof with it. I had to get a whole new roof, including replacing all of the wood. I had to replace a lot of siding then too- it was blown off my house and mangled by the wind far beyond repair.

    If a structure can't withstand windstorms here, no way is newspaper and straw going to stay put. That's the big bad wolf fairytale, isn't it?

    Karen

  • 17 years ago

    Using newspaper, 4 to 6 pages is ample, allows you to use less mulch to accomplish what mulchinhg oes, but if the mulch layer is less than an inch at least that material will not hold the paper down. When you put a mulch material on the newspaper you need to put enough of that material on to hold the paper in place.

  • 17 years ago

    No Karen if the roof can't even stay on your house then no mulch is going to stay on the garden. That's pretty much a given. ;)

    But then very few of us lose the roof off our house on an annual basis either so most years garden mulch holds up just fine.

    Dave

  • 17 years ago

    I must be missing something. I've never heard of Preen so googled it to find out what the heck it is. I find there are different formulations depending upon application parameters. Preen Vegetable Garden MSDS lists the material identification as corn gluten. The label says Active Ingredient: 100% corn gluten meal.

    The other formulations are for applications other than edible plants from what I can tell.

    My questions are, is there something hazardous in CGM or is the claim being made that the labels are incorrect?

    Lloyd

    P.S. Karen gets the "I know wind better than most" award!

  • 17 years ago

    Hi, I just found corn gluten in a place that suprised me. We have a grocery store green house that's ran by a master gardener, and he has large bags of it for about half the price of the local greenhouse. Check out the unexpected before buying!

    Karen

  • 17 years ago

    Dave:

    what did you use to build your tomato cages? 2x4 welded wire? Are the cages staked?

  • 17 years ago

    If a structure can't withstand windstorms here, no way is newspaper and straw going to stay put. That's the big bad wolf fairytale, isn't it?

    :)))))))))))))

  • 17 years ago

    Preen with corn gluten gets poor remarks for efficacy & its not a big seller.

    At any rate, when I lived in western WA state, I lived right against the Cascades within rock-throwing distance of Chinook Pass. You can imagine what kind of tremendous wind we got there. I could make the cardboard stick, but the straw would end up feeding the black angus herd next parcel over. There's a threshold where straw won't stay and I quit using it, as when warning criteria were hit (38 kt) the straw went bye-bye. YMMV.

    Dan

  • 17 years ago

    citysoil - yeah those few are. Most are CRW but I had the roll of welded laying around so used it too several years back. Re-rod stakes and wire snipped picking holes and they work fine. Don't get rusty like the CRW does but over-all I prefer the CRW.

    Dave

    matersingarden - suggestion for you since you have a large garden why not do one section with the Preen, one section with cheapo corn meal gluten from the feed store, another section with black plastic (it is big over on the vegetable gardening forum right now), and one last section with wet cardboard or paper with some straw or hay on top.

    Monitor all for a couple of months and let us know which one or which combo ends up working best for you and why. Photos and details would be great to have.

    Good luck.

    Dave

  • 17 years ago

    Dave:

    I'm guessing CRW is concrete reinforcing wire or re-mesh. I have several cages made from 5-foot heavy-guage re-mesh. I love em. Tall, robust and room to reach through to harvest, water, mulch or weed.

    I've got more tomatoes than cages or stakes. I've got some extra 4-foot welded and was thinking about making cages. Then I saw your pic. Now, I'll give it a try.

    Thanks for the inspiration and information

    Chris

Sponsored
Peabody Landscape Group
Average rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars8 Reviews
Columbus' Reliable Landscape Design & Contracting