Software
Houzz Logo Print
wishmeluck_gw

best mulch to use

19 years ago

I have always used shredded wood chips for mulch, but lately have heard that they take nutrients from the soil as they decompose. Mushroom compost has been suggested as have coco beans. The shredded wood chips are the most economical for me, but I do want good soil and I need a mulch that will keep moisture loss down as well as control weeds. Any thoughts or advice that can help?

Comments (16)

  • 19 years ago

    Woodchips on the soil do not steal nutrients- that's outdated info. Keep using them if you have them.

    Shredded leaves are another good option- they don't last as long, but do build soil faster.

    Mushroom compost- I would anticipate lots of weed seeds blowing in and germinating on the surface.

    Coco mulch- too expensive if cost is a factor at all. Some coco mulches are bad for dogs as well.

  • 19 years ago

    I just had 10 yards of root mulch dropped in my driveway last weekend. I spread it around all my planting beds. I have used the stuff for years with no apparent ill effects

  • 19 years ago

    I'm happy to hear that wood chips won't take the nutrients out of my soil. I've never heard of root mulch before. Is it something you can easily get? Does it last relatively well?

  • 19 years ago

    Shredded leaves is my first choice if you have or can get them. Keeps in the moisture, reduces weeds, and builds soil. 3 gains for 1 mulch! Otherwise, straw or hay on top of a layer of compost for veggie beds and just coarse compost for flower beds.

    pablo - Woodchips on the soil do not steal nutrients- that's outdated info

    Now you know there are still at least 57 schools of thought on that question and they all have their little scientific studies to back up their claims ranging from none to some to a fair amount to lots to never use wood chips near anything living! ;^)

    The potential problem of FRESH GREEN wood chip use harming plants if in contact aside, whether or not woodchips will steal nutrients from soil depends on the degree of degradation in the soil, the nutrient levels it contains, and the amount of mycorrhizal fungi present to feed the plants sufficiently.

    So good soil with lots of organic matter present - no problem with wood chips - mulch away. But with poor soil with low levels of organic matter, nutrients, and beneficial MF, the use of wood chips MAY pose a leaching hazard for the existing plants.

    How's that for a disclaimer? ;^)

  • 19 years ago

    Wood chips, used as a mulch, will not "rob" your soil of nitrogen. Where that comes from is people mixing those wood chips into the soil and that is a soil amendment not a mulch. I have plunked down green wood chips, freshly cut and chipped trees, around many shrubs and have seen those shrubs grow faster and have deeper green leaves than shrubs nearby that did not get green wood chips.
    If Frank Teuton were still active here he would write prodigiously about using green wood to build soil.

    Here is a link that might be useful: soil building using ramail wood

  • 19 years ago

    digdirt- notice that I said "on the soil". To my knowledge, woodchips have not been shown to rob N to any real degree when used as a mulch.

  • 19 years ago

    "on the soil"..."in the soil" ...po-TA-toes...po-taaa-toes ;)

    Walk on it, it's in the soil. Hard rain, it's in the soil. Time passes, it's in the soil. It all ends up IN the soil. But notice I did say "MAY" ;-)

    Dave

    PS: kimmsr we all know that your soil is good to begin with *grin*

  • 19 years ago

    "on the soil"..."in the soil" ...po-TA-toes...po-taaa-toes ;)

    Walk on it, it's in the soil. Hard rain, it's in the soil. Time passes, it's in the soil. It all ends up IN the soil. But notice I did say "MAY" ;-)

    Dave

    PS: kimmsr we all know that your soil is good to begin with *grin*

  • 19 years ago

    I use only one mulch -- compost. Costs nothing since I make it myself. OK, not true. I spend time and gas driving around to get stuff from dumpsters that are out of my way.

    But I know where it came from. Plus compost holds water up to about 135% of its weight. A thick layer of compost does inhibit some plants, and those that come up will be easy to pull out.

  • 19 years ago

    Even though I have two 4 x 4 compost bins that produce every year a couple of tons of compost I do not have enough to use as mulch. I use shredded leaves over the compost.

  • 19 years ago

    Don't want to seem difficult but I think there is a huge difference between "on the soil" and "in the soil." At least with a heavy clay soil like I have.

    So far things don't seem to penetrate my soil in a timely manner unless I manually cultivate it. Not last fall but fall of '05 I put down about 3-4 inches of hardwood mulch on top of cardboard in my relatively new veggie bed.

    As of this year I am still coming across undisturbed spots that one can see where the mulch was and where my native soil begins. The mulch is about a 2 to 3 inch layer of compressed, really dark, really crumbly stuff while my soil is still grey and thick.

    Until my soil greatly improves, more worms move in, the local bacteria and fungi become more happy, I do believe there will remain a difference between "on the soil" and "in the soil."....but of course all of this is in *my* experience;-)

  • 19 years ago

    Wishmeluck,

    Are you having problems using the wood mulch? If not then I wouldn't worry about it. What's that old saying? "If it aint broke don't fix it?"

    I would think that using wood mulch would only become a problem if you are trying to grow the plants in that rather than in the soil. Btw, I kinda did that last year in my veggie bed with bad results. I wouldn't recommend it at all.

    Stick with what works for you. That's my advice.

    Michelle

  • 19 years ago

    If wood on the soil "might" rob the nitrogen, why wouldn't the leaves?

  • 19 years ago

    If leaves were to be used as a soil amendment, ie. mixed into the soil, then they too would cause the soil bacteria to get busy digesting them and in the process those soil bacteria would take all the available Nitrogen to do that leaving you plants with very little so the would show signs of chlorosis.
    However, shredded leaves put down as a mulch, on top of the soil since a mulch is never, ever mixed into the soil, the leaves will aid in suppressing "weed" growth, aid in retainig soil moisture, aid in keeping the soil cooler, and over time as the soil bacteria get time to leaisurly work on them, add more organic matter to your soil, but they will not "rob" your soil of N when used as a mulch.

  • 19 years ago

    Thank you for all your help. I did go back to wood chips after buying and using about 6 bags of mushroom compost. It was liking sticking my hands in fresh horse manure. I will keep using the shredded wood chips, I guess, until something better comes along that is as good and maybe more affordable. I would still like to know what root mulch is though.

  • 19 years ago

    Wishmeluck - root mulch is ground up roots and stumps. Its fairly cheap in that 10 yards cost me $240 delivered. It looks pretty good and its great exercise loading it into my tractor cart and then spreading it around.

Sponsored
Miller Woodworks
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars23 Reviews
Franklin County's Trusted Custom Cabinetry Solutions