Software
Houzz Logo Print
tpaul_gw

Electric vs. Manual PTO

19 years ago

I noticed the new sears riding mowers with manual PTO use a cable attached to the arm under the steering wheel. The cable seems rather thin with alot of tension to engage the blades. Is this a better, more reliable set-up as compared to the electric clutch to engage the blades?

Comments (8)

  • 19 years ago

    I wouldn't say it is more/less reliable. Electric clutches have a very good history. I can almost ensure you it is a cheaper set-up though.

  • 19 years ago

    Until a few years ago, Sears (and AYP/Electrolux) tractors used a rod operated arrangement to engage the deck on their lower price tractors. So do most other manufacturers. In 2003 or so, they changed to a cable design.

    As previous post says they are not more reliable but are defintely cheaper to manufacture, which is why they are on low end machines. The cable vs. rod is probably no cheaper but is easier on manufacturing as one operator and cable can serve many different tractor models.

    I have two tractors (Bolens and Sears) with electric PTO and like very much. Also belts seem to last a little longer because they are not also being slipped when engaged as a clutch. On the other hand a new electric clutch is about $250 whereas parts for a manual are very cheap.

  • 19 years ago

    Folks seem to love them till they break. And depending on the manufacturer, they can be troublesome. I seen lots of big snazzy Cub Cadet's awaiting new clutches recently. Don't know if it was a manufacturing defect, or poor general quality. Either way, depending on the model and your technical savvy (whether you can do the work yourself or not), you can spend 50% of the cost of the mower to replace a zapped electric PTO in some cases.

    Its like new cars these days, all those heated cupholders are a hoot till the warranty runs out and one dies and you find out the hard way that its electric circuit is tied into the power windows which will now not operate...........

  • 19 years ago

    I don't know what kind of mowers you buy, but my electric pto replaced by me cost $110 as I recall. It wasn't real difficult, just had a learning curve. The first pto lasted 12 years. If the owners manual was better it may have lasted longer with adjustment.

  • 19 years ago

    I buy nothing with electric PTO. I buy used mowers for a few hundred bucks, run them several years till they die, or have a problem that is not cost effective to fix, then buy another used mower. I used to work at a small engine shop where we serviced them though, and either through poor design or abuse, electric PTO's seemed to be troublesome (mostly Cub Cadet, but some Craftsman, and even a few JD's rolled in with popped clutches. I suppose their quality may have improved in the three years since I worked on them.

  • 19 years ago

    IMO Manual with the Metal throw rod will last for ever or at least 18 years. Cable??? yek, they will fray and break, cheap maybe or if you make you own cable replacements, but problem prone, Elect. easy to use until the clutch goes, then you say, I wish I would of brought the manual model when you got to shell out 2 or 3 hundred for a new clutch and another 65 to 100 bucks for replacement if you can't do it yourself.

  • 19 years ago

    The front PTO on my old 1855MF is electric, I did repalce the bearing about 6-8 years ago, but the tractor is a1977or8 model with over 2500hrs on it. The rear PTO is manuel, twin belt w/tensioner, I've had to replace those belts twice but they really catch heck with the tiller or brush-hog on the tractor. Replacing the clutch really isn't too hard but I'd bet there's a transmission shop somewhere close to you that one of the guys would change it for you for a case of beer! Way cheaper and quicker than a dealer!

  • 19 years ago

    My experience is only with lever/rod actuated manual and electric PTO. Lever/rod actuation is basic and IMHO the cheapest most reliable method. Electric PTO is convenient, and provides more design flexiblity for the manufacturer. But it can require periodic adjustment, and failure can mean part replacement cost of $150 - $250. Based on prior experience with motorcycle, lawnmower, and bicycle cable actuated devices, I would guess cable actuated PTO will be less reliable than lever/rod or electric PTO actuation. Cable will be much cheaper to repair than electric PTO. Cables can stretch, slip, or wear. Reliability will be determined by cable quality, termination and cable carrier design. Any manufacturer using cable actuation is trying to save money, so I wouldn't necessarily expect superior design execution either. Again, IMHO.

    t

Sponsored
Franklin County's Heavy Timber Specialists | Best of Houzz 2020!