Software
Houzz Logo Print
pieohmy_gw

Which hay should I choose?

19 years ago

I have a choice between three types of hay Bahia, Bermuda, or Alchia. All three are the same cost so that is not a factor. I don't want weeds but realize that I will get them anyway (weeds grow no matter what I do here). I would like a good brown source for the summer. I'm just starting out so I don't have a good stockpile of browns from last fall. I presently have lasagna beds that really are in need of some brown layers. The hay will also be used as mulch and in composting grass clippings. The most important thing will be mulch for the upcoming drought season, followed by covering my half done lasagna beds, and composting (plenty of junk mail for that purpose so it is the least important).

Btw, I searched for the answer but Alchia isn't mentioned anywhere here and bahia is only addressed as growing. Any suggestions will be much appreciated in making this decision.

Comments (8)

  • 19 years ago

    I have never heard of Alchia so I cannot offer any input on that one.

    I have used Bahia as well as Bermuda with good luck.

    In fact, my entire garden is mulched over with layers of newspaper which is covered with a couple of inches of hay throughout.

    Both types will bring you some level of weed seeds as you said, but both of them will work well for what you are trying to do.

  • 19 years ago

    Thank you for the quick response, I wasn't sure if there was a difference. Gardening and weeds go hand in hand unfortunatly. I was thinking of going with bermuda since that is the type of grass we have our yard. That way I could pull it and relocate it lol. Maybe I'll get both types and see which is better in the long run.

  • 19 years ago

    As long as cost is about the same use what you can get the easiest. Also look around for any spoiled hay, which should be free since it can not be used for its original purpose any more.

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks for the suggestion. I asked the guy about spoiled hay and he said that he will call me when he has some. Now I need to go hit up the local Alpaca farm for manure :)

  • 19 years ago

    Given the choice of the three, I would take the Bermuda, (Especially if it is {{gwi:289387}}, which it probably is) because it is fine and most of the time will have few, if any seeds in it. Even if there is and some manage to come up thru the mulch, they are easy to deal with.

    I got this load free for the asking at our local feed store. They were unloading a truck and they were broken bales. I ran home and made me some side boards out of three pieces of plywood, went back and they threw it on and I tromped it down. It would really be hard to beat for mulch, or browns for compost. The only thing that I prefer is shredded oak leaves, but my big mower will also shred hay like this.
    Bill P.

  • 19 years ago

    I'm guessing the bermuda hay is some kind of coarse common bermuda which depending upon what kind of bermuda you have already might or might not stick out like a sore thumb. Bermuda is the hardest weed to get rid of in my garden. A piece of root will resprout into a grass plant that will then start to spread.

  • 19 years ago

    Bermuda does spread like crazy but I'm used to pulling it. The only thing I find irritating is that it will grow over barriers and on top of mulch. But that is also why I like it, with two dogs and two children it is tough enough to look good. If it is different, we are in the country so it won't matter ;)

    I didn't know that there were different types of Bermuda so I learned something new today. Coastal? Ours grows those long knee-high Y shaped sprigs when we don't mow (did I mention we live in the country?). Is that coastal bermuda?

  • 19 years ago

    Do not confuse Coastal Bermuda with the common Bermuda found in your yards which is a turf type grass. Coastal Bermuda hay is a hybrid cultivar that is sprigged into the ground to start pastures or fields with GREEN springs that are still alive. It produces few, if any seeds, and the cut, cured and dry hay will not cause any problems in your garden. You can cover it with some dirt and it will not sprout, it is dead. This link takes you to a very informative article on types of Bermuda grasses, by an Auburn University professor.

    It is a very valuable cash crop and people do not let a bunch of weeds grow in the fields that they are going to cut and bale. The second or third cutting is probably even better than the first one of the year. It is by no means coarse, as I stated in my posting above, it is fine and spreads easily for mulch. If you click on the link in my posting above to access the picture of the hay in my truck, roll the mouse cursor over the picture and click on the little magnifying glass with the + in it, you can see that it is pretty fine. That was very sweet smelling and excellent hay.

    It can be shredded up even finer with my mower. I have found straw to be much coarser and a lot more likely to contain seeds of oats or wheat, depending on what it was grown from. That really is little cause for alarm in most cases unless it is just thrown on the garden and neglected. The few plants that do manage to make it up thru thick mulch are easy to pull up.

    If your concerns are great about this issue, it would not be too hard to find some newspapers or cardboard boxes to use for mulch, but I think that the original question was "Which of three hays should the poster use?"
    Bill P..