Software
Houzz Logo Print
aubade

Mixing different fertilizers together

17 years ago

I don't see a specific fertilizer forum so I guess this is the place for this question.

I just got a new veggie garden with topsoil filled raised beds last year, and didn't fertilize much (or get a soil test yet). I did put in a little cottonseed meal, rock phospate and lime in the spring but that's it.

Right now I've gathered a couple things I think might be good to add: Maxicrop seaweed, possibly some compost tea (my pile only has produced a little so far, so I'm thinking I can just soak it in some water for a day or two and add it), and this I got yesterday at Lowe's, which appears to be made from soybean oils: http://www.bonnieplants.com/LearnGrowLibrary/GardeningMadeEasy/tabid/79/articleType/ArticleView/articleId/260/Bonnie-Herb-and-Vegetable-Plant-Food-Now-Available-for-Home-Gardens.aspx

My question is, can I mix all of these together into water and apply them together? Should I make them all more diluted than the directions say if I used them alone? Is it a good or a bad idea to put all of these on?

Sorry if this is too many questions - I'm very new to this and basically just guessing about what I should put on.

(I'm also a vegan gardener, and don't use animal products which is why I just don't add regular composted manure. Although I might - I don't think using the waste is necessarily that bad- I just prefer not to. But that is a whole other topic)

Comments (7)

  • 17 years ago

    Without a soil test you don't know what you need and are at risk of oversupplying the stuff you already have plenty of while neglecting the stuff you didn't know you lacked.

    Soil tests from state ag departments are free or inexpensive. Contact your county's ag department for info and then you can do what your garden really needs most. :-)

  • 17 years ago

    My question is, can I mix all of these together into water and apply them together? Should I make them all more diluted than the directions say if I used them alone?

    My answer is: what are the results of your soil analyses?This will tell you what to add. If you don't know, then you run the risk of wasting your money for nothing.

    Dan

  • 17 years ago

    As the others have said about a soil test so you know what is the readily available nitrient level of your soil what you propose adding may supply far more Nitrogen than is necessary which alone would create major problems with vegetables since you would get far too much lush, green growth and very little fruit production which is what you are growing those vegetables for, and that lush, green growth would be much more attractive to insect pests.
    Know your soil nutrient levels are before adding more of anything.

  • 17 years ago

    Well, let's take a look. Assuming your plants are already in the soil it may be unnessary to fertilize any further. Let the garden grow as it will for now and keep an eye on the plants as they grow. They'll tell you what they need, if anything, by coloration and growth behavior. Keep your watering steady but not heavy. You may, and only may, need to add a little non-organic ferts to help things along this year. Use some kind of mulch wether it's grass clippings, compost, etc. Come fall of the year you could, let's say should, incorporate a lot of organic matter into the soil to fluff it up and feed the medium. DO get a soil test done and go from there. It's not in your interest to just add things because they sound or look good. It takes a bit of time to get the hang of gardening but it's not all that hard. By all means lurk around this forum and you'll get the best advice available.

  • 17 years ago

    Thanks all for the replies. I did not put any fertilizers on since I posted based on the responses.

    However, I'm left wondering - why do the instructions on the maxicrop & bonnie fertilizer say to water the plants with the fertilizer solution once per week? Are they just trying to sell their product and it really isn't necessary?

    I guess I thought I needed to add a little something to help the plants what with all the rain we've had this year. They're all still pretty small, especially my peppers and beans...

  • 17 years ago

    why do the instructions on the maxicrop & bonnie fertilizer say to water the plants with the fertilizer solution once per week? Are they just trying to sell their product and it really isn't necessary?

    Yup! It increases their sales, and the help to the garden is minimal.

    Applying fertilizer will not make up for the lousy weather you had.

  • 17 years ago

    The companies that sell those products test them under conventional gardening practices in soils that are devoid of sufficient levels of orgnaic matter that do not have an active Soil Food Web and they need to "feed" the plants they grow frequently to attempt to make up for growing plants in unhealthy soils which makes those plants good targets for insect pests and plant diseases so you have to spend even more of your money on products to control those problems caused by trying to grow your plants in an unhealthy soil.
    Telling you to apply those products every week also increases their sales and profits, which does in some way help the nations economy.