Software
Houzz Logo Print
catlover_gardener

Does compost have a N-P-K value?

18 years ago

Mu compost is almost ready. How long do the nutrients in it last, after I mixed it in with the soil in my container of veggies. Do I have to keep adding more compost to the container in ordr to keep up the nutri value. Does it eventually lose its value?

In its "ready state" doaes it have the same NPK value as the ferts that are in the big box stores, eg, Miracle GRow, etc.?

Comments (15)

  • 18 years ago

    Nope. Numbers are lower and release is slower. The boxes at the hardware store have numbers like 12-10-10 or 8-10-10 for roses and vegatables.

    Sustainable Gardening Australia gives ranges of compost
    1.4-3.5 0.3-1.0 0.4-2.0

  • 18 years ago

    How long do the nutrients in it last, after I mixed it in with the soil in my container of veggies.

    Much longer than any of the water soluble fertilizers will last. With containers and their need for frequent watering, any source of nutrients will drain out eventually. MG and the like drain quickly, compost in its solid state much more slowly. But compost nutrients remain actively available to the plants as long as the bacteria in it remain active.

    Do I have to keep adding more compost to the container in ordr to keep up the nutri value.

    Adding fresh compost to the container is of great benefit and is no real problem - just place a fresh layer on top now and then. It revitalizes the bacteria, acts as a mulch, stabilizes moisture levels so less watering is needed, and feeds the plants - all at the same time. Or, make compost tea and use that - well diluted - to water the plants once a week.

    Please keep in mind that the numbers one sees on the boxes of plant food can be very misleading. They are a loose guideline indicator of ingredients in the box, not an indicator of what the plant actually gets. So they really can't be compared to compost nutrients in any valid way.

    Enjoy your plants. ;)

    Dave

  • 18 years ago

    N=Excellent
    P=Excellent
    K=Excellent
    Other=Excellent

    Repeat as available.

  • 18 years ago

    The nutrients in compost are pretty stable, not easily extracted for the soil tests which is why compost is listed as a soil amendment and not a fertilizer. However once in your soil, and moist, the soil Food Web will get to work and release those "locked" up nutrients so your plants can use them. Just how long compost, or any organic matter, will last in your soil depends on how active a Soil Food Web you have and for many of us that have been adding organic matter (that general term includes compost) to our soils have a very active Soil Food Web need to add more every year because the SFW chomps that material up so quickly. Those that do not have an active SFW, yet, find that the OM lasts longer in their soils.

  • 18 years ago

    catlover: the NPK of compost is about 1-1-1. But I would use it if the nutrient values were zero. First it replaces lost soil carbon (which has several clear advantages) but more important it increases biological activity in the soil. Finally, it's mimicing nature's recycling -- so if you aren't recycling, you're throwing it all away. Regards, Peter.

  • 18 years ago

    I have seen many lists of the nutrient value of compost, none of which were of useable value because the nutrients in compost are locked up. There must be more to compost than just the carbon value because the Soil Food Web that chomps on that compost needs, just like you, nutrients to exist, grow, and work and they get them from the compost and other organic matter that goes into soil.
    If compost only has about 1 percent Nitrogen where do the plants get the rest of that N they need to grow, when compost is the only source of nutrients used?

  • 18 years ago

    I have seen many lists of the nutrient value of compost, none of which were of useable value because the nutrients in compost are locked up.

    Damn Hobbits is real tricksyÂ

    How long are these nutrients locked up? Until the protozoa and nematodes eat the bacteria and fungi that ate the organic matter. They have a name for this process, it is called composting. Once eaten by the protozoa and nematodes (which too are eaten), the poop released is in a form the plants can use.

    So, lets say Blutranes has a big pile of organic matter; bacteria and fungi start feeding on the material, their population explodes within the pile. Blutranes gets a bright idea and pours Coke-Cola on the pile, the bacteria and fungi go nuts! They consume nitrogen in the pile to feed on the cola carbon soaked onto all the other organic matter. The pile starts to heat up to the point of smoking the feeding is so frantic. If something isnÂt done soon, the pile will be overpopulated with bacteria and fungi. Now comes the protozoa and nematodes, they smell food and they will not be denied, and they get at all this tasty eating. The pile starts to shrink; the feeding is intense and constant. Other organisms see their chance and get in on the feeding, shrinking the pile further. Blutranes knows all the action is mostly in the core of the pile, so he turns the pile so the organic matter on the outside gets to the inside. All hell breaks loose again, causing even more smoke to manifest. Blutranes pile is a prime example of birth, feeding, sex, pooping, and death. If this keeps up Blutranes will be left with a pile of completely decompose organic matter, a pile of finished compost. If Blutranes is patient enough to leave the pile alone, the feeding will continue to a lesser extent, but the results will be a pile of nutrients that have been consumed many times over, resulting in a pile of dynamite for his plants to feed on, the choice is Blutranes.

    If compost only has about 1 percent Nitrogen where do the plants get the rest of that N they need to grow, when compost is the only source of nutrients used?

    From the air, if the pile is left alone long enough to breed the bacteria that fix nitrogen from the air. Compost allowed to cure this long will provide not only nitrogen but all the other nutrients needed if said nutrients are provided to the soil food web. However, this requires patience and knowledge that the entire process will provide these results. Providing half the information makes learning real "tricksy" for those not aware, and not very good community relations, not very good at allÂ

    Blutranes

  • 18 years ago

    Catlover, I am assuming that the 'SWF 10' indicates that you live in SW Florida, Zone 10.

    One problem you will run into there is the rapid disintegration of compost in the soil due to the heat. I had the problem in Las Vegas, too. In cooler climates, the compost lasts longer, but where you are, you will have to replenish it more frequently than if you lived in, say, upstate NY.

    Keep in mind that compost and manure feed the soil, chemical fertilizers feed the plant and do nothing for the soil.

    Sue

  • 11 years ago

    Compost made in large amount contains most of the times enough nitrogen and phosphate, but is low on the potassium. For making the compost well balanced you can add seeweed, that is rich on potassium. You also add trace elements to do so. About one part seeweed you can add to seven parts green materials and seven parts brown( leaves?) The N/P/K is then about .4/.3/.6. Seeweed digest in compost on moisture conditions, so add water if the compost is too dry.

    Bart Sanderse

  • 11 years ago

    You could add seaweed (not seeweed) to compost if it is readily available but whether it would change the numbers much is not known since numerous studies don't confirm that. The N P K of compost is not readily available, not soluble, so testing does not show what is really in compost and those of us that have made and used compost for years see results that are not indicated by the numbers.

    My soil test numbers show an increase in nutrients over time that cannot be easily explained since all I add is the compost I make and other sources of vegetative waste (tree leaves, needles from evergreens, etc.) . Seaweed is not readily available to me so I do not use it.

    kimmq is kimmsr

  • 11 years ago

    In June 2015 I brought a sample of last years compost in for testing by CAES so it can indeed be tested.

    http://www.ct.gov/caes/cwp/view.asp?a=2836&q=378206


    While they don't provide NPK numbers for any sample the following is provided

    • Organic Matter - Medium
    • Soil Texture - Sandy Loam
    • pH -6.0
    • Nitrate Nitrogen - High
    • Ammonium Nitrogen - Low (indicating it was NOT fertilizer)
    • Phosphorous - Very High
    • Potassium - High
    • Calcium - High
    • Magnesium - High

    HTH

  • 11 years ago

    "The N P K of compost is not readily available, not soluble, so testing does not show what is really in compost"

    The NPK of compost is just as available and testable as with any other organic (once living) garden amendment - the information is just not included with any bagged or prepared material because it is not sold as a fertilizer, which require NPK labeling. Also the NPK in compost can vary rather measurably depending on the ingredients that went into the compost and how "finished" it might be. It has nothing to do with solubility.


    nutrient content of compost

  • 11 years ago

    So gardengal, perhaps you could explain why many of us that practice good organic growing find that by adding compost and other forms of vegetative waste to the soil find that the level of nutrients increases for a time and then stabilizes in balance. For example, the first soil test done here (some 40 years ago) showed the soils pH at 5.7 , P =low, K= low, Ca.=moderate, Mg.= low (Michigan soils are known to be low in Magnesium) while after three years of adding just compost and other forms of vegetative waste the soil test showed the soils pH to be 7.2 and P, K, Ca., and Mg. to be in the optimal range and in balance. Where did those nutrients come from? The air? A hidden bank in the soil that the earthworms brought up? Keep in mind that the presence of earthworms often follows the improvement in soil nutrients and not the other way around.

    I have heard, and read, that just adding compost, and other forms of vegetative waste to soils will not add enough nutrients to those soils, however, in my experience (and many others as well) that just is not true.

    kimmq is kimmsr

  • 11 years ago

    Did you read what I wrote, kimmsr? Did I state anywhere in that post that compost was NOT a nutrient source? Of course it adds to soil fertility, albeit slowly and in very moderate amounts, just the same as any sourced organic fertilizer does. I've been using compost as a mulch all of my gardening career and have found it virtually eliminates the need for any other supplemental fertilization.

    The point of my comment was to correct the misinformation previously presented about compost not being tested for NPK. It can and is tested from time to time depending on reason or need - it is just not labeled with that information, as that is only a requirement for a 'fertilizer'. Compost is not sold as or considered to be a fertilizer by definition (which is a legal definition involving specific regulations) but that does not mean it has no nutrient value. Lots of things which are not specifically "fertilizers" have NPK values and present a decent nutrient source. And neither has the solubility or insolubility of any of these materials/ingredients/fertilizers anything to do with their ability to be analyzed for NPK.

    That is simply all I was saying.

  • 11 years ago

    Just a few bits to add:

    When I tested 13 locally available bagged commercial composts plus my own home made, the median composition was 0.8-0.2-0.2. My own was the best, at 2.7 - 0.5 - 0.6.

    People often forget that you add pounds and pounds of compost to a garden rather than a sprinkling like you do with fertilizer. The important thing is the total quantity of nutrients added. A bag of compost may have approximately the same amount of nutrients as a handful of fertilizer. So don't be put off by the low numbers in compost.

    bartsanderse's comment about compost being low in K may or may not be relevant. It depends on your soil (whether it has high or low K to begin with and whether it can retain K well), and the demand (what your plants are removing). I have limestone based clay and after adding compost for 20 years the K level became very high to excessive. So I have no reason to worry about my compost being 'deficient' in K. Your mileage may vary. Since you have seaweed available I'm guessing you have a sandy coastal soil and perhaps K leaches away faster. Don't assume it's true everywhere.