Software
Houzz Logo Print
seedy_z5

linden between houses?

18 years ago

I'd appreciate some help about whether this is a stupid idea. I need to shade my brick house, and there is a 13-foot space between my house and the one to the south. The one to the south is shorter than mine, about 15 feet to the roofline, compared to 25 feet to mine. Would a greenspire linden be a good or bad idea in this space? Would pruning keep this tree to a beneficial size? Should I be concerned about the roots heaving a sidewalk or invading the basements?

Comments (8)

  • 18 years ago

    Sources give a mature width of this tree of about 30 feet. In a 13 foot space? I wouldn't try and prune a large shade tree to fit the space. I think you should try and find a tree that has a more strictly columnar shape. Some selections of oak, maple and Ginkgo come to mind.

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks for your thoughts. It's 13 feet wide at the base of the space, but wider once you get above the rooflines (at 15 feet up on the south and 25 feet up on the north; both houses have sloped roofs). Don't know whether that makes a difference to your point.

    I should probably also say that one of the reasons I'm considering this is that the local garden center has a nice linden available. It's probably 12 feet tall already. I was just about set to put in a chanticleer pear but then read up about its undesireableness.

  • 18 years ago

    That one will get way bigger than 30 ft. If you are trying to get significant shade on/near your house while you are still living there you will either have to install an architectural solution like a lath or arbor or plant a fast, tall and narrow-growing tree like one of the more narrow Freeman maple cultivars.

    Due to the abundance of such situations as yours these days large wholesale growers that make their own plant introductions are featuring both smaller- and narrower-growing shade and flowering trees. Have a look at the web sites of Lake County Nursery and Bailey Nurseries for starters, to see what may be available at garden centers that interests you.

  • 18 years ago

    It's not just the amount of trimming that would have to be done - possibly at the expense of the tree's best interests - to keep the lower branches from impacting the house(s) as it grows, it would also be the problem of branches over-growing both your house roof and the neighbor's house roof that would stop me from planting this tree in that location.

    If you can't let a tree grow in its natural shape in the spot you want to put it, my advice is; don't plant THAT tree in THAT location. There are many cultivars of trees that will grow in a columnar/fastigate form. You may not get as much shade from them, but you will have MANY fewer problems down the road with limbs growing into the house(s) and overhanging the roof(s).

  • 18 years ago

    bboy, thanks for the recommendations. We did put a very tall trellis up in front of one south-facing section.

    dibbit, yeah, you've hit on the concerns that I had myself. I fear that I am looking for a simple solution to a complex problem. While it is mostly the downstairs bay windows that we are attempting to shade, it seems this tree would be likely to have a detrimental effect on the tops of both houses. When I first saw the linden last week, I told my partner (who has nostalgic connection to lindens) that it would be a great tree for the parkway but would not be good for the side of the house.

    Thanks to all who are trying to talk some sense into me. Any other recommendations for specific trees I should look for? We planted some birches along the strip in question, and I was hoping for a longer-lived tree to take over once those are gone.

  • 18 years ago

    Two further reasons against the linden, apart from size: leaves in your gutters which will need clearing every year and the fact that lindens are attractive to aphids which cause 'honeydew' to drip from the leaves onto whatever is below. This in turn attracts sooty mould and is very hard to remove from cars, paving, garden furniture etc.

    As for the birches you seem to expect them to be short lived. Is there a reason for that? I would have thought they would last quite as long as you are likely to be in that house, and possibly longer. Obviously it depends on the species, conditions and location but they can thrive for 40 - 50 years easily and maybe up to a hundred if happy.

  • 18 years ago

    I have a similar situation. I want to plant some trees in a 17 foot space between my house and the neighbors yard. I am strongly considering a screen of Dakota Pinnacle birch. They are from North Dakota State University (my alma mater), hardy to zone 3, borer resistant and grows 35 feet tall and 8 feet wide. Life expectancy is up to 40 years. I know that Forest Farm sells them. Click on the link for more info.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Northscaping-Dakota Pinnacle

  • 18 years ago

    The Dakota Pinnacle sounds great. Thanks for the tip. We do actually have some other birches in that area. Unfortunately the middle one broke in a crazy storm, so we're looking to replace it. I suppose I should reconsider getting anything other than another birch.